Because you've said EG should not do [X]. But [X] is OK for some women, just not all women. How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't? Your answer keeps going back to, [X] is obvious, everyone should know that.
Er, no. My answer is that since he can't tell, if he doesn't want to accidently make the woman uncomfortable, he should refrain from asking her to his room in the elevator. I think it's clear that it isn't obvious to all, but hopefully this conversation has enlightened those who did not realize that it would discomfort many women.
OTOH, the evidence of elevator assaults does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone on an elevator with a strange man. The evidence of assaults on a woman alone with a strange man in every situation possible does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone with a strange man in any location whatsoever. It is not rational, if we define rational as evidence based, to fear the situation based solely on the elements we have as described by RW, a seemingly polite come on in an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am.
Again, you use the term fear, and describe it as an 'exceptional' fear. I think this is a major point of contention. RW was not afraid, she was uncomfortable.
A large percentage of women have stated they too would be uncomfortable in that situation. That means that what you are describing as 'exceptional' fear isn't exceptional, it's common, and isn't fear, it's discomfort. Why conclude that because you would not be bothered by the elements RW described that it isn't rational for other women to feel uncomfortable in that situation?
You are ignoring pages of discussion including some of your own which included the following: "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault". That's fear, not merely embarrassment or other forms of discomfort. RW never claimed she feared EG and in fact IIRC, she denied it. But that hasn't stopped the direction of the conversation toward the 'fear factor'.
I'm not ignoring those comments. I've made some of them. There is a vast difference between being uncomfortable and being afraid. I would be uncomfortable in the situation RW described.
Fear is what happens when a man I don't know grabs me, pushes me up against the wall, presses his body up against mine and informs me that if I'm not nice to him he'll hurt me.
Discomfort describes the awareness that you are in a place (such as an elevator) where such a thing could occur and you are powerless to stop it if the male with you chooses to do that.
Fear describes the emotion felt when such a event actually happens. (Just to make it clear, I'm not claiming to speak for all women. Some other women, such as yourself, might not find such a situation fear inducing.)
What is it they are to be made aware of?
That many women are discomfitted by strangers asking them to come to their room while in an isolated space without a convenient exit, such as an elevator.
Some women don't want to be approached?
This is where you are extrapolating beyond what is reasonable.
This is where you are claiming all should see things your way.
I don't see this as claiming all should see things my way. I see this as helping others to understand my POV. But I'll try to keep your reaction in mind.
Frankly, if I were EG, given the image RW actively promotes, I'd be surprised by her reaction and would not think it was reasonable to expect RW would have reacted the way she did.
As described by RW, EG was polite and considerate.
No. Polite may be an apt description, but considerate he was not.
He didn't whip out his dong. The rest is a judgement call that depends solely on one's individual values which we agree vary.
Yes, we agree such values vary. OTOH I think it's reasonable to expect a bit more from adult men in our society than just keeping their dong in their pants in public places. It's possible to be rude and/or inconsiderate while keeping it sheathed.
Parking lots, empty streets and dark alleys have evidence based support for the conclusion more assaults occur in those locations than other locations. According to the evidence we have, that is not the case for elevators.
I disagree. I look at the evidence and come to a different conclusion that you do. I think elevators have more assaults than say, hotel lobbies and restaurants. I think the risk is less than parking lots and dark alleys, but that doesn't mean it's as safe as any other location.
Basically, it's an isolated place where an attacker can prevent you from leaving or others from entering. That makes it riskier than the hotel lobby, bar or restaurant. If you don't agree, before claiming the evidence supports your view, I suggest you do some googling to compare how many reported rapes or sexual assaults have happened hotel lobbies and compare it to the reports of rapes or sexual assaults in hotel elevators.
The harm is the impossibility for men to use the lowest common denominator for deciding what is OK and what is not OK for how one approaches a woman. Whipping out one's dong is a very high common denominator. Asking a women to your room for coffee is a very low common denominator. It's not that far from the very lowest common denominator of don't ever approach a woman because some of them don't want to be approached.
Asking a woman you've never met to your room is not exactly a low common denominator - sure, some women might be willing but the majority of sane rational women do not accompany strangers to private places like hotel rooms. Combine that request with asking in an enclosed isolated space and we're not talking about the lowest common denominator but one that is going to make a large percentage, quite possibly more than half, of women uncomfortable.
Since we are not talking about what you term the 'lowest common denominator', what exactly is the harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.