Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

beachnut,

Could you walk me through how the hijackers plotted their course? Does the black box hold data about coordinates being entered after the hijacking?
This would be easy. You enter a compass heading into the auto pilot (heading hold) and after that put the big building in the windshield. He screwed up the approach altitude and had to do a sloppy descending turn.

They had to know how to read a map (and look out the window).

Would you find this difficult?

ETA: Not answering for beachnut but, that's the jist of it.
 
Last edited:
beachnut,

Could you walk me through how the hijackers plotted their course? Does the black box hold data about coordinates being entered after the hijacking?

This is cool... You are going west to SF or LA on a domestic flight. You want to take the plane and crash it into the Pentagon or WTC. Guess what direction you need to go? EAST

Plus the murderers, the 19 nuts, the pilots, got the directions for the 767/757 and they understood VORs... thus they could if they tried set the autopilot to track to the VOR next to the WTC, or Pentagon.

As a pilot, I would head east and look for the WTC. The WTC tower would be visible over 200 miles from altitude, thus a simple VFR maneuver.

Do you understand VOR? Pilots are taught ( at least in the "old" days) to use VOR, and they can set the VOR and an arrow points to the VOR in the cockpit, and you turn the plane east, and follow the VOR. BINGO - a kid with less than 40 hours flying time can do this... I did it, and the failed humans, the terrorists pilots did it too... they had more than 40 hours flying time, and were taught how to use VOR.

The terrorists had the instructions for 767/757 flight systems; but I am saying it is easy to use VORs and VFR flight rules to find your target, or simple DR, called dead reckoning, the very basic flight navigation.

What would you do?

Thus if you are heading west, which is known... you turn east and decide what you will do; figure out the 757/767 nav system, or use RAW VOR, or use VFR, and see the WTC sticking up 200 miles away...

I was good at navigation, or lucky, but on 911 with flight going west, how hard is it to turn east, and find your target? This is not Atlanta where there are infinite Peachtree streets to figure out, it is an east west problem. Even a Marine can do better on nav than the failed humans, terrorist pilots... right

(actually in 2001 GPS was going, i would have a GPS set for the WTC or Pentagon, and follow the yellow brick road, i love to take the easy way backed up with logic and knowledge... I did have a GPS and I used it to back up my VOR and DR as I flew all over the West coast with my single engine planes at the end of my USAF career flying small planes as CAP liaison for the USAF... and my cell phone did work in flight, but the noise was ... )

I think the FDR does have info for which VORs were tuned in... by frequency. For 77, it was the VOR right next to the Pentagon.
 
Last edited:
beachnut,

Could you walk me through how the hijackers plotted their course?
Easy. Initially, follow the logged flight plan so nobody notices or has any reason to suspect a hijacked airliner. Obey all ATC instructions. When ready, log the VOR/DME waypoints into your FMC which will guide you to your target, set transponder to off so nobody know who you are for sure, disengage AP at the last minute, hit building. It isn't rocket magic. A moron could do it.

Does the black box hold data about coordinates being entered after the hijacking?
There is no such thing as a "black box". There are orange boxes. In the case of 911, some very few were retrieved and some were destroyed as would be expected. Nevertheless, you are falling into the pothole of thinking that all ORANGE boxes are equal. They are not. You could investigate that. I know you won't bother because that's how you rock.
 
This would be easy. You enter a compass heading into the auto pilot (heading hold) and after that put the big building in the windshield. He screwed up the approach altitude and had to do a sloppy descending turn.

They had to know how to read a map (and look out the window).

Would you find this difficult?

ETA: Not answering for beachnut but, that's the jist of it.

On a VFR day (clear and a million) you turn east, hit big buildings. Can't believe they wasted money on learning how to fly...

In Hani's case he was a failed pilot, unable to get hired in the short term; most likely helped him hate the US... and become an idiot for UBL.

If I had to to do 911, I would have used a handheld GPS, and avoided learning the BS 757/767 systems which would be a royal waste of time based on my mission...

It appears the nuts actually used 767/757 systems so they could track to the VORs and use the flight nav systems. A waste based on the GPS available at the time. I used a GPS to back up my nav during the same time period, but flew the VOR flight routes, using the GPS as back up.

As I said before; pilots are trained in their first 40 hours of flight to use VOR, and thus the nav on 911 is a non issue since all the dolt pilots for UBL murdering plot were trained with many more than 40 hours...
We tune in the VOR, and the arrow points to the VOR... simple stuff even pilots can do.

How do you know there is a pilot at your party...
 
Firstly, MicahJava, welcome to the forum.
You may be wondering why you are getting the reaction you are. This is because, for one thing, these same questions have been raised and answered repeatedly over the years, so there is a certain sense of exasperation at having to do the same old thing over and over again. Unpleasant, but understandable.
Another reason is the unfortunately all-too-predictable response from the "earnestly questioning truthers" that turn up here from time to time. At first, it looks like a request for input and information from knowledgeable sources. However, it all-too-often becomes clear that the questioner has no intention of accepting or processing any of the answers, but is actually a dyed-in-the-wool conspiracy theorist, immune to facts and intent only on trying to score points against the shills and sheeple they imagine frequent this forum.
The fact that this has happened so many times has also made some of the members here somewhat jaded and suspicious, especially as it is beginning to look like you are doing this too. You have had, for example, links to successful simulations from myself and other people, as well as input from actual, seasoned pilots. I urge you to examine their evidence with an open mind and balance it against that of Jesse Ventura, Balsamo etc. I did this myself some time ago, and was shocked at just how dishonest and ignorant the "Truthers" actually were. This is not about ideology- I am no supporter of the US, or any government per se. Governments, like people in all walks of life, are capable of good as well as evil, and I personally consider Dick Cheney to be the embodiment of evil on earth. However, I think it is vital to look at each case on its own evidence, and make a judgement on that alone. Look at what has been shown to you here, with an open mind. Your responses so far have rung warning bells here: you are holding up your speculations and gut feelings against solid facts, which makes it look like you are not really looking for information. Please prove me wrong!
If you fail to take in what is being said to you here, the tone of the discussion is likely to worsen, for the reasons I have given above, and I don't think anyone (OK, with the possible exception of Beachnut- no offence mate!) really wants that.
Now, here's a question for you:
If the Pentagon attacks were faked, why would the conspirators deliberately create an impossible scenario? Why go to all the trouble to fake a plane crash that no plane or pilot could accomplish? Why not either fake a plausible flight path, or, and way easier, simply use a real plane?
 
Firstly, MicahJava, welcome to the forum.
You may be wondering why you are getting the reaction you are. This is because, for one thing, these same questions have been raised and answered repeatedly over the years, so there is a certain sense of exasperation at having to do the same old thing over and over again. Unpleasant, but understandable.
Another reason is the unfortunately all-too-predictable response from the "earnestly questioning truthers" that turn up here from time to time. At first, it looks like a request for input and information from knowledgeable sources. However, it all-too-often becomes clear that the questioner has no intention of accepting or processing any of the answers, but is actually a dyed-in-the-wool conspiracy theorist, immune to facts and intent only on trying to score points against the shills and sheeple they imagine frequent this forum.
The fact that this has happened so many times has also made some of the members here somewhat jaded and suspicious, especially as it is beginning to look like you are doing this too. You have had, for example, links to successful simulations from myself and other people, as well as input from actual, seasoned pilots. I urge you to examine their evidence with an open mind and balance it against that of Jesse Ventura, Balsamo etc. I did this myself some time ago, and was shocked at just how dishonest and ignorant the "Truthers" actually were. This is not about ideology- I am no supporter of the US, or any government per se. Governments, like people in all walks of life, are capable of good as well as evil, and I personally consider Dick Cheney to be the embodiment of evil on earth. However, I think it is vital to look at each case on its own evidence, and make a judgement on that alone. Look at what has been shown to you here, with an open mind. Your responses so far have rung warning bells here: you are holding up your speculations and gut feelings against solid facts, which makes it look like you are not really looking for information. Please prove me wrong!
If you fail to take in what is being said to you here, the tone of the discussion is likely to worsen, for the reasons I have given above, and I don't think anyone (OK, with the possible exception of Beachnut- no offence mate!) really wants that.
Now, here's a question for you:
If the Pentagon attacks were faked, why would the conspirators deliberately create an impossible scenario? Why go to all the trouble to fake a plane crash that no plane or pilot could accomplish? Why not either fake a plausible flight path, or, and way easier, simply use a real plane?

This is truth, reality, and more. my shout
 
As beachy says, the towers are visible 200 miles away
They are the tallest structures on the horizon with ocean beyond them.

The Pentagon is enormous laterally, lies alongside a major waterway, is located within a mile of a VOR/DME , is bookended by large parking lots,and is a very distinctive shape.

The towers represent American wealth and economic power. The Pentagon represents American military power.

So the buildings hit are both very identifiable from the air and representative if a form of American power.

There was a fourth plane of course. Stands to reason its target was also a large identifiable building representative of a form of American power. The Whitehouse? Maybe, but its not really that big and hidden by trees on some sides.
My sincere feeling is that its target was the Capitol Building. Its huge, distinctively shaped and represents American political power as much as does the Whitehouse.
 
Last edited:
Here's the 3D view of the turn (with height amplified to better see the "bumps").

[qimg]http://11-s.eu.org/11-s/Julio-descenso2.PNG[/qimg]



He was too high when he started the turn; if he descended at the necessary angle, his speed would have increased to a point where the plane might have been uncontrollable. So he descended, and descended too much. As a result, he was close to crashing against the floor.


That 3D illustration is impressive. I am definitely more open to the planes being controlled by the hijackers.
 
That 3D illustration is impressive. I am definitely more open to the planes being controlled by the hijackers.

Most people require overwhelming evidence to go against an accepted theory that's backed by ample contrary evidence.

Your approach (and that of most Truthers) is to start with an extravagant counter-theory backed by nothing but speculation, then demand overwhelming contrary evidence. Then, often, reject that very evidence.

Doesn't it occur to you that the tail is wagging your dog? That the planes were controlled by hijackers is the default position, and all evidence supports it. Why do you actively look for reasons to disbelieve? Why were you ever closed to the planes being controlled by hijackers?
 
Most people require overwhelming evidence to go against an accepted theory that's backed by ample contrary evidence.

Your approach (and that of most Truthers) is to start with an extravagant counter-theory backed by nothing but speculation, then demand overwhelming contrary evidence. Then, often, reject that very evidence.

Doesn't it occur to you that the tail is wagging your dog? That the planes were controlled by hijackers is the default position, and all evidence supports it. Why do you actively look for reasons to disbelieve? Why were you ever closed to the planes being controlled by hijackers?

That's one approach.
Alternatively, you could be happy that MicahJava is open to the idea of following the evidence and altering his/her opinions as a consequence, rather than continuing to attack them. Support and encouragement will hopefully reinforce this attitude.

Which of these two do you think will produce the most positive results?
 
That's one approach.
Alternatively, you could be happy that MicahJava is open to the idea of following the evidence and altering his/her opinions as a consequence, rather than continuing to attack them. Support and encouragement will hopefully reinforce this attitude.

Which of these two do you think will produce the most positive results?

Starting from where he came in, the latter of course. What I'm wondering is how one gets into the position where such persuasion is necessary. What made him reject the standard, abundantly evidenced, theory in the first place?
 
Your approach (and that of most Truthers) is to start with an extravagant and, practically speaking, impossible counter-theory backed by nothing but speculation, then demand overwhelming contrary evidence. Then, often, reject that very evidence.

FTFY. It's been established well beyond reasonable doubt that there was, at least in September 2001, no way of remote controlling standard build Boeing 757s and 767s in the way truthers like to speculate, and it would be practically speaking impossible to conjure up replacement airliners and substitute them in the way that some other truthers like to speculate; yet they act as though the burden of proof is on those who disagree with the impossible.

Dave
 
Starting from where he came in, the latter of course. What I'm wondering is how one gets into the position where such persuasion is necessary. What made him reject the standard, abundantly evidenced, theory in the first place?

The mentality and psychology of the basis of conspiratorial beliefs has been discussed extensively on this forum. I suggest you start your research there, rather than launching an attack against a single poster. All you will succeed in doing is alienating someone of a type we really should be helping and encouraging in their attempts to be more critical and less gullible and blinkered in their thinking.
MicahJava: in essence I agree with GlennB's opinion, but differ in the approach. It is my hope that you will learn how to distinguish ignorance from knowledge, and fact from propaganda, much as I did. This forum is invaluable for that: I have learned so much, and so am eager for others to do the same.
 
That 3D illustration is impressive. I am definitely more open to the planes being controlled by the hijackers.
You can even notice how the plane ascends rather than descending at some points. That is noticeable in the simulated flight path too.

The bottom line is that not being able to see it doesn't mean it's not so. We're not experts in many fields, and relying on someone else's expertise to let us see what we couldn't by ourselves is one way to go.

And even then one needs to be careful with whom to ask. Does the expert hold views on the subject that could bias the expert opinion? If so, then it's better to check with experts on both sides, if you can't check with an unbiased one. Now you're being told two contradictory stories by the experts on both sides of the discussion. I've merely given you one more piece of evidence that should help you make up your mind on which opinion is more plausible. You've also been informed on flaws in the reasoning of the experts you've relied on. The honest proceeding would be to weigh them in disregarding your emotional attachment.

I know, however, that that last bit is especially hard for you because you said this in the thread that this one was split from:
I have a wonderful husband and we both strongly question 9/11 (although we don't involve lasers hehe).
 
That 3D illustration is impressive. I am definitely more open to the planes being controlled by the hijackers.

Who controlled the plane in your fantasy version of 911? Who flew 77 like a failed pilot who can't pass a check ride? It is neat 911 truth pilots can't match the poor flying skills of a failed murderer who could not get hired by the Saudi Airlines. The pilots you found on the Internet or on Jesses's BS show of woo, did not fly a jet as good as a failed pilot who committed suicide.

Your expert pilots are idiots who sell lies about 911 mocking the murder of thousands with BS and fantasy.

Did Jesse do more than BS and sell soap, did he have an explanation which was backed with evidence?
 
There is one thing that anyone thinking about the flight path should wrap their head around:

Flying a large airliner is easy.

Granted, some maneuvers are somewhat complicated:
  • Flying is more difficukt when your plane is damaged
  • Landing is a bit complex and requires planning and practice so you arrive at the correct speed, heading, altitude, attitude
  • Intercepting another plane can be tricky

The hijackers needed to do none of those complicated maneuvers. They had just three things to do:
  1. Navigate to their target area
  2. Descend from cruising altitude to a thousand feet or so
  3. Point the nose at target and crash
These three points are in chronological order as well as in descending order of difficulty.

They did the navigating pretty well. Then again, they had plenty of time to do this.
UA93 never got to do 2. and 3,.
Of the remaining three, only Atta in AA11 did a competent job cooking off altitude in time.
The easiest part was pointing the nose at the target and crash.

Why is it easy to point and hit a target?
Because Boeing (and Airbus and...) do their best to make it easy. They buold really good planes with excellent controls.
It's a safety feature: If it was difficult to fly a plane where the pilots want them to fly, they'd use too much of their brain capacity on basics, and that would make it more difficult to do the other chores.
But flying is easy: As long as you are within a range of reasonable velocities and not going up or down too steeply, the plane will go exactly where you point i to: You pull on the horn - it goes up. You pull more - it goes up more. You push the horn left - you fly left. You push it more left - you fly more left. Essentially, the plane goes where you direct it to.

And that's what all three pilots did who made it to their targets: They pointed and hit - because that is the easiest part of flying.


Think of it that way:
Suppose a teenager had taken a few driving lessons in a car, and then hijacked a bus. Would you doubt that the kid could crash the bus into the bus depot? Or a family residence? Of course he could. Crashing a bus into a building is easy. Parking it accurately may be a problem, avoiding curbs in narrow city streets may be tricky. But crashing a bus is easy, because a bus, like a car, goes where you point it to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom