EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

He's been mentioned but whereas you are more in the know than some, could you clarify the Dr Buzz0 issue and was that the same guy or a different guy? If a different guy, was he possibly mentally ill? Inebriated (not that that is an excuse)?

We had a mentally ill guy come to our skeptic meeting. Our host had to ask him not to return. It's one of the risks of an open to the public social group.

I've no idea what the DrBuzz0 "issue" is.

This was DrAdequate.

Whether or not he is mentally ill is for professionals to determine.

Inebriated? I don't know. Five women over the course of multiple days. Is inebriation an excuse at that point?
 
And btw, asking me to call out the person kind of sucks. Not because I have an issue with it, in and of itself, but because I like my private life to remain private, and this seems like just asking for it to not be. Especially since I don't have the option of remaining anonymous, since I used to work for the JREF and my nick is inextricably tied with my real name.
 
And btw, asking me to call out the person kind of sucks. Not because I have an issue with it, in and of itself, but because I like my private life to remain private, and this seems like just asking for it to not be. Especially since I don't have the option of remaining anonymous, since I used to work for the JREF and my nick is inextricably tied with my real name.
The Dr Buzz0 thing was brought up here a number of times. I didn't expect you to add more than what was publicly known among the forumites.

No one is asking you to "call anyone out". I was looking for a factual account as opposed to a rumored account and if you don't have direct knowledge or don't want to comment, you merely need say so. The point of this thread is to collect valid evidence as opposed to selective memory conclusions.
 
Last edited:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=176131

Noblecaboose and Athon left on page 2 and 3 of the thread and haven't been back to the forum since.
Collateral damage of the skepchick movement's evolution, I suppose. Sad, I miss them both. :(
Another thread where someone complained about sexualisation of female skeptics.
That thread offered me some great insights from LL.
Alright, this whole subject is officially completely retarded.

Now, to be fair, I would bet the low attendance of women has more to do with ambivalence than any actual sexism-based repulsion.
Until they meet a few male skeptics? :duck: Where's bookitty, anyway? :D
But again, since "Skepticism" is almost entirely made up of people from higher education (both in terms of the leaders/speakers and attendees), that's a good place to look. Why would women who fight their way through endless BS in their professional academic lives go spend their leisure time with the very same people that are giving them ******
Ka ching. Insert pithy joke about RD here ...
If your interest is trying to figure out why the male-female ratio is as it is, or even more broadly, how sexism is affecting women in the skeptical movement, this is not a good approach. If you want to try to infer from a lack of specific stories from women to a conclusion that therefore sexism isn't turning women off, you're on the right track.
But we aren't talking about a broad event.
yes, we are, and a broad generalization ...
So you agree, without evidence, perhaps people are imagining there is some particular sexism problem at skeptic/atheist/freethinker events?
It appears that there is evidence, at least in the form of anecdotes, provided by Remie and Bookitty regarding selected skeptic events.
Interesting, Dunstan, thanks.
Hmmm. So is it possible that the reason theism and belief in the paranormal is so prevalent around the world is because the genes that encourage skepticism and atheism also hinder procreation?
*Snort*
I think there is plenty of sexism around here, and it annoys me.
Then show us your tits.
(That joke works better if you are a guy, maybe not so well if you are a gal.)

I'd like to point out that the internet and the blogosphere often act as echo chambers. Perhaps there isn't as much sound as there is fury.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
...
It appears that there is evidence, at least in the form of anecdotes, provided by Remie and Bookitty regarding selected skeptic events. ....
Cheers.
Not really. The anecdotes so far represent no more than the background rate or less sexism than one might expect in the population at large. And the anecdotes so far represent in particular, even less than the amount of sexism that is waning but not absent from the academic and scientific communities. No one has claimed a skeptic never acts like an ass at a conference. That is not the claim RW makes. She makes the claim things are so bad it chases female members of the community away from events.

I know I'm taking a while to get to the Ouellette blog. I want to address it properly and it is a long blog.

I'm only this far along so far:
Jennifer Ouellette writes:

(emphasis mine). More at the link.
I've been thinking this issue through given I know people like TraneWreck are likely to simply accuse me of confirmation bias when I question certain claims. But here's the issue with this kind of evidence. We have to judge the incidents for ourselves, without the conclusions of the person who experienced it. As RW's little incident demonstrates, what she perceived as some sexist come-on was not universally viewed the same way by all.

Let's look at Jennifer's comments starting with the men at CERN vs Linda Henneberg. Once again we have someone telling us about their experience but the impression is included along with the details.

Do we know if Henneberg's experience at CERN was due to her not being a physicist, or due to her being a woman? I would conclude it was a combination.
Henneberg holds an undergraduate degree is in physics and a graduate degree in science communication, yet “[P]eople here, men especially, treat me like some sort of novelty item. Like because I am not a physicist, I have nothing substantive to contribute to CERN, but it’s cute that I try.”

In my profession, nursing, we get little respect from the physicians in lots of situations, (I don't mean cordial treatment, but respect for our professional opinions about the patients). But the nurses who work in critical specialties and many of the charge nurses are very much respected for their skills and contributions by most physicians. There is definitely an educational elitism in the ranks of our profession. But it's based on reality as much as bias. There is a very broad continuum of education and skills in the medical/nursing field. I can imagine top notch physicists being a tad impatient with someone's contributions to a conversation if there was any naivete about the science in the non-PhD's comments.


There's much too much more specific to the JREF community that needs to be specifically looked at to leave it at this. So I plan to, hopefully soon.
 
Last edited:
Not really. The anecdotes so far represent no more than the background rate or less sexism than one might expect in the population at large.

What is the "background rate" and how did you determine this?

And the anecdotes so far represent in particular, even less than the amount of sexism that is waning but not absent from the academic and scientific communities.

How did you determine this?

I know I'm taking a while to get to the Ouellette blog.

Yes, we've noticed that.

I want to address it properly and it is a long blog.

Plus, all those google searches for "Ouellette + calendar photos" and "Ouellette + bordello party" aren't paying off.

I'm only this far along so far:I've been thinking this issue through given I know people like TraneWreck are likely to simply accuse me of confirmation bias when I question certain claims.

I don't think you're guilty of confirmation bias. That's an explanation that is consistent with honesty. I think you're well into "moving the goalposts" territory.

But here's the issue with this kind of evidence. We have to judge the incidents for ourselves, without the conclusions of the person who experienced it. As RW's little incident demonstrates, what she perceived as some sexist come-on was not universally viewed the same way by all.

Well yes, that is the nature of anecdotal evidence.

Your OP states: "This thread is requesting specific anecdotes (yes, anecdotes sometimes are evidence)." Now you want to complain that the anecdotes aren't peer-reviewed double-blind controlled studies. I wish I could say I was surprised.

Let's look at Jennifer's comments starting with the men at CERN vs Linda Henneberg. Once again we have someone telling us about their experience but the impression is included along with the details.

The nerve of her!

Do we know if Henneberg's experience at CERN was due to her not being a physicist, or due to her being a woman? I would conclude it was a combination.

Both Henneberg and Ouellette said as much.

There's much too much more specific to the JREF community that needs to be specifically looked at to leave it at this. So I plan to, hopefully soon.

I'm sure you will.
 
Plus, all those google searches for "Ouellette + calendar photos" and "Ouellette + bordello party" aren't paying off.
Cheap shot. No value. You discredit yourself.


I don't think you're guilty of confirmation bias. That's an explanation that is consistent with honesty. I think you're well into "moving the goalposts" territory.
See above.

Well yes, that is the nature of anecdotal evidence.

Your OP states: "This thread is requesting specific anecdotes (yes, anecdotes sometimes are evidence)." Now you want to complain that the anecdotes aren't peer-reviewed double-blind controlled studies. I wish I could say I was surprised.

Skeptic Ginger made no such implication much less such a statement. She is correct in that we must look at each situation on its own merits. Just because she asks for examples of sexism doesn't mean that we all will agree that any given example is actually sexism. Many of us disagree that RW's story was anything more than an ordinary late-night courtship ritual that routinely happens in bars.

Furthermore, just because someone says sexism is a problem doesn't mean that there is. That's the whole point in asking for evidence. The Ouellette blog mentions men interrupting women in a meeting far more often than men. That might be sexism. It might not be. In my experience those who allow themselves to be interrupted without saying something like, "Excuse me, but I was talking. Please don't interrupt me. Thank you," will be interrupted far more often than those who express their objection.

Without knowing more about the dynamics of the situation, who can say it's sexism? For all we know the women all took the interruptions meekly. In that same blog Ouellette discusses how few women are willing to accept opportunities to be presenters. It could be that same mentality at work.
 
Cheap shot.

No, it was richly earned.

Furthermore, just because someone says sexism is a problem doesn't mean that there is. That's the whole point in asking for evidence. The Ouellette blog mentions men interrupting women in a meeting far more often than men. That might be sexism. It might not be. In my experience those who allow themselves to be interrupted without saying something like, "Excuse me, but I was talking. Please don't interrupt me. Thank you," will be interrupted far more often than those who express their objection.

Without knowing more about the dynamics of the situation, who can say it's sexism? For all we know the women all took the interruptions meekly. In that same blog Ouellette discusses how few women are willing to accept opportunities to be presenters. It could be that same mentality at work.

In other words, this thread purports to ask for evidence, only to dismiss every example provided on the grounds that we don't know the whole "dynamics of the situation." Hence my conclusion that it's an insincere venture. SG intends to do that to every anecdote offered, and then when people get tired of playing her game, she'll say, "see, there was no good evidence provided, therefore I was right all along!"

Calling someone out on that behavior is not a cheap shot.
 
No, it was richly earned.
Well, you convinced me!


In other words, this thread purports to ask for evidence, only to dismiss every example provided on the grounds that we don't know the whole "dynamics of the situation." Hence my conclusion that it's an insincere venture. SG intends to do that to every anecdote offered, and then when people get tired of playing her game, she'll say, "see, there was no good evidence provided, therefore I was right all along!"

I haven't seen any examples dismissed. Care to provide some evidence? I haven't seen any conclusions drawn by Skeptic Ginger either.

What I find oh, so amusing, is that you would probably be right behind her approach were she asking for evidence from people claiming something like deja vu being far more prevalent at a new age convention. First, we'd want to establish that what the person experienced was what we reasonably agree deja vu to be. We'd also ignore any conclusions people drew about deja vu being more prevalent since we're looking for evidence to support a conclusion we know people have already drawn.

It's more of that subtle sexism I described in another post. If men were arguing that women at skeptical/atheist gatherings were more, let's just say, "sexually liberated," I feel confident about how you would probably react, and it wouldn't be like this.

Calling someone out on that behavior is not a cheap shot.
Do you have evidence that Skeptic Ginger was Googling for the terms you claimed? If not, it was a cheap shot.
 
Well, you convinced me!

I'm not trying to convince you.

I haven't seen any examples dismissed. Care to provide some evidence? I haven't seen any conclusions drawn by Skeptic Ginger either.

Then you haven't read this thread or its predecessor. Or not very well. Either way, not my problem.

What I find oh, so amusing, is that you would probably be right behind her approach were she asking for evidence from people claiming something like deja vu being far more prevalent at a new age convention. First, we'd want to establish that what the person experienced was what we reasonably agree deja vu to be. We'd also ignore any conclusions people drew about deja vu being more prevalent since we're looking for evidence to support a conclusion we know people have already drawn.

Actually, you've got it backwards. The proper thing to do is define the criteria before you start looking for evidence. Otherwise it becomes too easy to redefine your criteria on the fly so as to dismiss any evidence you might come across. Even if you're honestly trying to be objective, it's still a source of bias, and it's a source of perceived bias.

Here, the OP invited anecdotes. There was no limitation that we have to have multiple eyewitness accounts or tape recordings, or that there couldn't be any complicating factors or extraneous variables involved. Stating those later-invented criteria upfront would have made it obvious that no evidence would be found acceptable. So instead, the OP was open-ended, and then every example provided was deemed insufficient using later-added criteria and limitations: oh, that involved philosophers, not skeptics. Oh, we don't have the other person's side of that story. Oh, that might be prejudice against non-physicists rather than sexism. Etc. Etc.

So no, I would not have been "right behind" this approach if it was applied to traditional "woo" claims. I would have objected to it as playing right into the stereotypes of "bad skeptics" who engage in special pleading to dismiss any evidence provided.

It's more of that subtle sexism I described in another post. If men were arguing that women at skeptical/atheist gatherings were more, let's just say, "sexually liberated," I feel confident about how you would probably react, and it wouldn't be like this.


Do you have evidence that Skeptic Ginger was Googling for the terms you claimed? If not, it was a cheap shot.

It's a joke, not a factual claim. Admittedly, a joke with a point, based on SG's admission that she was gleeful about his discovery of past complaints of sexism against RW. It's a reasonable inference on my part that she is now doing her best to come up with ways to attempt to discredit Ouellette.

You know, sort of like you've made several inferences in your post about what I would or would not support or how I would or would not react in other contexts. You happen to be wrong, but I'm not whining about them being "cheap shots."
 
Until they meet a few male skeptics? :duck: Where's bookitty, anyway? :D

I'm too exhausted from dealing with the Norway attack to even try here. Playing word games about stuff that makes people uncomfortable, dunno, just lost my taste for it.

In a few weeks, a new thread, maybe. I think there are a lot of people here who really are interested in evidence, making things better, making dialog easier and all that. When they want to talk, maybe I'll be around.
 
Sigh. I don't suppose it means much to you Dunstan, that it is because I am concerned about skeptic causes and women's lib that I've been drawn to comment so much on this subject.

I see evidence being put forth that amounts to the same garbage we skeptics would never accept were it presented as evidence supporting other nonsense. People think they see, feel it's true, and so on. Yet you are asking me to support my claims that I haven't thought or felt the same things after my decade worth of experiences with the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities.

It would be nice if we had a perfect study documenting the baseline sexism in the public at large, in the scientific and academic communities and we were able to compare it to the sexism documented in the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities.

But science is often not so accommodating and I don't have access to the resources or time to undertake such a study. Consider my attempt to collect data a pilot study. I'm trying at this point, only to validate or invalidate the claims like Ouellette's and RW's perception of this rampant sexism that is responsible for the lack of female attendance at our events. It is so classic of the problem of selective memory to hear these claims that sexism is common.

The lack of specific incidents in this thread is not consistent with such claims. I am not claiming it disproves anything.

As for the baseline, I'm accepting without challenge the fact that sexism was common in the scientific and academic fields for a long time. And it is less today. Those are historical facts easily verified as Ouellette does citing numerous known examples.

Ouellette claimed knowledge of frequent sexist behavior at CERN. I'm not challenging that per se. I have not been there. But I can comment there are alternative hypotheses such as education elitism which could account for the same observations. My uninformed opinion is, it is probably a little of both. The relevance of this is not that there is or is not sexism at CERN, rather the description of the evidence demonstrates a problem with collecting this kind of evidence. It is subject to observer bias in a big way.

I tend to post here in frequent short bursts. It's tedious and time consuming to address something that needs more involvement to address. And sometimes I decide I don't want to take that time, or more often, I just put it off. But I have to get to this sooner or later, so, you goaded me into stopping my procrastination.

The section titled, "The Elevator Pitch" is the full section where Ouellette discusses TAM incidents specifically. Go to the link to see the full comments in context since we are not supposed to quote so much at once from links.
For the two people in the science blogosphere who missed it, here’s what happened. Rebecca Watson, ... [snipped some of the story] ... Towards the end of the video, she casually related her discomfort at being approached in an elevator at 4 AM by an intoxicated Irish guy, who asked her back to his room “for coffee.” Watson wasn’t hysterical, or raving, or even angry. (You can see for yourself here. It starts at the 4:30 mark.) She simply said, “Look, guys — don’t do that. It makes me very uncomfortable,” and briefly outlined the reasons why.
We all know that, so I suspect a straw man cometh next. And of course it did. This is the same misperception repeated time and time again in these discussions. The issue is not RW's video. It was her talk at the subsequent CFI Student Conference and two subsequent blogs, one by PZ and one by RW where the issues emerged. And anyone claiming it was RW's initial video blog such as Ouellette is doing, is repeating that straw man. It's becoming quite tiring especially considering this is supposed to be a skeptic community. Surely if you are blogging about elevator-gate you should be reading enough to notice the dozens and dozens of pleas to notice the initial video was not the catalyst here, merely the first action in a cascade.

Ouellette claims:
I waded through the ensuing comment threads with a growing sense of dismay, then anger, then outright revulsion at many of the opinions being expressed.

Watson was vilified for over-reacting, for being a diva, a “media-whore,” an attention-monger, a bitch, a man-hating feminazi, and a troublemaker who was deflecting attention away from far more important issues. She was accused of being anti-sex (as if), calling all men rapists (she did not), and was threatened with sexual assault at the upcoming TAM “to give you something to complain about.” (Being threatened with rape is not a new experience for Watson, alas.)
If Ouellette truly waded through all the comments, how is it she missed such a blatant problem with her straw man version of events?

Confirmation bias perhaps? Granted lots of people have mistakenly attributed arguments to RW that RW did not make. But by far the bigger problem is people oblivious to what RW actually did say beyond the initial video. One would think Ouellette simply skipped anything RW blogged or spoke about.

Those who spoke up and came to her defense received similar treatment — including a couple of women who had survived sexual assaults.
Were the women's anecdotes merely noted as not relevant unless it happened at one of the events in question? Is that why their comments were discounted? I don't know as I don't know who she is referring to. But I can see other biased comments throughout the blog.

... Watson was being attacked by members of her own community, who prided themselves on their rationality and critical thinking — in short, by the very people who should have had her back.
Now who is dismissing out of hand the valid objections to RW's claims?

Here is the message being sent to the women skeptics and atheists say they want to join their ranks: “If an atheist/skeptic man behaves boorishly toward you, or refuses to respect your boundaries, whether social or sexual, and you have the gall to state firmly that this is not okay, you will be publicly pilloried, ridiculed for being hysterical, called a man-hating feminazi (or worse), and have your concerns belittled and dismissed.”
Considering what RW called McGraf for saying she didn't think the guy was doing anything more than expressing sexual or romantic interest, this comment is beyond ironic and doesn't help Ouellette's case.


[snipped claims about sexism in the science community which are not being questioned] ...
Case in point: When I spoke two years ago at TAM7, I was flooded afterwards with friend requests on Facebook from the skeptical community. ... but there have been a dozen or so instances over the last two years where a man has become obnoxious, offensive, overbearing, overly flirtatious, or just plain creepy about personal boundaries, forcing me to defriend him. With one exception, they were all from the skeptic/atheist community. I now rarely accept Facebook friend requests from skeptic/atheist men. No, it isn’t “fair.” But even though 98% of them are probably very nice guys, I just don’t have the time to comb through each profile, trying to ferret out clues as to who is most likely to tweak out on me unexpectedly.
This is really hard to evaluate. So let's take the claim at face value and assume Ouellette had verification the 'friends' were not just using phishing terms to claim acquaintance. A dozen Facebook friend requests over 2 years amounts to one every 2 months out of "flooded" friends requests.

I have a hard time finding this concerning. What does this woman expect? That there are no creeps on FaceBook?

FaceBook friend phishing: "Hi, I'm from your [fill in the blank] community...."

[Snipped a reference back to the academic community]


I'm sorry Dunstan, but now that I looked more carefully at the specific reference to incidents within the skeptical community, I find the same generalization. Sexism occurs in the scientific and academic communities therefore it must occur here.
 
...
Actually, you've got it backwards. The proper thing to do is define the criteria before you start looking for evidence.
I did. Perhaps you missed it. :rolleyes:


...Here, the OP invited anecdotes. There was no limitation that we have to have multiple eyewitness accounts or tape recordings, or that there couldn't be any complicating factors or extraneous variables involved. Stating those later-invented criteria upfront would have made it obvious that no evidence would be found acceptable. So instead, the OP was open-ended, and then every example provided was deemed insufficient using later-added criteria and limitations: oh, that involved philosophers, not skeptics. Oh, we don't have the other person's side of that story. Oh, that might be prejudice against non-physicists rather than sexism. Etc. Etc.
No, I see instead you didn't get what I was asking for.

A personal anecdote is going to be the majority type of evidence that we can find here. But what I am looking for are specific incidents, not general like, "I've experienced a lot of sexism". I haven't, others have. That's called equivocal evidence. I'm looking for specific incidents.

Jen McCreight spoke at an event and comments were heard about her "Boobquake" event. That is an example of a specific incident. (I saw her last week, BTW, but she suggested she was burned out on elevatorgate so I decided to ask her about the incident next time I see her.)



...It's a joke, not a factual claim. Admittedly, a joke with a point, based on SG's admission that she was gleeful about his discovery of past complaints of sexism against RW. It's a reasonable inference on my part that she is now doing her best to come up with ways to attempt to discredit Ouellette....

You happen to be wrong, but I'm not whining about them being "cheap shots."
I don't know if I'd call this a cheap shot, but it is an ad hom and it is false. I said I wanted to look at Ouellette's specific examples, not her ties to Skepchick.
 
Last edited:
How did you define the "background rate" of sexism?
Might we conclude you don't read those tl,dr posts? :rolleyes:

From my post above:
It would be nice if we had a perfect study documenting the baseline sexism in the public at large, in the scientific and academic communities and we were able to compare it to the sexism documented in the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities.

But science is often not so accommodating and I don't have access to the resources or time to undertake such a study. Consider my attempt to collect data a pilot study. I'm trying at this point, only to validate or invalidate the claims like Ouellette's and RW's perception of this rampant sexism that is responsible for the lack of female attendance at our events. It is so classic of the problem of selective memory to hear these claims that sexism is common.

The lack of specific incidents in this thread is not consistent with such claims. I am not claiming it disproves anything.

As for the baseline, I'm accepting without challenge the fact that sexism was common in the scientific and academic fields for a long time. And it is less today. Those are historical facts easily verified as Ouellette does citing numerous known examples.

You do know, I hope, that technically we consider it the responsibility of the person making the claim first to support that claim.

I have not seen evidence other than the equivocal claims of people who are witness to the rampant sexism vs my being witness to it not being there in the significant way that is being claimed.

To be precise, the claim has been made directly by RW and agreed with by the RW Camp, that sexism is the reason there are fewer women at our events than men. I challenge anyone to provide evidence this claim is true.

So far all that has been presented are women saying yes it is true, they've seen it. Fine, just like I would with any other similar claim, I'm asking for more evidence than a claim, "I've seen it" without any specific incidents that support those claims. Evidence of sexism in the scientific and academic communities has been presented. Where is the evidence of sexism in the skeptic community and why are so many skeptics throwing the need for evidence out the window here?

I haven't seen evidence of sexism in the events I have attended and I go to lots of them locally and one TAM. And even if I had seen it, where is the evidence it is the reason more women are not at our events?

You are asking the one person actually looking for evidence before dismissing a claim to provide the evidence the claim is false. That is not standard skeptical process.
 
Last edited:
I was going to make a similar point as Dunstan but thankfully I read your response. I have not read every post but there is some interesting info. I'm really surprised that skeptics or people claiming to be skeptics would make anything other than a "seems to me" claim. How do they control for bias?

It would be interesting to see a proper study done.
 
Might we conclude you don't read those tl,dr posts? :rolleyes:

I do, which is how I'm able to catch your equivocations. For example, here's what you claim is your "answer" to my question:

As for the baseline, I'm accepting without challenge the fact that sexism was common in the scientific and academic fields for a long time. And it is less today. Those are historical facts easily verified as Ouellette does citing numerous known examples.

But that doesn't describe a baseline. Vague words like "common" and "less today" don't provide a basis for comparison.

So when you say this:

The anecdotes so far represent no more than the background rate or less sexism than one might expect in the population at large. And the anecdotes so far represent in particular, even less than the amount of sexism that is waning but not absent from the academic and scientific communities.

I want to know your basis for concluding that the anecdotes provided don't represent more than the background rate. You haven't provided one.

Now, it may be that it's difficult or impossible to quantify these things. But there's no basis for anyone to accept your conclusion over Ouellette's.

To be precise, the claim has been made directly by RW and agreed with by the RW Camp, that sexism is the reason there are fewer women at our events than men.

Is it? My understanding is that sexism is being cited as "a" reason, not "the" reason.

So far all that has been presented are women saying yes it is true, they've seen it.

And experienced it personally.

Fine, just like I would with any other similar claim, I'm asking for more evidence than a claim, "I've seen it" without any specific incidents that support those claims. Evidence of sexism in the scientific and academic communities has been presented. Where is the evidence of sexism in the skeptic community and why are so many skeptics throwing the need for evidence out the window here?

Who's throwing the need for evidence out the window? Seriously, who's saying that?

The problem is that there aren't good sources of data for something like this. I don't know how you would do a controlled experiment on this. Surveys are possible, but I don't think anyone's done one, and it's doubtful anyone is going to spend the resources on it.

So we're left with poorer quality evidence at least to begin with, i.e. anecdotes.

I haven't seen evidence of sexism in the events I have attended and I go to lots of them locally and one TAM.

And other women have said differently.

And even if I had seen it, where is the evidence it is the reason more women are not at our events?

Well, some of them say it is. Other women, like Ouellette, have said it almost discouraged them from attending but they decided it was worth it.

You are asking the one person actually looking for evidence before dismissing a claim to provide the evidence the claim is false. That is not standard skeptical process.

No, I'm not.

I'm pointing out that you have asked for anecdotes, and then rejected each and every one that is presented to you because they're anecdotes. That suggests that you're not "actually looking for evidence."

If I were a woman who had been turned off of skeptical events because of sexism, I doubt I'd bother to post about it in this thread just so you can cast scorn and doubt on it.

I was going to make a similar point as Dunstan but thankfully I read your response.

I hope you didn't take her response at face value.

I have not read every post but there is some interesting info. I'm really surprised that skeptics or people claiming to be skeptics would make anything other than a "seems to me" claim. How do they control for bias?

It would be interesting to see a proper study done.

It would, but how would you go about it? You'd probably have to do a survey, but what population would you choose? If you survey the people who actually attend TAM or some other conference, you're missing all the people who have stayed away from such events. Ditto for surveying members of local skeptic's groups. On the other hand, if you just survey the general population, you're going to have 99% of the responses be from people who have no idea what "skeptics" are or what "skeptical events" they might attend.
 
Then you haven't read this thread or its predecessor. Or not very well. Either way, not my problem.
RW, is that you? The whole "if you don't agree with me you must not get it" schtick gave you away.


Actually, you've got it backwards. The proper thing to do is define the criteria before you start looking for evidence. Otherwise it becomes too easy to redefine your criteria on the fly so as to dismiss any evidence you might come across. Even if you're honestly trying to be objective, it's still a source of bias, and it's a source of perceived bias.

She did set some criteria for the requested evidence, but people such as yourself seem to think that a place like CERN falls under skeptical/atheist/freethinker communities, which is what Skeptic Ginger requested. Anybody can go to a skeptics in the pub meetings every week or spend several days at TAM. Not gonna happen at CERN.

More importantly, what she's doing is a valid way of seeing just what people mean when they make the unsupported claim about higher than normal levels of sexism keeping women away from events like TAM. She put out a broadly worded question to give the best chance of capturing relevant data.

You can whine all you want about what you think she's doing with it (sounds like a personal issue between you two to me). Or you can take the very same evidence and build up whatever case you want to make. I'm reading this thread to see what shows up, and no disrespect meant to Skeptic Ginger, but I don't care what conclusion she draws. I care about my conclusion.


So no, I would not have been "right behind" this approach if it was applied to traditional "woo" claims. I would have objected to it as playing right into the stereotypes of "bad skeptics" who engage in special pleading to dismiss any evidence provided.
Special pleading? Let me tell you this as an outsider: I think your reasoning is faulty. Based on your tone, it sounds like a personal issue is coloring the issue. Do you and she have a history or something?

It's a joke, not a factual claim. Admittedly, a joke with a point, based on SG's admission that she was gleeful about his discovery of past complaints of sexism against RW. It's a reasonable inference on my part that she is now doing her best to come up with ways to attempt to discredit Ouellette.
Skeptic Ginger didn't seek out ways to "discredit" RW. She, like many others, found it quite silly that RW would complain about such a benign incident calling it sexism when sexuality is such a major part of persona. That she would seek out to "discredit" Ouellete doesn't follow.

You know, sort of like you've made several inferences in your post about what I would or would not support or how I would or would not react in other contexts. You happen to be wrong, but I'm not whining about them being "cheap shots."
I didn't make inferences. I made direct claims. I don't think I'm wrong. I don't think you'll see just how distorted your view is, most likely because it's personal in nature. But at least now I know better.
 
I hope you didn't take her response at face value.
As long as she admits that her request for information isn't anything close to a scientific study then I don't have a problem with it. We could find a negative correlation. It wouldn't be definitive by any stretch of the imagination but it would be interesting. So, I grant you your criticisms.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom