EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

What's wrong with:

[X] makes some [G1] uncomfortable but it's really such a small thing that no one need adjust their behavior. It's simple enough for [G1] to simply say, no thanks.
Or how about those 'uncomfortable women' might want to consider it is they who need to adjust their behavior and it is sexist to believe it is up to [G2] to adjust theirs?
How are you proposing those women adjust their behavior? Simply saying 'no' is about all that they are going to do. Feeling uncomfortable is an internal reaction that many women will experience and have little control over. So are you are asking them to shut up and stop whining about it? Or are you telling them their feelings are wrong and need to change?
 
I think this argument is dependent on content, not form. There are examples that work both ways.

EX: <snip examples>

I think that this gets to the heart of where our disagreement lies. I think the argument is flawed completely.

It takes a specific fact and applies it too broadly.

"[X] makes many [G1] uncomfortable" is a fact.

but also

"[X] makes many [1 - G1] comfortable or indifferent" is a fact where [1-G1] is the remainder of the [G1] population.

Where do we draw the line between [G1] and [1-G1]? Should we draw a line? Is this rule overreaching?

We make such rules all the time but is "comfort" enough of a reason to apply such a broad brush? Wouldn't it be less work if people learned to deal with their own discomforts?
 
What's wrong with:

[X] makes some [G1] uncomfortable but it's really such a small thing that no one need adjust their behavior. It's simple enough for [G1] to simply say, no thanks.

Or how about those 'uncomfortable women' might want to consider it is they who need to adjust their behavior and it is sexist to believe it is up to [G2] to adjust theirs?

People who are made uncomfortable when a stranger approaches them unasked need to adjust their behavior? How would they do that? They have no choice in the matter.

How far do you want to take this? Because Jim's got a thread about women enjoying their own rapes and this sentiment would fit right in.
Thought of the day: Evil is in the eye of the beholder. In many cases. Sometimes regarding evil as evil is more harmful to yourself than choosing the side of evil and agreeing with it.

A practical application: A woman being raped might be much better off if she agrees to it and goes with the flow, the act becoming consensual as soon as it starts, so she might actually enjoy some of it, and anyway shed the weight of the incident from upon her shoulders as soon as it ends.
 
Last edited:
I think that this gets to the heart of where our disagreement lies. I think the argument is flawed completely.

It takes a specific fact and applies it too broadly.
That is why I don't think the form of your argument is particularly telling one way or the other.
"[X] makes many [G1] uncomfortable" is a fact.

but also

"[X] makes many [1 - G1] comfortable or indifferent" is a fact where [1-G1] is the remainder of the [G1] population.

Where do we draw the line between [G1] and [1-G1]? Should we draw a line? Is this rule overreaching?

We make such rules all the time but is "comfort" enough of a reason to apply such a broad brush? Wouldn't it be less work if people learned to deal with their own discomforts?

It really depends on a) the proportion of people who are affected, b) the extent of their discomfort, and c) the relative difficulty that G1 and G2 have in changing their behavior. Given the large proportion of women who are made uncomfortable, the extend of their discomfort (IMO it's much worse than chewing gum or even farting in an elevator) and the relatively small change in behavior that is being asked of men versus the difficulty in changing emotional reactions in a large percentage of women, I don't think it's an unreasonable request to make of men. Clearly, others have different opinions.

In the end, people will do whatever they choose to do. Men will behave as they want and women who don't like it can either put up with it or choose not to go places where they will be subjected to behaviors that make them uncomfortable. Women who are objecting to the behavior are trying to make people aware that it is uncomfortable for many woman and that some of them will not attend gatherings where that sort of behavior is considered acceptable. If that fact bothers those who do attend and they feel it's keeping too many woman away, they can attempt to change the acceptable standard of behavior.

IMO, that's basically what all this conversation has been about. Should such behavior be considered acceptable? Not wrong or bad, just as nudity or praying isn't considered wrong or bad (well, not by the majority of people anyway :) ), but acceptable versus unacceptable behavior in certain public spaces.
 
It takes a specific fact and applies it too broadly.

"[X] makes many [G1] uncomfortable" is a fact.

but also

"[X] makes many [1 - G1] comfortable or indifferent" is a fact where [1-G1] is the remainder of the [G1] population.

Where do we draw the line between [G1] and [1-G1]? Should we draw a line? Is this rule overreaching?

We make such rules all the time but is "comfort" enough of a reason to apply such a broad brush?
Agreed. Hasty Generalization fallacy.
 
Given the large proportion of women who are made uncomfortable, the extend of their discomfort (IMO it's much worse than chewing gum or even farting in an elevator) and the relatively small change in behavior that is being asked of men versus the difficulty in changing emotional reactions in a large percentage of women, I don't think it's an unreasonable request to make of men. Clearly, others have different opinions.
You simply assert your claims without justifying them nor do you provide any context. What if most women were discomforted with most proposals? What then? Why should we single out this elevator incident? It's not teaching people to think it teaches people to create a check list. It's not conducive to improving cohesion and better relations.
 
Agreed. Hasty Generalization fallacy.

Mapping out acceptable behavior is a futile exercise to begin with. We're dealing with people. The ramifications following an encounter with [G1] vs [1-G1] are completely different.


If a boorish man propositions [1-G1] they will shrug it off and forget it.

If a boorish man propositions [G1] that woman will feel uncomfortable. She will remember that feeling and want to avoid it in the future. So, like every other human on the planet, she will look for patterns. If enough guys at TAM make her uncomfortable, TAM will be the pattern that should be avoided.

If some pompous skeptic sits her down and says "Look, you met dozens of men who didn't freak you out, there were only those guys. Why don't you just apply logic and get over it." She will feel as if the people who made her uncomfortable are being protected when she is not. She will then see TAM as even more hostile.

There are social situations that can not be addressed with logic because they are informed by far too many variables, past and present. In the case above, the [G1] is expected to wave away real social discomfort when presented with an over-simplified argument.

You can't say "Well, that's what skeptics do!" because social issues are far too nuanced to be answered with ethics 101. If the skeptics are willing to use the lowest common denominator in order to answer the social ills within their group, they are conforming to every stereotype of the pseudo-intellectual nerd who is too removed from human interaction to understand basic niceties.
 
Mapping out acceptable behavior is a futile exercise to begin with. We're dealing with people. The ramifications following an encounter with [G1] vs [1-G1] are completely different.
Agreed completely.

If a boorish man propositions [1-G1] they will shrug it off and forget it.

If a boorish man propositions [G1] that woman will feel uncomfortable. She will remember that feeling and want to avoid it in the future. So, like every other human on the planet, she will look for patterns. If enough guys at TAM make her uncomfortable, TAM will be the pattern that should be avoided.
I'm fine with this.

If some pompous skeptic sits her down and says "Look, you met dozens of men who didn't freak you out, there were only those guys. Why don't you just apply logic and get over it." She will feel as if the people who made her uncomfortable are being protected when she is not. She will then see TAM as even more hostile.
Another topic. Not my opinion. Not relevant to much. It happens. Conversely too much will be made of the event. It's important to the individual. It's worthy of discussion. It's NOT worthy of hasty generalizations or categorical conclusions.

There are social situations that can not be addressed with logic because they are informed by far too many variables, past and present. In the case above, the [G1] is expected to wave away real social discomfort when presented with an over-simplified argument.
That may well be but sans logic there is nothing else but intuition and feelings. Which is fine but those are not the basis for broad social decisions. That's life. From Infidels.org

  • I want to talk to the person in charge.
  • The person in charge is Bob.
  • I hate Bob and I don't want to talk to him.
Sometimes logic can't fully solve our problems.

You can't say "Well, that's what skeptics do!" because social issues are far too nuanced to be answered with ethics 101. If the skeptics are willing to use the lowest common denominator in order to answer the social ills within their group, they are conforming to every stereotype of the pseudo-intellectual nerd who is too removed from human interaction to understand basic niceties.
I have said repeatedly that what we should do is discuss the relevant issues, feeling and opinions. We should try to lead an examined life. What we should NOT do is categorically decide for everyone what is right and what is wrong. To do that is to use logic and to do so erroneously.
 
Agreed completely.

I'm fine with this.

Another topic. Not my opinion. Not relevant to much. It happens. Conversely too much will be made of the event. It's important to the individual. It's worthy of discussion. It's NOT worthy of hasty generalizations or categorical conclusions.

That may well be but sans logic there is nothing else but intuition and feelings. Which is fine but those are not the basis for broad social decisions. That's life. From Infidels.org

  • I want to talk to the person in charge.
  • The person in charge is Bob.
  • I hate Bob and I don't want to talk to him.
Sometimes logic can't fully solve our problems.

I have said repeatedly that what we should do is discuss the relevant issues, feeling and opinions. We should try to lead an examined life. What we should NOT do is categorically decide for everyone what is right and what is wrong. To do that is to use logic and to do so erroneously.

I'm fine with that. But how do you propose we correct for personal bias in the people who are examining their lives?
 
I'm fine with that. But how do you propose we correct for personal bias in the people who are examining their lives?
The problem doen't change regardless of what we do. At best we can discuss the issues in an attempt to change the zeitgeist. We can remind people to try and recognize their bias and to be objective in their analysis but at the end of the day we are limited to how much we can change. i think being realistic important.
 
The problem doen't change regardless of what we do. At best we can discuss the issues in an attempt to change the zeitgeist. We can remind people to try and recognize their bias and to be objective in their analysis but at the end of the day we are limited to how much we can change. i think being realistic important.

And how do you do that without "categorically decide for everyone what is right and what is wrong."

Humans have established social rituals to smooth interaction between strangers. These are neither set in stone, nor universally recognized but they do have commonalities.

For example - I mentioned offering your name before hitting on someone. Everyone opposed has been shocked, shocked I tell you! that I would try to instigate such a draconian, fascist measure! Think of all those people who get off on having sex with utter strangers, what will they do! It's horrible to think that I would try to ruin their fun, isn't it.

Actually, for this to be draconian and fascist, I would need some way to enforce it. There is none, nor will there be. Even if the JREF were to send out a social guidelines for TAM which included it, it would be as a suggestion. Not a rule because nobody is going to play "introduction monitor."

Offering suggestions is not categorically deciding. Dismissing suggestions that can not be universally applied (all of them) is once again ignoring nuance.

ETA: If there is a problem, recognizing it leads to change. Evidence? a million historical examples. Don't buy into Ginger's "a tru femenist stays sweet" nonsense.
 
Last edited:
@ Beth and Bookitty,
How are you proposing those women adjust their behavior? Simply saying 'no' is about all that they are going to do. Feeling uncomfortable is an internal reaction that many women will experience and have little control over. So are you are asking them to shut up and stop whining about it? Or are you telling them their feelings are wrong and need to change?
Good grief! Take some responsibility for your own reaction. React anyway you want, but don't hold EG responsible for your reaction. You are responsible for your reaction. EG is responsible for EG's actions, not your reaction.


People who are made uncomfortable when a stranger approaches them unasked need to adjust their behavior? How would they do that? They have no choice in the matter.
How is it neither of you have heard of the concept you control your own reaction, other people cannot 'make' you do or feel anything.


Why is it any less acceptable to consider EG's feelings than it is to consider RW's? All RW had to do was say, no thanks. That's it, end of story. All this crap about how horrible it was for RW is mind boggling. How awful for EG. It's possible he was devastated. Men are forced by society to suffer rejection. He didn't hurt anyone. He didn't attack anyone. He didn't rape or attempt to rape anyone. Maybe he didn't want to ask in front of others because the rejection would have been amplified if witnessed. The elevator was merely convenient. In the hall he might have had to catch up to RW or wait for her, making it more awkward for him. The elevator where two people are stopped and can talk seems like a reasonable place to ask someone if they are mutually interested.




How far do you want to take this? Because Jim's got a thread about women enjoying their own rapes and this sentiment would fit right in.
So you equate, "you interest me" with rape? :rolleyes:
 
And how do you do that without "categorically decide for everyone what is right and what is wrong."
The question doesn't make sense. I honestly don't know what you mean. How do I do what? Nothing in my post is categorical, implies a categorical nor does it rquire a catagorical. Perhaps I should have said "we should strive to be realistic".

Humans have established social rituals to smooth interaction between strangers. These are neither set in stone, nor universally recognized but they do have commonalities.
Conceded.

For example - I mentioned offering your name before hitting on someone. Everyone opposed has been shocked, shocked I tell you! that I would try to instigate such a draconian, fascist measure! Think of all those people who get off on having sex with utter strangers, what will they do! It's horrible to think that I would try to ruin their fun, isn't it.
I don't understand the relevance. Are you saying everyone MUST do this or are you saying that in your opinion we ought to consider ti?

Actually, for this to be draconian and fascist, I would need some way to enforce it. There is none, nor will there be. Even if the JREF were to send out a social guidelines for TAM which included it, it would be as a suggestion. Not a rule because nobody is going to play "introduction monitor."
Exactly. This is what I have been saying from day 1.

Offering suggestions is not categorically deciding. Dismissing suggestions that can not be universally applied (all of them) is once again ignoring nuance.
I'm not opposed to suggestions. I've made that point quite clear. It's why I say over and over we need to discuss the issues.

ETA: If there is a problem, recognizing it leads to change.
Conceded and I've made this same point over and over.
 
@ Beth and Bookitty,
Good grief! Take some responsibility for your own reaction. React anyway you want, but don't hold EG responsible for your reaction. You are responsible for your reaction. EG is responsible for EG's actions, not your reaction.


How is it neither of you have heard of the concept you control your own reaction, other people cannot 'make' you do or feel anything.


Why is it any less acceptable to consider EG's feelings than it is to consider RW's? All RW had to do was say, no thanks. That's it, end of story. All this crap about how horrible it was for RW is mind boggling. How awful for EG. It's possible he was devastated. Men are forced by society to suffer rejection. He didn't hurt anyone. He didn't attack anyone. He didn't rape or attempt to rape anyone. Maybe he didn't want to ask in front of others because the rejection would have been amplified if witnessed. The elevator was merely convenient. In the hall he might have had to catch up to RW or wait for her, making it more awkward for him. The elevator where two people are stopped and can talk seems like a reasonable place to ask someone if they are mutually interested.




So you equate, "you interest me" with rape? :rolleyes:

No, I equate the idea that women must control an involuntary reflex or be considered weak with the idea that women must control their involuntary response to rape.

In both cases, the suggestion is that women shut up and take it. If they don't, any negative response is on them regardless of the fact that they did not invite that attention.

The idea that other people can't "make" you feel anything is a ridiculous remnant of 70's pop-psychology. Scientific psychology recognizes that human beings react to each other within every type of social construct and that these reactions are caused by previous encounters, social messages, and other human experience.
 
Last edited:
Good grief! Take some responsibility for your own reaction. React anyway you want, but don't hold EG responsible for your reaction. You are responsible for your reaction. EG is responsible for EG's actions, not your reaction.
We are responsible for our actions, but I don't know that it makes sense to say that we are responsible for our feelings. It seems to me that while we can easily choose how we act, we can only choose how we feel through long term conscious effort, drugs, and/or psychotherapy.

So I don't understand what you are saying women should change. RW's reaction was to tell EG 'no thanks', which is the response you said women should make. You've said previously that she is entitled to whatever feelings she may have had. So what do you think she should have done differently?
 
The question doesn't make sense. I honestly don't know what you mean. How do I do what? Nothing in my post is categorical, implies a categorical nor does it rquire a catagorical. Perhaps I should have said "we should strive to be realistic".

Conceded.

I don't understand the relevance. Are you saying everyone MUST do this or are you saying that in your opinion we ought to consider ti?

Exactly. This is what I have been saying from day 1.

I'm not opposed to suggestions. I've made that point quite clear. It's why I say over and over we need to discuss the issues.
Conceded and I've made this same point over and over.

I believe you but the tendency towards rationalization via close examination of potential exceptions makes that a bit difficult. Any suggestion is either ignored or meets with cries of "but what if" followed by a scenario that is not impossible but doesn't represent the norm.
 
Why is RW not responsible for EG's feelings? Why is EG responsible for RW's? Is it because EG spoke? But our society expects the man to speak.

Is it because it was in an elevator? The idea elevators are confined spaces blah blah blah has not been established. A perception has been claimed and without evidence that is supposed to be enough. Is this a skeptics forum or not? Did the incident occur among proclaimed skeptics or not? Perception without evidence is not typically a standard for this group. Why is this an exception?

Does RW's opinion, one who claimed she didn't want to be approached, have more weight than the skeptics and atheists who state openly they do want to meet people they might be attracted to at said events?

I have not seen answers to these challenges other than sexist biased opinions of the vulnerable women, and the man who must treat said women as they dictate. What harm did EG really do? OMFSM, a woman was discomforted. He merely invited a woman to his room. Gosh, what a horrible man.
 
Why is RW not responsible for EG's feelings? Why is EG responsible for RW's? Is it because EG spoke? But our society expects the man to speak.

Is it because it was in an elevator? The idea elevators are confined spaces blah blah blah has not been established. A perception has been claimed and without evidence that is supposed to be enough. Is this a skeptics forum or not? Did the incident occur among proclaimed skeptics or not? Perception without evidence is not typically a standard for this group. Why is this an exception?

Does RW's opinion, one who claimed she didn't want to be approached, have more weight than the skeptics and atheists who state openly they do want to meet people they might be attracted to at said events?

I have not seen answers to these challenges other than sexist biased opinions of the vulnerable women, and the man who must treat said women as they dictate. What harm did EG really do? OMFSM, a woman was discomforted. He merely invited a woman to his room. Gosh, what a horrible man.


I'm sorry, what point are you addressing here? I can not find any connection to this and the last few posts.
 
I'm sorry, what point are you addressing here? I can not find any connection to this and the last few posts.
No connection? :rolleyes: Why, because you've tried to paint over your sexism with the brush of "EG might be more successful if"? You are merely suggesting.....

I'm merely pointing out the obvious continuously overlooked point. If you approach this case with a bit more gender neutrality as opposed to the woman on a pedestal approach, there is no evidence RW was ever in danger or actually intimidated, so the threat aspect is not in evidence. That leaves two equal people. Shouldn't RW defer to EG's discomfort from being rejected and seek to neutralize the discomfort by politely declining rather than making a public announcement that EG was not just rejected, but rejected with emphasis on his disliked behavior?
 
No connection? :rolleyes: Why, because you've tried to paint over your sexism with the brush of "EG might be more successful if"? You are merely suggesting.....

I'm merely pointing out the obvious continuously overlooked point. If you approach this case with a bit more gender neutrality as opposed to the woman on a pedestal approach, there is no evidence RW was ever in danger or actually intimidated, so the threat aspect is not in evidence. That leaves two equal people. Shouldn't RW defer to EG's discomfort from being rejected and seek to neutralize the discomfort by politely declining rather than making a public announcement that EG was not just rejected, but rejected with emphasis on his disliked behavior?

I have no idea how you went from "the poor menz must do this!" to gender neutral. Even more baffling is the idea that the passive party must take both control and responsibility for the interaction.

You are saying that a person who does not invite a social interaction owes the aggressive party the benefit of the doubt and furthermore should do what they can to make that interaction pleasant for the aggressor. There are entire chunks of nearly every major religion that are dedicated to this very premise, especially when it comes to women.

Also, you seem to have missed Beth's question

So I don't understand what you are saying women should change. RW's reaction was to tell EG 'no thanks', which is the response you said women should make. You've said previously that she is entitled to whatever feelings she may have had. So what do you think she should have done differently?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom