Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
You just substituted one woo (a god) with another: you admit it to be untestable and unfalsifiable, thus of no value whatsoever to science.

Also, don't flatter yourself calling it a thought experiment anymore: you just admitted it being non-testable and non-falsifiable. What kind of experiment is one of those?

From Wikipedia, "Thought Experiment"
"A thought experiment is a proposal for an experiment that would test or illuminate a hypothesis, theory,[1] or principle.

Given the structure of the proposed experiment, it may or may not be possible to actually perform the experiment and, in the case that it is possible for the experiment to be performed, no intention of any kind to actually perform the experiment in question may exist. The common goal of a thought experiment is to explore the potential consequences of the principle in question.

Famous examples of thought experiments include Schrödinger's cat, illustrating quantum indeterminacy through the manipulation of a perfectly sealed environment and a tiny bit of radioactive substance, and Maxwell's demon, in which a supernatural being is instructed to attempt to violate the second law of thermodynamics."

Maybe you should pay particular attention to the phrase "explore the potential".

It has the same value as exploring the idea that an untestable, unfalsifiable god created the world in 6 days some 6000 years ago. Thats is, none.

Other possible untestable, unfalsifiable theories of the universe:
Multiple universes, cyclical universe, Big Freeze (heat death), Big Bounce, Big Crunch, etc.

Scientific speculation is not the same as religion. Generally, if you have any scientific awareness you understand this.

And it is telling that you left off my final point. Apparently, the limits of your imagination prevent you from exploring anything that you cannot see, sniff, lick, hear or poke with your finger.
 
Last edited:
From Wikipedia, "Thought Experiment"
"A thought experiment is a proposal for an experiment that would test or illuminate a hypothesis, theory,[1] or principle.

...

Um... So what was the experiment you proposed to test your speculation? I must have missed it.
 
Um... So what was the experiment you proposed to test your speculation? I must have missed it.

For your edification, again:

Imagine an environment without our universe (or without any universe).
Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.
It is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.
It has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.
A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might randomly occur in this environment which results in the what we call a Big Bang.
...
 
I know it seems an obvious question, even simple. A simple answer would be appreciated.
If god is the cause of the existence of the universe, what was the cause of the existence of god?

What was the cause of the singularity,and what caused that? etc.....
 
What was the cause of the singularity,and what caused that? etc.....
And what does a so-called god explain, what can be done with that information. It is funny how people talk about science has if it has been around for thousands and thousands of years and hasn't answered all the questions yet, as if any religion has done that after its thousands and thousands of years.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
That's your hypothesis, where is the experiment?

Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

Experiment:
Imagine...
Imagine...
Imagine...

Conclusion:
This scenario is a logically consistent, comparatively simple concept,
and it is a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Online)
"Thought Experiments"

"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination used to investigate the nature of things. We need only list a few of the well-known thought experiments to be reminded of their enormous influence and importance in the sciences: Newton's bucket, Maxwell's demon, Einstein's elevator, Heisenberg's gamma-ray microscope, Schrödinger's cat. "

"...the creation of quantum mechanics and relativity are almost unthinkable without the crucial role played by thought experiments. Contemporary philosophy, even more than the sciences, would be severely impoverished without them."
 
Last edited:
From Wikipedia, "Thought Experiment"
"A thought experiment is a proposal for an experiment that would test or illuminate a hypothesis, theory,[1] or principle.

Care to propose such an experiment?

Given the structure of the proposed experiment, it may or may not be possible to actually perform the experiment and, in the case that it is possible for the experiment to be performed, no intention of any kind to actually perform the experiment in question may exist. The common goal of a thought experiment is to explore the potential consequences of the principle in question.

Famous examples of thought experiments include Schrödinger's cat, illustrating quantum indeterminacy through the manipulation of a perfectly sealed environment and a tiny bit of radioactive substance, and Maxwell's demon, in which a supernatural being is instructed to attempt to violate the second law of thermodynamics."

Maybe you should pay particular attention to the phrase "explore the potential".

So why don't you "explore the potential"? Might it be because there's none?

Other possible untestable, unfalsifiable theories of the universe:
Multiple universes, cyclical universe, Big Freeze (heat death), Big Bounce, Big Crunch, etc.

The only one of those that has a hint of untestability is the multiverse hypothesis. The rest all are (AFAIK) either related or are being actively investigated through observations. I'm no cosmology expert, so I welcome any corrections.

Scientific speculation is not the same as religion. Generally, if you have any scientific awareness you understand this.

Giant strawman is giant strawman. I didn't claim that scientific speculation is the same as religion. I said that exploring untestable, unfalsifiable hypothesis has the same value as exploring any other untestable, unfalsifiable hypothesis, a prime example being religion.

And it is telling that you left off my final point. Apparently, the limits of your imagination prevent you from exploring anything that you cannot see, sniff, lick, hear or poke with your finger.

Right... Let's see that crushing final point, lest I be called a coward.

To me that does not mean that it has no value or is not worth exploring, but rather it can be explored unrestricted by anything except the limits of the imagination.

I thought I addressed the value of exploring useless ideas earlier, but thanks for proving my point once again. Exploring something unrestricted has no value whatsoever. Any kind of useful exploration should be restricted by observation. You know, reality.

( I am a big fan of Asimov, Bradbury, Clarke, etc. and Gardner, Hofstadter, JH Conway, etc.)

Am I safe to leave this un-addressed?
 
Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

OK...

Experiment:
Imagine...
Imagine...
Imagine...

No. Imagining something is not an experiment.

Conclusion:
This scenario is a logically consistent, comparatively simple concept,
and it is a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

Yes. Although your "explanation" makes less sense than ID or Creationism. What does that tell you?
 
Care to propose such an experiment?
Read my previous post.

So why don't you "explore the potential"? Might it be because there's none?
Read my post on the previous page.

The only one of those that has a hint of untestability is the multiverse hypothesis. The rest all are (AFAIK) either related or are being actively investigated through observations. I'm no cosmology expert, so I welcome any corrections.

I stand corrected. My hypothesis is testable by current investigative techniques of cosmology.

Giant strawman is giant strawman. I didn't claim that scientific speculation is the same as religion. I said that exploring untestable, unfalsifiable hypothesis has the same value as exploring any other untestable, unfalsifiable hypothesis, a prime example being religion.

I guessed I missed the distinction you forget to make.

I thought I addressed the value of exploring useless ideas earlier, but thanks for proving my point once again. Exploring something unrestricted has no value whatsoever. Any kind of useful exploration should be restricted by observation. You know, reality.

Too bad the multitude of respected scientists who have you used thought experiments through history didn't know that they were wasting their time.
 
OK...

No. Imagining something is not an experiment.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Online)
"Thought Experiments"
"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination used to investigate the nature of things."

Yes. Although your "explanation" makes less sense than ID or Creationism. What does that tell you?

You are impersonating a senseless theist?
 
Last edited:
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Online)
"Thought Experiments"
"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination used to investigate the nature of things."

You are impersonating a senseless theist?


Formal schooling isn't necessary for education.

However, I'm curious about what makes you tick.

Please describe your formal college schooling and any degrees.

Also, please describe any educational activities that you have engaged in apart from formal schooling.
 
Formal schooling isn't necessary for education.

However, I'm curious about what makes you tick.

Please describe your formal college schooling and any degrees.

Also, please describe any educational activities that you have engaged in apart from formal schooling.

What a setup for a comparative education competition.

If you don't agree with my ideas use reason to present yours.

Note how easy it was to present an absolute counter, with authoritative evidence, to laca's ridiculous assertion about thought experiments .
 
Note how easy it was to present an absolute counter, with authoritative evidence, to laca's ridiculous assertion about thought experiments .
No. Please expand on this claim. Using your own words.
What is a Thought Experiment?

It should be very easy for you to do so since you seem to understand the definition and processes involved.
 
What a setup for a comparative education competition.

If you don't agree with my ideas use reason to present yours.

Note how easy it was to present an absolute counter, with authoritative evidence, to laca's ridiculous assertion about thought experiments .


You're wrong.

You have several peculiar and incorrect ideas and an unproductively odd way of thinking.

I want to understand where you've gotten your wrong ideas and poor habits of thought from.

I'd like to see which majors and interests led you down the path that you're on today. I don't care whether you've been formally schooled or self-taught - it really doesn't matter.

Whatever you've done, however, is part of a cautionary tale that others could learn from.

As to your discussion with laca, he's got you well in hand, and I'll leave you to his tender mercies.

I will note, however, that you have presented no 'absolute counter', and offered no 'authoritative evidence'.
 
Last edited:
You're wrong.

You have several peculiar and incorrect ideas and an unproductively odd way of thinking.

I want to understand where you've gotten your wrong ideas and poor habits of thought from.

I'd like to see which majors and interests led you down the path that you're on today. I don't care whether you've been formally schooled or self-taught - it really doesn't matter.

Whatever you've done, however, is part of a cautionary tale that others could learn from.

As to your discussion with laca, he's got you well in hand, and I'll leave you to his tender mercies.

I will note, however, that you have presented no 'absolute counter', and offered no 'authoritative evidence'.

Are you blind?
 
Read my previous post.


Read my post on the previous page.

Oh, I've read them. The questions still stand.

I stand corrected. My hypothesis is testable by current investigative techniques of cosmology.

Excellent! Now how would you go about testing your hypothesis?

I guessed I missed the distinction you forget to make.

I did not make one, because I thought it is obvious. Scientific speculation is backed up with observations, experiments and discarded if the data doesn't fit. That's why it's different from pure speculation.

Too bad the multitude of respected scientists who have you used thought experiments through history didn't know that they were wasting their time.

I'm beginning to feel like I'm wasting my time. We're also derailing the thread. I suggest that you start a thread about your hypothesis if you want to.
 
Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.
Or it might not have...
Experiment:
Imagine...
Imagine...
Imagine...

You are trying to test if people can imagine your hypothesis? If it can be imagined, it proves something? I can imagine that it didn't happen that way, therefore your hypothesis fails.
Conclusion:
This scenario is a logically consistent, comparatively simple concept,
and it is a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

Or not.

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Online)
"Thought Experiments"

"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination used to investigate the nature of things. We need only list a few of the well-known thought experiments to be reminded of their enormous influence and importance in the sciences: Newton's bucket,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_argument

Newton actually imagined a physical experiment and used it to demonstrate a principle. He didn't just say "Imagine a bucket".

Maxwell's demon,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell's_demon
wiki said:
Maxwell's demon is a thought experiment created by the Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell to "show that the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics has only a statistical certainty." The thought experiment demonstrates Maxwell's point by describing how to violate the 2nd Law. In the experiment an imaginary container is divided into two parts by an insulated wall, with a door that can be opened and closed by what came to be called "Maxwell's Demon". The hypothetical demon is able to let only the "hot" molecules of gas flow through to a favored side of the chamber, causing that side to appear to spontaneously heat up while the other side cools down

A bit more than just saying "Imagine the second law of thermodynamics could be violated somehow".

Einstein's elevator,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_relativity

It's in there somewhere, but again, a lot more than just saying "Imagine my hypothesis is true..."

The same for the rest. You haven't done a thought experiment, you just want people to imagine that you have...

Heisenberg's gamma-ray microscope, Schrödinger's cat. "

"...the creation of quantum mechanics and relativity are almost unthinkable without the crucial role played by thought experiments. Contemporary philosophy, even more than the sciences, would be severely impoverished without them."

Imagine that!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom