Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're wrong.

You have several peculiar and incorrect ideas and an unproductively odd way of thinking.

I want to understand where you've gotten your wrong ideas and poor habits of thought from.

I'd like to see which majors and interests led you down the path that you're on today. I don't care whether you've been formally schooled or self-taught - it really doesn't matter.

Whatever you've done, however, is part of a cautionary tale that others could learn from.

The cautionary tale is that Complexity is starting to troll.

As to your discussion with laca, he's got you well in hand, and I'll leave you to his tender mercies.

You think laca will still try to defend his lame position on thought experiments?

I will note, however, that you have presented no 'absolute counter', and offered no 'authoritative evidence'.

This is a perfect example of an "absolute counter":

"Imagining something is not an experiment."
vs
"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination."

This is a perfect example of an authority:
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Online)

"Welcome to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (SEP). From its inception, the SEP was designed so that each entry is maintained and kept up to date by an expert or group of experts in the field. All entries and substantive updates are refereed by the members of a distinguished Editorial Board before they are made public. Consequently, our dynamic reference work maintains academic standards while evolving and adapting in response to new research. "

When you make such completely ridiculous statements you lose any credibility you might have had.
 
This is a perfect example of an "absolute counter":

"Imagining something is not an experiment."
vs
"Thought experiments are devices of the imagination."


When you make such completely ridiculous statements you lose any credibility you might have had.
No. It is not. You seem to lack a basic understanding of actual logic.

In what way was your rather idiotic version of using imagination, the same as the process of Thought Experiment as used and described ny philosophers?

Please do described the process of Thought Experimentation.
 
Oh, I've read them. The questions still stand.

Again, is it your memory or your attention span that fails you?

Excellent! Now how would you go about testing your hypothesis?

My resources are limited, I will defer to your answer: "The rest all are (AFAIK) either related or are being actively investigated through observations."

I did not make one, because I thought it is obvious. Scientific speculation is backed up with observations, experiments and discarded if the data doesn't fit. That's why it's different from pure speculation.

My interpretation of your statement is that scientific research (scientific speculation) is different from a thought experiment (pure speculation). So you are finally figuring that out after all.

I'm beginning to feel like I'm wasting my time. We're also derailing the thread. I suggest that you start a thread about your hypothesis if you want to.

I don't really think it would help your lack of speculatability.
 
Or it might not have...

You are trying to test if people can imagine your hypothesis? If it can be imagined, it proves something? I can imagine that it didn't happen that way, therefore your hypothesis fails.

Or not.


It sounds like you are claiming that the hypothesis of my thought experiment might not be true. Wow, you really have a hold on this stuff, don't you?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_argument

Newton actually imagined a physical experiment and used it to demonstrate a principle. He didn't just say "Imagine a bucket".

I bet his brain got really crowded from sticking all that physical equipment in there. Or are you just saying that his mind could imagine things into existence -- something-from-nothing as it were?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell's_demon

A bit more than just saying "Imagine the second law of thermodynamics could be violated somehow".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_relativity

It's in there somewhere, but again, a lot more than just saying "Imagine my hypothesis is true..."

The same for the rest. You haven't done a thought experiment, you just want people to imagine that you have...

Imagine that!

"Thought experiment"
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"The common goal of a thought experiment is to explore the potential consequences of the principle in question."

Why are you so steadfast in trying to put some arbitrary limits on thought experiment, which by all accounts has no limits?

You are fundamentally saying that we must limit our thoughts, which as an intellectual policy I find abhorrent.
 
No. It is not. You seem to lack a basic understanding of actual logic.

You seem to lack a basic understanding of actual rebuttal.

In what way was your rather idiotic version of using imagination, the same as the process of Thought Experiment as used and described ny philosophers?

Please do described the process of Thought Experimentation.

1) Think about a question.

2) Think about an answer.
 
That may be case but I seem to have missed an actual Thought Experiment you have presented.

Would you be so kind as to actual present it?

Let me be clear about this--you want me to restate my thought experiment that you described as a "rather idiotic version of using my imagination" because you never read it.

Guess how many synonyms for "pathetic" are in the thesaurus.
 
You seem to lack a basic understanding of actual rebuttal.
No. I understand it very well. A rebuttal actual rebutes something. Your attempt was a false equivcation.
Basically YOUR "imagination as an experiment" argument is not the same as a Thought Experiment.

1) Think about a question.

2) Think about an answer.
No. Try again.
 
Let me be clear about this--you want me to restate my thought experiment that you described as a "rather idiotic version of using my imagination" because you never read it.
Yes because I don't see any.
I do see claims by fiat and a very convoluted and illogical arguments. You know, the "idiotic versions based on your imagination".
Guess how many synonyms for "pathetic" are in the thesaurus.
Yes, I'm very "pathetic". Since your definitions are not the standards used by the vast majority of people, I'll take that as a compliment.

Please do restate your "thought experiment."(as defined and used by philosphers and not your own made up based one)

Thank you.
 
You are fundamentally saying that we must limit our thoughts, which as an intellectual policy I find abhorrent.
Nope but to be useful they are limited to silly things reality, knowledge, logic and evidence.

Otherwise the way you are using it is commonly called "making crap up".
 
No. I understand it very well. A rebuttal actual rebutes something. Your attempt was a false equivcation.
Basically YOUR "imagination as an experiment" argument is not the same as a Thought Experiment.


No. Try again.


Gainsaying is not a valid rebuttal either.
 
Yes because I don't see any.
I do see claims by fiat and a very convoluted and illogical arguments. You know, the "idiotic versions based on your imagination".

Yes, I'm very "pathetic". Since your definitions are not the standards used by the vast majority of people, I'll take that as a compliment.

Please do restate your "thought experiment."(as defined and used by philosphers and not your own made up based one)

Thank you.

"Restate what you have stated" is not a valid rebuttal either.
 
Gainsaying is not a valid rebuttal either.

"Restate what you have stated" is not a valid rebuttal either.

Appeal to Ridicule is not a valid rebuttal either.
I'm sorry.

Your use of the word "rebuttal" does not coincide with how the rest of humanity uses it. Could you please provide your own made up definition of rebuttal because hand waving is not commonly considered a rebuttal but is commonly referred to by the kids as "epic fail".

I am still eagerly awaiting for:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.

All I see is a complete and utter failure and pretty useless to boot. Try again.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry.

Very good, you went to the thesaurus as I suggested and found that "sorry" is a synonym for "pathetic".

Now see if you can find the definition for "set up line" or "straight line".

Your use of the word "rebuttal" does not coincide with how the rest of humanity uses it. Could you please provide your own made up definition of rebuttal because hand waving is not commonly considered a rebuttal but is commonly referred to by the kids as "epic fail".

I am still eagerly awaiting for:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.

All I see is a complete and utter failure and pretty useless to boot. Try again.

Someone, maybe a member of humanity, once said, "A rebuttal actual rebutes something."

Some of your recent attempts to rebut what I said:

Gainsaying: "No. It is not."
Restate: "Please do restate your "thought experiment."
Appeal to Ridicule: "commonly called "making crap up" "

Humanity commonly considers these to be invalid types of rebuttal.

You can eagerly await all you want, but if you were incapable of reading the posts that answered those questions before why would this time be any different?
 
Very good, you went to the thesaurus as I suggested and found that "sorry" is a synonym for "pathetic".

Now see if you can find the definition for "set up line" or "straight line".



Someone, maybe a member of humanity, once said, "A rebuttal actual rebutes something."

Some of your recent attempts to rebut what I said:

Gainsaying: "No. It is not."
Restate: "Please do restate your "thought experiment."
Appeal to Ridicule: "commonly called "making crap up" "

Humanity commonly considers these to be invalid types of rebuttal.

You can eagerly await all you want, but if you were incapable of reading the posts that answered those questions before why would this time be any different?
I'm sorry.
I still do not see any actual rebuttals.
Are you sure you speak english or understand the actual definition of "rebuttal"?
I understand if you do not understand the word but you really need to provide your own definitions to words that you are using in ways no one else uses otherwise people may consider your arguments to be dishonest attempts at obfuscation the fact that you don't have an actual rational or intelligent point.

On yes, I still don't see any answers.
I am still eagerly awaiting for:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.

Why have you continually failed to provide these simple answers?
Why are you using red herring and Argumentum ad whining child(ie the "I'm being persecuted" excuse) to run way from providing such simple answers?

I eagerly await your honest answers to these simple questions that you should be able to easily answer.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry.
I still do not see any actual rebuttals.
Are you sure you speak english or understand the actual definition of "rebuttal"?
I understand if you do not understand the word but you really need to provide your own definitions to words that you are using in ways no one else uses otherwise people may consider your arguments to be dishonest attempts at obfuscation the fact that you don't have an actual rational or intelligent point.

On yes, I still don't see any answers.
I am still eagerly awaiting for:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.

Why have you continually failed to provide these simple answers?
Why are you using red herring and Argumentum ad whining child(ie the "I'm being persecuted" excuse) to run way from providing such simple answers?

I eagerly await your honest answers to these simple questions that you should be able to easily answer.

Why don't you go back a few pages, start reading, and then await that way.
Much easier and you'll get just what you want, as I have repeatedly said.

And talk about a whining child, you've got me covering my ears.

"Don't say I don't have rebuttals, where's your rebuttals?"

Keep it down to a low roar, Pax.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom