This is interesting. I feel the same about what you wrote. That there is no right or wrong, yet it appears to me that you are trying to say there is. I'll talk more about why I feel that way below. Can you tell me why you feel that I am saying that some responses are right and some are wrong?
Because you've said EG should not do [X]. But [X] is OK for some women, just not all women. How is EG supposed to know when it is OK and when it isn't? Your answer keeps going back to, [X] is obvious, everyone should know that.
It's obvious EG should not whip his dong out on the elevator. It is not obvious EG should refrain from speaking politely to a lone woman on an elevator. It is not obvious that asking said lone woman back to EG's hotel room for coffee means EG wants sex, nor that it is obvious no woman would ever go to EG's hotel room or feel safe doing so.
Beth said:
So far, what you are posting basically amounts to "if I'm not apprehensive, I don't consider it rational for other women to be apprehensive either." I hope you'll understand why I don't find that argument persuasive.
SG said:
This straw man just won't die. When are you going to stop repeating it?
Beth said:
I'm not sure why you consider this to be a straw man argument. If you don't consider it irrational for other women to be apprehensive in such situations, why do you say such things as the following:
SG said:
What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.
and
SG said:
I feel sorry for women who are as fearful as you are describing, but I certainly don't expect them to be like me.
Beth said:
Such statements are why I paraphrased you as above and why I feel that you are saying that there are right and wrong ways to respond to such situations. Such statements seem denigrating those women who find such situations uncomfortable by calling them fearful and implying that their apprehension is misplaced - i.e. irrational.
Perhaps the quibble here is over the term, "rational" vs accepting someone's individual reaction might differ from mine.
There are many variables that could go into a woman's reaction to EG or to how the woman feels about being alone in an elevator with a strange man. I don't claim to know all such variables and to be able to say if an individual's response was rational given those variables.
OTOH, the evidence of elevator assaults does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone on an elevator with a strange man. The evidence of assaults on a woman alone with a strange man in every situation possible does not support 'exceptional' fear of being alone with a strange man in any location whatsoever. It is not rational, if we define rational as evidence based, to fear the situation based solely on the elements we have as described by RW, a seemingly polite come on in an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am.
You are again substituting fearful for uncomfortable. But fearful is not a synonym for uncomfortable or even apprehensive in this context. I wouldn't consider RW a fearful woman. She travels alone to foreign countries, serves as a keynote speaker at a conference and hangs out in the hotel bar until 4am. Fearful woman don't do that. She was made uncomfortable, not afraid, due to EG's actions. That discomfort is, in fact, a very common reaction.
You are ignoring pages of discussion including some of your own which included the following: "enclosed space" "no exit" "no witnesses" "potential for assault". That's fear, not merely embarrassment or other forms of discomfort. RW never claimed she feared EG and in fact IIRC, she denied it. But that hasn't stopped the direction of the conversation toward the 'fear factor'.
I think it is reasonable for men to be aware of that. I think that this conversation has hopefully been enlightening in that regard for those men who were not aware of that.
What is it they are to be made aware of? Some women don't want to be approached? This is where you are claiming all should see things your way. Frankly, if I were EG, given the image RW actively promotes, I'd be surprised by her reaction and would not think it was reasonable to expect RW would have reacted the way she did.
I don't think they have unreasonable expectations. Why do you find it an unreasonable expectation for a man, hoping to get better acquainted with a woman he hasn't met yet, to be considerate in making a request and think about how his request is likely to be perceived by a woman he wants to get better acquainted with?
As described by RW, EG was polite and considerate. He didn't whip out his dong. The rest is a judgement call that depends solely on one's individual values which we agree vary.
I think some people extended it to dark alleys and empty streets late at night. I don't think anyone ever said that they should never approach a woman.
Parking lots, empty streets and dark alleys have evidence based support for the conclusion more assaults occur in those locations than other locations. According to the evidence we have, that is not the case for elevators.
Future EG's could wait until the elevator is open and the woman isn't confined in an isolated space with him before asking her to his room. Or they could ask her for coffee at a location that isn't their hotel room. Or they could just go ahead and ask and take the risk that she'll find him creepy and never want to talk with him again. Clearly there are many different options available to men including going ahead with approaches such as EG made. No one has said that they can't. The expression 'guys don't do this' wasn't a command. It wasn't saying that men should never approach women. It was a way of letting guys know that many, perhaps most, women are going to find such behavior creepy and off putting.
I realize that not all women would be uncomfortable in such a situation, but what is harm in suggesting that, absent any knowledge of what the woman is like, they avoid triggering such discomfort in case the woman they are soliciting does find it creepy.
The harm is the impossibility for men to use the lowest common denominator for deciding what is OK and what is not OK for how one approaches a woman.
Whipping out one's dong is a very high common denominator. Asking a women to your room for coffee is a very low common denominator. It's not that far from the very lowest common denominator of don't ever approach a woman because some of them don't want to be approached.