Hi Again,
Some interesting comments and suggestions but also some very puerile remarks which are totally unnecessary in an arena supposedly based on intelligent thoughtful debate.
Firstly, (to reiterate for those sexually focused on touching knees or swollen hands) I am not interested in making this challenge for the money. Yes, I know others have said that before, and they were no doubt unable to make the challenge or had failed miserably. All I would ask for as payment, is James Randi`s original check (cheque) for $10,000 which has been signed `cancelled` by the said James Randi. The money should be distributed equally to 5 hospices in Britain, Europe and America.
Secondly, I am not a fool making wild or irrational claims. My ability - call it what you will, is not delusional. It has worked and continues to work for me. I sincerely do not think, nor would I be foolish to think that I am the only person in the world that can do this. I suspect that some potentially genuine challengers may have been dissuaded previously by some of the vitriolic commentators on this forum. If you view my offer as an excuse to point ridicule at me, then you have defeated your own argument, surely?
Thirdly, my method of working involves making fingertip contact with a subject. Being behind a curtain, or whatever means may look impressive, but that is outside the realms of experience for me. That kinda strikes me more as a showmanship demonstration rather than as an example of my alleged ability. - I say `alleged` because that is all it is to any rational `open`mind at this stage. If we can keep the debate open-minded and impartial I am prepared to take it further. As I have stated originally, I am a sceptic regarding many outrageous claims on paranormal matters debunked in the past, and commend anyone like Randi that can expose them.
How should the test be performed?
Well, believe it or not, I actually feel drained and very tired after a period of time when performing this ability. It is visually evidenced by very dark rings that appear around my eyes which illustrate this fatigue. - Please no sarcastic one liners!
I can work per session for around 30 minutes, no more. I don`t set the rules, I become very tired and emotionally drained after this period.
I would respectfully suggest 10 volunteers, all chosen impartially by a third party not associated with me or with any sceptics group.
The volunteers should be open minded individuals who (despite previous mainstream medical treatment) are still suffering with pain or some form of discomfort.
The 10 volunteers should be divided into two groups. One group should be assigned to a `placebo healer`, i.e a person with no history or claim to be a healer. Preferably, a total sceptic or avowed non-believer. The other group are then assigned to me. Both groups are placed in separate rooms with the placebo group and `healer` having no direct knowledge of me and my group, or the true reason of the experiment. The placebo healer is instructed to try and heal these peoples ailments following the same procedures in my group. At the end of the experiment - 30 mins, - no more, the results from both groups are compared. There should I hasten to add, be a medical doctor present to evaluate the subjects before and after each demonstration.
Caveat - I would also request that I choose discretely the placebo healer to eliminate the possibility that this person may have the same abilities as me. Why? Well, if he or she is not be a placebo, that would invalidate this experiment totally. Lastly, both groups should be filmed during the process as a matter of public record to show complete rigidity to the governing rules of this demonstration to remove from the most ardent sceptics mind any suggestion of trickery or malpractice by the Randi organisation or those nominated by the said Randi organisation.Conversely, that too would also apply to me.
I would also suggest that this same experiment is repeated on separate occasions 3 times using different volunteers and placebo healers in three different locations across (preferably) the U.K.
At the end of this `trial`, the results can be compared.
If, out of 15 people, 10 state a removal of pain or major reduction during the demonstrations then I feel vindicated. I personally am aiming at 15/15, but can say through experience that it does not work for everybody. I believe the figure of 10 to be a good pass rate as an average would be around 40 to 60%.
So there are the suggested rules for this challenge. I believe them to be completely fair and totally above board in establishing whether the phenomenon of contact healing works. I don`t presume this ability to be a miracle, its simply an ability outside the norms of conventional medical science.
Please leave sensible comments.