EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

You found N attacks with cameras. You'd need to know how many attacks were deterred by cameras to know what percentage were and were not deterred.

To be fair, so would you, to conclude that cameras make a difference at all. My only point was, I didn't have to do any work to find elevator assaults involving cameras. The first four that came up all had security cameras and that wasn't even the criteria I was looking for.
 
If there is no greater risk on an elevator, the risk would be equal to any other place in which one was alone with a stranger. To always feel absolutely no apprehension under those circumstances would be fool-hardy.
You are making a false claim here. All places one might be alone with a stranger are not equal, nor are all encounters with strangers equal. But seriously, if you are that paranoid, how do you leave your house? You are claiming it is fool-hearty to not be apprehensive every time and in every place where a woman encounters a man alone? Good grief!


I'd also like to know how "rational thinkers" are supposed to ascertain the danger of very specific circumstances before the research has been done as you somehow expect of Watson.

Let's say I am in the stairwell of a subway, a very specific location in which I am always a bit more cautious. I have not googled to check how many attacks in subway stairwells have been reported to the media.* If I were to do so and then divide that number by the estimated number of people on subway stairwells at any given time, the statistics would show that I have little to worry about. There are millions of people on subway stairwells worldwide on any given day and even if the reports of attacks were in the 100's, using your version of risk-assessment would indicate that it is safe.

Should I then relax my guard?

(*A rather silly method of ascertaining definite numbers, btw.)
This has been discussed ad nauseum. RW was welcome to feel anyway that suited her. You are welcome to feel anyway that suits you.

What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.
 
Attacks in subway stairwells might be so common that they are under-reported in the media because it is not news. Using the logic above would lead someone who is not familiar with a subway system to conclude that it is safe. This would be detrimental.

Rape is very often unreported. Even if it is reported, not every rape will make it into the papers regardless of location because rape is also too common. Of the three women I know who were brutally raped, only one had mention in the newspapers. That was only because there was speculation that her attacker might have been the night stalker (a famous serial killer.)
Again, there is real risk and perceived risk. We encounter both daily throughout our lives. Some real risk, people hardly think twice about. The most common cause of death for young adults is vehicle accidents. Does that keep you from getting in a car when you want to do something as unnecessary as going to the store for a candy bar? Do you plan your day to include as little time in your car as possible?

Do you eat at restaurants? Aren't you afraid someone will infect you with a disease? It happens all the time. Food borne illness is extremely common. Shouldn't you prepare all your own food so as to not take risks?

Aren't you apprehensive every moment you are in public? Suppose some mass shooter crosses your path? Do you have bars on your windows? Aren't you afraid a man will break in your house and rape you? And why fear strangers? Aren't more rapes carried out by acquaintances than strangers?


How did you decide that being alone in the vicinity of a male was the thing to fear and not being home alone, or being in a crowd where a shooter might like the easy target of a bunch of people together?


IMO, your approach to risk is flawed.
 
Again, there is real risk and perceived risk. We encounter both daily throughout our lives. Some real risk, people hardly think twice about. The most common cause of death for young adults is vehicle accidents. Does that keep you from getting in a car when you want to do something as unnecessary as going to the store for a candy bar? Do you plan your day to include as little time in your car as possible?

Do you eat at restaurants? Aren't you afraid someone will infect you with a disease? It happens all the time. Food borne illness is extremely common. Shouldn't you prepare all your own food so as to not take risks?

Aren't you apprehensive every moment you are in public? Suppose some mass shooter crosses your path? Do you have bars on your windows? Aren't you afraid a man will break in your house and rape you? And why fear strangers? Aren't more rapes carried out by acquaintances than strangers?


How did you decide that being alone in the vicinity of a male was the thing to fear and not being home alone, or being in a crowd where a shooter might like the easy target of a bunch of people together?


IMO, your approach to risk is flawed.

Would that be my actual approach to risk, or the one you have created for me? Seeing as they are completely unrelated, I will need further clarification.
 
Would that be my actual approach to risk, or the one you have created for me? Seeing as they are completely unrelated, I will need further clarification.
It's quite interesting you, of all people, should complain about straw men.
 
You are making a false claim here. All places one might be alone with a stranger are not equal, nor are all encounters with strangers equal. But seriously, if you are that paranoid, how do you leave your house? You are claiming it is fool-hearty to not be apprehensive every time and in every place where a woman encounters a man alone? Good grief!
Could you give an example of an isolated space where it is NOT reasonable to be 'apprehensive' when approached by a stranger requesting sex? I'm having a hard time thinking of one. (Please don't say 'elevators' as that is the space under dispute.)
What you are not welcome to do is to tell every male that he must anticipate your fear, regardless of how misplaced your fear is, and he must treat all women as if they were fearful little creatures lest the man frighten the poor little things.

No one has said this. What they have said is that if a man is going to proposition a woman he's unacquainted with, it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep, which is unproductive for him and is likely to create a situation that is unpleasant for both parties. Your rephrasing of that suggestion to what your wrote above is insulting and incorrect.
 
Last edited:
Could you give an example of an isolated space where it is NOT reasonable to be 'apprehensive' when approached by a stranger requesting sex?
Did we decide that an invitation to coffee is a defacto request for sex? How long have we been dealing with this and it is still characterized this way? If SG conceded this point and I missed it or if you are assuming the point for arguments sake then I sincerely apologize.

No one has said this. What they have said is that if a man is going to proposition a woman he's unacquainted with, it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep, which is unproductive for him and is likely to create a situation that is unpleasant for both parties. Your rephrasing of that suggestion to what your wrote above is insulting and incorrect.
Many women will find being propositioned by many men creepy regardless of the situation.

This is another thing that I cannot fathom as to how its missed. It's been argued ad nauseam yet people still craft arguments as if no one had ever uttered a word.

There are NO bright and shiny lines. There are no absolutes. Now, I think what I understand you to be saying, which is really quite different from what you are saying. That there is some percentage of the population that is more likely to find being asked to coffee (and can we be honest enough to state the facts and not some assumption) in an elevator to be creepy than others.

If you can agree to that and stick to that I would not bother to reply.
 
Last edited:
<snip>What they have said is that if a man is going to proposition a woman he's unacquainted with, it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep, which is unproductive for him and is likely to create a situation that is unpleasant for both parties. <snip>

What if there is a man that wants to rule out going out with women that would be creeped out by that behavior and the best way to spot these women is to proposition them in this manner? With this behavior he could be removing an unsuitable person while at the same time giving himself the possibility of finding a person that he would enjoy spending time with. Your discomfort becomes irrelevant to such a person.
 
What if there is a man that wants to rule out going out with women that would be creeped out by that behavior and the best way to spot these women is to proposition them in this manner? With this behavior he could be removing an unsuitable person while at the same time giving himself the possibility of finding a person that he would enjoy spending time with. Your discomfort becomes irrelevant to such a person.

Yes. What point are you trying to communicate?
 
To be fair, so would you, to conclude that cameras make a difference at all. My only point was, I didn't have to do any work to find elevator assaults involving cameras. The first four that came up all had security cameras and that wasn't even the criteria I was looking for.

If I were trying to say that they made a difference instead of pointing out that they constituted an equivalent or better to an eye-witness, then, yes I would. I think that evidence exists, but it's not very important, as we already have some primary information about the safety of hotel elevators.
 
Rape is very often unreported. Even if it is reported, not every rape will make it into the papers regardless of location because rape is also too common. Of the three women I know who were brutally raped, only one had mention in the newspapers. That was only because there was speculation that her attacker might have been the night stalker (a famous serial killer.)

It is true that it is unreported very often. Only a minority of cases are reported, in the case of sexual assault and battery, a small minority. However, a couple of things.

We can play with the numbers. The number of reported rapes in hotel elevators is so small that, even if multiplied by 100, it is less than the number of deaths by lightning over a similar time period.

We can also compare reports to vicim surveys. Victim surveys always produce higher numbers than police reports, and by comparing the two, we can get a pretty good idea of what percentage of crimes are reported. It's unfortunately low, but nowhere near as low as 1 in 100.

As for reporting, I'm sure that very few crimes make big stories, but most newspapers have "blotter" columns that report most reported crimes, and these would show up on searches as well.

There's also the security camera aspect. I don't know what the probability is that a security operator would report a crime to the police, but it would have to be extremely low indeed to make much difference with respect to the argument.
 
Yes. What point are you trying to communicate?

<snip>What they have said is that if a man is going to proposition a woman he's unacquainted with, it's appropriate for him to try to anticipate common fears that many women will experience because otherwise, he is acting like a creep, which is unproductive for him and is likely to create a situation that is unpleasant for both parties. <snip>

In my example I am pointing out that the bolded part of your quote would not be true. My example shows that the exchange would be productive for that person and he might not have an unpleasant experience. With that in mind telling that person not to proposition people he is not acquainted with does not work.
 
In my example I am pointing out that the bolded part of your quote would not be true. My example shows that the exchange would be productive for that person and he might not have an unpleasant experience. With that in mind telling that person not to proposition people he is not acquainted with does not work.

Okay. You're right. For men who don't care about discomfitting other people and are not interested in successfully propositioning a woman who would find such behavior creepy, but instead want to make potential partners feel creeped out in order to weed out those individuals who are put off by such behavior, such advice is not appropriate.

OTOH, I think it's reasonable to assume that most men would prefer to make their proposition in such as way that they have the best possible odds of getting a positive response. For those guys (which I hope is the vast majority of men in my society), it's good advice.
 
Okay. You're right. For men who don't care about discomfitting other people and are not interested in successfully propositioning a woman who would find such behavior creepy, but instead want to make potential partners feel creeped out in order to weed out those individuals who are put off by such behavior, such advice is not appropriate.

OTOH, I think it's reasonable to assume that most men would prefer to make their proposition in such as way that they have the best possible odds of getting a positive response. For those guys (which I hope is the vast majority of men in my society), it's good advice.

I don't think anybody has any problem with the statement:

"Some women have a fear of being propositioned in enclosed space so work your strategy in such a way to minimize that fear if at all possible"

The problem was always with:

"Never proposition women in elevators"
 
I don't think anybody has any problem with the statement:

"Some women have a fear of being propositioned in enclosed space so work your strategy in such a way to minimize that fear if at all possible"

The problem was always with:

"Never proposition women in elevators"

Neither of those two statements is equivalent to what I have said.
 
Okay. You're right. For men who don't care about discomfitting other people and are not interested in successfully propositioning a woman who would find such behavior creepy, but instead want to make potential partners feel creeped out in order to weed out those individuals who are put off by such behavior, such advice is not appropriate.

OTOH, I think it's reasonable to assume that most men would prefer to make their proposition in such as way that they have the best possible odds of getting a positive response. For those guys (which I hope is the vast majority of men in my society), it's good advice.
It MIGHT be good advice.

Is this thing on?

Life really isn't so neat and tidy. And you DON'T know what is the best strategy. You think you do. I get that. And that's fine but your opinion is just that. Not without some reason but it's just an intuition based on your life's experiences.

This kind of "I know and you don't" is counter productive to a discussion.
 
OTOH, I think it's reasonable to assume that most men would prefer to make their proposition in such as way that they have the best possible odds of getting a positive response. For those guys (which I hope is the vast majority of men in my society), it's good advice.

Now, this is new and interesting. Do you really hope that? One of the biggest complaints that I hear from women about men is that they do optimize for their chances of success at the expense of honesty.
 
  • Side A: Let's look at the data, discuss and leave it to the individual to decide (they will anyway).
  • Side B: Let's all agree that statistics show that there is only one appropriate way to act.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom