Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nonsense. Do you really think that if you grant that water has the necessary properties to sustain fish, you would be forced to say that water has any and all properties? So, because water can sustain fish, that means it must also have the necessary properties to power a diesel engine or build a computer chip out of. You really are not thinking this through, are you Bill?

But anyway, you are ignoring the central argument here, so lets get back to the point. A property of your environment is atemporality, but you also claim that your environment is nothing and therefore has no properties. You are contradicting yourself.

I didn't say any and all, I said infinite.
Which you just verified by saying that the lack of something (time) constitutes a property.
 
Bill Thompson 75 said:
Nonsense. Do you really think that if you grant that water has the necessary properties to sustain fish, you would be forced to say that water has any and all properties? So, because water can sustain fish, that means it must also have the necessary properties to power a diesel engine or build a computer chip out of. You really are not thinking this through, are you Bill?

But anyway, you are ignoring the central argument here, so lets get back to the point. A property of your environment is atemporality, but you also claim that your environment is nothing and therefore has no properties. You are contradicting yourself.

I didn't say any and all, I said infinite.
Which you just verified by saying that the lack of something (time) constitutes a property.

You ignored the argument again. I'm shocked.:rolleyes:
 
bluskool said:
But anyway, you are ignoring the central argument here, so lets get back to the point. A property of your environment is atemporality, but you also claim that your environment is nothing and therefore has no properties. You are contradicting yourself.

You ignored the argument again. I'm shocked.:rolleyes:

Apparently you don't get the obvious. The lack of a characteristic is not equivalent to having a property.

What are the properties of a basketball? It is round, approximately 29.5" in circumference, weighs 22 oz., it bounces, it does not have fish swimming in it, it is not filled with unicorn farts, it is not hotter than Hades, it is not inside your computer... and so on to infinity.

I said that the non-temporal, non-spatial environment had no properties, based upon a common usage of that term. I'll give you that it has properties based on your convoluted definition.
The non-temporal, non-spatial environment has the property of not having the properties of time and space.
How's that?
 
Apparently you don't get the obvious. The lack of a characteristic is not equivalent to having a property.

What are the properties of a basketball? It is round, approximately 29.5" in circumference, weighs 22 oz., it bounces, it does not have fish swimming in it, it is not filled with unicorn farts, it is not hotter than Hades, it is not inside your computer... and so on to infinity.

I said that the non-temporal, non-spatial environment had no properties, based upon a common usage of that term. I'll give you that it has properties based on your convoluted definition.
The non-temporal, non-spatial environment has the property of not having the properties of time and space.
How's that?

So the one and only property of this atemporal non-spatial nothingness is that it creates Universes? It has no time, space, energy or matter, and yet it is the source of all time, space, energy and matter in our universe... is that right?

So... is it bigger than a breadbox?
 
So the one and only property of this atemporal non-spatial nothingness is that it creates Universes? It has no time, space, energy or matter, and yet it is the source of all time, space, energy and matter in our universe... is that right?

A property is fundamentally a limiting feature of a thing, in that it generally restricts an object to a specific class of objects and the more properties that can be assigned to an object the smaller its class is.
The environment has no properties and no restrictions on what occurs. It is the source of random events, one of which may be a universe that generates a space-time continuum within itself.

So... is it bigger than a breadbox?
It is non-spatial.
 
Last edited:
A property is fundamentally a limiting feature of a thing, in that it generally restricts an object to a specific class of objects and the more properties that can be assigned to an object the smaller its class is.
The environment has no properties and no restrictions on what occurs. It is the source of random events, one of which may be a universe that generates a space-time continuum within itself.


It is non-spatial.

So as long as we don't try to narrow it down at all by defining it or describing any properties it might have, we can imagine it doing anything, everything and nothing?

Could it be said that it doesn't even exist?- Existence being a property and all...
 
So as long as we don't try to narrow it down at all by defining it or describing any properties it might have, we can imagine it doing anything, everything and nothing?

We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily pay attention.

Could it be said that it doesn't even exist?- Existence being a property and all...

It doesn't have the property of non-existence, nor the property of being false, nor the property of being imaginary, and therefore, it really, truly exists.
 
It doesn't have the property of non-existence, nor the property of being false, nor the property of being imaginary, and therefore, it really, truly exists.

It doesn't have the property of existence, nor the property of being true, nor the property of being real and therefore it really, truly doesn't exist.

This is fun. :)
 
It doesn't have the property of existence, nor the property of being true, nor the property of being real and therefore it really, truly doesn't exist.

This is fun. :)

But not very original. :(

(And your conclusion should have been "fictitiously, falsely doesn't exist")
 
Bill, imagine a chair. Would you say that it is acceptable for the chair to lack both of these properties?

A. the property of being painted green.
B. the property of not being painted green.
 
We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily pay attention.



It doesn't have the property of non-existence, nor the property of being false, nor the property of being imaginary, and therefore, it really, truly exists.

This is starting to sound a bit like that ontological argument for God. The one that says that God is defined as being perfect and that to be truly perfect an object must exist, therefore God exists...

Please tell me you aren't arguing that.

We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily exist.
 
This is starting to sound a bit like that ontological argument for God. The one that says that God is defined as being perfect and that to be truly perfect an object must exist, therefore God exists...

Please tell me you aren't arguing that.

We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily exist.

Yeah, but this thing is special, you see!
 
This is starting to sound a bit like that ontological argument for God. The one that says that God is defined as being perfect and that to be truly perfect an object must exist, therefore God exists...

Please tell me you aren't arguing that.

We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily exist.

I've told him the exact same thing. Here we are, pages later...
 
This is starting to sound a bit like that ontological argument for God. The one that says that God is defined as being perfect and that to be truly perfect an object must exist, therefore God exists...

Please tell me you aren't arguing that.

Me: "I said that the non-temporal, non-spatial environment had no properties"

You: "So the one and only property of this atemporal non-spatial nothingness is that it creates Universes?"

Me: "The environment has no properties and no restrictions on what occurs."

You: "So as long as we don't try to narrow it down at all by defining it or describing any properties it might have, we can imagine it doing anything, everything and nothing?"

You: "Existence being a property and all.."

I thought it was pretty clear that that you were making the God argument, the one about existence as a property.

We can imagine anything, but it won't necessarily exist.

You weren't so confused that you thought this was anything more than speculation, were you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom