Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Robin, I was with you for the majority of your discussion of time, but I'm going to have to start disagreeing with you. I'll get into more detail later, but as for now, let me ask you this:

We use the word "week" to describe the amount of time it takes the earth to move around the sun a given distance. How is it any less valid to define "week" as the time it took the tomato in your example to double in size?
No less valid. I am not sure how that contradicts what I said.

Let's go back to my example - if I define "a week" as the time it took for the transition S0 --> S1 then did it take longer or shorter than a week for the transition S1 --> S2?
 
.Could you rephrase to clarify these two questions?
The second is a rephrasal of the first. I am not sure how I can make the second question clearer, it seems perfectly clear to me.

You already introduced the concept of something that can and cannot exist, so you should not have any problem with the concept of something that cannot not exist.

And you should not have any problem with the concept of something that is finite.

So I am simply asking if there is a contradiction is saying "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?
No, not if the source is an environment of nothingness.
I am not sure what you mean by that.

Are you saying that an "environment of nothingness" can be a source of something?

Surely and "environment of nothingness" is a contradiction in terms.
 
The second is a rephrasal of the first. I am not sure how I can make the second question clearer, it seems perfectly clear to me.

You already introduced the concept of something that can and cannot exist, so you should not have any problem with the concept of something that cannot not exist.

And you should not have any problem with the concept of something that is finite.

So I am simply asking if there is a contradiction is saying "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?

No.
I am not sure what you mean by that.

Are you saying that an "environment of nothingness" can be a source of something?

Surely and "environment of nothingness" is a contradiction in terms.

This could simply be the non-temporal non-spatial environment we have been discussing.
 
Perhaps, but in order to show the assumption wrong, you only need to explain how an object can exist without a place to exist in.
I don't need to show that your assumption is wrong.

The fact that it is an assumption means that it is not necessarily correct.

The concept of something existing, but not existing at any place does not involve any contradiction.

Therefore we cannot rule it out a priori.

And we certainly cannot rule it out on the basis that you assume that it is impossible.
For example:

That at some point, a much more drastic revolution or discontinuity in our system of beliefs will be required. And that this revolution will likely change the way we think about space and time, maybe even eliminate them completely as a basis for our description of reality—that is, leave us regarding them rather as emergent approximate concepts that are useful under certain circumstances.

David Gross in an interview with PBS​
 
Any change purported in an atemporal environment implies overlapping states, thus a steady condition of dual-statedness and thus no change! Elsewise there is a cause-effect or before-after and voilá, time.
 
Bill and Robin, if change is possible without time, please tell me which definition of the word "change" you are using.
As above, I am defining change as a sequence of states.

Incidentally, how are you defining "time"?
Furthermore, please use the word "change" in a sentence that does not reference time.
"X changes"

Can you give an example of the usage of "time" where we are not comparing the change in one thing with the change in another?

Note that you previously used the phrase "the time it took the tomato in your example to double in size" so you have unconsciously separated the concepts:

1. The tomato doubling in size
2. The time it took for the tomato to double in size.
 
Last edited:
Any change purported in an atemporal environment implies overlapping states, thus a steady condition of dual-statedness and thus no change! Elsewise there is a cause-effect or before-after and voilá, time.
No, that would only be the case if you defined time as change. The environment I described had change and non-overlapping states.

I posed the question about an environment in which there was only one thing and that one thing changed from S0 --> S1 and S1 --> S2.

Did the first transition take longer or shorter than the second? Was it in state S0 longer than it was in state S1? What would be the basis for deciding the answers to those questions?
 
Last edited:
No, that would only be the case if you defined time as change. The environment I described had change and non-overlapping states.

I posed the question about an environment in which there was only one thing and that one thing changed from S0 --> S1 and S1 --> S2.

Did the first transition take longer or shorter than the second? Was it in state S0 longer than it was in state S1? What would be the basis for deciding the answers to those questions?

How about the basis for deciding when it was in S0 and in S1? How else can you know whether it actually changed?
 
The bottom line is that I cannot think of one example of change that doesn't involve spacetime in some way, but I will change my mind if you can provide one.
You want me to give an example???

I think you have misunderstood what I was saying. I didn't claim this environment actually existed. Someone said that change implied time and I described a theoretical environment in which there was change, but no time.
 
Any change purported in an atemporal environment implies overlapping states, thus a steady condition of dual-statedness and thus no change! Elsewise there is a cause-effect or before-after and voilá, time.

You seem to be using "overlapping" and "steady" to indicate time. In that case these words would have no meaning in an atemporal environment.
 
How about the basis for deciding when it was in S0 and in S1? How else can you know whether it actually changed?
Since this environment has sequence we can say that it was in S0 prior to being in S1 and in S1 prior to being in S2.

But that still would say nothing about how long it was in each state.
 
=Robin]So if the universe is finite, then clearly that does not imply that it begins to exist.
I would think just the opposite.
So you think there is a contradiction in "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?

Earlier you said there wasn't.
Yes, but it is the source of objects such as our universe.
You have completely lost me there. This environment is "nothingness" and it has properties and events?

That makes no sense.
 
Since this environment has sequence we can say that it was in S0 prior to being in S1 and in S1 prior to being in S2.

That's just fancy talk for "Since this environment has time".

But that still would say nothing about how long it was in each state.

Nor anything about how to discern between those two states.
 
Robin said:
In the atemporal environment you posit - suppose that there are two entities:

A has the properties {p1...p8}
B has the properties {q1...q4}

And these are properties that, as discussed earlier, are such that having pi implies that the same entity does not have pj, j not equal to i.

In other words they both exhibit atemporal change according to your definition.

So suppose that p1 is the reason for q1 and p4 was the reason for q2 and p8 was the reason for q3.

Wouldn't that imply that an observer can quantify the change in B in terms of the change in A?
Yes, I would think so.
So this environment has change, sequential change and the change in one object can be quantified in terms of the change in another.

It seems to exemplify all the properties that I would associate with time.
 
That's just fancy talk for "Since this environment has time".
So you define "time" as "sequence"?

I don't mind if you do, but just be aware that you are including your conclusion in your definition.
Nor anything about how to discern between those two states.
It is a given of the example that there is sufficient information in the states to differentiate it from the prior, ie S0 is not equal to S1.
 
So you define "time" as "sequence"?

No, I define time as something we measure change with.

I don't mind if you do, but just be aware that you are including your conclusion in your definition.

Well, no. But since we're on the subject, do you actually have a conclusion of some sort?

It is a given of the example that there is sufficient information in the states to differentiate it from the prior, ie S0 is not equal to S1.

Oh, it's a given? Sorry. Didn't know we were on bare assumption land. ;)
 
Robin, as for your questions in regards to the length of time between S0 and S1, I would say it really depends on how strict you are with your states. If you are defining it in the strictest sense (which is how I prefer to do it), that any change whatsoever is a change between one situation and the next, then the length of time for any one situation is nonsense. That would be like asking what is the distance of a single point. Points have no distance, but the space between two of them does. It requires a comparison between situations. And thus, if we are still speaking on the strictest of terms, the distance between S0 -> S1, and S1 -> S2, is necessarily identical.

I will be posting my thoughts on this later tonight. I'm at work at the moment and I'd say more if I had the time. (har har)
 
No, I define time as something we measure change with.
So in other words saying that the environment has "sequence" is not a fancy way of saying it has time, as you earlier claimed? You can't have it both ways.

Incidentally, can you give an example of using time to measure change where you are not measuring one change with reference to the change in something else?
Well, no. But since we're on the subject, do you actually have a conclusion of some sort?
Conclusion about what?

Someone said that change implies time and I gave a description of a theoretical environment that had change and not time.

As I have said all along, it really depends upon how you define time.
Oh, it's a given? Sorry. Didn't know we were on bare assumption land. ;)
No, a "given" is not an assumption. I am not assuming anything because I am not claiming that this environment actually exists.

If I say "X changes" I mean that X changes.

I don't mean that X doesn't change.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom