Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bill Thompson 75 said:
This environment is "nothingness" and it has properties and events?

The non-temporal non-spatial environment has no properties. A random event/object can obtain existence in the environment, as our space-time universe did.

I already tried to get Bill to see this point. He doesn't understand what nothing means. He also doesn't understand that an "event happening" or an "object existing" in this environment would be properties of the environment.
 
True ... because you say so?

If the existence of a universe is finite, then in some other state it did not exist. It didn't exist, then it existed...it began. So I say.

So, let me get this straight.

In the first case you are saying

1. a IMPLIES NOT b​

and in the second

2. a AND b​

And you are telling me that 1 and 2 are consistent?

I am not sure what a and b refer to here.

a - finite
b - exists

1. a implies b
2. a and b
No inconsistency.
 
I already tried to get Bill to see this point. He doesn't understand what nothing means. He also doesn't understand that an "event happening" or an "object existing" in this environment would be properties of the environment.

And a fish is a property of water?
And a barking dog is a property of time?
And the sun is a property of space?


("He doesn't understand what nothing means." I don't know that I understand the meaning of everything, but thank you for the unintended compliment.)
 
Last edited:
And a fish is a property of water?
And a barking dog is a property of time?
And the sun is a property of space?

The ability to sustain fish is a property of water. The second question makes no sense. A property of the universe is the ability to contain stars. And the occurrence of straw men is a property of most of your arguments.

("He doesn't understand what nothing means." I don't know that I understand the meaning of everything, but thank you for the unintended compliment.)

Wow Bill, even your joke is flawed. If I really meant that you don't understand the meaning of no things, the principle of contradiction would say that you do understand the meaning of some things, not all things. Of course, the principle of contradiction doesn't even apply to empty categories, so even if you modified the statement you would still be wrong.
 
The ability to sustain fish is a property of water. The second question makes no sense. A property of the universe is the ability to contain stars. And the occurrence of straw men is a property of most of your arguments.

A property of a forum is to post foolish claims of strawman arguments.

A property of water is to support life within an artificial environment, such as a submarine.
A property of water is to support any living organism that lives in water, or to float anything that floats, or to prevent adjacent volumes of water from flowing away, or to prevent the atmosphere from sinking to the ocean floor...

Could you provide your list of the properties of water?

If I count all the properties of water, let's see, that comes to ... infinity.

You make the concept of "property" vacuous.

Wow Bill, even your joke is flawed. If I really meant that you don't understand the meaning of no things, the principle of contradiction would say that you do understand the meaning of some things, not all things. Of course, the principle of contradiction doesn't even apply to empty categories, so even if you modified the statement you would still be wrong.

Once I met someone who lived in this universe. He bumped his head and his sense of humor fell out. He couldn't laugh at anything either.
 
You make the concept of "property" vacuous.

Do you realize that the analysis of properties is basically the same as the analysis of categories? Water has the property of "sustains human life," so we could also say that water is in the categories of "items necessary to sustain human life."

Shall include categories in the category of vacuous concepts?
Does the concept of properties have the property of being vacuous?
 
Do you realize that the analysis of properties is basically the same as the analysis of categories? Water has the property of "sustains human life," so we could also say that water is in the categories of "items necessary to sustain human life."

Shall include categories in the category of vacuous concepts?
Does the concept of properties have the property of being vacuous?

Yes, according to Bluskool.
 
And how do you get the idea that an entity having an infinite quantity of properties (which I certainly do not grant), makes "properties" meaningless?
 
What if it was a square circle inside a married bachelor's four sided triangular concrete tent in a non-existent atemporal camping ground?
 
On the one hand you want to tell me that when I say "sequence" I really mean "time".

Then when I ask if you are defining time as sequence you say no.

That is trying to have it both ways. You have to make up your mind.

There is a difference between defining A as B and A being a kind of B.

Nice evasion.

I am perfectly happy for you to give me a theoretical or an actual example.

I get your point, but I find it utterly useless to fantasize about an environment where there is one and only one "thing".

It does not make it invalid either.

I don't know any other way of speculating about the possibility of change without time, other than to speculate about a theoretical environment which has one and not the other.

What makes an entirely theoretical environment valid or otherwise? It is not, as far as I can tell, self-contradictory. I don't know of anything that would rule out the possibility of it.

It's not up to me to prove its non-validity, but up to you to do so otherwise. Would such an environment even be observable/falsifiable?

As I said before I have defined time as the quantification of the change in one thing with reference to the change in another.

I think that every time we refer to time, that is what we are doing.

I think so too.

So now we are substituting emoticons for reasoning?

:rolleyes: right back atcha.

What are we substituting for a sense of humor? :boggled:
 
A property of a forum is to post foolish claims of strawman arguments.

A property of water is to support life within an artificial environment, such as a submarine.
A property of water is to support any living organism that lives in water, or to float anything that floats, or to prevent adjacent volumes of water from flowing away, or to prevent the atmosphere from sinking to the ocean floor...

Could you provide your list of the properties of water?

If I count all the properties of water, let's see, that comes to ... infinity.

You make the concept of "property" vacuous.

Nonsense. Do you really think that if you grant that water has the necessary properties to sustain fish, you would be forced to say that water has any and all properties? So, because water can sustain fish, that means it must also have the necessary properties to power a diesel engine or build a computer chip out of. You really are not thinking this through, are you Bill?

But anyway, you are ignoring the central argument here, so lets get back to the point. A property of your environment is atemporality, but you also claim that your environment is nothing and therefore has no properties. You are contradicting yourself.
 
I am not sure what a and b refer to here.

a - finite
b - exists

1. a implies b
2. a and b
No inconsistency.
You forgot your own claim - let me refresh your memory:
Bill Thompson 75 said:
This is true:
1) If a universe is finite, then it begins to exist.

This is not a contradiction:
2) X is finite and X necessarily exists.

1) and 2) are not contradictory either
So, you said "necessarily exists", not just "exists".

And you will no doubt agree that if something begins to exist then it does not have necessary existence.

So :

a = X is finite
b = X exists necessarily

So your 1) is equivalent to:

a IMPLIES NOT b

and you 2) is equivalent to:

a AND b
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom