Skeptic Ginger said:
.... you are coming across as doubting other people's experiences.
Of course I come across that way, that's what I'm doing. D'uh, I'm a skeptic!

But you misunderstand, I'm not doubting RW's honesty about her experience. I'm doubting her conclusions.
It seems to me that you define certain terms, like sexism, differently that RW does. At any rate, I'm not in disagreement with you on that point. But I also think that RW's definition matches a lot of other people's definition of sexism.
For me, whether you call it sexism or not isn't important to me. It's the behavior itself and the reaction to a complaint about it that has aroused so much passion from a great many people, not whether it meets the definition of sexism.
This doesn't seem as appropriate a response for a claim of experiencing sexual harassment (which many people define as including unwanted sexual propositions) as it does for claims of alien spacecraft.
Really? I see a number of parallels, the biggest one being drawing a false conclusion from true evidence. Venus rising becomes a UFO, and simple flirting becomes objectification.
I have no difficulty believing that there was a guy in the elevator who asked her to come back to his room. That she chooses to term it sexism, well, maybe it was. I wasn't there. But I don't find the claim of sexism to have the same level of improbability as the claim of an alien spacecraft.
Further, many women are bothered by the type of behavior RW described. Depending on the circumstances and the man's demeanor, it could be very disturbing to me. Personally, I'd really rather not attend events where that sort of thing might happen. Further, I don't seem to be in the minority with this opinion.
Are we voting on truth now?
I think it's more like voting on manners. We can, as a community, discuss what is and isn't appropriate behavior in public spaces, like elevators.
The issue is not, "I'm liberated and it wouldn't have bothered me", vs a more traditional female bothered by all kinds of impolite come-ons. The issues are RW calling my position misogynist, and claiming the sexism is so bad it is keeping women away from our events.
The first is your issue, not mine. I basically agree with you on that point. I don't think that RW, or any of the other feminist sites should label disagreement as misogyny. I do think RD's response could appropriately be labeled misogynist. But if you disagree, that's fine. In this case, that's not my issue.
Yes, it would. Assume that the results indicate that sexism is less than elsewhere. What would your response to that be?
Now assume that the results indicate that sexism is worse than elsewhere. What would your response to that be?
What is the difference in actions you would take as a result of knowing that information?
The best outcome I could expect from this thread is to show a mirror to skeptics reflecting how unskeptical they are being over this brouhaha.
Interesting. The actual outcome would make no difference to your response.
The second useful outcome would be to point out to people, if there is a problem (not enough women at our events), the scientific process starts with a proper assessment of the problem, not with throwing solutions at it when you don't even know if you are addressing the actual cause.
This seems reasonable. How do you think such a problem could be assessed?
I think you also have to use their definition of sexism to test that claim. I don't know that I want to argue against your definition as I agree that EG wasn't necessarily being sexist. But after reading hundeds of blog posts and comments on this, I think that many women regard a lot of men hitting on them as harassment even if the individual guys don't do so repeatedly. That is, they regard the environment/community as harassing and don't go.
You are presenting an impossible standard if you think men wanting to meet women at our events with the hopes of starting a relationship (short term or long term) is sexism. Single women who might also be looking for men they have something in common with might not want such flirting or come-ons to be prohibited.
This response completely ignores my point that you have to use the same definition of sexism if you want to test the claim. I didn't say anything about prohibiting anything. That would a solution suggestion. This is the 'assessing the problem' stage remember?
Why did Paula say that they can't get women to agree to come and be speakers? Why are all the women being invited saying "no thanks" to the invitation?
I don't believe I heard that concern over sexism was the reason invited women speakers turned the invitation down. Could you find that claim so I can look at it? I thought the issue of invited female speakers turning down the offer was posted as a reason TAM didn't have many female speakers in 2008.
Yes, you are correct. No one has said why the female speakers decided to turn the invitations down. Hence my questions above.
What is the measure of the baseline? How do they define sexist behavior? You'll need to use the same definition to measure the skeptical community in order to make a determination based on something other than your gut feeling about it after reading about the specific incidents.
As Sling says, you can't tell other people what the relevant issues are. For a great many people, it's the behavior of EG in the elevator that seems egregious, not RW's behavior. I don't know what RW said exactly, although if what I've heard is true, then an apology from her to Steph would be in order. Even so, I find the reaction to her video astounding.
It's hard to maintain my patience when these straw men keep coming up again and again. You just admitted not knowing what the core issues are in this discussion.
No. What I've admitted is that your core issues are not my core issues. That was not a straw man argument. That's my opinion.
So is it sexism or too many guys who'd like to meet women that is the problem? You seem to be saying the latter is sexism. And somehow I don't think you believe that.
I'm saying that I don't care whether or not it's called sexism. I'm saying that in other circumstances, that sort of behavior has been considered sexism. Consider this excerpt from one of the threads you posted earlier:
Library Lady said:
Disrespect was shown in little ways...Like being instructed by my female co-workers which men not to get on an elevator with alone.
What the incident with Steph may have been a later sequence in the chain, for most people posting about it, the main issue is the EG's behavior and then RD's letter.
Good grief! It's the incident with McGraf that caused all this. The people who believe Dawkins' comments were in response just to RW's video are being seriously unfair to Dawkins.
I don't think you can claim that the incident with McGraf 'caused' all this although it certainly played a part in escalating it to the massive attention that has been paid to the original incident. I don't believe that Dawkin's comments were in response to RW, but his comments still come across as very offensive and arguably misogynist.
You lost me here. Ouellette said that after speaking at TAM she was flooded with friends requests, meaning her reception was very positive. Then over 2 years a dozen friend requests were sexist. She used this as an example to say how that showed extensive sexism within our ranks.
Come on. There are men on FaceBook. Do you really think a dozen out of "flooded" friends requests is evidence of significant sexism in the skeptic community?
I think what she was saying is that it indicates there is a larger proportion of men from atheist/skeptical community than other groups who exhibit behavior that Ms. Ouellette find obnoxious to the point of defriending them on facebook and no longer accepting such friend requests.
Whether that behavior should be considered sexist or not, I don't care. I agree with Ms. Ouelette when she says
Ouelette said:
Here is the message being sent to the women skeptics and atheists say they want to join their ranks: “If an atheist/skeptic man behaves boorishly toward you, or refuses to respect your boundaries, whether social or sexual, and you have the gall to state firmly that this is not okay, you will be publicly pilloried, ridiculed for being hysterical, called a man-hating feminazi (or worse), and have your concerns belittled and dismissed.”
Even if it isn't the issue you think should be important, I think that's why so many people are upset. It's why I tend to side with RW even though I agree that the behavior may not have been sexist. Even though I agree that she may have been in the wrong in the way she treated McGraf.
If you disagree with that being the message sent, that's fair. It's also fair to point out that even if it isn't a message being deliberately sent, it's still the interpretation many people are taking from this incident and the controversy that has followed in its wake.