Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course you would think that since you wouldn't have to do any thinking.
And restating a question as if hasn't already been answered multiple times makes it sound like a legitimate dodge.

Yes, yes. Zing. You totally got me with your razor-sharp wit. I'm slain. You must be so popular at parties.

And while dodging might be the one thing I'd actually believe you have expertise in, you haven't satisfactorily answered the question, although it indeed has been asked before.

I recall you saying at one point that this 'environment' of yours didn't have any properties. Did you revoke that statement at some point? Because 'being able to contain random something-from nothing events that result in an universe' is a property.

And if we allow one property for your 'environment', then you really have no reason whatsoever to reject any other properties it might have. So what you have postulated is not a simple, elegant idea, as you seem to think, but a very crude idea you've tried to paint all over with 'it contains nothing'. But as Elmsworth points out, it doesn't work. We can see the handkerchief in your sleeve.
 
First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that after our universe existed then another could not.

Not necessarily. IF there is something that permits you to meaningfully talk about "after our universe" (and maybe before), then, no, that conclusion would not follow. I.e. if our universe exists within some sort of meta-time-thingy, then there could be another one after ours.

If not, it is not possbile to meaningfuly talk about afters and befores. (There might be other universes still though, just not before or after.)


Secondly, you must have missed my analogy.

I have seen that you were probably trying to make some sort of analogy. Something about water and a rock, IIRC. What with it?

You just jumped around til you got confused and blamed it on magic.

I am not the one who is confused, or jumping around. I do however place some blame on magic. Word-magic, to be precise.
 
Is it nonsensical to ask someone if it is possible to write the first line in an empty book, to continue your analogy?

It was intended more as an example, and less as an analogy.

Be that as it may, to answer your question, it is not nonsensical to ask, of course. But only if we are in a world that is not atemporal, or frozen in time, i.e. it does only make sense if there is a future in which that first line could be written. If there is not, if there is only "now" (along with the empty book) then it is nonsensical indeed.
 
I don't know if the 'devoid of everything' or 'absolute nothing' is meant to represent the BBT, that is standard, so maybe it is.

The 'place' prior to the BBE is unknown, that does not mean it was nothing, that means nothing is what we know about it.

The BBE did not comes from nothing it came from unknown.
 
In this case, there is no book. No pen. No nothing.

You are wise to abandon your analogy.

If there's some sort of underlying principle to the universe, whether it's dimensionless (spaceless, timeless), lawless, matterless and energyless, it's NOT nothing, still.

I can't seem to redefine "principle" to apply to your characterization.
Why don't you give it a try?
 
Sheesh. ANOTHER poster who doesn't know what an ad hominem is.

Is there no end to them ? They're just like lemmings.

We just know it's not a valid rebuttal technique, which shows a lack of aptitude in debate.
For example, if you were to call someone a lemming, that would indicate that you lack the ability to form a more cogent argument.
 
I recall you saying at one point that this 'environment' of yours didn't have any properties. Did you revoke that statement at some point? Because 'being able to contain random something-from nothing events that result in an universe' is a property.


What is your convoluted definition of "property"?
 
Not necessarily. IF there is something that permits you to meaningfully talk about "after our universe" (and maybe before), then, no, that conclusion would not follow. I.e. if our universe exists within some sort of meta-time-thingy, then there could be another one after ours.

If not, it is not possbile to meaningfuly talk about afters and befores. (There might be other universes still though, just not before or after.)

That's fine, I didn't realze you were going off to another idea and not referring to my environment anymore.

I have seen that you were probably trying to make some sort of analogy. Something about water and a rock, IIRC. What with it?

Never mind, water and rocks can be complicated concepts.

I am not the one who is confused, or jumping around. I do however place some blame on magic. Word-magic, to be precise.

Magic only works on those who aren't paying attention.
 
It was intended more as an example, and less as an analogy.

Be that as it may, to answer your question, it is not nonsensical to ask, of course. But only if we are in a world that is not atemporal, or frozen in time, i.e. it does only make sense if there is a future in which that first line could be written. If there is not, if there is only "now" (along with the empty book) then it is nonsensical indeed.

A guess your example of reading the first line of an empty book is nonsensical indeed, also.
 
You are wise to abandon your analogy.

Apparently, since you seem unable to understand that analogies are never perfect.

I can't seem to redefine "principle" to apply to your characterization.
Why don't you give it a try?

Do you genuinely understand nothing or are you simply stalling ?

We just know it's not a valid rebuttal technique, which shows a lack of aptitude in debate.
For example, if you were to call someone a lemming, that would indicate that you lack the ability to form a more cogent argument.

NO! That's not an ad hominem. But thanks for playing.

1) "Your argument is invalid because you're an idiot" is an ad hominem.
2) "Your argument is invalid. You are also an idiot" is NOT one.
3) "You are an idiot" is not an ad hominem, either.
 
Apparently, since you seem unable to understand that analogies are never perfect.

But shouldn't you go to the effort of putting together one that works?

An example of stalling:
Do you genuinely understand nothing or are you simply stalling ?

NO! That's not an ad hominem. But thanks for playing.

1) "Your argument is invalid because you're an idiot" is an ad hominem.
2) "Your argument is invalid. You are also an idiot" is NOT one.
3) "You are an idiot" is not an ad hominem, either.

4) Your inability to identify the connection between statements and derogatory remarks is a measure of your lack of analytical intelligence. You unintelligent dolt. This is not an ad hominem.
 
That's fine, I didn't realze you were going off to another idea and not referring to my environment anymore.

Here is what I was responding to:
First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that after our universe existed then another could not​
Those are your words. And I don't think that they were referring to your environment anymore.


A guess your example of reading the first line of an empty book is nonsensical indeed, also.

It was intended as an example of something nonsensical, yes. :confused:
 
Here is what I was responding to:
First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that after our universe existed then another could not​
Those are your words. And I don't think that they were referring to your environment anymore.

It exactly refers to my environment.

Lord Emsworth said:
You are not presenting one environment, you are presenting two slightly different ones. The former is devoid of everything, while the latter is not.

The thought experiment only 'works' as long as people don't realize that the first environment (in which nothing exists) is being swapped out for the second environment (in which object, events and so on exist).

The thought experiment works fine because it doesn't continue into any "second environment" conditions that you posit.

And your "second environment" argument is wrong because the random occurrence of one event in the environment would place no limitations upon another random event.
 
We just know it's not a valid rebuttal technique, which shows a lack of aptitude in debate.
For example, if you were to call someone a lemming, that would indicate that you lack the ability to form a more cogent argument.

Calling someone a lemming would be an insult not an ad hom.
 
It exactly refers to my environment.
Like this you mean?
First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that [in my environment] after our universe existed then another could not​

If so, then just strike out what I replied earlier and replace it by "Whatever."


The thought experiment works fine because it doesn't continue into any "second environment" conditions that you posit.

I am not positing anyhting. I was just pointing out.

And your "second environment" argument is wrong because the random occurrence of one event in the environment would place no limitations upon another random event.

There are no events in your first environment. There are also no objects. There is nothing. There is no future, no beginning and so on. You defined it so. Later on you are trying to re-define it - I grant you that. ;)
 
Last edited:
I suggest that he has some doronshadmi-like characteristics, most important of which is imperviousness to critique.

Take 'doronshadmi', change two (or three) letters, and you have my new proposed name for Bill.

do rot sh at mi?


ETA: the sh and the at shouldn't have a space between them
 
Last edited:
Calling someone a lemming would be an insult not an ad hom.

Suppose I said that your argument would have more force if it hit the ground strapped to your back in the middle of a streaming herd.

Is that an insult, an ad hom, or an ab scopulus ergo proptor scopulus (over the cliff, therefore because of the cliff)?
 
Like this you mean?
First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that [in my environment] after our universe existed then another could not​

If so, then just strike out what I replied earlier and replace it by "Whatever."

I am not positing anyhting. I was just pointing out.

There are no events in your first environment. There are also no objects. There is nothing. There is no future, no beginning and so on. You defined it so. Later on you are trying to re-define it - I grant you that. ;)

"Whatever" works for all of that.
 
"Devoid of absolutely everything" is a description. Now you decide whether the phrase accurately describes an enviroment where objects do exist or whether it does not. I wouldn't think it does, at all. I would also think that it is nonsensical to ask somebody to read the first line of an empty book to you.

I don't know what you are driving at with asking for a property though.

I think that describes an environment where things don't--and can't--exist. However, I'm not so sure it's an environment where something couldn't begin to exist, although the instant that happened it would no longer be an environment devoid of anything.

I don't know what you're getting at with the book analogy.

What I am driving at is whether an environment devoid of anything has the property that nothing can begin to exist in it, while acknowledging that any sort of event means that it is no longer the environment devoid of anything originally described. Of course the absence of anything has properties, not being anything is a property in itself, so I'm not arguing that the described environment can't have the property or quality that it can't change into another environment, one with 'stuff'. I am wondering whether it is necessarily unchanging, always an environment devoid of anything. If so, such an environment never existed, since 'there's stuff' now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom