Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is your convoluted definition of "property"?

You know, you really should invest in a dictionary. Or at least bother navigating to an online one. It would take you all of fifteen seconds to find out what a 'property' is. Instead you choose to ask me, avoiding actually answering the point I raised in my post. The fact that you constantly avoid actual argumentation like this strongly suggests that your goal here is not to convince anyone of your 'idea', but to simply insult people. And even though I am foolish enough to occasionally keep responding to your silly claims, I'm not masochistic enough to play by your convoluted rules.

If you want to have a discussion, learn the words. Otherwise, go away.
 
I think that describes an environment where things don't--and can't--exist. However, I'm not so sure it's an environment where something couldn't begin to exist, although the instant that happened it would no longer be an environment devoid of anything.

Sure, it could be that it is devoid of everything at one point ('in time') and then things begin to exist at some point ('in time') and so on. However this is explicitly excluded as well. The environment as origianally stipulated is atemporal. The best you can do is to say that there just is nothing. There is no room for could be.


I don't know what you're getting at with the book analogy.

Just pointing out that you can't have it both ways. An empty and not empty book. Just like you can't have an environment devoid and not devoid. You can have two different books though, one empty and the other one not, just as you can have two different environments.

And as I told Bill, it was not intended as an analogy. Rather as as example to aid me get my point across. (I guess it was not overly successful.)

What I am driving at is whether an environment devoid of anything has the property that nothing can begin to exist in it, while acknowledging that any sort of event means that it is no longer the environment devoid of anything originally described.

Well, I don't like this talk of properties. It just feels awkward to me.

However, I think that if I am asked to imagine an environment, then I am also asked to imagine the whole environment (unless stated otherwise, either implicitly or explicitily). I am not asked to imagine just a part of it. And that is what I did.

And "devoid of absolutely everything" then is a very clearly articulated ... hrmph ... property, which I am forced to assume holds true for the whole environment, and not just some part of it. Right?

Now take that other environment where something begins to exist. I wouldn't ever think of that whole environment as empty. Parts of it, maybe. The whole, no.

So, yes, there are two different environments, with different ...uhmm ... properties being described.


Of course the absence of anything has properties, not being anything is a property in itself, so I'm not arguing that the described environment can't have the property or quality that it can't change into another environment, one with 'stuff'. I am wondering whether it is necessarily unchanging, always an environment devoid of anything. If so, such an environment never existed, since 'there's stuff' now.

I would agree.
 
Let's simplify some of these issues using my water and rock analogy.

When you drop a rock into a pool of water the water doesn't change into something else. And so you can drop another rock into the same water. And the water still doesn't change into something else. And water has the property of not being a rock. And it has the property of not having non-water properties.

Even the word "property" has the property of not being water or a rock.
And if you use the word "property" so as to make it devoid of any meaning then it doesn't have any meaning.

The property of not having properties is devoid of meaning.

But the environment still has the property of being the environment, no matter how many rocks you drop in it.
 
Let's simplify some of these issues using my water and rock analogy.

When you drop a rock into a pool of water the water doesn't change into something else. And so you can drop another rock into the same water. And the water still doesn't change into something else. And water has the property of not being a rock. And it has the property of not having non-water properties.

Even the word "property" has the property of not being water or a rock.
And if you use the word "property" so as to make it devoid of any meaning then it doesn't have any meaning.

The property of not having properties is devoid of meaning.

But the environment still has the property of being the environment, no matter how many rocks you drop in it.

But it starts as an environment of water with no rocks in, then changes into an environment of water with rocks in...
 
Suppose I said that your argument would have more force if it hit the ground strapped to your back in the middle of a streaming herd.

Is that an insult, an ad hom, or an ab scopulus ergo proptor scopulus (over the cliff, therefore because of the cliff)?

It would be a statement that made absolutely no sense.
 
Let's simplify some of these issues using my water and rock analogy.

When you drop a rock into a pool of water the water doesn't change into something else. And so you can drop another rock into the same water. And the water still doesn't change into something else. And water has the property of not being a rock. And it has the property of not having non-water properties.

Even the word "property" has the property of not being water or a rock.
And if you use the word "property" so as to make it devoid of any meaning then it doesn't have any meaning.

The property of not having properties is devoid of meaning.

But the environment still has the property of being the environment, no matter how many rocks you drop in it.

You started with dry rocks and now you have wet rocks, the water went from no rocks to rocks so we can say the environment has been altered.
 
But shouldn't you go to the effort of putting together one that works?

:rolleyes: Bill, NO analogy will work the way you want it to when trying to compare a universe-less environment.

Also, I notice that, again, you are having trouble following the conversation. It wasn't MY analogy. I was simply responding to your comments on it.

4) Your inability to identify the connection between statements and derogatory remarks is a measure of your lack of analytical intelligence. You unintelligent dolt. This is not an ad hominem.

Indeed, it isn't.

Suppose I said that your argument would have more force if it hit the ground strapped to your back in the middle of a streaming herd.

Is that an insult, an ad hom, or an ab scopulus ergo proptor scopulus (over the cliff, therefore because of the cliff)?

Neither.
 
Sure, it could be that it is devoid of everything at one point ('in time') and then things begin to exist at some point ('in time') and so on. However this is explicitly excluded as well. The environment as origianally stipulated is atemporal. The best you can do is to say that there just is nothing. There is no room for could be.

Just pointing out that you can't have it both ways. An empty and not empty book. Just like you can't have an environment devoid and not devoid. You can have two different books though, one empty and the other one not, just as you can have two different environments.

Thanks for clarifying, Lord Emsworth. Atemporality would seem to exclude such an environment from existence, since it would contradict the temporal environment we observe. My poor brain can't even encompass the concept of no space and no time: I can't 'not imagine' the initial condition of the universe without mentally placing it in a void of space in the time before it expands. So thanks for being patient.

Perhaps an 'unstable nothingness' as opposed to 'completely devoid nothingness' is a possible predecessor to our universe, but the eternal 'branes idea seems to have more explanatory power.
 
You have defined the water as being rock-free. It is no longer rock-free water.

I presented no such definition.

You, however are implying that water can have the "property" of being rock-free.

You demonstrate what I pointed out that it is easy to make "property" devoid of meaning.
 
The question was whether or not the environment had changed. It should be fairly obvious that an environment composed solely of water and an environment of water with a rock in it are different - hence, the environment has changed.

However, when this was pointed out to you, you moved the goalposts, saying that the water itself did not change. Well, in a sense, that's true. It's also a complete non-sequitur. Even if the water did not change, the environment did. And if you define the environment as just the water - well, then there are no rocks in it.
 
The question was whether or not the environment had changed. It should be fairly obvious that an environment composed solely of water and an environment of water with a rock in it are different - hence, the environment has changed.

However, when this was pointed out to you, you moved the goalposts, saying that the water itself did not change. Well, in a sense, that's true. It's also a complete non-sequitur. Even if the water did not change, the environment did. And if you define the environment as just the water - well, then there are no rocks in it.

I can go with that.

The difference is that where a rock displaces water, in the environment an object displaces nothing because there is nothing to displace. The object does not affect the environment because there is nothing to affect.
The object has no location in the environment because the environment is non-spatial.

If you want to create a new working definition for "change" then that's fine.

But you cannot compare the environment from "before" the object to "after" the object because the environment is non-temporal.

Just like in the pool where the water is still water and the rock is still a rock, the environment is still the environment, and an object exists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom