Beth
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 5,598
I think that so many people are drawn to comment on this incident because it's right on the boundary of a number of things that people are concerned about.Sigh. I don't suppose it means much to you Dunstan, that it is because I am concerned about skeptic causes and women's lib that I've been drawn to comment so much on this subject.
I don't think that anyone is doubting your experiences. Instead, you are coming across as doubting other people's experiences. This doesn't seem as appropriate a response for a claim of experiencing sexual harassment (which many people define as including unwanted sexual propositions) as it does for claims of alien spacecraft.I see evidence being put forth that amounts to the same garbage we skeptics would never accept were it presented as evidence supporting other nonsense. People think they see, feel it's true, and so on. Yet you are asking me to support my claims that I haven't thought or felt the same things after my decade worth of experiences with the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities.
Just because you have not experienced it doesn't mean that other women haven't. Further, many women are bothered by the type of behavior RW described. Depending on the circumstances and the man's demeanor, it could be very disturbing to me. Personally, I'd really rather not attend events where that sort of thing might happen. Further, I don't seem to be in the minority with this opinion.
It would be nice if we had a perfect study documenting the baseline sexism in the public at large, in the scientific and academic communities and we were able to compare it to the sexism documented in the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities.
Yes, it would. Assume that the results indicate that sexism is less than elsewhere. What would your response to that be?
Now assume that the results indicate that sexism is worse than elsewhere. What would your response to that be?
What is the difference in actions you would take as a result of knowing that information?
I think you also have to use their definition of sexism to test that claim. I don't know that I want to argue against your definition as I agree that EG wasn't necessarily being sexist. But after reading hundeds of blog posts and comments on this, I think that many women regard a lot of men hitting on them as harassment even if the individual guys don't do so repeatedly. That is, they regard the environment/community as harassing and don't go.I'm trying at this point, only to validate or invalidate the claims like Ouellette's and RW's perception of this rampant sexism that is responsible for the lack of female attendance at our events. It is so classic of the problem of selective memory to hear these claims that sexism is common.
Why did Paula say that they can't get women to agree to come and be speakers? Why are all the women being invited saying "no thanks" to the invitation?
What is the measure of the baseline? How do they define sexist behavior? You'll need to use the same definition to measure the skeptical community in order to make a determination based on something other than your gut feeling about it after reading about the specific incidents.As for the baseline, I'm accepting without challenge the fact that sexism was common in the scientific and academic fields for a long time. And it is less today. Those are historical facts easily verified as Ouellette does citing numerous known examples.
As Sling says, you can't tell other people what the relevant issues are. For a great many people, it's the behavior of EG in the elevator that seems egregious, not RW's behavior. I don't know what RW said exactly, although if what I've heard is true, then an apology from her to Steph would be in order. Even so, I find the reaction to her video astounding.The section titled, "The Elevator Pitch" is the full section where Ouellette discusses TAM incidents specifically.
We all know that, so I suspect a straw man cometh next. And of course it did. This is the same misperception repeated time and time again in these discussions. The issue is not RW's video. It was her talk at the subsequent CFI Student Conference and two subsequent blogs, one by PZ and one by RW where the issues emerged. And anyone claiming it was RW's initial video blog such as Ouellette is doing, is repeating that straw man. It's becoming quite tiring especially considering this is supposed to be a skeptic community. Surely if you are blogging about elevator-gate you should be reading enough to notice the dozens and dozens of pleas to notice the initial video was not the catalyst here, merely the first action in a cascade.
Ouellette claims:If Ouellette truly waded through all the comments, how is it she missed such a blatant problem with her straw man version of events?
What the incident with Steph may have been a later sequence in the chain, for most people posting about it, the main issue is the EG's behavior and then RD's letter.
No, that there would be no more creeps in the skeptic/atheist community than elsewhere. The part in regards to the skeptic/athiest community was this:This is really hard to evaluate. So let's take the claim at face value and assume Ouellette had verification the 'friends' were not just using phishing terms to claim acquaintance. A dozen Facebook friend requests over 2 years amounts to one every 2 months out of "flooded" friends requests.
I have a hard time finding this concerning. What does this woman expect? That there are no creeps on FaceBook?
there have been a dozen or so instances over the last two years where a man has become obnoxious, offensive, overbearing, overly flirtatious, or just plain creepy about personal boundaries, forcing me to defriend him. With one exception, they were all from the skeptic/atheist community.
Do you think that the skeptic/atheist community composes 11 out of 12 of her facebook friend requests? I don't. I think that her specific incident indicates a higher percentage of unpleasant men than from other groups.
I'm sorry Dunstan, but now that I looked more carefully at the specific reference to incidents within the skeptical community, I find the same generalization. Sexism occurs in the scientific and academic communities therefore it must occur here.
It seems a reasonable extrapolation to me. It doesn't make it true, it just makes it a good bet. Any reason to think it would be different? Oh yeah, I remember, you said it's because atheists/skeptics have a more enlightened way of thinking or something to that effect. I think we'll just have to assume a different null hypothesis on that question.
Like 11 out of 12 guys that were so unpleasant she unfriended them on facebook? Seems fairly specific to me.A personal anecdote is going to be the majority type of evidence that we can find here. But what I am looking for are specific incidents, not general like, "I've experienced a lot of sexism". I haven't, others have. That's called equivocal evidence. I'm looking for specific incidents.