Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

Psychic Physicist, perhaps it has already been mentioned here, but I find your posts very difficult to read.

You might consider spacing in between your paragraphs. Otherwise, it's just page after page of dense text, which is hard for many (like myself) to read.

Just a thought.
 
... On the other foot, I know that all life and our existence are not plainly and easily explainable with quick scientific fixes.[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]
An easy illustration is the age old mind bender which asks, `Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?
Not even a sceptic can answer that one.

I still can't believe that only two posts have addressed this silly statement, which was part of the OP.
A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.
 
I still can't believe that only two posts have addressed this silly statement, which was part of the OP.
A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.
It is indeed silly and pointless, but I don't know that it is truly a link in the "chain."

The guy either has "healing powers" or he doesn't. Any pseudo-philosophical statements he makes are beside the point.
 
But they are as indicative of a certain mindset as quantum qi energy healing can be.
 
Let us forget for a moment all the side issues about what healing principle is involved, what is normal or not, what is acceptable for the challenge or not etc. and take this as an exercise in basic logic.

A person claims to be able to produce beneficial effects to another person who displays a physical ailment just by touching the affected part. The most effective results are obtained in series of 5 sessions or less of up to 60 minutes each.

Therefore if:

· A suitable number of patients in groups <= 5 is selected on the basis that they state their belief in touch healing;
· each patient is told that a test is being conducted to check the effectiveness of various healers and they will be touched by a healer or a non-healer, but they will not be told which;
· the claimant touches all patients;
· after the session, unbeknown to the claimant, each patient states whether he/she felt the healing power or not;
· the number of patients who felt “healed” is significantly above placebo

then the claimant has a healing power.

Is there any fault in this logic?
 
Yes, if you are going to use a statistical test to evaluate the results, you need more participants (formerly called "subjects"). At least 10 in each group to give it a fair test. And if the claimant touches all, where's the placebo?
 
Last edited:
I still can't believe that only two posts have addressed this silly statement, which was part of the OP.

When newer posters consider making claims for the JREF prize, they often have philosophies or beliefs that seem to lack critical thinking. Engaging such posters in discussions about such beliefs (in a thread devoted to testing procedures) really slows down discussion of test design.

I think everyone noticed the observations and the faults with them. Perhaps the best solution would be to move this thread to the Challenge sub-forum and ask P.P. if he has time to outline his beliefs in a new thread in the Religion/Philosophy sub-forum.
 
Sorry, I didn't know this thread was only about testing procedures. I thought it was about the OP, which evolved into issues about how to test the extra-ordinary claim.
 
Jeff Corey said:
Yes, if you are going to use a statistical test to evaluate the results, you need more participants (formerly called "subjects"). At least 10 in each group to give it a fair test. And if the claimant touches all, where's the placebo?

I am starting to think that my English is the problem here.

"suitable number" = N adequate to produce statistically significant results

N is the population (10, 20, 30, whatever, tested in s sessions where N/s <= 5 as requested by the claimant)

X patients (subjects) blindly evaluate the claimant as "healer", N-X as "non-healer"

P subjects (20-30% has been suggested) may feel "healed" because of placebo anyway.

If X significantly >P the claim is proven.

Clearer?
 
X patients (subjects) blindly evaluate the claimant as "healer", N-X as "non-healer"

P subjects (20-30% has been suggested) may feel "healed" because of placebo anyway.

If X significantly >P the claim is proven.

You're saying that the real healer touches all the subjects, correct? Then how do you determine what P would normally be?

It's necessary to run a trial on similar subjects, duplicating the treatment as closely as possible but without the "active ingredient" (in this case, the actual healer's touch). That's the only way to establish accurately what P would be. Otherwise, there's no way of telling whether X is significantly greater than P, because you don't know what P would be.

Maybe I'm misunderstanding?
 
maybe I have misunderstood a previous post as suggesting that P could be given on the basis of previous studies. Assuming that this is a red herring, let say that the claim is proven if X is significantly larger than N-X. Even more stringent.
 
Sorry, I didn't know this thread was only about testing procedures. I thought it was about the OP, which evolved into issues about how to test the extra-ordinary claim.

I was just making a suggestion. If you feel the need to address the ridiculousness of the philosophical assertions, have at it.
 
PsyPhy,
It would make things very easy for everyone to understand if you answered these three simple questions in one or two sentences:

1) What do you claim to do?

2) Under what circumstances are you able to do it? (for example, "I can only do it on Thursdays after having eaten a turkey sandwich" or something like that.)

3) What degree of success do you claim?

Two sentences maximum for each answer...that will really help us boil down what, exactly, we're talking about here.
 
Hi,
This is the man that Corey refers too as an `idiot`. Also the same person that `lacks critical thinking`. Also the same person `that writes bunched up` or whatever, obviously making his claim too difficult for minds the size of Einstein to understand.

Your perception of me clearly speaks volumes. I don`t think that I am an idiot, but then I don`t claim to `think too much` either.

J Lam is so intelligent that despite the copious amounts of text, he/she still cannot understand what I claim to do.
Even better, having left some of you for a period on your own, you tear into each other! Obviously, my absence makes the heart grow fonder.

I am not going to fuel some of your prejudices by repeating everything I have said. I personally don`t feel I am an idiot, but like my healing claims, it all boils down to belief and opinion.

What a bland empty life-scape some of you must dwell in. A world of black and white, a world where everything is rationally understood (according to your own rules) and any challenge to your beliefs is treated with the same zeal and hysteria as the the Spanish inquisition?

Because I claim something that is beyond your personal understanding of the world in which you exist, does it mean therefore that it cannot exist?

Does it also give you the right to rubbish this persons opinion because you feel so smugly right?

I on the contrary am open minded, I do not discount everything out of hand because I haven`t experienced it personally, but instead try to seek answers rather than dismiss everything.

As I have said, I respect people like Randi who expose liars and fraudsters because of the damage that some of these people cause to other peoples lives. But equally, I have had experiences in my life that have no predetermined logical explanation, and am therefore trying to seek the truth about these things. Does that make me a complete fool because it is outside your own terms of reference?

To conclude, I really don`t give a toss what you think, I suggest that you show respect for others that don`t subscribe to your alleged empirical assertions of anything you really don't understand. That is made plainly obvious by the manner under which you feel these tests should be made.

So much for thoughtful debate. I`ve obviously arrived at the wrong forum!

PS: I haven`t referred to it, but the statement made concerning the universe - that was a deliberate red herring. You certainly passed the test and satisfied my own curiosity. Thankyou..
 
Last edited:
Just a final thought.. Try to get out more. You might find that the outside world is more challenging than you think.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm. This thread seems to have followed EXACTLY the same life cycle as the "Pink Lady" thread. Linda left the forum in a huff and it was decided that it was because JREFrs had been too rude to her.

Now Psychic psychiatrist is getting miffed too, and so far he has had quite a gentle ride.

I can't find the post, but someone once described the life cycle of these posts, going something like:
1. Person makes a vague claim of abilities
2. JREFrs try and condense this to a few simple testable sentences
3. Person leaves in a huff
 
Hi,

I am not going to fuel some of your prejudices by repeating everything I have said. I personally don`t feel I am an idiot, but like my healing claims, it all boils down to belief and opinion.

See, right here is the problem. You say that your healing claims boil down to belief and opinion. We say healing claims should never consist of belief and opinion but rather should always consist of evidence and properly conducted trials. Many of your posts indicate that you, too, see the usefulness of a properly-controlled study.

What a bland empty life-scape some of you must dwell in. A world of black and white, a world where everything is rationally understood (according to your own rules) and any challenge to your beliefs is treated with the same zeal and hysteria as the the Spanish inquisition?

If you feel that what you were exposed to is somehow akin to the Spanish inquisition, I would suggest that it is you and not us that needs to experience more of the outside world.

Because I claim something that is beyond your personal understanding of the world in which you exist, does it mean therefore that it cannot exist?

No. Because you claim a power that, if true, would start a scientific revolution as far-reaching as Copernicus's or Einstein's, we ask for evidence. At the beginning of the thread when we talked about what specific kind of evidence is required, you seemed to agree that carefully controlled evidence was necessary. Now you seem to have switched you position.

I on the contrary am open minded, I do not discount everything out of hand because I haven`t experienced it personally, but instead try to seek answers rather than dismiss everything.

And,like you, the majority of posters in this thread "tried to seek the answers" by helping you design a protocol for a JREF Challenge test.



- [more angry accusations snipped for length] -

Of course, the best possible way to give us our comeuppance would be to take the test and pass it. That will really show us how right you are and how wrong we are. I do hope you'll apply.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom