Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well now, I'm sure glad that we got all that evidence for a so-called god out of the way.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I can go with that.

The difference is that where a rock displaces water, in the environment an object displaces nothing because there is nothing to displace. The object does not affect the environment because there is nothing to affect.
The object has no location in the environment because the environment is non-spatial.

If you want to create a new working definition for "change" then that's fine.

But you cannot compare the environment from "before" the object to "after" the object because the environment is non-temporal.

Just like in the pool where the water is still water and the rock is still a rock, the environment is still the environment, and an object exists.

Well, you really should not have used the analogy in the first place if you were going to discard all of it's traits. So it's atemporal, non-spatial water, which doesn't exist at all. So why call it water?

That also goes for your whole theory, or thought experiment, or whatever. What you describe as an 'environment' has none of the properties of what is commonly referred to as an 'environment'. So why call it an environment? From your description, it would be much more reasonable to simply call it 'nothing'.

With that, your theory takes the form "At first there was nothing. Since nothing can't stop something, something appeared without any reason. But nothing is still there". Which is the same thing, only it sounds as ridiculous as it is.
 
Wow, I don't think I can tell who's arguing for what, but we seem to be discussing the problem of how the universe could have come into existence.

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that there must have been a "beginning" (though I think this may be a mistake).

I'm also willing to assume that something other than the universe must have caused this beginning.

This still does not provide an iota of evidence for the existence of anything that should be worshipped as a god, let alone such a detailed picture of God as that described in the Bible or other religions.

Put simply, the proposition that "The universe must have had a creator" does not contain sufficient information to deduce anything more about this god than that it created the universe. The ancient Israelites / Greeks / Vikings / Egyptians etc. had far less information about the beginnings of the universe than we do today, and that is the knowledge base that their versions of God are based on.

To make my point a third time, any of the following could still be consistent with the proposition that a God must have created the universe:
- This God had to sacrifice itself to give birth to the cosmos
- This God is indifferent to everything that has happened in our universe since
- This God may have created the universe as a practical joke that will be revealed next Tuesday on the Tonight Show.
- This God was not a person

However, theists seem to think that if they can prove that only a God could have created the universe, it also follows that:
- God revealed himself to the prophets of ancient Israel
- God has a personal will and consciousness
- God consists of three parts that are actually one
- That God sent one of these parts of itself, the Son, to ancient Israel, where he had to be killed (except not really) in order to atone for the sinfulness of the humanity that He created
- That God is everywhere and knows everything and can do anything
- That God is invisible
- That God loves "his children"
- That God desires our worship
- That we have souls that survive our physical bodies but are essential to our identity
- That our souls may meet eternal joy or suffering (there is disagreement on the grounds for either result
- That there is a heaven and a hell
- That we are morally obligated to believe in God, Jesus and everything else above

None of that flows logically from the proposition that a God must have created the universe. It is merely how one ancient group of people made sense of the world. A lot more evidence about the world has come in since then, it's time to update some of our ideas, cherished as they may be.
 
Well, you really should not have used the analogy in the first place if you were going to discard all of it's traits. So it's atemporal, non-spatial water, which doesn't exist at all. So why call it water?

I don't know what unique form of reasoning you used to reach this conclusion.

That also goes for your whole theory, or thought experiment, or whatever. What you describe as an 'environment' has none of the properties of what is commonly referred to as an 'environment'.

Since the topic of my thought experiment was not a common idea I used the word "environment" with a specific detailed meaning.

So why call it an environment? From your description, it would be much more reasonable to simply call it 'nothing'.

I don't think that would lessen your confusion.

With that, your theory takes the form "At first there was nothing.
Since nothing can't stop something, something appeared without any reason. But nothing is still there". Which is the same thing, only it sounds as ridiculous as it is.

Here is the cosmologist's version.

At first, there may have been nothing.
Our universe appeared without any known reason.
We don't know if it can happen again.
Let's think of some scenarios that could answer these mysteries.

Sounds ridiculous doesn't it?
 
I presented no such definition.

You, however are implying that water can have the "property" of being rock-free.

You demonstrate what I pointed out that it is easy to make "property" devoid of meaning.

Why are you scare-quoting "property"?
 
I can go with that.

The difference is that where a rock displaces water, in the environment an object displaces nothing because there is nothing to displace. The object does not affect the environment because there is nothing to affect.
The object has no location in the environment because the environment is non-spatial.

If you want to create a new working definition for "change" then that's fine.

But you cannot compare the environment from "before" the object to "after" the object because the environment is non-temporal. Just like in the pool where the water is still water and the rock is still a rock, the environment is still the environment, and an object exists.

Now you're changing the properties of the environment.
 
How has the water changed?

Here's your statement:

But the environment still has the property of being the environment, no matter how many rocks you drop in it.

You'll notice you went from a question about the environment to one about water, that's moving the goalposts.
 
Well now, I'm sure glad that we got all that evidence for a so-called god out of the way.

Paul

:) :) :)

I think we're now discussing "Is water wet" in a non-temporal environment but I'm not sure what game we're playing. I'll see if I can tell when the goalposts come around again.
 
Here's your statement:

But the environment still has the property of being the environment, no matter how many rocks you drop in it.

You'll notice you went from a question about the environment to one about water, that's moving the goalposts.

I would call it a mixed metaphor.
"Moving the goalposts" usually refers to changing the requirements of evidence.
 
At first, there may have been nothing.
Our universe appeared without any known reason.
We don't know if it can happen again.
Let's think of some scenarios that could answer these mysteries.

Sounds ridiculous doesn't it?
If it is a magic man in the sky that would be a ridiculous answer because it only adds another layer to the question without telling us anything.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
If it is a magic man in the sky that would be a ridiculous answer because it only adds another layer to the question without telling us anything.
Paul

"The magic man and his world of woo,
I don't subscribe to this point of view." - Sting (sort of)
 
Wow, I don't think I can tell who's arguing for what, but we seem to be discussing the problem of how the universe could have come into existence.
:)
Any evidence of God's existence yet?
No, but we're making progress. If we can't figure out how the universe could have come into existence, then the usual argument against abiogenesis et cetera will say it couldn't have happened, ergo no creation, no creator God, no us.

At that point the question of God's existence becomes somewhat academic, and we can return to pondering evidence for bigfoot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom