Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
It sounds like you are claiming that the hypothesis of my thought experiment might not be true. Wow, you really have a hold on this stuff, don't you?

Yes I am claiming that it might not be true. Now a real thought experiment would require that you invent a scenario that demonstrates that your hypothesis is true, you haven't done that yet.

I bet his brain got really crowded from sticking all that physical equipment in there. Or are you just saying that his mind could imagine things into existence -- something-from-nothing as it were?
I'm saying that he imagined an actual experiment to test his hypothesis. He didn't just speculate and assume he was right.

"Thought experiment"
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"The common goal of a thought experiment is to explore the potential consequences of the principle in question."

How has your "thought experiment" done this? You just asked us to imagine it, you haven't tested anything at all.

Why are you so steadfast in trying to put some arbitrary limits on thought experiment, which by all accounts has no limits?

You are fundamentally saying that we must limit our thoughts, which as an intellectual policy I find abhorrent.

All thought experiments are imagined, but not everything that is imagined is a thought experiment.
 
Would a moderator be so kind to split that atemporal thought experiment nonsense from this thread - it has nothing to do with the OP and results in a pissing contest.
 
Yes I am claiming that it might not be true. Now a real thought experiment would require that you invent a scenario that demonstrates that your hypothesis is true, you haven't done that yet.

Not all experiments validate a hypothesis.

I'm saying that he imagined an actual experiment to test his hypothesis. He didn't just speculate and assume he was right.

How has your "thought experiment" done this? You just asked us to imagine it, you haven't tested anything at all.

All thought experiments are imagined, but not everything that is imagined is a thought experiment.

You come up with a reasonable description of a thought experiment and tell me why the scenario below doesn't fit.

Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

Experimental Thoughts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.

If it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy then it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.

If it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass, then there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event.

If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.

Conclusion:
This environment is a possible explanation for the existence of our universe.
 
Why don't you go back a few pages, start reading, and then await that way.
Much easier and you'll get just what you want, as I have repeatedly said.

And talk about a whining child, you've got me covering my ears.

"Don't say I don't have rebuttals, where's your rebuttals?"

Keep it down to a low roar, Pax.
I'm sorry.
Why are you such a failure at answering such simple questions? Why so much poor attempts at making up excuses for your failure to provide answer?

On yes, I still don't see any answers.
I am still eagerly awaiting for:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.

Why have you continually failed to provide these simple answers?
Why are you using red herring and Argumentum ad whining child(ie the "I'm being persecuted" excuse) to run way from providing such simple answers?

I eagerly await your honest answers to these simple questions that you should be able to easily answer.

Edit: Looks like you answered number 2(see below). How about number 1 and 3?
 
Last edited:
Not all experiments validate a hypothesis.
Why yes. But an experiment needs to actually TEST a hypothesis.

You come up with a reasonable description of a thought experiment and tell me why the scenario below doesn't fit.

Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

Experimental Thoughts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.

If it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy then it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.

If it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass, then there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event.

If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.

Conclusion:
This environment is a possible explanation for the existence of our universe.
Finally, the "Thought Experiment". Why so coy?

So you asked people to imagine "none existence with nothing known to mankind that follows no known physics or anything known" as a possible explanation for all that exist?
Your "thought experiment" involves "multiplying unknown entities ad infinitum" until it makes your conclusion valid.

You know what Bill? I agree with you. This is a Thought Experiment in the loosest sense of the word.
It is completely useless and pretty much irrelevant but yes. Your "thought experiment", which basically special pleaded a scenario filled with every unknown to humanity, is a great use of imagining things that has no basis with reality, mathematics or human knowledge. But then your Thought Experiment is based on assuming that logic, rationality, math and everything is irrelevant...what is that called again?
 
Last edited:
Not all experiments validate a hypothesis.



You come up with a reasonable description of a thought experiment and tell me why the scenario below doesn't fit.

Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

Experimental Thoughts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.

If it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy then it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.

If it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass, then there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event.

If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.

Conclusion:
This environment is a possible explanation for the existence of our universe.

What Paximperium said. Plus: Since there are no constraints on what this imagined environment can or cannot do, I imagine there is no reason to assume that it ever existed or created our universe.

I'm sure it was said several pages back, but here it is again; You have just re-stated the idea that: "In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded".

Ponder Stibbons would be proud.
 
Which sounds weirder. in the beginning there was nothing which then exploded or this. In the beginning there was nothing, then god appeared.
 
Why yes. But an experiment needs to actually TEST a hypothesis.

I'll let you know how that went when I get my paper published.

Finally, the "Thought Experiment". Why so coy?

So you asked people to imagine "none existence with nothing known to mankind that follows no known physics or anything known" as a possible explanation for all that exist?

I guess since the current theory is that known physics started with our universe it would make sense then that before our universe known physics would not have existed.

Your "thought experiment" involves "multiplying unknown entities ad infinitum" until it makes your conclusion valid.

How did you multiply nothing by nothing and get infinity?

You know what Bill? I agree with you. This is a Thought Experiment in the loosest sense of the word.

I gave you the chance to detail your concept of "thought experiment" and the best you can come up with is "not so loose"?

It is completely useless and pretty much irrelevant but yes. Your "thought experiment", which basically special pleaded a scenario filled with every unknown to humanity, is a great use of imagining things that has no basis with reality, mathematics or human knowledge. But then your Thought Experiment is based on assuming that logic, rationality, math and everything is irrelevant...what is that called again?

Lateral thinking.

Multiple universes is a common idea in the study of cosmology.
I cannot imagine that any one other than ours would necessarily have the same reality, mathematics, logic or knowledge as ours.

It wouldn't be so dark where you are if you tried thinking outside of the box.
 
What Paximperium said. Plus: Since there are no constraints on what this imagined environment can or cannot do, I imagine there is no reason to assume that it ever existed or created our universe.

So, you finally agree with what I have repeatedly been saying.

I'm sure it was said several pages back, but here it is again; You have just re-stated the idea that: "In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded".

Exactly, in the beginning there was this Big Bang. I hope I get credit for this idea if it ever becomes popular.
 
If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.

No, this is simply linguistic sleight of hand. Remember the constraints that you placed? Those that permit random objects, events or beginnings. Here:
Experimental Thoughts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.

Devoid of objects, beginnings or events. Yes. Without objects, beginnings, or events. Yes.

So, no objects that randomly begin to exist.
 
I'll let you know how that went when I get my paper published.
More excuses for your failures.
Please take responsibility for your failures instead of playing little rhetorical tricks.
Your "Thought Experiment" is a failure. It tests nothing and is based on nothing.
I guess since the current theory is that known physics started with our universe it would make sense then that before our universe known physics would not have existed.
Most definitely. But imagining things based on nothing isn't "physics".
Why? Are you claiming it is based on physics?
How did you multiply nothing by nothing and get infinity?
No, no, no Bill. How did you?
(And what a clumsy attempt at throwing a Red Herring. Its as if you dishonestly tried one of your many rhetorical tricks in a lame attempt at covering up your unparsimonious nonsense...why is that?)
Why are you blaming me for the epic idiocy of your "thought experiment"?
You are demanding others use many unsupported concepts to even make your unsupported concept semi-coherent. What do people call that?
I gave you the chance to detail your concept of "thought experiment" and the best you can come up with is "not so loose"?
You did? Wow. I feel so honored to be allowed to defend YOUR own claims against your own incompetent concepts that you don't even understand.
Oh yes, I'm still waiting:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.
Lateral thinking.
Thinking? Where? Are you using your own made up definitions again?
Multiple universes is a common idea in the study of cosmology.
Yes. Only because the MATH makes sense.
What's your excuse?
I cannot imagine that any one other than ours would necessarily have the same reality, mathematics, logic or knowledge as ours.
"It wouldn't be so dark where you are if you tried thinking outside of the box.". Very cute.
It wouldn't be so dark where you are if you tried thinking outside of the box.
Why would I want to base my thinking on making crap up, pure conjecture and has no basis on anything?
 
Last edited:
No, this is simply linguistic sleight of hand. Remember the constraints that you placed? Those that permit random objects, events or beginnings. Here:


Devoid of objects, beginnings or events. Yes. Without objects, beginnings, or events. Yes.

So, no objects that randomly begin to exist.

I'm going to pretend to be Bill for a minute: As soon as something begins to exist, the "environment of nothingness" ceases to exist...

This is fun.
 
I'm going to pretend to be Bill for a minute: As soon as something begins to exist, the "environment of nothingness" ceases to exist...

This is fun.
Billy: Dude.
Bob: Dude.
Billy: Man, imagine a cosmic chicken.
Bob: Woah.
Billy: This cosmic chicken lays a cosmic egg, man.
Bob: Woah.
Billy: So which came first, the chicken or the egg?
Bob: Woah, deep dude. That's so deep.
Billy: I'm so smart.
 
Hmm. Big Bang vs Big Braggart They both sound pretty weird.

Which is more plausible? A sliver of energy that's always been there, that at some time 14 billion years ago for no apparent reason exploded in what is termed the B/B. Remember, energy cannot be destroyed. This sliver of energy could have been a leftover of the last B/B, which in turn could have been another leftover from another previous B/B and so on.

Or an extremely complex being coming into existence with no cause whatsoever from nothing.:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom