EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Could you give an example of an isolated space where it is NOT reasonable to be 'apprehensive' when approached by a stranger requesting sex? I'm having a hard time thinking of one. (Please don't say 'elevators' as that is the space under dispute.)
"Stranger requesting sex" is not part of the specific scenario my comments applied to. Beth, you are not posting as rationally as usual in this discussion.

But as long as you want to add things to the scenario, if an attractive man approached me in a stairwell or on the street alone, and with a nice smile said, "Hi, what's your name?", I would not be "apprehensive". In fact, it has happened and I was not.


No one has said this.
Yes they have. "Guys, don't do that", was the exact quote, and people in the discussion suggested men should not approach women because 'some' of the women might be made uncomfortable.


What they have said is that if a man is going to proposition a woman he's unacquainted with, it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep, which is unproductive for him and is likely to create a situation that is unpleasant for both parties. Your rephrasing of that suggestion to what your wrote above is insulting and incorrect.
Your rephrasing shows you aren't paying attention to the comments in the discussion. But even taking the claim as you have rephrased it, we are back to the same problem you keep sidestepping. It comes back to what Linda asked in the first page of the main elevator thread. Please address it in light of your statement: "it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep,"

I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?)

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?)

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar?

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date.

Linda
(emphasis mine)
 
Last edited:
OTOH, I think it's reasonable to assume that most men would prefer to make their proposition in such as way that they have the best possible odds of getting a positive response.
Sure, but if that was the only concern, making propositions in elevators suddenly sounds like a great idea.

The thing is, if this is the only concern, then women who say no effectively don't matter. A no is just a no regardless of whether she is 'creeped out' or not. So whenever I find myself in an elevator at 4 am with a woman I'm not introduced to, I should proposition her. Because I'm very unlikely to get a better chance, I should take the small chance I have.

So I think you need to understand that while I certainly agree that men should take women's comfort into the equation, that requires sacrifice on the part of the man. It's not just a matter of being 'smart', since, as RW:s story shows, it's not enough to just be polite and optimize your chances. You actually have to forsake some chances altogether.
 
If I were trying to say that they made a difference instead of pointing out that they constituted an equivalent or better to an eye-witness, then, yes I would. I think that evidence exists, but it's not very important, as we already have some primary information about the safety of hotel elevators.

You know what? I was all ready to go back and quote you saying that it does make it safer and "ha HA!" you but when I read back, I realized you said nothing of the sort. I do apologize and can only assume I was reading words but not reading what you were saying. My apologies.
 
"Stranger requesting sex" is not part of the specific scenario my comments applied to. Beth, you are not posting as rationally as usual in this discussion.
I went back and reviewed the prior posts with regard to this branch of the conversation. There really isn't any indication one way or the other, so I don't think that misunderstanding is entirely my fault and I don't think your accusation is justified. At any rate, I specifically included the part about 'stranger requesting sex' because it is part of the circumstances that I think should be taken into account in understanding why some apprehension is justified.
But as long as you want to add things to the scenario, if an attractive man approached me in a stairwell or on the street alone, and with a nice smile said, "Hi, what's your name?", I would not be "apprehensive". In fact, it has happened and I was not
And if the man was not attractive and instead of asking your name, asked you to come to his hotel room? Personally I think a bit of apprehension would be justified. As to whether a street would be considered an isolated space depends on specifics. Even if they aren't other people around, if there are homes or open businesses, it's not exactly isolated. A street in the warehouse district after midnight, OTOH, would likely be fairly isolated. In that situation, I think apprehension would be justified, particularly if a man you didn't know approached and propositioned you.

IMO there are relatively few circumstances where a woman is expected to share an isolated space with a single strange man - places like stairwells, elevators and parking lots - and those are places that women are given specific instructions to help them stay safe in those situations.

That was why I was wondering if you could give examples of isolated spaces where apprehension about being approached by a strange man requesting sex would not be justified. So far, what you are posting basically amounts to "if I'm not apprehensive, I don't consider it rational for other women to be apprehensive either." I hope you'll understand why I don't find that argument persuasive.

What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.
No one has said this.
Yes they have. "Guys, don't do that", was the exact quote, and people in the discussion suggested men should not approach women because 'some' of the women might be made uncomfortable.
Those statements are not the same. You are inferring a great deal from the phrase 'guys don't do that' that isn't part of the original message. Even the later suggestions that men not approach women don't amount to telling every male that he must anticipate their fear regardless of how misplaced it might be. In addition, the suggestions I've seen were that certain venues, such as elevators, were inappropriate for a man to approach a woman, not that they should never do so.

Your rephrasing shows you aren't paying attention to the comments in the discussion.
I think that statement would apply more to your rephrasing than to mine.
But even taking the claim as you have rephrased it, we are back to the same problem you keep sidestepping. It comes back to what Linda asked in the first page of the main elevator thread. Please address it in light of your statement: "it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep,"
(emphasis mine)
I don't think I've sidestepped this issue, but I'll answer it now. This is the phrase you bolded :
But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

This is not a binary situation, as there can be considerable overlap. IMO, 'hitting on someone' is indicating you want to have sex with them. I think that it's possible to indicate that you are attracted to someone without also indicating you want sex. For example, EG could have asked RW if she wanted to have coffee with him somewhere other than his hotel room. It would have indicated he was attracted to her yet it would not have been interpreted as a request for sex - i.e. hitting on her.
 
It would have indicated he was attracted to her yet it would not have been interpreted as a request for sex - i.e. hitting on her.
Would you consider re-wording this. I think this hits the nail on the head of the problem. I don't think every woman would interpret it as a categorical. I think you are talking about probabilities but conflating that with absolutes.
 
I went back and reviewed the prior posts with regard to this branch of the conversation. There really isn't any indication one way or the other, so I don't think that misunderstanding is entirely my fault and I don't think your accusation is justified. At any rate, I specifically included the part about 'stranger requesting sex' because it is part of the circumstances that I think should be taken into account in understanding why some apprehension is justified.
I'm not sure we need to quibble over this so don't take this as me making a big deal of it. I add this for clarification, and not much more. I don't see how you can read "stranger requesting sex" as included in Bookitty's original claim:
So where do you draw the line? Please tell me the precise location where a woman can be assured of zero risk when encountering a stranger.
You used the word, "propositioned" and said, "IMO, it is the awareness of being in a vulnerable space with a stranger whom they cannot predict his next actions." But my reply was to Bookitty's comment that encountering a stranger alone anywhere would necessarily cause "apprehension".
If there is no greater risk on an elevator, the risk would be equal to any other place in which one was alone with a stranger. To always feel absolutely no apprehension under those circumstances would be fool-hardy. ...
Let's say I am in the stairwell of a subway, a very specific location in which I am always a bit more cautious. I have not googled to check how many attacks in subway stairwells have been reported to the media.* If I were to do so and then divide that number by the estimated number of people on subway stairwells at any given time, the statistics would show that I have little to worry about. There are millions of people on subway stairwells worldwide on any given day and even if the reports of attacks were in the 100's, using your version of risk-assessment would indicate that it is safe.

Should I then relax my guard? ...


Anyway, moving on...


And if the man was not attractive and instead of asking your name, asked you to come to his hotel room? Personally I think a bit of apprehension would be justified. As to whether a street would be considered an isolated space depends on specifics. Even if they aren't other people around, if there are homes or open businesses, it's not exactly isolated. A street in the warehouse district after midnight, OTOH, would likely be fairly isolated. In that situation, I think apprehension would be justified, particularly if a man you didn't know approached and propositioned you.
You are talking about your opinion and experience vs mine. There is no right or wrong yet it appears you are trying to say there is.

Are we not allowed to view the world differently in regards to risk? I repeat what I said early on in this discussion, I've traveled all over the world, frequently and often alone. I can probably count the times I was ever in danger on one hand. The Universe I live in is shockingly safe.


IMO there are relatively few circumstances where a woman is expected to share an isolated space with a single strange man - places like stairwells, elevators and parking lots - and those are places that women are given specific instructions to help them stay safe in those situations.

That was why I was wondering if you could give examples of isolated spaces where apprehension about being approached by a strange man requesting sex would not be justified. So far, what you are posting basically amounts to "if I'm not apprehensive, I don't consider it rational for other women to be apprehensive either." I hope you'll understand why I don't find that argument persuasive.
This straw man just won't die. When are you going to stop repeating it?

I feel sorry for women who are as fearful as you are describing, but I certainly don't expect them to be like me.

The issue has NEVER been about anyone's individual reaction. The issue has ALWAYS been about expecting men to treat all women as fearful when some of us clearly aren't. How are men supposed to know in advance which women are OK with the elevator come on and which women are not OK with it? The claim is being made that fearful women are the norm and men should know that and act accordingly.



Those statements are not the same. You are inferring a great deal from the phrase 'guys don't do that' that isn't part of the original message.
I beg to differ with you. RW elaborated on her meaning of, "Guys, don't do that" as have most of the people siding with camp Rebecca. They've made clear their unreasonable expectation of what guys should not do at atheist and skeptic events.


Even the later suggestions that men not approach women don't amount to telling every male that he must anticipate their fear regardless of how misplaced it might be. In addition, the suggestions I've seen were that certain venues, such as elevators, were inappropriate for a man to approach a woman, not that they should never do so.
Just in those situations involving elevators?

I think that statement would apply more to your rephrasing than to mine.

I don't think I've sidestepped this issue, but I'll answer it now. This is the phrase you bolded :
But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

This is not a binary situation, as there can be considerable overlap. IMO, 'hitting on someone' is indicating you want to have sex with them. I think that it's possible to indicate that you are attracted to someone without also indicating you want sex. For example, EG could have asked RW if she wanted to have coffee with him somewhere other than his hotel room. It would have indicated he was attracted to her yet it would not have been interpreted as a request for sex - i.e. hitting on her.
The whole point has been that not all women agree with yours, Bookitty's and RW's conclusion that EG's actions were obviously wrong. So what are the future EG's to do? Assume all women are fearful and not approach them the way the original EG did? Or assume some women are not so fearful and consider, why not ask?
 
Last edited:
The whole point has been that not all women agree with yours, Bookitty's and RW's conclusion that EG's actions were obviously wrong. So what are the future EG's to do? Assume all women are fearful and not approach them the way the original EG did? Or assume some women are not so fearful and consider, why not ask?

Take elevator sex out of the equation and I don't see how procreation can be on-going. Where do people hook up?
 
I'm not sure we need to quibble over this so don't take this as me making a big deal of it. I add this for clarification, and not much more. I don't see how you can read "stranger requesting sex" as included in Bookitty's original claim:You used the word, "propositioned" and said, "IMO, it is the awareness of being in a vulnerable space with a stranger whom they cannot predict his next actions." But my reply was to Bookitty's comment that encountering a stranger alone anywhere would necessarily cause "apprehension".


Anyway, moving on...


You are talking about your opinion and experience vs mine. There is no right or wrong yet it appears you are trying to say there is.

Are we not allowed to view the world differently in regards to risk? I repeat what I said early on in this discussion, I've traveled all over the world, frequently and often alone. I can probably count the times I was ever in danger on one hand. The Universe I live in is shockingly safe.


This straw man just won't die. When are you going to stop repeating it?

I feel sorry for women who are as fearful as you are describing, but I certainly don't expect them to be like me.

The issue has NEVER been about anyone's individual reaction. The issue has ALWAYS been about expecting men to treat all women as fearful when some of us clearly aren't. How are men supposed to know in advance which women are OK with the elevator come on and which women are not OK with it? The claim is being made that fearful women are the norm and men should know that and act accordingly.



I beg to differ with you. RW elaborated on her meaning of, "Guys, don't do that" as have most of the people siding with camp Rebecca. They've made clear their unreasonable expectation of what guys should not do at atheist and skeptic events.


Just in those situations involving elevators?

The whole point has been that not all women agree with yours, Bookitty's and RW's conclusion that EG's actions were obviously wrong. So what are the future EG's to do? Assume all women are fearful and not approach them the way the original EG did? Or assume some women are not so fearful and consider, why not ask?

Ignoring (as usual) the fact that I said it was rude, not wrong, EG wanted Watson in his room for coffee. That did not happen. In fact, it backfired strongly enough that Watson discussed it negatively. It's safe to say that if developing any sort of relationship with Watson was his goal, his approach was wrong. It failed.
 
Ignoring (as usual) the fact that I said it was rude, not wrong, EG wanted Watson in his room for coffee. That did not happen. In fact, it backfired strongly enough that Watson discussed it negatively. It's safe to say that if developing any sort of relationship with Watson was his goal, his approach was wrong. It failed.
I'm not sure how failure is proof of anything other than one or multiple variables conspired against EG (conspired is metaphorical). Let me see if I understand you. Any and all failure is proof that you are doing something wrong and must never do that again? If another woman simply doesn't like me, if I ask her in the right way and in the right place I will be successful regardless?

I apologize if that is in anyway condescending. I re-wrote it a couple of times.
 
Ignoring (as usual) the fact that I said it was rude, not wrong, EG wanted Watson in his room for coffee. That did not happen. In fact, it backfired strongly enough that Watson discussed it negatively. It's safe to say that if developing any sort of relationship with Watson was his goal, his approach was wrong. It failed.

Just because you haven't had an elevator experience doesn't mean one can't be around the corner. I can only be in so many places at once :rolleyes:
 
I'm not sure how failure is proof of anything other than one or multiple variables conspired against EG (conspired is metaphorical). Let me see if I understand you. Any and all failure is proof that you are doing something wrong and must never do that again? If another woman simply doesn't like me, if I ask her in the right way and in the right place I will be successful regardless?

I apologize if that is in anyway condescending. I re-wrote it a couple of times.

EG's act was a singular moment. The variables in place are not likely to be repeated. If his goal was to further his relationship with Watson, that action he took at that time was not successful.

There is nothing to be learned by separating out each particular variable and finding/defending it's flaws. Under different circumstances, each would be better or worse. Not being aware of the whole created a failure that was noteworthy. This is not the first time that Watson has been approached* and declined. Those incidents were not noteworthy because there were fewer negative variables.

EG was not passive, there was no outside conspiring, even metaphorically. There was a guy who just made a few bad choices. This isn't uncommon, it will happen again and the variables for that instance will only superficially resemble elevatorgate. The only way to avoid such a thing, if that is even a goal, is to consider the surroundings.

(*although it may be the last :D)
 
Skeptic Ginger said:
You are talking about your opinion and experience vs mine. There is no right or wrong yet it appears you are trying to say there is.
This is interesting. I feel the same about what you wrote. That there is no right or wrong, yet it appears to me that you are trying to say there is. I'll talk more about why I feel that way below. Can you tell me why you feel that I am saying that some responses are right and some are wrong?
Are we not allowed to view the world differently in regards to risk? I repeat what I said early on in this discussion, I've traveled all over the world, frequently and often alone. I can probably count the times I was ever in danger on one hand. The Universe I live in is shockingly safe.
Absolutely, we are allowed to view the world differently. The universe I live in has a 100% fatality rate for humans. :)
So far, what you are posting basically amounts to "if I'm not apprehensive, I don't consider it rational for other women to be apprehensive either." I hope you'll understand why I don't find that argument persuasive.
This straw man just won't die. When are you going to stop repeating it?
I'm not sure why you consider this to be a straw man argument. If you don't consider it irrational for other women to be apprehensive in such situations, why do you say such things as the following:
What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.
and
I feel sorry for women who are as fearful as you are describing, but I certainly don't expect them to be like me.
Such statements are why I paraphrased you as above and why I feel that you are saying that there are right and wrong ways to respond to such situations. Such statements seem denigrating those women who find such situations uncomfortable by calling them fearful and implying that their apprehension is misplaced - i.e. irrational.
The issue has NEVER been about anyone's individual reaction. The issue has ALWAYS been about expecting men to treat all women as fearful when some of us clearly aren't. How are men supposed to know in advance which women are OK with the elevator come on and which women are not OK with it? The claim is being made that fearful women are the norm and men should know that and act accordingly.
You are again substituting fearful for uncomfortable. But fearful is not a synonym for uncomfortable or even apprehensive in this context. I wouldn't consider RW a fearful woman. She travels alone to foreign countries, serves as a keynote speaker at a conference and hangs out in the hotel bar until 4am. Fearful woman don't do that. She was made uncomfortable, not afraid, due to EG's actions. That discomfort is, in fact, a very common reaction. I think it is reasonable for men to be aware of that. I think that this conversation has hopefully been enlightening in that regard for those men who were not aware of that.
Those statements are not the same. You are inferring a great deal from the phrase 'guys don't do that' that isn't part of the original message.
I beg to differ with you. RW elaborated on her meaning of, "Guys, don't do that" as have most of the people siding with camp Rebecca. They've made clear their unreasonable expectation of what guys should not do at atheist and skeptic events.
I don't think they have unreasonable expectations. Why do you find it an unreasonable expectation for a man, hoping to get better acquainted with a woman he hasn't met yet, to be considerate in making a request and think about how his request is likely to be perceived by a woman he wants to get better acquainted with?
Even the later suggestions that men not approach women don't amount to telling every male that he must anticipate their fear regardless of how misplaced it might be. In addition, the suggestions I've seen were that certain venues, such as elevators, were inappropriate for a man to approach a woman, not that they should never do so.
Just in those situations involving elevators?
I think some people extended it to dark alleys and empty streets late at night. I don't think anyone ever said that they should never approach a woman.
The whole point has been that not all women agree with yours, Bookitty's and RW's conclusion that EG's actions were obviously wrong. So what are the future EG's to do? Assume all women are fearful and not approach them the way the original EG did? Or assume some women are not so fearful and consider, why not ask?
Again, you equate uncomfortable in that situation with being a fearful woman. I do not think these are synonymous.

Future EG's could wait until the elevator is open and the woman isn't confined in an isolated space with him before asking her to his room. Or they could ask her for coffee at a location that isn't their hotel room. Or they could just go ahead and ask and take the risk that she'll find him creepy and never want to talk with him again. Clearly there are many different options available to men including going ahead with approaches such as EG made. No one has said that they can't. The expression 'guys don't do this' wasn't a command. It wasn't saying that men should never approach women. It was a way of letting guys know that many, perhaps most, women are going to find such behavior creepy and off putting.

I realize that not all women would be uncomfortable in such a situation, but what is harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.
 
<snip>

EG was not passive, there was no outside conspiring, even metaphorically. There was a guy who just made a few bad choices. This isn't uncommon, it will happen again and the variables for that instance will only superficially resemble elevatorgate. The only way to avoid such a thing, if that is even a goal, is to consider the surroundings. <snip>

The bolded part is the contention here.

That statement is only true in retrospect and only if we make the assumption that his goal was to have sex with Watson or some other woman who is fearful in enclosed spaces (which we can grant so we don't get too pedantic). Any general advice here would have to take the form of "hey keep in mind some women are fearful in enclosed spaces so if you want to increase your chance of success with such a person try to pick a better place".
 
The bolded part is the contention here.

That statement is only true in retrospect and only if we make the assumption that his goal was to have sex with Watson or some other woman who is fearful in enclosed spaces (which we can grant so we don't get too pedantic). Any general advice here would have to take the form of "hey keep in mind some women are fearful in enclosed spaces so if you want to increase your chance of success with such a person try to pick a better place".

Again - apprehensive or uncomfortable is not fearful.

Also, did you miss the entire paragraph about how individual details are not as important as the whole? The only advice that can be taken from this is "You've heard from some women about various situations that might make them uncomfortable. So, if your goal is a positive outcome, it might be better to pause for a few seconds and see if there is any way to decrease the possibility of discomfort." Or, if you prefer, "a little empathy goes a long way at the beginning of any sort of relationship."
 
Last edited:
EG's act was a singular moment. The variables in place are not likely to be repeated. If his goal was to further his relationship with Watson, that action he took at that time was not successful.
On that we can absolutely agree.

There is nothing to be learned by separating out each particular variable and finding/defending it's flaws. Under different circumstances, each would be better or worse. Not being aware of the whole created a failure that was noteworthy. This is not the first time that Watson has been approached* and declined. Those incidents were not noteworthy because there were fewer negative variables.
This doesn't answer my question. You provided a premise that we can use to determine the propriety of one's actions. You state explicitly that failure is proof of improper conduct. When challenged you don't respond in a meaningful way. You don't even say "yes" or "no". You simply go back over points that are not relevant to my focused query to you.

EG was not passive, there was no outside conspiring, even metaphorically.
:( I don't accept that you can know absolutely that the variables can and always will render a single given result.

There was a guy who just made a few bad choices. This isn't uncommon, it will happen again and the variables for that instance will only superficially resemble elevatorgate. The only way to avoid such a thing, if that is even a goal, is to consider the surroundings.
My point was quite simple and did not require all of this. The first sentence in this paragraph assumes the conclusion you are trying to establish. Your original premise, the one I took issues was simple and direct premise. Failure is proof that EG's actions were wrong. Your argument, IMO, begs the question in that it implicitly assumes the conclusion. But look, that's fine, can you just directly address my questions?

  1. Can we always assume that failure is proof that any all actions that lead to the failure were wrong?
  2. Is it possible that failure simply means that the other person does not like you?
  3. Is it possible that humans are varied and that what fails for one person will work for another?
 
Last edited:
Again - apprehensive or uncomfortable is not fearful.
That was not the point. You can take "fearful of enclosed spaces" and replace it with anything that person might be feeling at that time. The argument doesn't change. As you point out the argument is in effect about someone being considerate. That is fine as long as it is not made a universal rule. Calling what the guy did rude/wrong/stupid etc after the fact infers the opinion (always be considerate) as universal when it clearly can't be so.

Also, did you miss the entire paragraph about how individual details are not as important as the whole? <snip>

I did and disagree with it. The details are always important because in the end they make up the whole. If they are not correct or skewed then the whole can simply be wrong which negates the importance of the whole. Anyway this is not the point I wanted to argue anyway so that is why I didn't comment on it the first time around.
 
Last edited:
This is interesting. I feel the same about what you wrote. That there is no right or wrong, yet it appears to me that you are trying to say there is. I'll talk more about why I feel that way below. Can you tell me why you feel that I am saying that some responses are right and some are wrong?
Because you've said EG should not do [X]. But [X] is OK for some women, just not all women. How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't? Your answer keeps going back to, [X] is obvious, everyone should know that.

It's obvious EG should not whip his dong out on the elevator. It is not obvious EG should refrain from speaking politely to a lone woman on an elevator. It is not obvious that asking said lone woman back to EG's hotel room for coffee means EG wants sex, nor that it is obvious no woman would ever go to EG's hotel room or feel safe doing so.


Beth said:
So far, what you are posting basically amounts to "if I'm not apprehensive, I don't consider it rational for other women to be apprehensive either." I hope you'll understand why I don't find that argument persuasive.
SG said:
This straw man just won't die. When are you going to stop repeating it?
Beth said:
I'm not sure why you consider this to be a straw man argument. If you don't consider it irrational for other women to be apprehensive in such situations, why do you say such things as the following:
SG said:
What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.
and
SG said:
I feel sorry for women who are as fearful as you are describing, but I certainly don't expect them to be like me.
Beth said:
Such statements are why I paraphrased you as above and why I feel that you are saying that there are right and wrong ways to respond to such situations. Such statements seem denigrating those women who find such situations uncomfortable by calling them fearful and implying that their apprehension is misplaced - i.e. irrational.
Perhaps the quibble here is over the term, "rational" vs accepting someone's individual reaction might differ from mine.

There are many variables that could go into a woman's reaction to EG or to how the woman feels about being alone in an elevator with a strange man. I don't claim to know all such variables and to be able to say if an individual's response was rational given those variables.

OTOH, the evidence of elevator assaults does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone on an elevator with a strange man. The evidence of assaults on a woman alone with a strange man in every situation possible does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone with a strange man in any location whatsoever. It is not rational, if we define rational as evidence based, to fear the situation based solely on the elements we have as described by RW, a seemingly polite come on in an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am.


You are again substituting fearful for uncomfortable. But fearful is not a synonym for uncomfortable or even apprehensive in this context. I wouldn't consider RW a fearful woman. She travels alone to foreign countries, serves as a keynote speaker at a conference and hangs out in the hotel bar until 4am. Fearful woman don't do that. She was made uncomfortable, not afraid, due to EG's actions. That discomfort is, in fact, a very common reaction.
You are ignoring pages of discussion including some of your own which included the following: "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault". That's fear, not merely embarrassment or other forms of discomfort. RW never claimed she feared EG and in fact IIRC, she denied it. But that hasn't stopped the direction of the conversation toward the 'fear factor'.


I think it is reasonable for men to be aware of that. I think that this conversation has hopefully been enlightening in that regard for those men who were not aware of that.
What is it they are to be made aware of? Some women don't want to be approached? This is where you are claiming all should see things your way. Frankly, if I were EG, given the image RW actively promotes, I'd be surprised by her reaction and would not think it was reasonable to expect RW would have reacted the way she did.


I don't think they have unreasonable expectations. Why do you find it an unreasonable expectation for a man, hoping to get better acquainted with a woman he hasn't met yet, to be considerate in making a request and think about how his request is likely to be perceived by a woman he wants to get better acquainted with?
As described by RW, EG was polite and considerate. He didn't whip out his dong. The rest is a judgement call that depends solely on one's individual values which we agree vary.


I think some people extended it to dark alleys and empty streets late at night. I don't think anyone ever said that they should never approach a woman.
Parking lots, empty streets and dark alleys have evidence based support for the conclusion more assaults occur in those locations than other locations. According to the evidence we have, that is not the case for elevators.


Future EG's could wait until the elevator is open and the woman isn't confined in an isolated space with him before asking her to his room. Or they could ask her for coffee at a location that isn't their hotel room. Or they could just go ahead and ask and take the risk that she'll find him creepy and never want to talk with him again. Clearly there are many different options available to men including going ahead with approaches such as EG made. No one has said that they can't. The expression 'guys don't do this' wasn't a command. It wasn't saying that men should never approach women. It was a way of letting guys know that many, perhaps most, women are going to find such behavior creepy and off putting.

I realize that not all women would be uncomfortable in such a situation, but what is harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.
The harm is the impossibility for men to use the lowest common denominator for deciding what is OK and what is not OK for how one approaches a woman.

Whipping out one's dong is a very high common denominator. Asking a women to your room for coffee is a very low common denominator. It's not that far from the very lowest common denominator of don't ever approach a woman because some of them don't want to be approached.
 
Again - apprehensive or uncomfortable is not fearful.....
So "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault" are not part of the elevator discussion? Or are you claiming these conditions have zero to do with 'fear'?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom