I think that describes an environment where things don't--and can't--exist. However, I'm not so sure it's an environment where something couldn't begin to exist, although the instant that happened it would no longer be an environment devoid of anything.
Sure, it could be that it is devoid of everything at one point ('in time') and then things begin to exist at some point ('in time') and so on. However this is explicitly excluded as well. The environment as origianally stipulated is atemporal. The best you can do is to say that there just
is nothing. There is no room for
could be.
I don't know what you're getting at with the book analogy.
Just pointing out that you can't have it both ways. An empty and not empty book. Just like you can't have an environment devoid and not devoid. You can have two different books though, one empty and the other one not, just as you can have two different environments.
And as I told Bill, it was not intended as an analogy. Rather as as example to aid me get my point across. (I guess it was not overly successful.)
What I am driving at is whether an environment devoid of anything has the property that nothing can begin to exist in it, while acknowledging that any sort of event means that it is no longer the environment devoid of anything originally described.
Well, I don't like this talk of properties. It just feels awkward
to me.
However, I think that if I am asked to imagine an environment, then I am also asked to imagine the
whole environment (unless stated otherwise, either implicitly or explicitily). I am not asked to imagine just a part of it. And that is what I did.
And "devoid of absolutely everything" then is a very clearly articulated ... hrmph ... property, which I am forced to assume holds true for the whole environment, and not just some part of it. Right?
Now take that other environment where something begins to exist. I wouldn't ever think of that whole environment as empty. Parts of it, maybe. The whole, no.
So, yes, there are two different environments, with different ...uhmm ... properties being described.
Of course the absence of anything has properties, not being anything is a property in itself, so I'm not arguing that the described environment can't have the property or quality that it can't change into another environment, one with 'stuff'. I am wondering whether it is necessarily unchanging, always an environment devoid of anything. If so, such an environment never existed, since 'there's stuff' now.
I would agree.