EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Point of order, ladies and gentlemen.

I see a few posts up that RW is posited as having a below average threshold for creepiness.

I'd like to offer the following as a counter to that.

RW likes to hang around skeptics
Many skeptics are geeks
Some geeks are a bit creepy

It is quite possible that RW has an average to above average creepy tolerance, which puts EG in the average to above average in creepy quotient.

Does this make sense?
Not from my perspective buy maybe from some others'. I wasn't going by EG. I can't tell if he was or was not creepy based solely on RW's description.

What I did not find creepy was the elevator in a 5 star hotel alone at 4 am in Dublin. My comment was, I've traveled to numerous countries alone and only in extremely rare circumstances did I ever find myself concerned about my safety. None of said circumstances were in nice hotels, elevator or time included. I have had some concerns about fire safety in some hotels, and the security of leaving valuables in the room, but it was never other people threatening me that was my concern.

Linda also noted that speaking to RW shouldn't be any more creepy than simply being in the elevator with RW and not saying anything.
 
Last edited:
There's a guy in the skeptical community who goes out of his way to get women drunk, offers to walk them back wherever, and then just ushers them to his room. This individual lies about several key things as well - things that would really make a difference. After some asking around, I believe the women he has done this to numbers in the dozens. I should add - this is not a TAM-related thing.

Can you elaborate on how a man goes out of his way to get a woman drunk? We're talking about adult women who have experience drinking, not teenage girls having their first rum and Cokes, correct? You're not implying that he's pouring vodka shots into her lemonade when she's not looking, are you? How does he "usher" them to his room? Are they so inebriated they don't notice that they are on a different floor or whatever?

The description you've given paints women in a very negative light.
 
Well, I've made it through all 7 pages, and I have to say one of the things I find most creepy about the whole thing is this thread. This thread really shows that there are at least a few people on this forum that really don't understand what sexism, sexist behavior, or sexual harassment is.

Here is a clue.
YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "creepy".
YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's anxiety about a situation is justified or not.

There have been several examples put forth in this thread of women stating they felt sexually harassed in the skeptical community as well as at TAM events in particular.

An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "Our colleagues have told us they have been sexually harassed in our community or at our events. What can we do to stop this sexual harassment?"

An INappropriate response would be to start a thread asking for evidence of harassment so that you could (by some unknown and unstated formula) evaluate whether they were really actually harassed or not. Why would you feel a need to question their ability to state what happened or whether they felt harassed? Could you be harboring your own sexist delusions that women would lie about this, or that these women could not be trusted to understand what was really happening to them? These are all professional, smart, accomplished women. Why not just believe them?



And Thrasher, I have to say I think some of your comments here are sexist.

On the one hand you say that the stated example of women getting interupted in a meeting might not be sexist because the women were all just acting "meekly" (so it's her own fault if she gets interupted), and then you turn around and question how an adult woman could possibly get plied with alcohol by a man (again, so what she gets is her own fault) Add this to "We also don't know if the women who attend these events have a lower threshold for creepiness" (so their testimony really can't be relied upon) and "Then don't hang out in the hotel bar until 4:00 AM. If you do, expect those things that happen in and around a bar at 4:00 AM to happen but with more frequency." (again with the "it's her own fault" thing.)

Are you starting to see a pattern here? I do. I sincerely hope you will take these comments as an opportunity to examine and evaluate your own deeply held beliefs about women.



So here are a couple examples of sexism in the forum for you Skeptic Ginger. This thread itself, and Thrasher's comments.
 
Well, I've made it through all 7 pages, and I have to say one of the things I find most creepy about the whole thing is this thread. This thread really shows that there are at least a few people on this forum that really don't understand what sexism, sexist behavior, or sexual harassment is.

Here is a clue.
YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "creepy".
YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's anxiety about a situation is justified or not.

There have been several examples put forth in this thread of women stating they felt sexually harassed in the skeptical community as well as at TAM events in particular.

An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "Our colleagues have told us they have been sexually harassed in our community or at our events. What can we do to stop this sexual harassment?"

An INappropriate response would be to start a thread asking for evidence of harassment so that you could (by some unknown and unstated formula) evaluate whether they were really actually harassed or not. Why would you feel a need to question their ability to state what happened or whether they felt harassed? Could you be harboring your own sexist delusions that women would lie about this, or that these women could not be trusted to understand what was really happening to them? These are all professional, smart, accomplished women. Why not just believe them?
<snip>

Well that would certainly speed up the legal system if the prosecution's case was automatically believed to be the correct interpretation of events because the people presenting it were professional, smart and accomplished.

ETA: To clarify: there's obvious cases of sexist and misanthropic behaviour, and then there's a huge grey area where a behaviour, depending on the preferences and interpretations of the people involved, can result in pleasure, annoyance, disgust or fear.
 
Last edited:
Well that would certainly speed up the legal system if the prosecution's case was automatically believed to be the correct interpretation of events because the people presenting it were professional, smart and accomplished.

ETA: To clarify: there's obvious cases of sexist and misanthropic behaviour, and then there's a huge grey area where a behaviour, depending on the preferences and interpretations of the people involved, can result in pleasure, annoyance, disgust or fear.

This is not a crime, nor a legal case, though there do seem to be a few people acting as judge and jury. This seems to me to be a case of a community looking at itself and wondering whether it can or should do better.
 
Disclaimer: I'm skeptical and hypothesize other reasons for the imbalance. I think some of our female members have let their other interests in feminism causes bleed over into their views at the skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. This conflating of causes seems to me to be un-skeptically influencing some people's perceptions.

We all have our blind spots and pre-existing tunnels we see the world through. I am no exception. So I'm not looking to fault anyone for their unsupported assumptions. But I do want to look for evidence of the sexism-is-hurting-us hypothesis before I reject it based on my own experiences and underlying assumptions.


This thread is requesting specific anecdotes (yes, anecdotes sometimes are evidence) that support or refute the hypothesis that sexism is a problem within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities beyond a handful of random individual incidents.

Have members witnessed sexist comments about event speakers?
Do members know of sexist incidents at meetings or events where the men's behaviors bothered or could have bothered women there?
Do you have alternative hypotheses for the gender imbalance within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities or evidence there is not much of a gender imbalance in your local group?

Is the sexism real specifically within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities or is it an imaginary boogyman created out of unsupported assumptions and misinterpretations of benign incidents? Is this really an issue about our community, or is it just an issue about men in general? Or was this always about men in general and never about our community?

No WAY am I going to read through 13 pages of the forum. So I will just answer the questions that the OP gave.

I was in my late 30s while getting my BA, my classmates were all in their 20's. And I saw this kind of "we need to strike out at the injustice that is in the world" theme all the time. Marching to the chancellors office, demanding things. Most of the students had no idea what they were asking for, or only in a general sense.

So I'm not shocked by some women throwing out the feminism card. I'm sad that they feel this way, and if they have something specific to say then I want to hear it, deal with the issue and get past it. But just this generic kind of "men are sexist" kind of statements is really cruel. I'm the mother of two adult MEN and I take offense that they are just thrown into this because of the randomness of them being men. How dare women generalize so.

I'm now almost 50 and I know what discrimination of women really feels and looks like. Women who are much older than I am can say that what I experienced growing up is nothing compared to what they grew up with.

I've been involved in the skeptic movement since 2000, attending events since 2002. And I've been to A LOT of events. Usually there are more men than women, it is improving, by big gains.

I'm not all that keen on trying to gain diversity unless the term "diversity" is defined. Male/Female, PhD/not PhD, Bald Men/Full Head of Hair ect.... I'm not trying to be funny, but what really are we talking about? I've seen at least 3 "diversity panels" at different skeptic events, all totally trying for different kinds of diversity. One had a Mom on the panel, and she sure had a different opinion than the younger woman also on the panel (and they were meant to be on the same side as they were both women).

So in my experience...

Nothing comes to mind when thinking about men's behavior at skeptic events. I am outgoing not someone who is going to be hiding in a dark corner waiting for someone to come talk to me. As I said, I know sexist remarks when I hear them (you need to hear Harley bike riders for an example...Yikes!) and I don't remember ever overhearing a remark or having one directed at me.

Until real evidence is handed out then I think this conversation is just derailing us from important matters at hand. When there is an issue, it should be dealt with and move on. Men I know are all scared to say anything that might set off a blog. We need to support each other.

All the woo out there are LAUGHING at us! They are LOVING that we are distracted by this division. Can we just acknowledge that some people are more sensitive than others and just say "I'm sorry" when there is a misunderstanding?
 
Well, I've made it through all 7 pages, and I have to say one of the things I find most creepy about the whole thing is this thread. This thread really shows that there are at least a few people on this forum that really don't understand what sexism, sexist behavior, or sexual harassment is.

Here is a clue.
YOU don't get to decide whether what someone else experienced is "creepy".
No one has claimed to. I think you are making a straw man here, but I'll grant you the possibility you just misunderstood something.

YOU don't get to evaluate other people's motives (which you could never possibly find out anyway).
We agree.

YOU don't get to decide whether someone else's anxiety about a situation is justified or not.
Actually, psychiatrists do that all the time, but that's another matter. The issue here is not about anxiety being justified or not. The issue is whether an observed instance of sexism would be seen that way by most people or not.

There have been several examples put forth in this thread of women stating they felt sexually harassed in the skeptical community as well as at TAM events in particular.

An appropriate response would be something along the lines of "Our colleagues have told us they have been sexually harassed in our community or at our events. What can we do to stop this sexual harassment?"
In other words, you cannot or will not consider the sexual harassment didn't occur, and was the figment of someone's imagination?


An INappropriate response would be to start a thread asking for evidence of harassment so that you could (by some unknown and unstated formula) evaluate whether they were really actually harassed or not. Why would you feel a need to question their ability to state what happened or whether they felt harassed? Could you be harboring your own sexist delusions that women would lie about this, or that these women could not be trusted to understand what was really happening to them? These are all professional, smart, accomplished women. Why not just believe them?
Because humans are known to perceive things which are not true. You seem to have ruled out mistaking someone's intentions as if such a thing were not possible.



And Thrasher, I have to say I think some of your comments here are sexist.

On the one hand you say that the stated example of women getting interupted in a meeting might not be sexist because the women were all just acting "meekly" (so it's her own fault if she gets interupted), and then you turn around and question how an adult woman could possibly get plied with alcohol by a man (again, so what she gets is her own fault) Add this to "We also don't know if the women who attend these events have a lower threshold for creepiness" (so their testimony really can't be relied upon) and "Then don't hang out in the hotel bar until 4:00 AM. If you do, expect those things that happen in and around a bar at 4:00 AM to happen but with more frequency." (again with the "it's her own fault" thing.)

Are you starting to see a pattern here?
Yes, but not the one you are probably seeing.


I do. I sincerely hope you will take these comments as an opportunity to examine and evaluate your own deeply held beliefs about women.



So here are a couple examples of sexism in the forum for you Skeptic Ginger. This thread itself, and Thrasher's comments.
Since I'm certain I am an avid promoter of women's lib, I can say for certain your perception of me is wrong.

Have you considered how un-empowering it is to play the feminist victim role?



Just so you know, the purpose of this thread is to collect evidence of a claim which was put forth without definitive evidence. Saying one believes, thinks, feels, etc. sexism is fine. We can conclude from that the person making the claim experienced what they said they experienced.

But when the claim is made that sexism is significant enough it has affected the male/female ratio at skeptic and or atheist events, we need more than that someone believes it is true. We need specific examples that other people can also evaluate.
 
Last edited:
Either there is evidence of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism, or there isn't. It'll be one of the two.

Really, Captain Obvious? Really?

Do you really think that there is even the smallest chance that if an actual examination of the skeptical community could be made (assuming anyone could actually agree on what that means), and somehow all parties, witnesses, evidences, etc could actually be obtained, that there is even the remotest possibility that "There is no evidence of sexism in the skeptical community" could be what they find?


The question is not IF sexism exists, the question is What, if anything, are we going to do about it?
 
No WAY am I going to read through 13 pages of the forum. So I will just answer the questions that the OP gave.....
So in my experience...

Nothing comes to mind when thinking about men's behavior at skeptic events. ....
Until real evidence is handed out then I think this conversation is just derailing us from important matters at hand. ...
Thanks for your input. I too have been to many skeptic and atheist events and not witnessed any female speakers being disrespected or any of the sexism that has been claimed to be common. The flirting I've seen has been casual and done equally by both genders.

One of the reasons I started this thread was to consider my experience might not have been typical. I did not want to dismiss the claims a number of people made without an honest look at the facts.

In addition, I see people claiming we need to expend those resources you are talking about derailing to correct this 'sexism' within our ranks. I'd like people to be reminded that to solve problems one needs to properly assess them first. You don't start throwing solutions at a problem you have not properly determined a cause for. If the imbalance of genders in our community is not due to sexism, as I suspect, then why waste time addressing sexism within the community?

By the same token, if some female members believe they are experiencing sexism, it would be nice to determine the cause as well. Is it unreasonable expectations like no men should come on to any women? Is it joining the crowd as you described in your college experience? Is it a limited number of intoxicated event participants? Is it a single person with a broad impact such as the Aussie organization leader mentioned? Is it misinterpreting innocent comments about "Boobquake" when the speaker happens to be the person who created "Boobquake" in response to some Islamist's true sexist claim women who dress immodestly caused earthquakes. (*I'm still waiting to ask Jen about her experience as a speaker at the event these comments were made, so I don't know yet if she was bothered by the comments or not, but from what I know having met her, I doubt she was bothered.)


Meg's post follows a pattern indeed. The pattern is to dismiss dissent with angry ad homs rather than consider the dissenter does indeed take the complaints seriously. I just don't have the same approach to the problem. I have advocated for empowering women to not be bothered by men when it isn't necessary. That puts me in charge, not me as a victim. I don't particularly fear a guy in a hotel elevator at 4am in a foreign country. The world is just not that dangerous. I want women to go out and see the world, not fear the world needlessly.
 
Really, Captain Obvious? Really?

Do you really think that there is even the smallest chance that if an actual examination of the skeptical community could be made (assuming anyone could actually agree on what that means), and somehow all parties, witnesses, evidences, etc could actually be obtained, that there is even the remotest possibility that "There is no evidence of sexism in the skeptical community" could be what they find?


The question is not IF sexism exists, the question is What, if anything, are we going to do about it?
Oh my lord! This is in such contrast to what you posted in the thread about Dave's blog that I was going to cite:
Hello Dr Grimes,

First, thank you for the link to your blog. It is a most excellent read, and I look forward to reading a lot more of your writings.

Secondly, I think the answer to your question: "Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?" is an emphatic and obvious "Yes"

Any arguments that center around statements such as "RW is a _____, therefore her comments are ____" or "rich, white men are ___, therefore ___" or "members of ___ community are socially inept, therefore __" or "feminists are ___, therefore ___" or, well, you get the idea, are obviously promoting stereotypes over rational thinking.

No one really enjoys looking deeply at their own beliefs, knowing that it can result in realizing that we were wrong, our parents or other admired people taught us poorly, or that we just plain bought into a concept without thinking about it very much. I think skeptics sometimes have an even more difficult time with it than most, because we like to think that since we are so rational and logical in one area, we must be equally rational with everything we think. Or that since we successfully eradicated our irrational beliefs about religion or other wooish beliefs, that we therefore have eradicated ALL irrational beliefs from our brains. Utter hogwash, of course, but I think it persists.

We also, like everyone, tend to suffer from the Fundamental Attribution Error. We tend to think "If I think X, I have a damn good reason. If YOU think X, it's because you're a racist/misogynist/homophobe/insert-other-negative-thing here.

Which is certainly not to say that racism, sexism, homophobia, or other bigotries don't exist in our community. The fact that this has become "elevatorgate" speaks volumes, in my opinion.

Meg

I was looking for the link to Dave's blog when I saw that post. The relevant part from the blog I wanted to cite was:
the truth is any ideological movement based on ideals and aspirations has dogma, and as such is separate to skepticism. It is equally laudable, but it is impossible to marry the philosophy of skepticism with ideologies....
Your insistence we go address this sexism that you are convinced exists when there is a lack of supporting evidence to tell us exactly what it is we should address is just the thing you are saying in the above quote, we should not do.


What an interesting blind spot you have.
 
Last edited:
Actually, psychiatrists do that all the time, but that's another matter. The issue here is not about anxiety being justified or not. The issue is whether an observed instance of sexism would be seen that way by most people or not.
But you are not a psychiatrist, are you? And you were not entrusted by any court or anyone at all to evaluate anyone's anxiety levels. And the way sexual harassment or hostile environment cases are actually decided is not based on a standard of how things are seen "by most people". They use the "reasonable woman" standard. How would this situation be seen by a reasonable woman?



Have you considered how un-empowering it is to play the feminist victim role?
I really don't understand what you mean by this. Are you feeling unenpowered?



Just so you know, the purpose of this thread is to collect evidence of a claim which was put forth without definitive evidence. Saying one believes, thinks, feels, etc. sexism is fine. We can conclude from that the person making the claim experienced what they said they experienced.
If you actually believe that, why do you keep "evaluating" these claims and looking for reasons to negate their validity?

But when the claim is made that sexism is significant enough it has affected the male/female ratio at skeptic and or atheist events, we need more than that someone believes it is true. We need specific examples that other people can also evaluate.
Why? Which "other people"? And exactly how are they to be "evaluated"?
 
The question is not IF sexism exists, the question is What, if anything, are we going to do about it?
What does RW say?

"Guys, don't do that".

Okay, I guess I'm going to have to get back to you on that one. I have a friend in Alan West's district. Perhaps he has an idea.
 
By the same token, if some female members believe they are experiencing sexism, it would be nice to determine the cause as well. Is it unreasonable expectations like no men should come on to any women? Is it joining the crowd as you described in your college experience? Is it a limited number of intoxicated event participants? Is it a single person with a broad impact such as the Aussie organization leader mentioned? Is it misinterpreting innocent comments about "Boobquake" when the speaker happens to be the person who created "Boobquake" in response to some Islamist's true sexist claim women who dress immodestly caused earthquakes. (*I'm still waiting to ask Jen about her experience as a speaker at the event these comments were made, so I don't know yet if she was bothered by the comments or not, but from what I know having met her, I doubt she was bothered.)

Didn't she discuss that here?
http://www.blaghag.com/2011/05/were-not-here-for-eye-candy.html

My patience was gone. I had three very inappropriate remarks made during the conference about my chest, and another woman confided in me that a male attendee made an astoundingly inappropriate remark about her appearance...
 
And the way sexual harassment or hostile environment cases are actually decided is not based on a standard of how things are seen "by most people". They use the "reasonable woman" standard. How would this situation be seen by a reasonable woman?
Flippancy aside, interesting, I honestly had never heard of "reasonable woman" standard. Not so surprising since I'm not an atty and only think I know everything.

There's not much on the net that is quickly clear on the subject.

I assume a man could use the standard to evaluate a case right? How would he know what a reasonable woman would consider compared to a reasonable man.

Again, it's interesting. I'd like to know more. I'm a bit skeptical of the idea but that's likely ignorance on my part.
 
Flippancy aside, interesting, I honestly had never heard of "reasonable woman" standard. Not so surprising since I'm not an atty and only think I know everything.

There's not much on the net that is quickly clear on the subject.

I assume a man could use the standard to evaluate a case right? How would he know what a reasonable woman would consider compared to a reasonable man.

Again, it's interesting. I'd like to know more. I'm a bit skeptical of the idea but that's likely ignorance on my part.
Okay, so from what I can tell it's not as if the reasonableness of men is somehow different from the reasonableness of women, it's that what a man might finds objectionable is likely to be different from what a woman finds objectionable (statistically speaking). I'm less skeptical.
 
Great. Now I don't have to ask her. (As I noted, she said she was tired of elevatorgate when I saw her a week ago.)

So we'll add those specific examples to the list, expanding on the earlier record.

She adds that Dr Eller apologized in earnest later.
I learned two things during the weekend: a Jewish man reminded me that "Judeo-Christian" is a Christian-privileged way of speaking about religion, since Judaism and Christianity are really quite different. So I am more aware now of both the Christian privilege and the male privilege in my speech and thought, and I will try to overcome and eject both.

As for suggested solutions, this one is worth mentioning:
Part of me hates blogging about stuff like this, because I don't want to promote in-fighting or tarnish an otherwise successful conference with this issue. But the more we let crap like this slide, the more it's going to get perpetuated. And I don't want the atheist movement of 2021 to be a room full of white men scratching their heads, wondering what went wrong.
Immediate reply, (just as with children, ;) ) seems to be effective.
 
Wow, she took two examples, one of which has blonde hair and one of which has brown hair, and described them both as blonde. Why is it that when women complain about objectification of women, they so often get so obsessed about blonde hair that they talk about it even when it isn't even there? This reminds me of a black person I know who keeps claiming that Jesus is always depicted as blond and blue-eyed. He practically never actually is. (Blue-eyed, maybe about half the time, which is high for a Middle Eastern Jew in the Roman Empire, but still, depictions without brown/black hair are few and far between.) And the same complaint was also thrown at the Rohirrim in "The Lord of the Rings", even though for them it would have been appropriate in context, and it still wasn't true even for them; brown was still distinctly more common for both hair and eyes even among them. This obsession some people have with claiming that people with blond(e) hair get special treatment is just downright bizarre, given the complete lack of any actual cases of it and the fact that even the specific examples they use to illustrate it are false. You'd think, if it were anywhere near true, or even just not obviously blazingly false, they could at least cherry-pick some actual examples once in a while, but no, instead they keep pointing out someone with brown hair and complaining that it's an example of special treatment given to blond(e) hair. :boggled:

* * *

Anyway, aside from that delusional aspect of it, feminists really should drop the whole issue about people being judged for looks alone or having only the looks commented on regardless of the same person's other traits or actions. They're just shooting themselves in the foot, at least until women quit doing the same thing to men at least 20 times as much as men do it to women.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom