Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.

There is no "loopdeloop", it was a less than standard turn to get down in altitude, he showed up in the DC area too high to make a normal 3 to 4 degree impact at the Pentagon, so he had to do a "360 turn to get down", it is what pilots do when they fail to plan a proper straight in decent to be down in time to land, it is a penalty box kind of maneuver, for bad pilots.

You say the Pentagon is some giant Bullseye, yet you fell for the BS of pilots can't hit it! Which is it, giant Bullseye, or a hard target to hit? Make up your mind on what it is, and stop falling for BS from 911 truth idiots.

How can Hani hit the roof? Explain in detail, decent angles, speed, and more on how he can just hit the roof and skip the loopdeloop, which was actually a let down turn... What angle... BTW, at 6 degrees down, a 767/757 would be over speed in a few seconds and be unrecoverable passing MACH 1 quickly... did you do the physics before playing the dive bomber BS card?

Do you know the angle we land at? Do you know the angle at top speed clean we descend at?

Where do you get the loopdeloop BS from?

As for replicating the impact of Hani? We do it every time we land, we hit a target very precisely, and land almost exactly in the same touchdown zone on the runway, where there are a bunch of skid marks from tires.
We have no clue where Hani was trying to hit and he was only 40 feet from impacting the highway before hitting the Pentagon a second and a half later.

We have the flight data recorder (FDR) for 77, and it shows a poor pilot crashing at 483.5 knots at Full Throttle. You have BS from 911 truth; incredibly stupid claims based on nonsense.
 
Last edited:
The "Programmed Flight Control" page on 911research.wtc7 does have sources that say that a Boeing 757 and 767 can be remote controlled with their "flight management computer system".
...

No.
You can automate certain flight programs (there is, after all, an autopilot), but the Boeings in the service of United Airlines and American Airlines most certainly had no capacity to wrest control from the pilot and be actually remotely controlled.

Your huge problem here is that both American Airlines and Boeing would of course have known perfectly well if RC had been possible with the particular airframe that did flight AA77 on 9/11. That means the pilots, the maintenance crews, etc. We are talking about a substantial number of individuals. Such a system, if it had existed, would have required FAA certification, which of course wasn't issued - still more individuals that would be in the know.

Why would AA cover up for remote controlled murder?
Why would AA's insureres cover up for remote controlled murder?
Why would Boeing cover up for remote controlled murder?

RC also solves none of the other problems that Truthers love to blab about:
- The "impossible speed" - RC doesn't make the airframe stronger
- The "ground effect" - RC doesn't affect fluid mechanics
- The angle of attack - the same reasons you claim for a human pilot to choose a diving attack would also apply to a RC approach
- The 300° turn - it was so wobbly and uneven - that was not at all how a computer flies a plane
 
The "Programmed Flight Control" page on 911research.wtc7 does have sources that say that a Boeing 757 and 767 can be remote controlled with their "flight management computer system".

Unless the hijacker pilots couldn't see that well, they could have descended down to hit The Pentagon on the roof without having to pass it and make that turn.

That is not remote control, it is control systems in the cockpit. The 767/757 can't be remote controlled outside the cockpit. Where do you get this BS? From 911 truth nut web pages, like 911research web pages, which are open loop BS.

Oh, Hani trained to hit the Pentagon from 20,000 feet straight down, or at an angle you can't supply due to making this up as you go, or plagiarizing what nuts in 911 truth come up with.

The 757 will not like being nosed over to 40 degrees down, and the aircraft will pitch up... how will you point the nose down for a dive angle never used in a 757? Normal angles for decent are 3 to 5 degrees, and anything over 4 degrees needs drag; the 757 will glide without engines at 300 knots at 3 degrees down...
Why would a pilot who is use to 2 to 3 degrees for decent not use what is normal, what he knows, he never trained to go straight down, or an angle you can't explain.

Its not an aviation term , Beach?
:D
Yes, I have done many "loopdeloops"...

He did not do a loopdeloop, he did a decent in a turn; a boring over 3 minute turn, which he did to get down.

As for the loopdeloop, I did loops at 3-5gs, in the vertical, in "my" T-38... US tax dollars at work (over 40 years ago)

DSC_5718%20pilot%20training.jpg



You said that aiming right for the roof in a "steep dive" would be more difficult than hitting the side. The clips from Italian television in September 11: The New Pearl Harbor has experienced pilots giving the opposite opinion. Then, there's the part in Jesse Ventura's show where they couldn't get close to replicating the path of Flight 77 in a full motion flight simulator no matter how many times they tried. Since experiment is the arbitrator of competing hypotheses, more examples of full motion simulator experiments would be a better way of settling the question than carefully selected individuals giving their opinion (professional or not). In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.

What a load of BS. It is easy to hit the Pentagon. But to fly like an idiot like Hani and try to replicate a BS flight path flow by a suicide pilot is silly nonsense.
The proof the Pentagon can be hit by pilots in their first real heavy jet flight, is proved by flight 11 hitting a 207 foot wide WTC tower, and flight 175 doing the same. Two first time heavy jet murderers hit 207 foot wide targets, and here you can't figure out it was easier to hit 900 foot wide Pentagon. Kind of anti-logic.

No one needs to replicate the poor flying of Hani. It is easy to hit a 900 foot wide Pentagon, and presenting BS pilots who can't is poof of nonsense.

What is hard about hitting the Pentagon?

If you missed it, someone did fly a simulator and hit the Pentagon with no problems.

Landing on a runway is much harder than hitting the Pentagon.

Landing requires an exact speed, crashing into the Pentagon can be at any speed from stall, to over Vd.
Landing requires an exact attitude, where as crashing can be from upside down to any attitude you can think of.
Landing requires an exact course, and hitting the Pentagon can be done at any angle, and course.
Thus pilots who can't hit the Pentagon, must not be able to land, because crashing is infinitely easier than landing as explained.

Thus you are asking the wrong people about this. Why are there pilots who can't do something simple able to fool you into thinking a poor pilot did the impossible, when crashing as proved by me is infinity easier than landing; are your pilots you believe (you were fooled by) unable to land?


How can pilot who never flew heavy jets, fly heavy jets okay the first time?

I never flew heavy jets before 1976, yet in January 1976 I flew a heavy jet for the first time and with zero time in a heavy jet I performed a perfect landing in a heavy jet the first time, and I had less time than the terrorists pilots had in small planes... Gee, how did I do it!
You have been fooled by a fringe few into thinking the poor flying done on 911 was some fantastic maneuver and now you can't handle the truth.

You have been bamboozled with BS about loopdeloop, and have no clue what a loopdeloop is. You have fallen for the BS of 911 truth.

And you can't provide any thing about 911 not explained, and never will. You are so sure there is something, but you can't come up with it.


TGIF
 
Last edited:
I don't know, if the justification for Hanjour's feats mostly rely on luck,



That right there is the problem. Dave wasn't talking about "luck", he was talking about randomness. Discussing luck implies that he wanted to hit this particular place out of all the places in the world he could have potentially hit. Randomness implies no such thing: Had he been able to fly the same approach a hundred times, he would have hit in a hundred different places, but he'd still have hit something.

The only reason to suppose that where he actually hit is exactly where he intended to hit is if you're presupposing that he had the motivations the CTers ascribe to him, which is putting the cart before the horse.
 
... In that sense, I probably shouldn't have even bothered commenting because nobody here would want to set up an experiment like that.
? There is no need to prove what was done; the FDR proves it was done, as does all physical evidence. What is your point? You found pilots who lied to you.

Pilots land everyday on runways, only 200 to 40 feet wide... why do we need to set up an experiment to prove what pilots do everyday. New pilots land first time on a runway, first time... I landed first time I flew a heavy jet on center-line, on-speed. What is your point?

You have the opinion of pilots who can't fly a simulator and hit a 900 foot wide target Hani hit. Kind of sad for the pilots who fall for 911 truth lies.

The FDR from 77 proves it was hand flown. Control Column Position and Control Wheel Position prove 77 was hand flown into the Pentagon. The BS 911 truth nutty pilots can't fly as good/bad as Hani, and they brag about it.

Hard to find pilots who brag about how their best pilot skills are not up to task of the worse pilot skills of a failed human, a low down murderer pilot, Hani, the super pilot who flew poorly on 911, and the super pilots you trust and believe can't do what Hani did. Now that is special.

There is nothing stopping you from renting simulator time and trying it yourself. The task is not to replicate Hani's flight path, the task is to hit the Pentagon.

Less than a second before impact, the terrorist pilot was pushing on the "stick".

This is not a loopdeloop.
aa77_final_maneuver.png

This is a less than standard rate turn, characterized by poor bank control, poor airspeed control, and poor planning. Who called this a loopdeloop?
Plus, Hani never flew around the Pentagon to hit the west face, he essentially hit the same side he was lined up to "hit" before the "drop down turn". Thus he did not maneuver to hit a different side, he hit the side he was lined up to "hit" in the first place.
 
I may have retired from interweb forum debate of 9/11 CT nonsense but I can still stop in every now and again and enjoy me some beechnut :D
 
Yes. The Dutch documentary program Zembla aired this in September 2006:
http://zembla.vara.nl/seizoenen/2006/afleveringen/10-09-2006

A low-quality copy with English subtitles is on YouTube. The bit where a guy with only small plane experience hit the Pentagon three times in three tries starts at 27:40 seconds:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Li89cUQNHZ4&t=27m41s


This is the same program, by the way, that so many Truthers quote from when they take Dutch explosive demolitions expert Danny Jowenko as their witness that WTC7 was a controlled demolition (starting 46:44), so it can't be said that Truthers never heard of this program. They just never tell you this important truth about the flight 77 simulation. Just like they never ever tell you that the same Danny Jowenko, in the same interview, starting at 32:19, explains why WTC1+2 collapses were definitely caused by fire, and why explosives were not possible. This example should teach you to never ever trust Truther films and Truther websites - they are willfully ignorant.


I don't know if you've seen September 11: The New Pearl Harbor, but the simulation from Dutch television isn't similar to the actual Pentagon attack because their approach is at a much higher angle, not low enough to clip light poles. The TV program also doesn't say what speed their simulated plane was flying. The simulation experiment on Jesse Ventura's show seems more accurate.
 
Last edited:
? There is no need to prove what was done; the FDR proves it was done, as does all physical evidence. What is your point? You found pilots who lied to you.

Pilots land everyday on runways, only 200 to 40 feet wide... why do we need to set up an experiment to prove what pilots do everyday. New pilots land first time on a runway, first time... I landed first time I flew a heavy jet on center-line, on-speed. What is your point?

You have the opinion of pilots who can't fly a simulator and hit a 900 foot wide target Hani hit. Kind of sad for the pilots who fall for 911 truth lies.

The FDR from 77 proves it was hand flown. Control Column Position and Control Wheel Position prove 77 was hand flown into the Pentagon. The BS 911 truth nutty pilots can't fly as good/bad as Hani, and they brag about it.

Hard to find pilots who brag about how their best pilot skills are not up to task of the worse pilot skills of a failed human, a low down murderer pilot, Hani, the super pilot who flew poorly on 911, and the super pilots you trust and believe can't do what Hani did. Now that is special.

There is nothing stopping you from renting simulator time and trying it yourself. The task is not to replicate Hani's flight path, the task is to hit the Pentagon.

Less than a second before impact, the terrorist pilot was pushing on the "stick".

This is not a loopdeloop.
[qimg]http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/aa77_final_maneuver.png[/qimg]
This is a less than standard rate turn, characterized by poor bank control, poor airspeed control, and poor planning. Who called this a loopdeloop?
Plus, Hani never flew around the Pentagon to hit the west face, he essentially hit the same side he was lined up to "hit" before the "drop down turn". Thus he did not maneuver to hit a different side, he hit the side he was lined up to "hit" in the first place.

Oh, I see. This whole time I thought Flight 77 passed by The Pentagon, and then the plane turned around to hit the opposite side. As for the "poor control", it apparently got the job done.
 
Conspiracy logic at work:

AA Flight 77 flew a complicated, wobbly path into the Pentagon. Ergo, Hani Hanjour, an inexperienced pilot, couldn't have flown the plane. :rolleyes:

But consider the alternate scenario: Flight 77 flies a straight and true path into the Pentagon. But how could Hani Hanjour, an inexperienced pilot, have flown such a perfect course? Ergo, Hanjour couldn't have been at the controls. It must have been a drone-type aircraft flying a preset course. :boggled:
 
And also, he didn't "hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts," because there was no such thing. The Pentagon was renovated in wedges, and Hanjour hit the junction between the renovated wedge and one of the un-renovated ones. And he didn't "loopdeloop", he made a turn.

Incidentally, the odds of choosing a side that was half renovated were therefore 40%. Not exactly implausible.

Dave

If you were to make a diagram of where exactly The Pentagon was recently renovated, where would it be? Like, if you were to use MS Paint to highlight the part on a picture?
 
Conspiracy logic at work:

AA Flight 77 flew a complicated, wobbly path into the Pentagon. Ergo, Hani Hanjour, an inexperienced pilot, couldn't have flown the plane. :rolleyes:

But consider the alternate scenario: Flight 77 flies a straight and true path into the Pentagon. But how could Hani Hanjour, an inexperienced pilot, have flown such a perfect course? Ergo, Hanjour couldn't have been at the controls. It must have been a drone-type aircraft flying a preset course. :boggled:

Doesn't look that "wobbly" to me on the 9/11 Commission animation or cjnewson88's simulation of the flight path on Youtube. It looks like it could've gradually lowered itself so it could easily fly onto the roof, but instead made a turn to get itself as level to the ground as possible to hit the wall. In my eyes, like trying to aim for the side of a dartboard.
 
Oh, I see. This whole time I thought Flight 77 passed by The Pentagon, and then the plane turned around to hit the opposite side. As for the "poor control", it apparently got the job done.

It is called crashing, it takes zero skill.

As for simulators, (aka some) many are not very good, and they automatically crash when you exceed the limits of the plane, which is not reality. For a fly by I accidentally flew past Vmo (the top speed you are allowed to operate your aircraft) and the plane did not fall apart, and it actually flew great, very good control, and I slowed down because I was rapidly catching the other planes, aka the SR-71, who were going 300 KIAS...
The KC-135 simulator sucked, and it required you to "fly" the simulator, and was not as stable as the aircraft. The simulator was used to teach us emergency procedures, not an accurate flight characteristics model.

The simulators have to have a good aero model to be accurate. I found the flight parameter in computer simulators are very good, where as old simulators are not as good.

We can't trust a fringe few pilots who say they can't do it... I have flown heavy jets (jets which can fly at 300,000 pounds and over) since 1976. The pilots who say it is impossible know better, and I can't explain why they lied to you and mislead people. Why do they lie?

The fact is you don't have to replicate Hani's flight path, you only have to hit the 900 plus foot wide Pentagon.


As for the turn; yes 911 truth lie and show a flight path circling the Pentagon, but the real flight path was not circling the Pentagon, it was a turn to get down from altitude. It is what a pilot would do, and Hani had over 250 hours flying. Most people could fly better than Hanit without training, but then I was a Santa Claus Evaluator, and a better instructor than I am a blogger... nicer... instructors have to tailor their instruction to the student, unlike people who are fooled by liars and BS artist, aka 911 truth.

Did the dolts who could not hit the Pentagon fly a real full aero model 767/757? Have you every solved and linearize the equation of motion for a plane? I have... unless the simulator has the full range aero model, trying to go do the speed and flying on 911 becomes BS. (okay, I copied the equations of motion for flight from my professor)... engineering is fun... but not good if you want to party at college.

ironically flight simulator and other programs are very good for flying parameters... but planes do not stop flying at Vmo, or Vd...

FDR shows the pilot was making the inputs to fly the plane... do you have a copy of the FDR?

lol, do you miss the dart board on a regular basis? A 70 foot high dart board which is over 900 feet wide on top? What is the point? Pilots hit an imaginary point 35 feet above the runway threshold everyday, and they do it within a few feet, a target which is an aim-point down the runway. Which works out to an imaginary point 35 feet above the runway threshold.


Doesn't look that "wobbly" to me ...

Did you know bad landing look okay from outside the cockpit, but inside the cockpit they look terrible.

Some idiot general made us film landing, and the bad landings on video tape did not look bad; it takes a full blown crash landing to look bad on video tape, or to a person not trained.
We land at 2 to 3 degrees, it is hard to see what looks bad when looking from the outside the cockpit.

When "we" look at the FDR, we see the terrorist pilot was not as "smooth" as the trained experienced airline pilot.

This is from Flight 77, and is typical of airline pilot vs terrorist pilot bank control... From the FDR, real data, not BS from dolt pilots who can't fly as good or bad as Hani did on 911...
11BankAnglecompare.jpg
 
Last edited:
Doesn't look that "wobbly" to me on the 9/11 Commission animation or cjnewson88's simulation of the flight path on Youtube. It looks like it could've gradually lowered itself so it could easily fly onto the roof, but instead made a turn to get itself as level to the ground as possible to hit the wall. In my eyes, like trying to aim for the side of a dartboard.
Hold on a second. You asked this...
Are there any examples of someone replicating the maneuvers of Flight 77 using a full motion cockpit simulator?

With The Pentagon basically being a giant bullseye from a terrorist's point of view, why would Hani Hanjour choose to attack the side?

Otherwise, I could just doubt that Hani would feel the need to loopdeloop around to hit the exact side that was renovated for blast/missile impacts. He could've just hit the roof without risking precious minutes.
And I said yes I have done it. Now that you are confronted with someone who has actually done it, you are avoiding the issue. I put it to you that you did not expect that members here have capabilities and access to the appropriate facilities to do the very thing that you thought nobody here would be able to answer.

Instead, you have chosen to run for cover with "it looks like" and "it seems to me" and such like dodges. You have already admitted right out that you are ignorant of all matters aviation and the last thing you really wanted was to happen upon anyone who had done the very thing you demanded. That is why you are avoiding me, isn't it?

YOU asked had anyone done it, well, here I am. I have done it. What are you afraid of? There are very good reasons why a steep dive would be a very bad move. When one has that level of access to that level of gear you bet your sweet bippy one will try out all manner of scenario at every opportunity. Before you ask, yes, we tried the nose dive scenario for curiousity because we all knew it would fail, but anyway, what happens is you build speed rapidly, rip off the control surfaces in very short order leaving you with pretty much no directional control and hit the ground as much as 5 miles off target or more. Now there were three of us and we all had a go several times. What Hanjour did scored a 100% hit rate. The preposterous "dive bomb" scenario scored exactly 0%. We all knew this would likely be the result beforehand but gave it a whirl anyway.

Not only did you find out that many have actually done so, you found yourself with someone who actually has done so talking right back at you in this very thread. The moment that happened, you realised you were sunk without a trace so you ducked for cover and ran.

Do you now retract your nonsense claim?
 
Doesn't look that "wobbly" to me on the 9/11 Commission animation or cjnewson88's simulation of the flight path on Youtube.
Here's the 3D view of the turn (with height amplified to better see the "bumps").

Julio-descenso2.PNG



It looks like it could've gradually lowered itself so it could easily fly onto the roof, but instead made a turn to get itself as level to the ground as possible to hit the wall. In my eyes, like trying to aim for the side of a dartboard.
He was too high when he started the turn; if he descended at the necessary angle, his speed would have increased to a point where the plane might have been uncontrollable. So he descended, and descended too much. As a result, he was close to crashing against the floor.
 
I don't know if you've seen September 11: The New Pearl Harbor, but the simulation from Dutch television isn't similar to the actual Pentagon attack because their approach is at a much higher angle, not low enough to clip light poles. The TV program also doesn't say what speed their simulated plane was flying. The simulation experiment on Jesse Ventura's show seems more accurate.
So you are claiming they meant to do these things and have to be duplicated to prove it happened?

Do you know what the "Texas sharpshooter fallacy" is? You are posting a text book example.
 
I don't know if you've seen September 11: The New Pearl Harbor, but the simulation from Dutch television isn't similar to the actual Pentagon attack because their approach is at a much higher angle, not low enough to clip light poles. The TV program also doesn't say what speed their simulated plane was flying. The simulation experiment on Jesse Ventura's show seems more accurate.

As has been explained to you ad nauseam: There was nothing precise about Hani Hanjour's approach: He came in somehow, flew erratically, corrected flight parameters a lot like bad pilots do, and hit the Pentagon essentially randomly. He never intended to clip light poles, never intended to fly so low, he just did for no reason at all, barely avoiding an earlier crash.
Had he by random chance come in 300 feet higher (his altitude after the loop was essentially random, as he had such poor control of descent and turn rates) he might have almost overflown the Pentagon and hit the roof or the far side of the court or whatever, and Ventura, the fool, would be trying to replicate that path.

You have been advised to educate yourself on the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy
Read it. Now. Report back what you have learned and how you now understand that and how Ventura, the fool, committed the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.
 
As has been explained to you ad nauseam: There was nothing precise about Hani Hanjour's approach: He came in somehow, flew erratically, corrected flight parameters a lot like bad pilots do, and hit the Pentagon essentially randomly. He never intended to clip light poles, never intended to fly so low, he just did for no reason at all, barely avoiding an earlier crash.
Had he by random chance come in 300 feet higher (his altitude after the loop was essentially random, as he had such poor control of descent and turn rates) he might have almost overflown the Pentagon and hit the roof or the far side of the court or whatever, and Ventura, the fool, would be trying to replicate that path.

You have been advised to educate yourself on the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy
Read it. Now. Report back what you have learned and how you now understand that and how Ventura, the fool, committed the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy.

Exactly, and Hani was forced to fly this way because this is how the plane would fly and react under the conditions Hani made happen.
 
Doesn't look that "wobbly" to me on the 9/11 Commission animation or cjnewson88's simulation of the flight path on Youtube. It looks like it could've gradually lowered itself so it could easily fly onto the roof, but instead made a turn to get itself as level to the ground as possible to hit the wall. In my eyes, like trying to aim for the side of a dartboard.
From a mile away a telephone pole can look pencil sharp.

I used to have to charter small float planes to get to remote communications sites. On hot days it gets real bumpy up there. However to watch from the ground you really have to concentrate to even see the wings wobbling let alone the dips and rises.

However flt77, the turn itself should, for an experienced pilot, be a circle. Look at the flightpath, it isnt a circle, its oblong, meaning that bank angle was not constant, meaning the pilot wasnt that good. Then when one examines the fdr one notes this exact thing, the pilot kept making adjustments to bank angle and pitch and heading.
So yeah it actually does look wobbly.

If you try to aim directly at the exact point and follow the exact path that Hanjour followed, yeah it will be difficult. Here's a thought experiment: I'll shoot at a target from 100 meters then you step up and try to put your bullet through my bullet hole. Difficult? Yep sharpshooter stuff. But I didnt need to be a sharpshooter to make that first hole. However if all we ask you to do is hit the target it gets a lot easier, exactly as easy as it was for me.
 
Last edited:
beachnut,

Could you walk me through how the hijackers plotted their course? Does the black box hold data about coordinates being entered after the hijacking?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom