Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

So if your source lied so blatently about the engines why should we think there are no other lies in the video?
 
Commercial passenger 767's cannot travel at .86 Mach at sea level.

Actually it can, when its pushed to the max a few seconds before it hits a building. It was above its max operating velocity for a maximum of ten seconds. Why Lear expects it to disintegrate in that time frame is pure lunacy. Then again Lear has never shied away from lunar issues.;):D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_BOca173YE

BTW Usain Bolt can run just as fast in Nepal as he can in Bahrain, as far as the friction due to passage through the air goes (availability of oxygen is another matter). Comparing fluid friction of air to that of water is an enormous exaggeration, to the point of lying.
 
Last edited:
Commercial passenger 767's cannot travel at .86 Mach at sea level.
Oh yes they very much can. What you are suggesting is that somehow, in the 40+ 767 hull losses on record, every single one slowed down before crashing into the earth. Think about what the unintended consequences are for that argument. You have now placed yourself in the position that all aircraft must decelerate before hitting the ground. Furthermore, you intentionally muddy the waters by mixing ground speed, air speed and Mach in such a way that I am certain that you haven't the foggiest what those numbers actually mean.

Do you think Usain Bolt can run 30mph underwater?
Strawman and non-sequitur all in one. Please do not do that.

Radar and video prove a 767 variant struck WTC2, they do not prove it was UA175.
Actually they do. What is conspicuously missing is your phantom copyjets.

Without simply invoking the "he's lying" rebuttal, can you refute Leer's claims?
Lear is flat out bonkers and to be honest, you do not cover yourself in glory by being unable to spell the man's name.

<snip pointless yooboob nonsense>

Upon reflection, I'm certain this is where I first heard about the NY engine discrepancies, but there are many more videos/pages with similar theses..
Done to death over and over and over and...well, you get the picture.
 
Last edited:
Airliners will not be certified to carry passengers if they are difficult to fly, or if they show any instability when the controls are left alone at cruise, etc.

Airliners have to pass rigorous flight testing, and many other types of testing, to be certified to carry passengers in commercial service.

No relatively modern airliner can be said to be "difficult" to fly as far as basic maneuvering, imo.

If that were the case, no certifying agency in the world would approve it, imo.
 
Commercial passenger 767's cannot travel at .86 Mach at sea level. Do you think Usain Bolt can run 30mph underwater? Radar and video prove a 767 variant struck WTC2, they do not prove it was UA175.

Without simply invoking the "he's lying" rebuttal, can you refute Leer's claims?

I don't believe commercial passenger 767s could accelerate to .86 Mach in level flight, but that has nothing to do with the events of 9/11. Altitude is energy (for planes and buildings), and a 767 in a dive can accelerate until it disintegrates.
 
Why does the engine found on the sidewalk in NYC not match a UA 767?
It does. Anyone who claims otherwise is lying or uninformed.

In the various pieces of footage ( Google " all known footage second impact " ) of the second impact you can see the engine exit the building near the corner and leave a spiral smoke trail. Because the event was filmed by random New Yorkers at distances of 100' to 5 miles away and ranging around the compass, you can easily replicate the work I've done over and over for you people and will not redo yet again - estimate trajectory, use frame rates to calculate velocity and you will find that the engine at Church and Murray left the building at ~400 mph and fell 80 stories to end up in that spot, clearly filmed from many directions.

Alternatively, if I'm wrong, I've handed you the tools to prove it.

Not only does the engine match the plane in question, but its passage through the building is consistent in trajectory and velocity with the initial impact speed and direction, as calculated from the various pieces of footage.

Alternatively, you can look at the clips and do the math yourself to prove me wrong.

One way or another the engine left the building and fell to that spot. Provable. So if the engine is "wrong" ( it isn't - those who claim otherwise are uninformed or lying) then either a different plane than the one that matches all the other debris serial numbers hit the building, or someone fired the engine from a cannon on the 80th floor set perfectlyto relplicate the trajectory of an engine that is consistent will all other trajectory facts.

Where would you like to start throwing out facts so you can make your theory work?
 
One way or another the engine left the building and fell to that spot. Provable. So if the engine is "wrong" ( it isn't - those who claim otherwise are uninformed or lying) then either a different plane than the one that matches all the other debris serial numbers hit the building, or someone fired the engine from a cannon on the 80th floor set perfectlyto relplicate the trajectory of an engine that is consistent will all other trajectory facts.

And, at the planning stage, someone must have said, "Let's leave an engine lying about somewhere so that people think an airliner hit the towers. Sorry, what? Make sure it's the right kind of engine? Why the hell bother, it's not like there's any difference," thus exhibiting the classic blend of fiendish foresight and blind stupidity that conspiracists always seem to attribute to their imaginary villains.

Dave
 
I get tired of typing the same crap over and over again so here is a copy paste from a post i did on another form. I don't think the link works any more but basically it said if you drill 4 1/4" holes in PN 769316 to let a little more air in, it then becomes PN 815392 and that is is what is used on the JT9-7rd4. the parts look exactly the same.



Thank you for providing us with your Youtube evidence, now here is the real evidence that shows what a load of crap that video is.

Your video claims that the JT9D-7A and the JT9-7R4D are a different engine type and size this is not true. The 7A does have a larger fan but it is the same type and size engine.

They also claim that this part PN 769316 is not found on the JT9-7R4D

6a00e00982d2c988330120a5bf58d4970c-500wi_zps49a41cd5.jpg


This document explains in great detail how to replace or modify PN 769316 on the JT9-7R4D

http://119.97.245.12:8080/技术部门/手册/维修及维护手册/Eagle Disc JT9D-7R4G2 EM and EIPC/sb/72-512.pdf

Since most Truthers have a phobia of clicking links that destroy their claims, I took the liberty of Highlighting in green some of the parts of the document that debunk your video.

Screen%20shot%202015-03-22%20at%204.20.36%20PM.jpg


The engine found on Murray st. was the engine from UA 175. There is no evidence to the contrary.
I can provide other documents linking PN 769316 to the JT9-7R4D if you want.

And to top it off both the port and starboard landing gear from UA 175 were recovered.
The landing gear is defiantly from a Boeing 767 no doubt about it.
Therefore the engine also came from a boeing 767.

Screenshot2011-04-08at125729AM.png


Flight175_Strut_2_455.png


The flap actuator (yellow arrow) they found ....

Wtc-photo.jpg


also came from a B767.

Screenshot2013-04-30at123411PM.jpg



This piece of debris can be directly identified as belonging to UA 175 (N612UA)

1.jpg


2.jpg


3.jpg


dsc00478kcopycopy.jpg


6.jpg


UA 175 / N612UA crashed into the south tower, the engine found on Murray st. came from UA 175 this is a fact.
 
Commercial passenger 767's cannot travel at .86 Mach at sea level.
Which commercial 767 traveled .86 MACH at sea level on 911? Which one? Oh noes, 911 truth don't know...

Where do you get this BS from? You realize jet engines have the most thrust at sea level? Are you trying to play the air is too thick at sea level for jet to go fast? There is a speed limit for jets below 10,000 feet to be at or below 250 knots... this is a regulation...

did you try to look up how the 767/757 were designed? Designed to be flutter free to 1.2Vd so aircraft can be upset, go too fast, yet recover and save life, avoid being destroyed. Why can't 911 truth do reality and use facts?

Flight 11, 470 mph, aka 408 knots, and Vd, a flight test speed is 420 knots... OOPS, Flight 11 was inside the envelope for flight, as flight tested. Why does 911 truth fail to think and use facts, or know anything about 911? Why the big fail? Flight 11 was not at sea level... I can't remember when the sea level was over 700 feet up in the sky... do you know what sea level is?

Flight 175 was only going .78 MACH, not .86. Why can't 911 truth get anything right about 911. Flight 175 was in a decent, and only over 1.2Vd for less than 7 seconds. How can an aircraft designed to be flutter free to 1.2Vd not reach that speed and beyond? Explain why a plane which could go over MACH 1 in a dive, can't reach the slow speed of .78 MACH as proved by RADAR? Don't repeat the lie it was not 175, it was 175; a solid fact you can't refute. Explain using math, physics and aerodynamics why a 767 can't go as fast as Flight 175. When do you think you can do this? never...

Flight 77 was over Vmo for less than 20 or 30 seconds at full throttle. Flight 77 went from 300 knots to 483.5 knots in less than 30 seconds in a dive at Full Throttle. 484.5 knots is not 504 knots, which is 1.2 Vd. Did you look up anything? A 747 went over MACH 1, and was recovered, explain to me why a 767 and 757 can't go at the speeds they did on 911? What do you have to prove a 767/757 can't do what they did on 911;

Flight 93 crashed in a 40 degree nose low dive, almost upside-down. What is the max speed? Do you know why 93 did not go faster than... do you even know the speed 93 impacted at? No?
Flight 93 impacted at 487.5 knots, 561 mph.
Why not faster, at 40 degrees nose low a clean 757 would reach MACH 1... what happened? The ground did get in the way, is one reason the speed was not faster, and the other reason is the terrorist pilot loaded up the jet, and was pulling up to 4gs prior to impact. If you want to slow down, pulling gs is a good way to slow down... wonder if the terrorist pilot passed out at 4 g... 3 times in the last four minutes of flight the terrorist pilot pulled over 3gs, and also unloaded 3 times...

Which plane was .86 MACH at sea level? lol - did you pull that BS out of thin air, or was it underwater running track... do you have some more silly failed analogies to help make 911 truth lies funnier as they mock the murder of thousands with idiotic claims and failed lies...

If flew heavy jets, which weighed up to 302,000 pounds, and at 300 feet MSL clean, I exceeded Vmo in a few seconds with near full throttle - why can't aircraft with more than enough thrust, and in a dive not exceed all speed limits? They have on accident, and this is why they are designed to be flutter free past all limits, so in accidents there is a chance to recover, even if parts or skin is ripped off, or the Elevator is damaged...

Do you think Usain Bolt can run 30mph underwater?
Which planes on 911 were underwater? This analogy fails... The planes on 911 were in air, not water; the analogy makes as much sense as all 911 truth claims... big fail on the analogy; redo

Radar and video prove a 767 variant struck WTC2, they do not prove it was UA175.
Yes, Radar, Video, Witnesses all confirm Flight 175 hit the WTC. Because 911 truth can't do the science of Radar, they lie and claim it was not Flight 175. 911 truth followers with no evidence repeat this lie. Why? Ignorance or gullibility?
Explain why Radar, which tracked Flight 175 from takeoff to impact do not prove it was 175?

Oh no, you are playing the BS card of John Lear - yes his claims are essentially lies, or BS, take your pick. Got some math and physics to back up Lear's BS? No, never will. You can't pick one of Lear's lies, or what? Which claim is true from Lear? (BIG HINT, all his 911 claims are BS) I asked you for math and physics, you present BS.
Without simply invoking the "he's lying" rebuttal, can you refute Leer's claims?

http://youtu.be/belm78njlm0
LOL, this is super stuff, "John Lear Alien Bases on the Moon and Mars Anomalies". John Lear is a BS expert, and spreads lies about 911. You got a nut for an expert, and John Lear knows he is a nut. Good job self debunking the 911 truth claims by presenting John Lear who talks to aliens, and believes there are alien bases on the Moon. Big fail for 911 truth claims. Can't believe you debunked yourself using Lear's BS.

Using John Lear for your source, means you have top notch dumbed down BS based on nothing. Why can't John Lear do reality on 911, why are his claims lies on 911? You don't know.

Upon reflection, I'm certain this is where I first heard about the NY engine discrepancies, but there are many more videos/pages with similar theses..
Is it all of 911 truth who don't have evidence or any clue where they got the lie about the engine. 911 truth followers repeat lies without knowing, or do they repeat lies on purpose.
 
Last edited:
...Do you think Usain Bolt can run 30mph underwater? ...

You didn't pay attention: The usual Truther argument is not so much that a 767 doesn't have the thrust to accelerate to UA175's top speed, but that it would disintegrate.

The thrust problem is very obviously solved by noting that UA175 was descending.

Speaking of Usain Bolt: He can in fact exceed the vmax during his world record run, if he runs downhill, even near sea level. This is not safe for him, and chanced are he will stumble and fall if he tried to sustain a steep downhill race at his fullest thrust for 100 or 200 meters, but for a few seconds he should be able to cope. As did UA175 - it would probably have started to disintegrate had it continued flying at that speed and altutude, but the few seconds it did were not a problem.
 
Having been in and around aviation just about my entire life, as a kid with my dad a Navy A-4 pilot with over 4000 hrs and my own F-14 RIO career with 1250 total hours, I took a personal interest in the aviation aspect of 9/11. Years ago I wrote an old Navy friend of ours who had been an TA-4 pilot as a junior officer in my Dad's squadron, then F-4 pilot, then left active duty and flew airliners for the next 30 years with Eastern Airlines then Fed Ex. I asked him about the speeds the 9/11 aircraft were said to have been flying. here is his response:

Well............Let me make a few statements that will qualify what I am about to say. As you are probably well aware, commercial aircraft don't have the forward throttle stops that military tactical aircraft have...........meaning, jamming a throttle full forward, to the stops, on a fighter aircraft is common practice and is routinely done. For example, on takeoff, climb-out, and especially during a dogfight those throttles are bent forward to 100% RPM (or slightly under). The fuel control unit (military) will not allow that engine to overspeed and self destruct, if properly rigged. ( a guy's got to have means to get home after wrenching a kill on the enemy)

On commercial aircraft, the throttle must be set for takeoff and continually monitored and adjusted during climb by the pilot(s) or auto-throttles, if one's lucky enough to have them. The only time a throttle is bent forward on a commercial a/c is if ground contact appears imminent and it ain't a runway of intended contact. ie, the "escape" maneuver when an a/c is about to hit a mountain. It's firewall power, pull the nose up into buffet, and climb to the moon to clear any obstacle. Should a guy get himself safely on the ground somewhere thereafter, it is mandatory engine inspection and probably all engine removal and replacement. The engines will have been oversped and overtemped with possible other mechanical damage.

So.............of the aircraft of which I am familiar, the redline speed of an MD-10 at 10,000' is 375 KIAS. At sea level, it is 350 KIAS. ( the MD-11 is less than these speeds for a number of reasons that would only get boring) I'm quite sure the 757 and the 767 have very similar max speeds give or take 20-30 knots.

Interestingly, if a pilot didn't pull the throttles back to "cruise" settings (on a commercial a/c) when he leveled off at altitude, the aircraft would accelerate right thru redline on it's way to possible self destruction...........the engines are that powerful.

You know that the safety factors built into aircraft are 1.5 for structural components (wings, fuselage,etc.) and 2.5 safety factor for engines and landing gear, and control surfaces. Don't quote me on these exact components..........this is from memory from years ago. But it means that the design limits imposed by the manufacturer are what are safe to fly with, ie the speeds listed above and the "g" loadings. In reality, the aircraft has to be able to withstand 1.5 times the "g" loading design limits in order to be certified. I'm not sure if the same is true of the speeds, but I feel reasonably sure it is true as well. What this means is........ an aircraft will not show signs of destruction until it reaches the 1.5 times the design speed limit or its "g" limit. At least that is what the manufacturer guarantees, as required by the FAA. So..........

If I were to level off at 5000' (or 1000') and leave the throttles set at climb power, this aircraft would exceed the 350 KIAS (knots, indicated air speed) design limit. But it probably wouldn't come apart............yet. I don't know how fast it would ultimately go because I've never done that in a commercial airplane. We are not allowed to do that. But I do know that if a pilot then pushed the throttles up to the physical limits (stops), exceeding all the engine redline limits and warnings, the engines would accelerate and eventually self destruct as would the airframe itself..........say around 1.5 times 350 knots or 525 KIAS. Reasonably, I would guess the aircraft would start shedding pieces as it approached 500 KIAS.

In answer to your question...............a 757, or a 767, or an MD-11 can easily do 450 KIAS at low altitude at least once and maybe many times before it would show signs of damage and could do well beyond that if it were meant to be total destruction.

So Lear can go have tea with his moon-base aliens and Balsamo can go lead a circle-jerk with the rest of the morons in his tree fort and anyone else who doesn't have the cojones to educate themselves about these sorts of issues can keep making a royal ass out of themselves. Everything "aviation" related on 9/11 was perfectly capable of happening - speeds, altitudes, maneuvers, everything - and did happen by no-time-in-type pilots. It ain't difficult grabbing the yoke of one of those aircraft while already airborne and directing it to a crash.
 
Here's the 3D view of the turn (with height amplified to better see the "bumps").

[qimg]http://11-s.eu.org/11-s/Julio-descenso2.PNG[/qimg]



He was too high when he started the turn; if he descended at the necessary angle, his speed would have increased to a point where the plane might have been uncontrollable. So he descended, and descended too much. As a result, he was close to crashing against the floor.

thanks for the info, that purple portion of the line right before impact doesn't exactly look like a low and level approach to the first floor as implied by the witnesses, damage, and security video. Maybe this is the flight path of the Global Hawk which was crashed on scene to simulate a larger aircraft?
 
Having been in and around aviation just about my entire life, as a kid with my dad a Navy A-4 pilot with over 4000 hrs and my own F-14 RIO career with 1250 total hours, I took a personal interest in the aviation aspect of 9/11. Years ago I wrote an old Navy friend of ours who had been an TA-4 pilot as a junior officer in my Dad's squadron, then F-4 pilot, then left active duty and flew airliners for the next 30 years with Eastern Airlines then Fed Ex. I asked him about the speeds the 9/11 aircraft were said to have been flying. here is his response:

"But it probably wouldn't come apart............yet. I don't know how fast it would ultimately go because I've never done that in a commercial airplane."

So I have your above pilot claiming it "probably" wouldn't come apart. I also have the recollection of a face to face in depth conversation with Pilot Capt. Russ Wittenberg who is no more or less of a hero than your equivocal Veteran F-4 pilot. Not only does Capt. Wittenberg state that the 767's impacting the towers are incapable of those speeds at sea level, and the 757 that allegedly hit the Pentagon incapable of such a leveling off maneuver, but he actually flew both aircraft. He flew the specific airplanes that allegedly impacted each site. That testimony is not so easy to dismiss.
 
So I have your above pilot claiming it "probably" wouldn't come apart. I also have the recollection of a face to face in depth conversation with Pilot Capt. Russ Wittenberg who is no more or less of a hero than your equivocal Veteran F-4 pilot. Not only does Capt. Wittenberg state that the 767's impacting the towers are incapable of those speeds at sea level, and the 757 that allegedly hit the Pentagon incapable of such a leveling off maneuver, but he actually flew both aircraft. He flew the specific airplanes that allegedly impacted each site. That testimony is not so easy to dismiss.
Russ is wrong, as Radar proves his claim is BS. Science, the science of electromagnetic waves harnessed to keep us safe in-flight, Radar, proves Russ is wrong, a liar, or just plain dumber than dirt. Which is it?

His testimony is based on BS, his opinion. The fact is what is stopping the 767 from going 590 mph. Please state a scientific reason why a 767 can't make 590 mph at 700 MSL.
Got some evidence, or the BS opinion of 911 truth nut? BS

Flight 77 at the Pentagon never leveled off; you were lied to again.

The dumbest claim is Global Hawk did it... since a Global Hawk is not missing, and Global Hawk does not have the energy to do the damage, or carry the jet fuel which hit the Pentagon. Do you post lies on purpose, or what?

Why is global hawk the dumbest claim? Global Hawk can't go 483.5 knots, big fail. Giant BS claim. Where do you get this BS from?
 
Last edited:
You didn't pay attention: The usual Truther argument is not so much that a 767 doesn't have the thrust to accelerate to UA175's top speed, but that it would disintegrate.

The thrust problem is very obviously solved by noting that UA175 was descending.

Noted, but if by some mechanism Bolt were accelerated to a 30mph run underwater his ligaments would likely rip apart by the augmented fluid dynamics. His body is not equipped to handle those sorts of stresses in bipedal motion. Similarly, the standard lightweight commercial aircraft designed for economic fuel efficient passenger travel that was UA175 was not designed to handle top speeds in the significantly denser air of sea level and therefore would (as you're about to say) probably break apart.

Speaking of Usain Bolt: He can in fact exceed the vmax during his world record run, if he runs downhill, even near sea level. This is not safe for him, and chanced are he will stumble and fall if he tried to sustain a steep downhill race at his fullest thrust for 100 or 200 meters, but for a few seconds he should be able to cope. As did UA175 - it would probably have started to disintegrate had it continued flying at that speed and altutude, but the few seconds it did were not a problem.

Kudos to a nice analogy, and you're speculating that the aircraft would have eventually broken apart. I find it equally likely the aircraft didn't break apart because it was not the standard 767-200 allegedly used.
 
Noted, but if by some mechanism Bolt were accelerated to a 30mph run underwater his ligaments would likely rip apart by the augmented fluid dynamics. His body is not equipped to handle those sorts of stresses in bipedal motion. Similarly, the standard lightweight commercial aircraft designed for economic fuel efficient passenger travel that was UA175 was not designed to handle top speeds in the significantly denser air of sea level and therefore would (as you're about to say) probably break apart.



Kudos to a nice analogy, and you're speculating that the aircraft would have eventually broken apart. I find it equally likely the aircraft didn't break apart because it was not the standard 767-200 allegedly used.
Oops. a lie, it was a standard 767, and you keep spreading lies; why do you spread lies proved wrong with science? Guess 911 truth has to ignore Radar so they can keep their fantasy.

What plane on 911 was underwater... and Bolt top speed might be 30, but he averages less... just like planes can exceed their limits, and still function because they were designed to be controllable even past speed limits; and planes have been MACH 1, way over your BS they can't, and recovered and saved... now what for the BS claims of 911 truth; all based on zero evidence.

The aircraft did not break apart, as seen on video. You are debunked by video, Radar, and reality. You keep repeating lies, and you offer no evidence.
 
Last edited:
Russ is wrong, as Radar proves his claim is BS. Science, the science of electromagnetic waves harnessed to keep us safe in-flight, Radar, proves Russ is wrong, a liar, or just plain dumber than dirt. Which is it?

Radar proves a primary return hit the towers, it doesn't prove it was UA175 or AA11.

Please state a scientific reason why a 767 can't make 590 mph at 700 MSL.
Got some evidence, or the BS opinion of 911 truth nut? BS
A commercial passenger 767-200 cannot because it's airframe isn't reinforced to handle those forces. Reinforcing standard airframes to those tolerances would be expensive and inefficient for the airplane's purpose, not something a profit centered enterprise like AA or UA would undertake on their continental carriers. Augmented transport and tactical versions of the 767 could handle those forces because they are built for different missions.

Flight 77 at the Pentagon never leveled off; you were lied to again.
We have numerous eyewitnesses reporting officially that there was a low and level, and relatively slow for that matter, approach to the building. We have so many witnesses to this that the obviously fraudulent security camera footage which is part of the official mythos even shows a low and level approach.

You've seen the Pentagon security cam footage, how is that not leveled off?

The dumbest claim is Global Hawk did it... since a Global Hawk is not missing, and Global Hawk does not have the energy to do the damage, or carry the jet fuel which hit the Pentagon. Do you post lies on purpose, or what?
Remember, it's my conclusion the damage was primarily done by bombs within, but apart from that...

Why is global hawk the dumbest claim? Global Hawk can't go 483.5 knots, big fail. Giant BS claim. Where do you get this BS from?

I won't rest my hat on the Global Hawk, but I definitely did read a compelling article discussing the parts found on scene matching a Global Hawk (don't remember specifically where atm).
 
... the Global Hawk which was crashed on scene to simulate a larger aircraft?

Such BS is based on massive lack of knowledge. Where did you find this failed lie? Why do you repeat nonsense?

The impact of 77 was equal to 1200 pounds of TNT, and the damage to the Pentagon is consistent with a 757 impact equal to 1200 pounds of TNT.
http://911research.wtc7.net/cache/pentagon/official/asce_pentagon.pdf lol, a 911 truth web site sources the Pentagon performance report, which debunks the BS you keep posting... irony

The Global Hawk at top speed would be an impact equal in energy to 106 pounds of TNT, and not enough energy to do the Kinetic Energy impact damage the Pentagon suffered due to a 757, Flight 77.

The proof it was 77 was Radar data from over 5 independent Radar systems... Did you know 5 Radars were tracking the final impact of 77? No? Yes? maybe? Why can't 911 truth understand science, and Radar?

You got BS. Is spreading lies which might help idiots like the Boston bombers feel better about their actions against Americans a good thing to do?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom