Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Robin, as for your questions in regards to the length of time between S0 and S1, I would say it really depends on how strict you are with your states. If you are defining it in the strictest sense (which is how I prefer to do it), that any change whatsoever is a change between one situation and the next, then the length of time for any one situation is nonsense. That would be like asking what is the distance of a single point. Points have no distance, but the space between two of them does. It requires a comparison between situations. And thus, if we are still speaking on the strictest of terms, the distance between S0 -> S1, and S1 -> S2, is necessarily identical.
If the length of time of S0 and S1 is nonsense, why is the length of time of the gap between S0 and S1 not nonsense?

Or the "distance" between them, for that matter? Is there something that separates successive states in a change?
 
Last edited:
So in other words saying that the environment has "sequence" is not a fancy way of saying it has time, as you earlier claimed? You can't have it both ways.

Sequence is change as well. I don't want it both ways.

Incidentally, can you give an example of using time to measure change where you are not measuring one change with reference to the change in something else?

Example? You mean like your pure theoretical ones where you just say that it's that way and that's it? Sure... :rolleyes:

Conclusion about what?

Someone said that change implies time and I gave a description of a theoretical environment that had change and not time.

Yes, you posited one. That doesn't make it valid.

As I have said all along, it really depends upon how you define time.

Yes, that's true. How do you?

No, a "given" is not an assumption. I am not assuming anything because I am not claiming that this environment actually exists.

Ah, ok. My bad.

If I say "X changes" I mean that X changes.

I don't mean that X doesn't change.

:rolleyes:
 
Sequence is change as well. I don't want it both ways.
On the one hand you want to tell me that when I say "sequence" I really mean "time".

Then when I ask if you are defining time as sequence you say no.

That is trying to have it both ways. You have to make up your mind.
Example? You mean like your pure theoretical ones where you just say that it's that way and that's it? Sure... :rolleyes:
Nice evasion.

I am perfectly happy for you to give me a theoretical or an actual example.
Yes, you posited one. That doesn't make it valid.
It does not make it invalid either.

I don't know any other way of speculating about the possibility of change without time, other than to speculate about a theoretical environment which has one and not the other.

What makes an entirely theoretical environment valid or otherwise? It is not, as far as I can tell, self-contradictory. I don't know of anything that would rule out the possibility of it.
Yes, that's true. How do you?
As I said before I have defined time as the quantification of the change in one thing with reference to the change in another.

I think that every time we refer to time, that is what we are doing.
So now we are substituting emoticons for reasoning?

:rolleyes: right back atcha.
 
Last edited:
If the length of time of S0 and S1 is nonsense, why is the length of time of the gap between S0 and S1 not nonsense?

Or the "distance" between them, for that matter? Is there something that separates successive states in a change?

Picture a grid with two points on it, A and B. A is located at 0,0. B is located at 0,5.

If I ask, What is the distance of point A?, you cannot answer me. That question makes no sense. Same if I ask for B.

If I ask, What is the distance of the span between points A and B?, that is a question you can answer.

A point, or a single moment, has no "distance" in and of itself. The comparison of it and another of its type results in a difference (if there were no difference, we would be left with identity and thus no comparison). This gives us something to analyze, and we call it time.

Just to make sure I'm absolutely clear, if it seems like the combination of two nonsense concepts cannot result in anything that we can logically analyze, your error in reasoning would be something akin to the fallacy of composition.
 
So you think there is a contradiction in "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?

This is true:
1) If a universe is finite, then it begins to exist.

This is not a contradiction:
2) X is finite and X necessarily exists.

1) and 2) are not contradictory either.

This environment is "nothingness" and it has properties and events?

The non-temporal non-spatial environment has no properties. A random event/object can obtain existence in the environment, as our space-time universe did.
 
So this environment has change, sequential change and the change in one object can be quantified in terms of the change in another.

It seems to exemplify all the properties that I would associate with time.

Yes, but those properties do not exclusively belong to time.
 
Picture a grid with two points on it, A and B. A is located at 0,0. B is located at 0,5.

If I ask, What is the distance of point A?, you cannot answer me. That question makes no sense. Same if I ask for B.

If I ask, What is the distance of the span between points A and B?, that is a question you can answer.
But we are not talking about two points on a grid. So what is the relevance?
A point, or a single moment, has no "distance" in and of itself. The comparison of it and another of its type results in a difference (if there were no difference, we would be left with identity and thus no comparison). This gives us something to analyze, and we call it time.
So you are defining "time" as the difference between a state and a successive state?

But if someone says "the litmus paper turns from blue to white" then the difference between blue and white is not the time the change took.

In order to know the time the change took we have to make reference to the change in something else.
Just to make sure I'm absolutely clear, if it seems like the combination of two nonsense concepts cannot result in anything that we can logically analyze, your error in reasoning would be something akin to the fallacy of composition.
Just to make it clear, I never even remotely suggested that the combination of two nonsense concepts results in something we can logically analyse. Not even remotely.

So that would make your reasoning akin to the Fallacy of the Straw Man, wouldn't it?
 
IATS, I would be interested to read your answers to these:
Robin said:
Incidentally, how are you defining "time"?

...

Can you give an example of the usage of "time" where we are not comparing the change in one thing with the change in another?
 
This is true:
1) If a universe is finite, then it begins to exist.
True ... because you say so?
This is not a contradiction:
2) X is finite and X necessarily exists.

1) and 2) are not contradictory either.
So, let me get this straight.

In the first case you are saying

1. a IMPLIES NOT b​

and in the second

2. a AND b​

And you are telling me that 1 and 2 are consistent?
 
Last edited:
Proposition 1: It is raining outside my bedroom window.
Proposition 2: It is not raining outside my bedroom window.

I can make these statements on different days, and sometimes p1 will be true, other times, p2 will be true. But they're converse statements. They can't both be right.

What we have here is a variance of truth value within a distinct proposition. The framework to rectify this perceived contradiction is time. Time is a property of this universe. That is to say, this universe is a changing one.

A better way to analyze this change is to have a firm grasp on what a situation is. A situations is best thought of as a single infinitesimal moment, a snapshot of a given state of the universe. Try to imagine every single statement of fact in regards to the room you're in right now. It all can be broken down into dichotomous states. Your computer is on, not off. You're either sitting down, or you're not. There are seven pens at your desk, or not. We can even reduce this to the finest of details. The semi-colon key of your keyboard is composed of 783,493,291,494 atoms, or it is not. We can extrapolate this outward even further. This analysis need not be relegated to the room you're in now. It applies to the entirety of the universe. For any given proposition, it either is the case or it is not, even if nobody's bothered to verify it, or even think about it. The combination of every single one of these truth values all throughout the universe, this state of affairs, composes one single situation.

But these truth values don't always remain the same. Any change in any truth value whatsoever, no matter how diminutive, will constitute a new moment. After all, if there was no change, the situations would be identical, not separate. This is how we perceive time. We see things change.

So we live through many, many situations. That's what it means to live in a universe with time - there's more than one moment. An atemporal universe would have only one single moment. That is to say, the composition of truth values in such a world will never be any different, and they never have been. Everything that is true in such a universe is true simultaneously. After all, "simultaneously" means concurrent within the same moment. Given that there is only one, this is a necessity.

Therefore, to me, it is nonsense to say there there is change in a universe with no time. The only way I can see to rectify such a statement is to water down the definition of change to something akin to "difference." To me, stating that one person owns a blue car, and another owns a red car, does not denote difference between two distinct things, not one. I can't fathom change without a variance of truth values for a single distinct idea, and thus the necessity of time to reconcile that perceived contradiction.

All I can do is provide you with a logical framework that allows us to make the most sense of the world we live in. This is a pretty damn good one. It allows us to logically analyze time, be it the span of one moment to another, or statements about the future or past. If anyone has any questions, clarifications, comments, or would even like to present a completely different alternative, I'd love to hear it.

Thank you for your time.
 
Time is a property of this universe. That is to say, this universe is a changing one.

There is no evidence to support this. It might be that time is merely a product of the human mind and doesn't exist outside of it.

No one can explain why an event doesn't occur before the event that caused it. There is no logical, or mathematical, reason why time seems to only flow in one direction. Logically and mathematically we know time can stop and that same logic and math shows that there is no reason it can't run backwards, so why doesn't it seem to?

Another problem is that time cannot be defined without referring to motion (change) and motion cannot be defined without referring to time. In essence they are two parts of the same thing and no one knows what that thing is or if they are just our perception of some other, third, thing.

The basic problem is that no one knows what time is or if it even exists outside of our minds. It is a very fascinating subject but I don't think anyone is expecting to find a god, or lack there of, when, or if, it is all sorted out.
 
My Brain Hurts.
I wish you people would stop making me try to visualise atemporal environments that contain changing dimensionless points in nothingness. It's doing my head in.

Can't we go back to the good old days of destroying strawman arguments against evolution?
 
No one can explain why an event doesn't occur before the event that caused it. There is no logical, or mathematical, reason why time seems to only flow in one direction. Logically and mathematically we know time can stop and that same logic and math shows that there is no reason it can't run backwards, so why doesn't it seem to?

I would simply state that time itself does not change, our perception of it does. Even if we go into brain-in-a-jar solipsism, this still holds true. You are experiencing things in a specific way right now. Have you always been experiencing things in this particular way? Obviously not. There is a disparity there, and thus my previous analysis still works, even if it is nothing more than your perception.

And I am aware of the circular nature of defining time. Circularity is not always a problem, though. All definitions are, really. We describe things by relating them to other things. And we do the same with those things. On and on it goes.
 
Break an egg for breakfast, now unbreak that egg. Time seems to run one way, doesn't it.

Full the universe with broken eggs, and wait till just one unbreaks, I'll wait. :rolleyes:

Paul

:) :) :)
 
You want me to give an example???

I think you have misunderstood what I was saying. I didn't claim this environment actually existed. Someone said that change implied time and I described a theoretical environment in which there was change, but no time.

I am asking for a conceptual example, not an actual one.

Also, do you have a response to my objection to the idea of one thing changing?

...the problem I have with what you said above is with the concept of one object changing. The concept of one object is tricky to begin with. A tomato wouldn't cut it because a tomato is made up of many individual objects interacting with each other. The one object must be an elementary particle (or else something completely unknown to us). So, let's say the object is a single elementary particle. Exactly what change could a single particle in isolation go through since there are no other particles for it to interact with?
 
I would simply state that time itself does not change, our perception of it does. Even if we go into brain-in-a-jar solipsism, this still holds true. You are experiencing things in a specific way right now. Have you always been experiencing things in this particular way? Obviously not. There is a disparity there, and thus my previous analysis still works, even if it is nothing more than your perception.

But it isn't just our perception that changes, the thing we call time changes depending on conditions and that is confirmed regardless of our own perception.

And I am aware of the circular nature of defining time. Circularity is not always a problem, though. All definitions are, really. We describe things by relating them to other things. And we do the same with those things. On and on it goes.

Agreed. That is one of the major problems in science right now. Things have become so strange we have nothing to relate them to in order to comprehend them.

In the case of "time" though, the definition is definitely one of the major issues. It is easy to say we understand what time is, and most people think they have a pretty good idea, but what they mean by time is simply a perception they share with other human beings. It doesn't seem to exist that way in nature.

Everything we know about time has been decided arbitrarily by humans, a few humans. We have a notion of what a second, a minute an hour are but they are all arbitrary and they could be anything else and the universe would still work the same.

Hours, minutes and seconds are based on the speed of the rotation of the earth because people were trying to solve a particular problem when those terms were first decided on. They were trying to make it easy to locate the position of ships on the open ocean. Very soon we applied this to all aspects of our lives and it pretty much dominates them now which is why we have a certain perception of what time is but that perception doesn't hold up when we look at it closely.

(Not all cultures see time the same. Most cultures see the future as looking forward but a few see the future as looking backward. To them it is their past that is layed out before them, their future is behind them because it is somethign they can't see easily. When you ask them about the future, they actually turn around to look at it.)

And none of this has anything to do with what time is. Just because we have this idea ingrained in our culture and brain doesn't mean it holds true outside of our little sphere.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom