Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

... I know that all life and our existence are not plainly and easily explainable with quick scientific fixes....
Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?

Hi and welcome to the forum Psychic Physicist.

Yes, many things are currently unexplained,
but this is not a reason to invent weird explanations, you see ...
I exist; and "We don need yer stinkin universe!"
Regardless of our comprehension or definition of the universe, we exist.

LossLeader proposes an excellent test.
What do you think about it PP?
Lets get focussed on that easy million.
 
]An easy illustration is the age old mind bender which asks, `Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]
Not even a sceptic can answer that one.

The surface of a sphere has no beginning or end. Does that mean the sphere doesn't exist?

Steve S.
 
Hi Again,
Some interesting comments and suggestions but also some very puerile remarks which are totally unnecessary in an arena supposedly based on intelligent thoughtful debate.
Firstly, (to reiterate for those sexually focused on touching knees or swollen hands) I am not interested in making this challenge for the money. Yes, I know others have said that before, and they were no doubt unable to make the challenge or had failed miserably. All I would ask for as payment, is James Randi`s original check (cheque) for $10,000 which has been signed `cancelled` by the said James Randi. The money should be distributed equally to 5 hospices in Britain, Europe and America.
Secondly, I am not a fool making wild or irrational claims. My ability - call it what you will, is not delusional. It has worked and continues to work for me. I sincerely do not think, nor would I be foolish to think that I am the only person in the world that can do this. I suspect that some potentially genuine challengers may have been dissuaded previously by some of the vitriolic commentators on this forum. If you view my offer as an excuse to point ridicule at me, then you have defeated your own argument, surely?
Thirdly, my method of working involves making fingertip contact with a subject. Being behind a curtain, or whatever means may look impressive, but that is outside the realms of experience for me. That kinda strikes me more as a showmanship demonstration rather than as an example of my alleged ability. - I say `alleged` because that is all it is to any rational `open`mind at this stage. If we can keep the debate open-minded and impartial I am prepared to take it further. As I have stated originally, I am a sceptic regarding many outrageous claims on paranormal matters debunked in the past, and commend anyone like Randi that can expose them.
How should the test be performed?
Well, believe it or not, I actually feel drained and very tired after a period of time when performing this ability. It is visually evidenced by very dark rings that appear around my eyes which illustrate this fatigue. - Please no sarcastic one liners!
I can work per session for around 30 minutes, no more. I don`t set the rules, I become very tired and emotionally drained after this period.
I would respectfully suggest 10 volunteers, all chosen impartially by a third party not associated with me or with any sceptics group.
The volunteers should be open minded individuals who (despite previous mainstream medical treatment) are still suffering with pain or some form of discomfort.
The 10 volunteers should be divided into two groups. One group should be assigned to a `placebo healer`, i.e a person with no history or claim to be a healer. Preferably, a total sceptic or avowed non-believer. The other group are then assigned to me. Both groups are placed in separate rooms with the placebo group and `healer` having no direct knowledge of me and my group, or the true reason of the experiment. The placebo healer is instructed to try and heal these peoples ailments following the same procedures in my group. At the end of the experiment - 30 mins, - no more, the results from both groups are compared. There should I hasten to add, be a medical doctor present to evaluate the subjects before and after each demonstration.
Caveat - I would also request that I choose discretely the placebo healer to eliminate the possibility that this person may have the same abilities as me. Why? Well, if he or she is not be a placebo, that would invalidate this experiment totally. Lastly, both groups should be filmed during the process as a matter of public record to show complete rigidity to the governing rules of this demonstration to remove from the most ardent sceptics mind any suggestion of trickery or malpractice by the Randi organisation or those nominated by the said Randi organisation.Conversely, that too would also apply to me.
I would also suggest that this same experiment is repeated on separate occasions 3 times using different volunteers and placebo healers in three different locations across (preferably) the U.K.
At the end of this `trial`, the results can be compared.
If, out of 15 people, 10 state a removal of pain or major reduction during the demonstrations then I feel vindicated. I personally am aiming at 15/15, but can say through experience that it does not work for everybody. I believe the figure of 10 to be a good pass rate as an average would be around 40 to 60%.
So there are the suggested rules for this challenge. I believe them to be completely fair and totally above board in establishing whether the phenomenon of contact healing works. I don`t presume this ability to be a miracle, its simply an ability outside the norms of conventional medical science.
Please leave sensible comments.
 
Last edited:
It is usually impractical to create a protocol where you actually heal people, however. Do you think that if you held your hand behind a screen, a friend of yours could determine whether your hand was there or not? If you are giving off energy, this might be possible. Then it would be simple to place you behind a screen, have it randomly determined whether you place your hand out or not, and then ask your friend if it is there or not.
There's a description of just such an experiment here, showing how simply and cheaply something like this can be set up.
 
The 10 volunteers should be divided into two groups. One group should be assigned to a `placebo healer`, i.e a person with no history or claim to be a healer. Preferably, a total sceptic or avowed non-believer. The other group are then assigned to me.
It is important, though, that the "placebo healer" is able to convince the patient that they are a real healer, otherwise it wouldn't be an adequate control. In a test featured in a recent BBC series about alternative medicine, they used an actor, who studied the healer's technique and accurately reproduced it.
 
Hi Again,
Some interesting comments and suggestions but also some very puerile remarks which are totally unnecessary in an arena supposedly based on intelligent thoughtful debate.
<snip>
If we can keep the debate open-minded and impartial I am prepared to take it further. As I have stated originally, I am a sceptic regarding many outrageous claims on paranormal matters debunked in the past, and commend anyone like Randi that can expose them.
How should the test be performed?
Well, believe it or not, I actually feel drained and very tired after a period of time when performing this ability. It is visually evidenced by very dark rings that appear around my eyes which illustrate this fatigue. - Please no sarcastic one liners!
<snip>
Please leave sensible comments.

Hello and a warm welcome to you,

I cannot comment on your suggestion for the test, I will leave this to others with more experience in such matters.

I can tell you that when I joined this forum, I was quite shocked and annoyed by those who were downright rude to anyone suggesting that they had any belief considered paranormal.

Although I have only been here a short time, I have discovered the majority to be intelligent, polite, patient and accommodating. Unfortunately, I suspect that you will have to endure the minority who think a smart quip adds to debate and those that are just insulting.

Please be open to harmless humour designed to illustrate an opinion and please ignore humour designed to ridicule (like the "losing a hand" jokes).

Thank you for your courage. Please stick around.
Karl Quigley
 
Last edited:
Hi Mojo and Karl Quigley.
Firstly Mojo. I am quite happy to perform, as it were, behind a screen. But therein for me lies a problem. I view the energy subject of this controversy like a spark between a battery and a terminal. If my hand is too far from the subjects hand then the likelihood of it working could be rendered ineffective. I would need to ensure that it is just above the subjects hand. I cannot see the point of whether my hand is behind a screen or not. Why not simply blind-fold the subject and allow me to position my hand at a distance comfortable with what I do? Equally, what`s wrong with simple finger contact? I think in fairness to myself and the James Randi Foundation the experiment group should be doubled to encompass contact and non contact healing. If necessary, I have no objections to either experiment participants being blindfolded or not.
Secondly regarding the placebo healer. Yes, of course why not allow the placebo to convince them he is a healer. The proof is in the pudding as they say. Sorry, I should have covered that in my outline - that`s why I welcome suggestions from forum members.
If at the end of the day people view my ability as a `soothing placebo effect and nothing more` - as I suspect it will be, why am I rendered so tired and visibly weakened? Surely, there must logically be more to this.
Lastly, if I am imagining my ability through sub-conscious psychology and it works in making peoples lives a little more comfortable then what`s the harm in that? However, I don`t feel the latter to be a true reflection of this type of ability.

Karl, Thanks also (as with other forum members) for your support and encouragement.
 
Last edited:
Just one final point. On the subject of volunteers. Surely they can be raised with the participation of press involvement?
 
Firstly Mojo. I am quite happy to perform, as it were, behind a screen. But therein for me lies a problem. I view the energy subject of this controversy like a spark between a battery and a terminal. If my hand is too far from the subjects hand then the likelihood of it working could be rendered ineffective. I would need to ensure that it is just above the subjects hand. I cannot see the point of whether my hand is behind a screen or not. Why not simply blind-fold the subject and allow me to position my hand at a distance comfortable with what I do? Equally, what`s wrong with simple finger contact?
Ah. I think we were a bit at cross purposes. It appears from your O/P that it is the patient rather than the "healer" who feels the "energy".
I first discovered this ability around 10 years ago when a partner complained of a re-occurring pain in her knee joint. On one occasion I placed my hand over the knee to rub it, and she reported that energy from my hand had travelled to the affected area and had warmed an area deep inside her knee which completely removed the pain.
I naturally thought it pure chance but decided to follow through by testing this ability on other people’s ailments. Within a year, I had managed to work with 10 people from work to friends who although at first sceptical stated that a warm energy had travelled through their bodies to soothe away muscular pains or swellings.

Are you saying that they will only feel the "energy" when you are touching them and not when anyone else is? If that is the case. what I would suggest is that, rather than a test involving a degree of subjective judgment, like pain relief, you blindfold the subjects, and get them to tell whether it is you or somebody else that is touching them. This is a test that gives a simple yes/no result: either they correctly identify you or they don't.
 
Secondly regarding the placebo healer. Yes, of course why not allow the placebo to convince them he is a healer.
He has to convince them that he is a healer, otherwise there will be no placebo effect acting on the control group, and therefore no way of knowing that any positive results in the group you treat over the results for the control group are not a result of the placebo effect.

If at the end of the day people view my ability as a `soothing placebo effect and nothing more` - as I suspect it will be, why am I rendered so tired and visibly weakened? Surely, there must logically be more to this.
Again, this could well be the placebo effect: you think you have done something strenuous, so you feel tired. Do you remember feeling tired in a similar way before peiople reported to you that you were transmitting a "warm energy" to them (i.e. when you might have done this without being aware that it was happening)?

Lastly, if I am imagining my ability through sub-conscious psychology and it works in making peoples lives a little more comfortable then what`s the harm in that?
What if the pain you treat is an early symptom of some potentially serious underlying problem that you are not able to diagnose or treat?
 
Mojo expressed better and more simply what I tried to say before: the yes/no test cuts through all the other difficulties. Either your touch is "different" in whatever way or it is not. What could be simpler?
 
It is important, though, that the "placebo healer" is able to convince the patient that they are a real healer, otherwise it wouldn't be an adequate control. In a test featured in a recent BBC series about alternative medicine, they used an actor, who studied the healer's technique and accurately reproduced it.

I would also suggest that 10 people is way too low for a definitive test. Ok for a pilot maybe, but I would suggest that the placebo response rate would likely be 20-30% anyway, making an effect difference hard to pick up in a sample of 10, unless you cured 90%+ of the subjects in your healing group.
 
Hi Again,
Some interesting comments and suggestions but also some very puerile remarks which are totally unnecessary in an arena supposedly based on intelligent thoughtful debate.

Just ignore them. If you feel compelled to respond to them, then please consider opening another thread (perhaps in the religion/philospher sub-forum) to talk about those issues.

Well, believe it or not, I actually feel drained and very tired after a period of time when performing this ability. It is visually evidenced by very dark rings that appear around my eyes which illustrate this fatigue. -
I can work per session for around 30 minutes, no more.

How long does it take you to "recharge" and heal other people?

There should I hasten to add, be a medical doctor present to evaluate the subjects before and after each demonstration.

Why is a medical doctor necessary in a test where people describe their pain as reduced or not reduced? Can you reduce or eliminate physical symptoms that a doctor would recognize? If so, then that might be a better topic for the test.

Caveat - I would also request that I choose discretely the placebo healer to eliminate the possibility that this person may have the same abilities as me. Why? Well, if he or she is not be a placebo, that would invalidate this experiment totally.

How are you able to tell if another person does or does not have the power you claim?
 
Hi again,
Let me try to address some of your concerns or questions.
Regarding the `energy` disclosure.
I feel it, and hopefully so does the subject. I never contradicted myself. Without sounding inflammatory, some of you are `nit-picking` portions of what I have written as literal or definitive responses without thoroughly taking in what I am saying. Mojo, I`m sorry, but you are the worst offender in that department! :-) Further Mojo it logically goes without saying that the placebo has to convince them. It would be pointless otherwise.
The reason that I feel tired is simply that when I touch a subject - and depending on their symptom's I feel literally drained of energy after a while. I realise that concept seems incredulous with some of you, but that`s what happens. Causation and effect. In a day, I can normally work with two people in total of sessions (per individual) ranging from 30 minutes to an hour. I need at least 3 hours in between to recuperate. That normally involves sleep and rest.
A doctor should be present to note any obvious change to a persons condition. This generally involves observations in reduced swellings, or for example someone that had earlier difficulty bending a limb and so forth. The mere observation of an untrained non-medical eye would not be sufficient particularly if the doctor had some record of the patients prior medical state. Surely that seems logical?
With regard to the question of whether I can tell if someone is a healer or not is acceptedly difficult, and here you can jump all over me when I say that I can sense it. Don`t ask me how or why, I really don`t know, I have no way of showing or illustrating this point, but I can feel it, like a third sense.
With regard to `Dr Richard`s` comments. For me in any one session 5 people are as many as I can work with. The reasons have been described previously. I will be too tired. That`s why I suggested three sessions involving 15 people for me, and 15 people for the placebo.
In general there have been some good responses here from you, and I appreciate that. Many points raised have been helpful to me immensely and I thank all of you for that.

Just one final point. I have been reviewing the alleged abilities of some claimants for the money prize. I can now understand why you are very suspect of anyone who claims to perform something which is outside the realms of normal science. Some of these `claimants` are completely bonkers! I sincerely hope that you do not place me in that category, although I feel a minority here do. I am perfectly sane and quite rational, I don`t hear voices, I am not an emissary of god, and I don`t believe in devil`s, goblins or black magic spells, et al. As I said twice earlier, I am a sceptic in all matters until I can experience it myself, and commend the sceptics viewpoint in challenging for the truth. But at some-point you really have to concede that I am genuine and sincere with my own beliefs, and perhaps I can prove I am not deluding you or myself.
It has taken a lot of courage for me to sit on this forum and talk about this subject. I knew that I would be subject to some indifference and ridicule, but I feel compelled to try and show that life is not black and white. It is very often tinged with shades of grey. As I have said, if I could win the challenge then perhaps the money on offer could be used to make less fortunate peoples lives a little more comfortable. But for the challenge to succeed I feel would itself be a minor miracle.
I`m sure that if you really wanted to, you too could achieve what I claim to achieve, I believe it exists in everybody. Just lighten up a little, and peer outside the metaphorical box. You never know what you might find out there.
I now have printed off the entry form, no doubt my real name will soon appear in your chamber of horrors!
 
Without sounding inflammatory, some of you are `nit-picking` portions of what I have written as literal or definitive responses without thoroughly taking in what I am saying. Mojo, I`m sorry, but you are the worst offender in that department! :-)
What I'm trying to do is to take a claim from your O/P (that people you treat can feel the energy flowing into them) and point you towards a test that might be more acceptable in a challenge application than the one you are proposing. Note that the challenge requires a test giving a self-evident positive or negative result, with no judging required on the part of any participant.
Further Mojo it logically goes without saying that the placebo has to convince them. It would be pointless otherwise.
OK, fine. I just wasn't sure if you appreciated that (you wouldn't be the first...)
 
But at some-point you really have to concede that I am genuine and sincere with my own beliefs, and perhaps I can prove I am not deluding you or myself

I doubt any of us believe you are not sincere in your beliefs, or that you are trying to delude us. The question of whether you are deluding yourself is an entirely different matter however, and I expect most of us believe this is the case, as it has been for every test so far.

On a different note, there are major changes happening to the challenge, to be announced shortly - see this thread. It may be worth holding off from applying until we see where Randi is going with this.
 
Hi Mojo,
Well Cuddles has a point there on test aspects. I`ve posted the application so I`ll wait and see what cooks.
I cannot be deluding myself when in the case of swellings I have seen them disappear or reduce in size. If it were a delusion or surely, an `illusion` then that made two of use - both myself and the subject.
Regarding every test, yes you are right, and yes you are also right to remain sceptical.
Anyway, back to the real world! I might forward an interesting photo at some point for comments. I`d rather not continue with this debate as my application is pending. But I`ll be there for other discussions and probably taking your viewpoints - but with an open mind in view of my experiences.
See you all later, I have enjoyed this discussion.
 
PsyP,

I want to again encourage you to continue your practice, though a controled test may yield only marginal results, due to, as I pointed out before, the very subjective, personal, and individual thing you are doing. Unless, that is, you are wanting solid evidence that Therapeutic Touch, Reiki, Craniosacral Threrapy, and the like are therapeutic to the same degree and in the same catagory as medicine, so that a practicioner of these arts can claim the titile "Healer" and enhance a professional practice of them.

It is possible though, that a controled study would show the benifits of touch, as I indicated in a previous post. Indeed there is already a consensus out there in the medical world that touch and personal attention are benificial, and its one of the reasons Concord Hospital (in Concord NH) still provides Reiki (from volunteer practitioners) to patients who ask for it as a service.
I'm not sure then, that this would be paranormal enough for the Challenge. But if your agreed on results were relief from pain and swelling it would be doable.

But people are looking for something flashier than feel good touch to make a paranormal challenge over. Most of the respondents this thread don't have any experience of what you are talking about, so they frame it as energies that can be detected behind curtains and blinds. All tests of that sort that I've read of have come up blank. Also tests involving subjects with specific medical conditions to be healed, don't make a good show. Say we chose breast cancer. I think you understand how your assitance would be benificial in the contect of ordinary medical treatments and the patient's recovery, as an outright cancer cure, it would make no showing at all.

As for a "placebo control guy" who would mimic what you do, the chances are very good that he would be doing what you do.
Our culture is so removed from gentle attentive touch or interpersonal touch in most any circumstance except in sexual intimacy, that what ordinary happens between individuals looks mysteriuos and supernatural.

Here's something for the readers of this thread to do to get a little experience of what this feels like. Set down, count your out breaths for a little while to relax. Then hold your palms facing each other about six inches or a third of a meter apart. On inbreath focus on center of your palms and imagine you are breathing in through them. On outbreath imagine you are breathing out them.
Do this for a while, thenbegin to slowly move your palms toward each other.
Move them toward and away again and agiain maintaining your focus on your palms and what you feel between them. Practice this a few times on your own and explore the sensations you experience. Then get a friend or family member, or a stranger if you like. "Charge" up your palms again and do the same motions with their palms or foreheads or at chest level. Ask them what they feel. This engagges the parapympathetic nervous systems of both yourself and the other and we get sympathetic and in deep attention empathetic feelings.

Let me repeat. There isn't some mysterios energy that we ought to be able to detect by some instrumentation. These are subjective feelings associated with being in a light altered state of consciouness. And there's nothing wrong with being in such a relaxed and receptive place provided you aren't driving a car at the same time.

This is an anybody can do thing, Though some folks are more tactile oriented, and have more body awareness, and naturally exude more of a calming presence.

PsyB,

Regarding feeling drained after giving sessions:
I suggest you learn to meditate. This will help you contain yourself and maintain yourself. There are a lot of way woo-woo books on this subject but they do contain workable excercises of intent that you can do to avoid getting whacked out. Look into the woo-woo subject of "energetic boundaries." It's natural that after three or more sessions, you'd begin to feel tired, but one session as a stand alone should be invigorating as opposed to draining.

Confessions from my woo-woo past:
I'm a Reiki master. I've practiced "healing" touch for years. (It's not the sort of thing you admit on a skeptics board for reasons evident in this thread.) I don't do much of it these days, because I tend to "mesmerize" people a tad more than they are comfortable, especially in staid New England. As you can read in my posts, I've come to a perspective of this that recognizes why people like giving and recieving the so called "energy" modalities and feel its a good thing for themselves and others. It really is a nice thing to do and has its place in the human experience. However, it becomes bunk when exagerated claims are made about healings and cures.
 
Last edited:
If you are going to just be relying on the subjective opinion of a doctor it would probably be better to have the subjective opinion of 3 or more to try to control the subjectiveness of the evaluation. All patients should be examined before and after the treatment by the same doctors who have been blinded as to which treatment group each patient is in. A doctor, no matter how skilled still is making a subjective evaluation without objective data collection. You opinion of "healing" that occurs is a subjective evaluation as is the opinion of the subject who were "healed". In addition why is it not appropriate just to pick someone who claims not to have any healing powers? There should be no connection between you and the second person.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom