EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

So "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault" are not part of the elevator discussion? Or are you claiming these conditions have zero to do with 'fear'?

These are situations that could lead to increased awareness of one's surroundings. This can cause apprehension or discomfort. That is not the same thing as being fearful. People have degrees of response, not everyone has the dial turned up to 11 all the time.

You keep bragging about how you have waltzed through life without ever being apprehensive regardless of your surroundings. This does not mean that all women do, should be expected do, or are less whatever-the-hell you're trying to paint yourself. It is possible to be independent and to take care of yourself by noticing the world around you and being a bit more cautious based on your surroundings.
 
On that we can absolutely agree.

This doesn't answer my question. You provided a premise that we can use to determine the propriety of one's actions. You state explicitly that failure is proof of improper conduct. When challenged you don't respond in a meaningful way. You don't even say "yes" or "no". You simply go back over points that are not relevant to my focused query to you.

:( I don't accept that you can know absolutely that the variables can and always will render a single given result.

My point was quite simple and did not require all of this. The first sentence in this paragraph assumes the conclusion you are trying to establish. Your original premise, the one I took issues was simple and direct premise. Failure is proof that EG's actions were wrong. Your argument, IMO, begs the question in that it implicitly assumes the conclusion. But look, that's fine, can you just directly address my questions?

  1. Can we always assume that failure is proof that any all actions that lead to the failure were wrong?
  2. Is it possible that failure simply means that the other person does not like you?
  3. Is it possible that humans are varied and that what fails for one person will work for another?

If you have a goal and that goal is not reached because of your actions then you have failed. In EG's case, if we take him at his word, his goal was to have a longer conversation with Watson. His actions made that goal impossible to reach. He failed.

Your second question has nothing to do with EG and Watson. The reason she mentioned it was not because he shouldn't have hit on her, but that he should not have hit on her under circumstances that had many negative factors. You may not agree with the factors or with Watson's conclusion. That doesn't mean that she was saying simply "don't ever hit on people."

But to answer the question outside of elevatorgate - Yes, in some cases, no approach will work. There is nothing I can say or do that would make Johnny Depp invite me into his library. Any approach I take will end in failure. That failure will still be mine. This could happen with anyone I approach for any reason. If they don't respond to me or my request, I have failed. They carry none of the responsibility because they did not invite my approach or my request. Any response I get is on me.

Your third question is so over-simplified that it is either condescending nonsense or a leading question.
 
If you have a goal and that goal is not reached because of your actions then you have failed.
This is already conceded.

In EG's case, if we take him at his word, his goal was to have a longer conversation with Watson. His actions made that goal impossible to reach. He failed.
Doesn't answer the substance of the question but simply restates what has been conceded to over and over. That isn't helping the discussion.

But to answer the question outside of elevatorgate - Yes, in some cases, no approach will work. There is nothing I can say or do that would make Johnny Depp invite me into his library. Any approach I take will end in failure. That failure will still be mine. This could happen with anyone I approach for any reason. If they don't respond to me or my request, I have failed. They carry none of the responsibility because they did not invite my approach or my request. Any response I get is on me.
Then by your own addmission failure means little to nothing. One can do everything right and still fail. Therefore we cannot infer that failure is proof of impropriety or even bad decisions.

Your third question is so over-simplified that it is either condescending nonsense or a leading question.
:( No. It's substantive and goes to the very heart of everything.

If the proposition is true then we cannot infer that EG's failure must be extrapolated to other similar situations. Given that the variables are, by your own admission, crucial for success or failure then all must be considered. George Clooney might never be turned down in an elevator. It could be that 30% of men are never turned down in an elevator (totally made up figure). The bottom line is that we cannot make a hasty generaliztion from these specifics. Further, accusing me of condesension for simply stating a proposition and giving you the opportunity to falsify or confirm it is an ad hominem.

Look, I don't mind at all if you call me out for being snarky. I'm trying really hard not to be. But that isn't helping anything. Meet me half way here.
 
Last edited:
As for 'fearfulness' vs 'tendency to discomfort', it seems to be the same thing as discussed in this thread.

A 'tendency to discomfort' could be something entirely different. It could be someone who just felt embarrassed in the situation. It could be someone being slightly bothered because she was longing to get to bed. However, such 'discomfort' is trivial and clearly we can't expect people to anticipate this or to change their behaviour to avoid these possibilities.

However, if the discomfort is really based in a fear of assault, then it is still fear, even if the person is quite calm and only very moderately alarmed. This is the kind of discomfort that we can reasonably expect others to take into consideration.

I don't know what kind of discomfort RW meant, and I don't think it's wise to speculate. She clearly does not want to portray herself as a victim and shouldn't have to. But when discussing the general situation, I think we have to assume that we're talking about fear. Because I'm certainly not going to stop propositioning women simply because they might find it embarrassing. Trust me, it's much worse for me.
 
Because you've said EG should not do [X]. But [X] is OK for some women, just not all women. How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't? Your answer keeps going back to, [X] is obvious, everyone should know that.
Er, no. My answer is that since he can't tell, if he doesn't want to accidently make the woman uncomfortable, he should refrain from asking her to his room in the elevator. I think it's clear that it isn't obvious to all, but hopefully this conversation has enlightened those who did not realize that it would discomfort many women.
OTOH, the evidence of elevator assaults does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone on an elevator with a strange man. The evidence of assaults on a woman alone with a strange man in every situation possible does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone with a strange man in any location whatsoever. It is not rational, if we define rational as evidence based, to fear the situation based solely on the elements we have as described by RW, a seemingly polite come on in an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am.
Again, you use the term fear, and describe it as an 'exceptional' fear. I think this is a major point of contention. RW was not afraid, she was uncomfortable.

A large percentage of women have stated they too would be uncomfortable in that situation. That means that what you are describing as 'exceptional' fear isn't exceptional, it's common, and isn't fear, it's discomfort. Why conclude that because you would not be bothered by the elements RW described that it isn't rational for other women to feel uncomfortable in that situation?
You are ignoring pages of discussion including some of your own which included the following: "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault". That's fear, not merely embarrassment or other forms of discomfort. RW never claimed she feared EG and in fact IIRC, she denied it. But that hasn't stopped the direction of the conversation toward the 'fear factor'.
I'm not ignoring those comments. I've made some of them. There is a vast difference between being uncomfortable and being afraid. I would be uncomfortable in the situation RW described.

Fear is what happens when a man I don't know grabs me, pushes me up against the wall, presses his body up against mine and informs me that if I'm not nice to him he'll hurt me.

Discomfort describes the awareness that you are in a place (such as an elevator) where such a thing could occur and you are powerless to stop it if the male with you chooses to do that.

Fear describes the emotion felt when such a event actually happens. (Just to make it clear, I'm not claiming to speak for all women. Some other women, such as yourself, might not find such a situation fear inducing.)

What is it they are to be made aware of?
That many women are discomfitted by strangers asking them to come to their room while in an isolated space without a convenient exit, such as an elevator.
Some women don't want to be approached?
This is where you are extrapolating beyond what is reasonable.
This is where you are claiming all should see things your way.
I don't see this as claiming all should see things my way. I see this as helping others to understand my POV. But I'll try to keep your reaction in mind.
Frankly, if I were EG, given the image RW actively promotes, I'd be surprised by her reaction and would not think it was reasonable to expect RW would have reacted the way she did.
As described by RW, EG was polite and considerate.
No. Polite may be an apt description, but considerate he was not.
He didn't whip out his dong. The rest is a judgement call that depends solely on one's individual values which we agree vary.
Yes, we agree such values vary. OTOH I think it's reasonable to expect a bit more from adult men in our society than just keeping their dong in their pants in public places. It's possible to be rude and/or inconsiderate while keeping it sheathed.
Parking lots, empty streets and dark alleys have evidence based support for the conclusion more assaults occur in those locations than other locations. According to the evidence we have, that is not the case for elevators.
I disagree. I look at the evidence and come to a different conclusion that you do. I think elevators have more assaults than say, hotel lobbies and restaurants. I think the risk is less than parking lots and dark alleys, but that doesn't mean it's as safe as any other location.
Basically, it's an isolated place where an attacker can prevent you from leaving or others from entering. That makes it riskier than the hotel lobby, bar or restaurant. If you don't agree, before claiming the evidence supports your view, I suggest you do some googling to compare how many reported rapes or sexual assaults have happened hotel lobbies and compare it to the reports of rapes or sexual assaults in hotel elevators.
The harm is the impossibility for men to use the lowest common denominator for deciding what is OK and what is not OK for how one approaches a woman. Whipping out one's dong is a very high common denominator. Asking a women to your room for coffee is a very low common denominator. It's not that far from the very lowest common denominator of don't ever approach a woman because some of them don't want to be approached.
Asking a woman you've never met to your room is not exactly a low common denominator - sure, some women might be willing but the majority of sane rational women do not accompany strangers to private places like hotel rooms. Combine that request with asking in an enclosed isolated space and we're not talking about the lowest common denominator but one that is going to make a large percentage, quite possibly more than half, of women uncomfortable.

Since we are not talking about what you term the 'lowest common denominator', what exactly is the harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.
 
Last edited:
Asking a woman you've never met to your room is not exactly a low common denominator - sure, some women might be willing but the vast majority of sane rational women do not accompany strangers to private places like hotel rooms.
Majority, perhaps, but vast majority? Casual sex does happen. Frequently.
 
Er, no. My answer is that since he can't tell, if he doesn't want to accidently make the woman uncomfortable, he should refrain from asking her to his room in the elevator.
Still? Really?

So, again, since men can't know for certain, ever, just don't ever ask. :boggled:

Hey, I've never known for certain. Some women can be nice and cordial but not find you attractive. Asking them out can make them uncomfortable. It's not as if you don't have a point, it's that you push it to absurd extremes.
 
Er, no. My answer is that since he can't tell, if he doesn't want to accidently make the woman uncomfortable, he should refrain from asking her to his room in the elevator. I think it's clear that it isn't obvious to all, but hopefully this conversation has enlightened those who did not realize that it would discomfort many women.
Round and round the mulberry bush....

Stop yourself. Do not reply without thinking it through. You keep repeating this answer while avoiding the facts you have been asked to address.

How is EG supposed to know?
You claim he should assume [X].
You decided what [X] should be.
There are dozens of things EG could asume. What makes your [X] the correct thing EG should assume?

Some women are going to be discomforted no matter what the circumstances. That is the lowest common denominator.

According to your rationale, EG should never approach any woman ever because he could assume at least one of them would be discomforted regardless of the circumstances. If that is not your rationale, then how does EG determine what is rude and what isn't? If one woman feels it is rude, 10%, 50%?


Again, you use the term fear, and describe it as an 'exceptional' fear. I think this is a major point of contention. RW was not afraid, she was uncomfortable.
This semantics quibble is a red herring in this discussion.


A large percentage of women have stated they too would be uncomfortable in that situation. That means that what you are describing as 'exceptional' fear isn't exceptional, it's common, and isn't fear, it's discomfort. Why conclude that because you would not be bothered by the elements RW described that it isn't rational for other women to feel uncomfortable in that situation?
And a whole bunch of women said they would not be discomforted. EG has a 50:50 chance.


Let's go back to the supposed harm done. Hypothetically, say out of 10 women, 5 would be bothered, 4 would just say no thanks, and one might be interested. Should EG go for it? Was the harm done to the 5 discomforted women really so bad that EG should pass up the chance to meet that one woman who might have been interested?


That many women are discomfitted by strangers asking them to come to their room while in an isolated space without a convenient exit, such as an elevator.
If you are going to talk about "an isolated space without a convenient exit" then don't expect me to ignore that I interpret that description as fear, regardless of the degree.


This is where you are extrapolating beyond what is reasonable. I don't see this as claiming all should see things my way. I see this as helping others to understand my POV. But I'll try to keep your reaction in mind.
No. Polite may be an apt description, but considerate he was not.
Yes, we agree such values vary. OTOH I think it's reasonable to expect a bit more from adult men in our society than just keeping their dong in their pants in public places. It's possible to be rude and/or inconsiderate while keeping it sheathed.
This is all opinion. There is no right or wrong.

I've only insisted the evidence does not support the elevator as any more risky a location for an encounter than anywhere else. The rest is opinion which I have no issue that others' opinions vary. You can believe EG was rude and/or inconsiderate. I don't. There is no evidence which would prove you are right. It's opinion.



I disagree. I look at the evidence and come to a different conclusion that you do. I think elevators have more assaults than say, hotel lobbies and restaurants. I think the risk is less than parking lots and dark alleys, but that doesn't mean it's as safe as any other location.
Basically, it's an isolated place where an attacker can prevent you from leaving or others from entering. That makes it riskier than the hotel lobby, bar or restaurant. If you don't agree, before claiming the evidence supports your view, I suggest you do some googling to compare how many reported rapes or sexual assaults have happened hotel lobbies and compare it to the reports of rapes or sexual assaults in hotel elevators.
You have proposed an hypothesis. Because the elevator has [Y] qualities, you hypothesize it is a riskier place. However, Dr Buzzo is the only one so far to present evidence that tests your hypothesis and his evidence refutes your hypothesis.

I don't recall you have addressed this evidence or presented anything other than your hypothesis.


Asking a woman you've never met to your room is not exactly a low common denominator - sure, some women might be willing but the majority of sane rational women do not accompany strangers to private places like hotel rooms. Combine that request with asking in an enclosed isolated space and we're not talking about the lowest common denominator but one that is going to make a large percentage, quite possibly more than half, of women uncomfortable.

Since we are not talking about what you term the 'lowest common denominator', what exactly is the harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.
Here we are again. You claim you are not telling me what my opinion should be, then you procede to tell me what my opinion should be.

I'm telling you there is no evidence supporting your conclusion about the elevator. I have no problem with your different opinion of EG's behavior until you tell EG that he should conform to your opinion.


Can you address the evidence of elevator risk vs the opinion of proper behavior?
 
Last edited:
Round and round the mulberry bush....

Stop yourself. Do not reply without thinking it through. You keep repeating this answer while avoiding the facts you have been asked to address.
May I suggest you take your own advice.
How is EG supposed to know?
I don't think he can.
You claim he should assume [X].
You decided what [X] should be.
There are dozens of things EG could asume. What makes your [X] the correct thing EG should assume?
If you go back and actually read what I wrote, you'll notice that I phrased things as if....then. That means that I haven't decided what he should assume, but predicated the suggestion on the impression he might wish to make.
Some women are going to be discomforted no matter what the circumstances. That is the lowest common denominator.
Yes. The way you are phrasing it, I get the impression that something that only affected a very small proposition of women would be considered the 'lowest common denominator'. Am I misinterpreting your use of that phrase? Because I don't think that something that affects such a sizable portion of the female population is legitimately termed the 'lowest common denominator'.
According to your rationale, EG should never approach any woman ever because he could assume at least one of them would be discomforted regardless of the circumstances.
No, that is not my rationale.
If that is not your rationale, then how does EG determine what is rude and what isn't? If one woman feels it is rude, 10%, 50%?
It is of course up to EG (or other men in similar situations) to decide what proportion of women that might be offended is worth the risk.

I think it is at least helpful to them to have some idea of what that risk is. If the population of women who have posted comments to this incident is valid estimate of the overall population rate, it would appear that 50% or more are likely to consider it rude.

Let's go back to the supposed harm done. Hypothetically, say out of 10 women, 5 would be bothered, 4 would just say no thanks, and one might be interested. Should EG go for it? Was the harm done to the 5 discomforted women really so bad that EG should pass up the chance to meet that one woman who might have been interested?
He doesn't have to pass up that chance, he only needs to delay his request briefly to reduce his risk of offending and thereby increase his probability of success. And yes, I think the harm done exceeds whatever gain (if any) EG gets from making his request at an inappropriate time and place.
If you are going to talk about "an isolated space without a convenient exit" then don't expect me to ignore that I interpret that description as fear, regardless of the degree.
If you mean the same sort of 'fear' that you experience when you decide to get your keys out before you approach your car in a parking lot, then your choice of phrasing leaves the reader with inappropriate connotations. If that isn't what you mean, then it isn't an appropriate choice to describe the emotion. Apprehensive might be more acceptable to both of us.
This is all opinion. There is no right or wrong.
Excuse me. I said
I think it's reasonable to expect a bit more from adult men in our society than just keeping their dong in their pants in public places. It's possible to be rude and/or inconsiderate while keeping it sheathed.
Are you seriously saying it's a matter of opinion regarding whether it's possible for a man to be rude or inconsiderate if he hasn't taken his cock out and waved it around?
I've only insisted the evidence does not support the elevator as any more risky a location for an encounter than anywhere else.
I disagree. There are a number of documented instances of rapes occurring in hotel elevators. Not many, but not zero. I have not found one documented case of a rape occurring in a hotel lobby. It may have happened, but clearly not near as frequently as in the elevator. IMO, that is evidence that supports the hypothesis of the elevator being a riskier location for an encounter than the lobby.
You have proposed an hypothesis. Because the elevator has [Y] qualities, you hypothesize it is a riskier place. However, Dr Buzzo is the only one so far to present evidence that tests your hypothesis and his evidence refutes your hypothesis.
No, Dr. Buzzo's evidence does not test that hypothesis.
I don't recall you have addressed this evidence or presented anything other than your hypothesis.
Addressed this evidence in what way? That rapes occurring in a hotel elevator are rare? I don't contest that point, I simply don't draw the same conclusion from that evidence that you do.
Here we are again. You claim you are not telling me what my opinion should be, then you procede to tell me what my opinion should be.
????? Where did I tell you what your opinion should be?

I'm telling you there is no evidence supporting your conclusion about the elevator. I have no problem with your different opinion of EG's behavior until you tell EG that he should conform to your opinion.
????? Where did I tell EG he should conform to my opinion?
Can you address the evidence of elevator risk vs the opinion of proper behavior?
See above.
 
Ignoring (as usual) the fact that I said it was rude, not wrong, EG wanted Watson in his room for coffee. That did not happen. In fact, it backfired strongly enough that Watson discussed it negatively. It's safe to say that if developing any sort of relationship with Watson was his goal, his approach was wrong. It failed.

This is unquestionably true. However, there's something that I'm getting the impression that most women don't realize.

Disclaimer, I would never do anything like what EG did. If I wanted to get into Watson's pants (which seems highly unlikely), I would have developed a close rapport with her in the bar. If I wanted to talk to her (slightly less unlikely), I would have suggested a meeting the next day, perhaps breakfast. All that's as may be. I don't think that anybody is saying that EG was a smooth mofo.

Still, the probability of success per targeted pickup is really quite small. 5% is good. 25% is guru status. About the only way to get higher than that is a broadcast method, such as by being a rock star or going to a swing club and not being too picky.

So going on about a single failure isn't likely to be convincing.
 
You think EG was rude. I don't, Where does that leave us?
I don't think EG was rude. I don't think there is any reason to believe that most women would have had the same response as RW. I think at best we talk about the situation. Give advice. Try to find the best ways to solve problems and move on.

It's seems to me that this side is saying that RW is entitled to feel the way she did but there is nothing objectively wrong with what EG did. It's arguable that he could have picked a better place and a better time. It's arguable that his odds were poor for success. What's not arguable, IMO, is that there is only one narrow way to view the situation. And don't tell me that's a straw man or otherwise this whole mess would have been over with weeks ago.
 
This is already conceded.

Doesn't answer the substance of the question but simply restates what has been conceded to over and over. That isn't helping the discussion.

Then by your own addmission failure means little to nothing. One can do everything right and still fail. Therefore we cannot infer that failure is proof of impropriety or even bad decisions.

:( No. It's substantive and goes to the very heart of everything.

If the proposition is true then we cannot infer that EG's failure must be extrapolated to other similar situations. Given that the variables are, by your own admission, crucial for success or failure then all must be considered. George Clooney might never be turned down in an elevator. It could be that 30% of men are never turned down in an elevator (totally made up figure). The bottom line is that we cannot make a hasty generaliztion from these specifics. Further, accusing me of condesension for simply stating a proposition and giving you the opportunity to falsify or confirm it is an ad hominem.

Look, I don't mind at all if you call me out for being snarky. I'm trying really hard not to be. But that isn't helping anything. Meet me half way here.

It seems as if you are trying to convince me that there is no bad behavior, only unfortunate circumstances. I'm afraid I can not agree.

It is well documented that human beings are horrible at judging themselves. They think they are smarter, more insightful, better looking, etc, etc then they actually are. The Dunning–Kruger effect, for example. Amazingly they manage to do all that while simultaneously being terribly insecure and easily wounded by other people's opinion. Humans are strange. All of us.

Humans also tend toward personal bias and are very, very good at hearing what they want to hear. This gets exaggerated when self interest is involved. Add attraction and it's off the chart.

We have already seen that people are perfectly willing to risk discomforting the majority in case some unknown minority might respond favorably. The minority count is also being falsely magnified because a neutral response is being counted as a favorable one. "I don't mind" is given the same weight as "Yes, I will go to your room."

Even my most banal suggestions (Take a few seconds to consider the circumstances, or give someone your name before hitting on them) have met with vehement opposition. Which, frankly, I find a bit bizarre.

If you take it outside the implication of this specific argument, you have two average people who have never spoken before. The man leads with something that can be taken as a proposition. In real day-to-day life, what are his chances? Maybe 1% on a good day. Yes, casual sex happens. Yes there are people who will go to your hotel room without even knowing your name. But they are hardly the majority. Even those who have slept with someone after 2 seconds of knowing them and without names being exchanged, have also turned down other people, or spent some time getting to know other partners.

I've seen the intro stages to hundreds of one night stands. I've only seen "Nice shoes, wanna ****" work once.

The idea that there are attractive people out there who will follow you to your hotel room after the most cursory conversation is a lovely one. We all like to think that we are universally endowed with enough niftyness to make that happen. If we get any confirmation of that particular bias, we run with it. It's what human beings do. All of us.

So I am a little wary of saying anything that will feed into that because I have seen the effects of rude behavior. Worse, those who are most likely to be boorish are using EG to bolster their own bias. They are only listening to those people who tell them that they can, nay it's their right, to proposition any women, anywhere, anyhow. That's just not good for anyone.

So that is where I am coming from. It is not an argument or a refutation of what you have said.
 
Where did I tell you what your opinion should be?
Where did I tell EG he should conform to my opinion?
You think EG was rude. I don't, Where does that leave us?
I actually would like to know what caused to you to feel that I was telling you what your opinion should be or where I told EG he should conform to my opinion. It was not my intention to do so. I'd like to know why what I wrote was interpreted that way in order to adjust my phrasing in the future.
Even my most banal suggestions (Take a few seconds to consider the circumstances, or give someone your name before hitting on them) have met with vehement opposition. Which, frankly, I find a bit bizarre.
Some people have suggested that the extinction of the human race is the inevitable outcome if such suggestions were taken seriously. It boggles my mind. At the same time, apparently those who view this incident differently from us are equally mystified by our reactions.
The idea that there are attractive people out there who will follow you to your hotel room after the most cursory conversation is a lovely one. We all like to think that we are universally endowed with enough niftyness to make that happen.
Yes, it's only females that are so endowed. ;)
I am a little wary of saying anything that will feed into that because I have seen the effects of rude behavior. Worse, those who are most likely to be boorish are using EG to bolster their own bias. They are only listening to those people who tell them that they can, nay it's their right, to proposition any women, anywhere, anyhow. That's just not good for anyone.
So that is where I am coming from. It is not an argument or a refutation of what you have said.
bookitty, I want to thank you for your posts on this issue. I have, at times, felt like I was the only one posting with that POV on this forum. It's nice to know I'm not.

I think your last paragraph also returns to the original problem that RW was concerned with - that such behavior (whether you agree that it is sexist or not) is one reason that women are not well represented in the skeptic movement. While we can't know how much of a problem it is (it may not be significant), some women have indeed testified that is why they don't attend such events. The intense reaction to even 'banal' suggestions indicates to me that whatever the size of that problem, it isn't going to be getting smaller in the near future.
 
How about we try it like this:

This is the argument:
[X] makes many [G1] uncomfortable therefore members of [G2] should [Y]

X="Being propositioned in elevators or other encloses spaces"
G1= Females
G2= Males
Y="should try to avoid doing X"

Does that cover the argument from all sides? If not please lets clear it up.

Once that is done, let's start substituting the variables and see how that argument holds up.

EX:
X="Being rejected when propositioning for sex"
G1=Males
G2=Females
Y="should try to avoid doing X"
 
It seems as if you are trying to convince me that there is no bad behavior, only unfortunate circumstances. I'm afraid I can not agree.
Nope. Not even close. Entirely off the subject of what I was talking about but that's fine. I'm not trying to convince you of anything. I'm trying to show you that the logic you used in that one instance was flawed. And it is, demonstrably so.

But since you are attributing something to me that isn't remotely in keeping with my feelings on the subject I will respond.

  1. I believe that good people with good intentions can cause others to feel uneasy or unsafe.
  2. I believe it's a good thing for everyone, men particularly, to know this.
  3. I believe it was entirely appropriate for RW to express her feelings.
  4. I respect RW's feelings (the ones she had at the time).
  5. I DON'T believe that we have enough information to determine that EG's behavior was bad in any absolute sense.
  6. I DON'T believe EG's behavior was bad.
  7. I believe it can be argued that EG's behavior was perhaps unwise.
  8. I believe it can be argued that EG's behavior was poorly timed.
  9. I believe in the dialectic.
  10. I believe that those who are trying to get others to believe that there EG's behavior can only be seen as bad are wasting their time and have a faulty sense of ethics and morality.
 
How about we try it like this:

This is the argument:
[X] makes many [G1] uncomfortable therefore members of [G2] should [Y]

X="Being propositioned in elevators or other encloses spaces"
G1= Females
G2= Males
Y="should try to avoid doing X"

Does that cover the argument from all sides? If not please lets clear it up.

Once that is done, let's start substituting the variables and see how that argument holds up.

EX:
X="Being rejected when propositioning for sex"
G1=Males
G2=Females
Y="should try to avoid doing X"

I think this argument is dependent on content, not form. There are examples that work both ways.

EX:
X = "Protesting war"
G1 = Military people
G2 = Antiwar activists
Y ="should try to avoid doing X"

X = "Taxing the rich in order to reduce the deficit"
G1 = Rich people
G2 = Politicians
Y ="should try to avoid doing X"

X = "Saying Prayer at H.S. graduation"
G1 = Atheists
G2 = Graduation speakers
Y ="should try to avoid doing X"

X = "Eating Ice Cream in public"
G1 = Lactose Intolerant People
G2 = People who like ice cream
Y ="should try to avoid doing X"

X = walking around nude
G1 = non - nudists
G2 = nudists
Y ="should try to avoid doing X"

X = proselytizing religion on the street
G1 = some people
G3 = religious fanatics
X ="should try to avoid doing X"

Note that for the last two examples, one is legal behavior, the other is not. The illegal behavior is not, in and of itself, harmful to anyone as evidenced by nudist colonies where such behavior is perfectly acceptable.
 
Last edited:
What's wrong with:

[X] makes some [G1] uncomfortable but it's really such a small thing that no one need adjust their behavior. It's simple enough for [G1] to simply say, no thanks.

Or how about those 'uncomfortable women' might want to consider it is they who need to adjust their behavior and it is sexist to believe it is up to [G2] to adjust theirs?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom