Split Thread Flight paths and other questions

Lets try this:

A troofer says he has a Rolls Royce car that can do 700mph, a standard production model, road legal in Sweden, that runs on vegetable oil.

I come here to seek clarification. Should I then abandon all talk of Rolls Royce, cars, land speed records or anything else just because something they said is incorrect? Cars exist, Rolls Royce exists, 700mph exists, Sweden exists, vegetable oil exists.

If I then happily talk about whether a car could achieve 700mph with vegetable oil as a fuel source, that does not mean I am crediting the original claim with any validity, simply using it as a launchpad for an evolving discussion. If that discussion confirms that it is theoretically possible to get a car to 700mph using veg oil, that still does not mean we are verifying the original claim, and I will not leap out from behind a shrubbery shouting "gotcha!"

You can be too bloody guarded you know.
My first thought would be if there was any evidence it actually happened...............That's just me.


:)
 
Last edited:
You can be too bloody guarded you know.

Not with the history of this forum. We frequently get people making first posts saying "I've never believed the 9/11 conspiracy theories, but I just wondered about this one thing I read," then within a dozen posts they're ranting about faster than freefall, nanothermite and UAVs painted to look like Boeing 757s, accusing people left and right of being CIA plants, and calling for the summary execution of Dick Cheney. If we're suspicious, it's because that suspicion is usually justified, and if you find it irksome that you get treated the same, it's largely the fault of the procession of liars that have tried to achieve the exact type of Gotcha! you say you won't be looking for.

Dave
 
... I don't know anything about p4t, other than reading a few bits on their website and forums.

There are a few things that even today are still rock-solid indicators of the lack of any Truther common sense, and anyone affording any legitimacy to anything posted over at the Pilots for 9/11 Truth tree fort is one of them.

The latest melt-down is going on there as we speak, led by Mr. 11.2 g himself, Capt Bob. I have a sneaking suspicion his antagonist is someone we have come to know here, but who cares. When the lunatics in the asylum start to flight, pass the popcorn.
 
... I came here asking you about IRS.
Nope... not exactly...
I am not qualified ...
I saw an article on Pilots for 9/11 truth that I think may be spurious, ...

This article referred to INS .
You said INS the first time, but they are the same, sort of. You were right about pilots for truth, they lie and spread BS. Thus you thinking the article is spurious, false, is correct; but more like being misleading.

Your first post was about how...
Does anyone know how they navigated to the Pentagon? Did they simply head East and hope for the Best?
The terrorist nuts trained as pilots, there were two VORs in the 767/757 and the nuts studied the 767/757 planes. We are taught as pilots how to navigate, if you can't, you don't pass.

I have used INS... entered data, and used it for navigation.

...I still don't know how the bloody thing works, because I have never used one. What you have said doesn't gel with what they said, so it sounds like you are talking about two different systems.
Google INS. Expand the acronym if you are confused with the BS web hits which are not "INS"... we don't need more alive terrorists...

... They spoke of a manual input of coordinates, whereas it sounds like you are talking about waiting for something to line up, like when you wait for a compass to stop wiggling, or for a camera to automatically focus.
The INS has to be aligned. You input data, or it is available via the FMS in the 757. You have the IRS use the present position. You said you read the manual page... and why the zero knowledge... do you read what you post.

You put in the best position where you actually are, and let the IRS/INS align. Some navigators wanted as long as possible to let it sit before going to nav mode. Each system has procedures, but google INS and learn what an INS does...
Yes the INS/IRS has to figure out where it is; this is alignment... the more you pay, the better system you can get; but you don't need better, you need to get the job done. look up INS...

If you screw up the present position, like inserting 10 degree off, like 17 south in stead of 7 south, depending on the system, it might warn you it can't do it, or it will be messed up and not track right since the earth model it has is not in the right place you said it was... If you put in a bad starting point in the 757, it appears from the data you pointed to, it will come back with an error, and you have to figure out it was a bad position... and do the 10 minutes of alignment again. And if you are up past 78 north or south, it takes longer, and this was in the data path you supplied. in fact in following the things you presented, one could learn about INS/IRS...
... I understand that the system is inaccurate, and that there is drift over time.
No, it is not inaccurate, sort of. It can drift up to .5 nm per hour... This is not inaccurate. When we used the stars, sun, and the moon for navigation in aircraft, we had to be within 25 NM of our intended position, or we got in some trouble. Thus .5 NM per hour drift gives us many hours before we would be outside the standard for celestial navigation. Thus the INS is super accurate; you take three and let them loose, vote on who is best, and you got great navigation for flying.
You might be mislead by me and others, but you have to think before making the "inaccurate" call, you have to compare it to what is available. Why use it with GPS; because GPS is a signal, INS is self contained... it take little effort to see the reason why we use a system which combines navigation systems.


... But if they say it must be set exactly, and you say it can only be set to within a margin, then it doesn't sound like the same system.
There are specified margins for imputing present position.
The system is the same, you just said the opposite above, sort of.
How will this support your claim the planes were swapped?

... However, it does sound like they are getting their acronyms in a twist, because they tend to talk about manual input, and waiting for it to align. I don't know if it can be both, or if it has to be one or the other.
? Yes, you have to manually input, or use the FMS, if it has a present position you are sitting on.
If your system has a present position for the spot you are at, you use it, or insert it manually, you supplied the reference, read it.

INS, IRS, who cares. The fact is pilots for truth have no clue how accurate an INS/IRS is when it wakes up in nav mode after alignment.
If you read the INS stuff available on like it gets very technical, and even an engineer can see there is no way an INS can wake up with a perfect position. And you can learn why. You are an engineer, you could look up INS stuff and learn, and see the conclusions pilots for truth have are BS.

think of a gyro, three gyros, and align them perfectly in the three planes... You would have to have zero error in alignment of the gyros in three planes to have a perfect position possible (and that would be with perfect gyros, ...), because the gyros are operating on earth, there are problems if you are not exactly lined up... does this make sense? Think about shooting shells in the northern hemisphere, and then shooting the southern hemisphere and forgetting to set the ... look it up...

Next, what is an IMU? lol - how is the swapped plane claim and NIST lying coming along...
 
Nope... not exactly...

You said INS the first time, but they are the same, sort of. You were right about pilots for truth, they lie and spread BS. Thus you thinking the article is spurious, false, is correct; but more like being misleading.

Your first post was about how...

The terrorist nuts trained as pilots, there were two VORs in the 767/757 and the nuts studied the 767/757 planes. We are taught as pilots how to navigate, if you can't, you don't pass.

I have used INS... entered data, and used it for navigation.

Google INS. Expand the acronym if you are confused with the BS web hits which are not "INS"... we don't need more alive terrorists...

The INS has to be aligned. You input data, or it is available via the FMS in the 757. You have the IRS use the present position. You said you read the manual page... and why the zero knowledge... do you read what you post.

You put in the best position where you actually are, and let the IRS/INS align. Some navigators wanted as long as possible to let it sit before going to nav mode. Each system has procedures, but google INS and learn what an INS does...
Yes the INS/IRS has to figure out where it is; this is alignment... the more you pay, the better system you can get; but you don't need better, you need to get the job done. look up INS...

If you screw up the present position, like inserting 10 degree off, like 17 south in stead of 7 south, depending on the system, it might warn you it can't do it, or it will be messed up and not track right since the earth model it has is not in the right place you said it was... If you put in a bad starting point in the 757, it appears from the data you pointed to, it will come back with an error, and you have to figure out it was a bad position... and do the 10 minutes of alignment again. And if you are up past 78 north or south, it takes longer, and this was in the data path you supplied. in fact in following the things you presented, one could learn about INS/IRS...
No, it is not inaccurate, sort of. It can drift up to .5 nm per hour... This is not inaccurate. When we used the stars, sun, and the moon for navigation in aircraft, we had to be within 25 NM of our intended position, or we got in some trouble. Thus .5 NM per hour drift gives us many hours before we would be outside the standard for celestial navigation. Thus the INS is super accurate; you take three and let them loose, vote on who is best, and you got great navigation for flying.
You might be mislead by me and others, but you have to think before making the "inaccurate" call, you have to compare it to what is available. Why use it with GPS; because GPS is a signal, INS is self contained... it take little effort to see the reason why we use a system which combines navigation systems.


There are specified margins for imputing present position.
The system is the same, you just said the opposite above, sort of.
How will this support your claim the planes were swapped?

? Yes, you have to manually input, or use the FMS, if it has a present position you are sitting on.
If your system has a present position for the spot you are at, you use it, or insert it manually, you supplied the reference, read it.

INS, IRS, who cares. The fact is pilots for truth have no clue how accurate an INS/IRS is when it wakes up in nav mode after alignment.
If you read the INS stuff available on like it gets very technical, and even an engineer can see there is no way an INS can wake up with a perfect position. And you can learn why. You are an engineer, you could look up INS stuff and learn, and see the conclusions pilots for truth have are BS.

think of a gyro, three gyros, and align them perfectly in the three planes... You would have to have zero error in alignment of the gyros in three planes to have a perfect position possible (and that would be with perfect gyros, ...), because the gyros are operating on earth, there are problems if you are not exactly lined up... does this make sense? Think about shooting shells in the northern hemisphere, and then shooting the southern hemisphere and forgetting to set the ... look it up...

Next, what is an IMU? lol - how is the swapped plane claim and NIST lying coming along...

Not to mention precession and other quirky things that gyros get up to
 
I'm definately older, possibly wiser, and a damn sight less trusting of official sources and mainstream media, which makes finding out the truth a lot harder.

I thought the whole point was that they couldn't be trusted?? :confused:

You say they have no facts, but you want me to ask them about it?? What am I supposed to do with any answer they might give? Can I trust a liar if he tells me he is telling lies?

I think the point is that it would be advisable, in the interests of fairness and a balanced view, that you treat all media sources with the same level of skepticism. You seem to expect "mainstream media" to have to prove their presentation of the facts, and disprove accusations of agenda-driven bias and lies. It is only fair to subject P4T and their ilk to the same scrutiny.
 
Lets try this:

A troofer says he has a Rolls Royce car that can do 700mph, a standard production model, road legal in Sweden, that runs on vegetable oil.

I come here to seek clarification. Should I then abandon all talk of Rolls Royce, cars, land speed records or anything else just because something they said is incorrect? Cars exist, Rolls Royce exists, 700mph exists, Sweden exists, vegetable oil exists.

If I then happily talk about whether a car could achieve 700mph with vegetable oil as a fuel source, that does not mean I am crediting the original claim with any validity, simply using it as a launchpad for an evolving discussion. If that discussion confirms that it is theoretically possible to get a car to 700mph using veg oil, that still does not mean we are verifying the original claim, and I will not leap out from behind a shrubbery shouting "gotcha!"

You can be too bloody guarded you know.

I would ask those making the claim to support it with evidence.
 
You said you read the manual page... and why the zero knowledge... do you read what you post.

The manual was a pre-flight check list, not an equipment manual. It instructed the pilot that it must be set before every flight.

I think I've got a handle on the situation now, the inertial platform stuff is really interesting, I had no idea that such technology was so old, early ones must have weighed a ton.

So, if I understand correctly, procedurally the pilot should enter the co-ordinates of the gate supplied to him as his starting point as part of his pre-flight checks, however if he skips this step nothing will break.

He then should wait for a full alignment which can take several minutes, but again, nothing prevents him from moving or skipping this step.

P4t claim, that because the data is more than 3000ft off, the data cannot be accepted at face value, however this is very misleading to people with no knowledge of the systems used (which includes me).

Firstly, (unless I'm mistaken), it is unlikely that the coordinates used are going to exactly match the precise placement of the inertial platform, therefore a margin of error is allowed.

Secondly, the 3200ft error they claim as solid proof of something, is within the 0.6 nautical miles error margin of the equipment.

Thirdly, there is human error, if the co-ordinates are slightly out, or are entered incorrectly, then this could explain any divergence. Even rounding errors could affect this.

The last nails in the coffin would be the sensitivity of the equipment, could hitting a pothole, or braking sharply or an impact with a tractor falsely update the IRS?
 
The manual was a pre-flight check list, not an equipment manual. It instructed the pilot that it must be set before every flight.

I think I've got a handle on the situation now, the inertial platform stuff is really interesting, I had no idea that such technology was so old, early ones must have weighed a ton.

So, if I understand correctly, procedurally the pilot should enter the co-ordinates of the gate supplied to him as his starting point as part of his pre-flight checks, however if he skips this step nothing will break.

He then should wait for a full alignment which can take several minutes, but again, nothing prevents him from moving or skipping this step.

P4t claim, that because the data is more than 3000ft off, the data cannot be accepted at face value, however this is very misleading to people with no knowledge of the systems used (which includes me).

Firstly, (unless I'm mistaken), it is unlikely that the coordinates used are going to exactly match the precise placement of the inertial platform, therefore a margin of error is allowed.

Secondly, the 3200ft error they claim as solid proof of something, is within the 0.6 nautical miles error margin of the equipment.

Thirdly, there is human error, if the co-ordinates are slightly out, or are entered incorrectly, then this could explain any divergence. Even rounding errors could affect this.

The last nails in the coffin would be the sensitivity of the equipment, could hitting a pothole, or braking sharply or an impact with a tractor falsely update the IRS?
Couple of quick points

1. The hijackers never had to worry about preflight. They were already in the air before they initiated their plan.

2. The INS/IRS is specifically stablised to avoid that.

3. AP/GPS is easier. And more accurate. If it were me, I would not take the stick manually until the last minute.

Sent from my SM-A300FU using Tapatalk
 
I think the point is that it would be advisable, in the interests of fairness and a balanced view, that you treat all media sources with the same level of skepticism.

And, as I tried to highlight earlier, all accounts from the same source. It's a classic truther technique to quote someone who initially said something that could be construed to support the conspiracy theory, but to reject their later clarification or correction because "they must have got to them." It's a variant on the cherry-picking fallacy, in which evidence is very obviously accepted or rejected according to content rather than credibility of the source.

Dave
 
I think the point is that it would be advisable, in the interests of fairness and a balanced view, that you treat all media sources with the same level of skepticism. You seem to expect "mainstream media" to have to prove their presentation of the facts, and disprove accusations of agenda-driven bias and lies. It is only fair to subject P4T and their ilk to the same scrutiny.

Which is what I thought I was doing. Being skeptical of their claims, and seeking other sources.

If, as seems to be implied, I accepted their claims hook line and sinker, why would I be here asking questions about it? I am actively seeking another source on the subject.

I don't understand what you are trying to say.
 
Couple of quick points

1. The hijackers never had to worry about preflight. They were already in the air before they initiated their plan.
Irrelevant, we have already established that this is not something that would have changed anything on the day, this is information only

2. The INS/IRS is specifically stablised to avoid that.

Avoid what? You have not made it clear what you are replying to. Are you talking about potholes, bumps? The device is sensitive to movement, I personally don't know how sensitive, which is the reason for my question.

3. AP/GPS is easier. And more accurate. If it were me, I would not take the stick manually until the last minute.

Was GPS installed on Flight 77? I haven't got to that part of my questioning yet, but I suppose now is as good a time as any to introduce it.
 
Irrelevant, we have already established that this is not something that would have changed anything on the day, this is information only

Then I suggest you find a good Web Site (other than pfffff) to find answers to your questions. Here are a couple of good sites...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_navigation_system
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/tech_ops/read.main/197009/

Avoid what? You have not made it clear what you are replying to. Are you talking about potholes, bumps? The device is sensitive to movement, I personally don't know how sensitive, which is the reason for my question.

Now, this is just silly. No wonder you're not being taken seriously. The IRS/INS is designed to navigate in the AIR not on the ground. There are so many variables as to the sensitivity it is impossible to answer accurately. Generally, however, .6 nm per hour (with no updates) is allowed for Civilian systems. Issues such as age, accuracy of the coordinates, and quality of manufacture are relevant.


Was GPS installed on Flight 77? I haven't got to that part of my questioning yet, but I suppose now is as good a time as any to introduce it.

No it did not have GPS. If it had GPS we wouldn't be discussing this accuracy issue.
 
Last edited:
If, as seems to be implied, I accepted their claims hook line and sinker, why would I be here asking questions about it?

It's a common tactic, sadly.
It's generally known as JAQing off.
(Just Asking Questions).

There's usually a few rounds of questions, then the JAQer facade starts to slip.
 
It's a common tactic, sadly.
It's generally known as JAQing off.
(Just Asking Questions).

There's usually a few rounds of questions, then the JAQer facade starts to slip.

Which happened pretty dramatically in this case.
 
Which is what I thought I was doing. Being skeptical of their claims, and seeking other sources.

If, as seems to be implied, I accepted their claims hook line and sinker, why would I be here asking questions about it? I am actively seeking another source on the subject.

I don't understand what you are trying to say.

Since JFK, modern conspiracism has really centered on hoax theories, and the main "research" strategy has been to look for "anomalies" which supposedly expose the hoax using the faulty logic of anomaly => hoax => conspiracy. Your questions about the INS (and others, e.g. the Shanksville crater) appear to be such a hunt for anomalies as confirmation of some vague conspiracy theory. And then, instead of requiring PfT to substantiate their claims about the INS, you are asking someone else to disprove them. And then, you can't even work these "anomalies" into an actual coherent and plausible conspiracy theory. I think what many here are expecting next is the standard result of such "reasoning": "I don't know what happened, but I know the 'official story' isn't true."

Sorry, but this is a pattern that we've seen too many times to count. If you're being treated unfairly, blame it on the "truthers" who preceded you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom