Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
I must admit I am. I'm confused because I try to understand what you're babbling about and you keep utterly failing at bringing some sense into it.

That's a good comeback. It must be, it's such a common one when someone tries to disguise their confusion.
 
Don't flatter yourself. How about providing some use of an environment which has no properties at all instead?

No. That's why I said: "your choice". Duh.

ETA: Ah, edited... "We can go on and on" does not constitute going on and on. Only going on.
 
Last edited:
Bill, can you describe this hypothetical environment in positive terms? That is, tell me what it is, not what it isn't.
 
...
You weren't so confused that you thought this was anything more than speculation, were you?

Speculation about what? Just what is it that you are speculating about?

It has no time, no space, no physical laws, no actual existence at all and you seem to be saying that it created our universe...

So yes, I am confused.
 
Speculation about what? Just what is it that you are speculating about?

It has no time, no space, no physical laws, no actual existence at all and you seem to be saying that it created our universe...

So yes, I am confused.

Is pretending that you just joined a discussion, misrepresenting whatever might have been said, and then using a self-denigrating confession to justify your comments supposed to be some kind of debate technique?
 
Is pretending that you just joined a discussion, misrepresenting whatever might have been said, and then using a self-denigrating confession to justify your comments supposed to be some kind of debate technique?

I'm not pretending anything Bill. If you have answered these questions earlier in the conversation I must have missed it. I am also not intentionally misrepresenting anything, I am trying to get you to explain what you are talking about. I'm not even trying to debate the validity or otherwise of your position, because I don't know what your position is! (apart from a nonexistent atemporal environment that makes universes)

Earlier I made a flippant post about square circles and four-sided triangles in an attempt to present how your speculation looked to me (ie: self contradicting), since then I have seen nothing that has changed my mind. In fact it appears that you are just being a troll.

If you aren't just being a troll Bill, how about you try to explain what you mean? Of course I can't promise I'll understand, but an attempt might be nice.
 
explain what you mean

A claim was made that nothing preceded our universe, that our universe did not begin to exist, and that our universe needed no cause or explanation.
I presented a counter argument in the form of a scenario:

Imagine an environment without our universe (or without any universe).
Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.
It is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.
It has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.
A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might randomly occur in this environment which results in the what we call a Big Bang.

Externally this Big Bang object is not measurable since there is no time or space external to it.
Internally it has time, space, matter and energy and expands according to modern cosmology.

We then have a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

It is confusing to talk about a non-temporal, non-spatial environment when our language presupposes such, and that is why it is critical to consider the context of the descriptions of this hypothetical environment.
We must use the words we have to describe it, keeping in mind that we cannot talk about location, size, shape, dimension, age, duration, before, after, etc.

I believe it is a logically consistent concept, and a simple concept compared to other theories of physics and cosmology.

It is clearly a non-testable, unfalsifiable, theoretical construct presented as a thought experiment.
To me that does not mean that it has no value or is not worth exploring, but rather it can be explored unrestricted by anything except the limits of the imagination.
( I am a big fan of Asimov, Bradbury, Clarke, etc. and Gardner, Hofstadter, JH Conway, etc.)
 
A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might randomly occur in this environment which results in the what we call a Big Bang.

This is the part where you contradict yourself.

If this thing has the capability of performing or causing actions, then it is something, not nothing. Even if it cannot be described in physical terms, there's still something there.

I covered all of this in another post a long time ago.
 
A claim was made that nothing preceded our universe, that our universe did not begin to exist, and that our universe needed no cause or explanation.
I presented a counter argument in the form of a scenario:

Imagine an environment without our universe (or without any universe).
Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.
It is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.
It has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.
A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might randomly occur in this environment which results in the what we call a Big Bang.

Externally this Big Bang object is not measurable since there is no time or space external to it.
Internally it has time, space, matter and energy and expands according to modern cosmology.

We then have a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

It is confusing to talk about a non-temporal, non-spatial environment when our language presupposes such, and that is why it is critical to consider the context of the descriptions of this hypothetical environment.
We must use the words we have to describe it, keeping in mind that we cannot talk about location, size, shape, dimension, age, duration, before, after, etc.

I believe it is a logically consistent concept, and a simple concept compared to other theories of physics and cosmology.

It is clearly a non-testable, unfalsifiable, theoretical construct presented as a thought experiment.
To me that does not mean that it has no value or is not worth exploring, but rather it can be explored unrestricted by anything except the limits of the imagination.
( I am a big fan of Asimov, Bradbury, Clarke, etc. and Gardner, Hofstadter, JH Conway, etc.)

Thank you. It's not very satisfying though is it? You are just saying that nothing exploded into everything.

I prefer to imagine that the big bang is an example of an effect preceding a cause. The event that triggered the Big Bang hasn't happened yet and we are here as a result of probabilities. A collapsing wave front of quantum probabilities moving towards a point where a singularity necessarily requires an entire universe of events and experiences to have happened first.

Did I mention quantums? I'm pretty sure quantums are involved...

Can you tell that it is 4 am here and I have read too much Stephen Baxter?

Time for bed I think.
 
This is the part where you contradict yourself.

If this thing has the capability of performing or causing actions, then it is something, not nothing. Even if it cannot be described in physical terms, there's still something there.

I covered all of this in another post a long time ago.

There is nothing that can contradict anything else.

It has no capabilities, it doesn't perform or cause anything. It has no force, no substance, no limitations, no restrictions, no conditions, no cause and effect.

To say that a physical thing cannot come from nothing you would have to present a physical barrier for it. There is no physical barrier.

I do not see any logical barrier either because you would have to keep the logical separate from anything physical.

Our universe could be something-from-absolutely-nothing.
 
<snip some daydreaming>

We then have a possible explanation for our universe without any supernatural dependencies.

<snip some more>

It is clearly a non-testable, unfalsifiable, theoretical construct presented as a thought experiment.

You just substituted one woo (a god) with another: you admit it to be untestable and unfalsifiable, thus of no value whatsoever to science.

Also, don't flatter yourself calling it a thought experiment anymore: you just admitted it being non-testable and non-falsifiable. What kind of experiment is one of those?

To me that does not mean that it has no value or is not worth exploring, but rather it can be explored unrestricted by anything except the limits of the imagination.

It has the same value as exploring the idea that an untestable, unfalsifiable god created the world in 6 days some 6000 years ago. Thats is, none.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom