Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
But the answers that I am really interested in are:
That still does not answer my question (and you have been not answering this question for some time now)

Is there such a thing as:

a is the reason for b or
a results in b​

in an atemporal environment?
Yes.
and
Robin said:
And presumably "=" denotes assignation rather than equality?

But are you saying that the members of the set are not themselves sets?

So order is significant in non-temporal change?
Yes, to all.
This gives a fuller picture of your idea.

More on this later. Presumably you are posting that this atemporal environment is infinite?
 
Last edited:
Same as gravity. We know what it does, but can anyone describe it?
 
If you are right that it is conceptually possible to talk about things happening without time, then the answer is no. But I don't feel like it has been adequately explained how we can talk about things happening without time.
Like some others you are dismissing the explanation without even acknowledging the key point of it.

As an analogy, take a tomato. If we say "the tomato doubled in size" we are talking about change, but have not referred to time. If we say "the tomato doubled in size in seven days" we are talking about change and time.

So when we talk about time we don't just talk about change, we talk about change of one thing in relation to change in another, for example with the tomato we quantified the change in size of the to the change in the relative positions of the Earth and the Sun.

So my first example suggested a Universe that had only one thing which change. With that entity it's change can be quantified in terms of it's prior state, like the tomato doubling in size.

But it's change cannot be quantified in terms of other changing entities - because there are none.

Hence my conclusion that a Universe that contained only one thing that changed would have change, but no time.
 
Okay, now that you have stated the same thing for the 50th time, please explain how. I never said that existence is equivalent to spacetime. I am saying that spacetime is required for there to be existing things. You are claiming that things can exist without a place to exist in, so I don't think it is unreasonable to ask you to offer an argument in support of this idea, but I have my doubts that one will be forthcoming.
I think that you should offer an argument for why you think that spacetime is required for things to exist.

That seems to be entirely an assumption on your part.

If you want I could find a quote from a fairly well respected physicist who conjectures that space and time may turn out to be concepts that are meaningful only in certain contexts.

Or I could refer you the multiverse conjecture or M-theory - surely these ideas suggest the possibility of things existing apart from Universes.
 
Bill Thompson 75,

In the atemporal environment you posit - suppose that there are two entities:

A has the properties {p1...p8}
B has the properties {q1...q4}

And these are properties that, as discussed earlier, are such that having pi implies that the same entity does not have pj, j not equal to i.

In other words they both exhibit atemporal change according to your definition.

So suppose that p1 is the reason for q1 and p4 was the reason for q2 and p8 was the reason for q3.

Wouldn't that imply that an observer can quantify the change in B in terms of the change in A?
 
Like some others you are dismissing the explanation without even acknowledging the key point of it.

As an analogy, take a tomato. If we say "the tomato doubled in size" we are talking about change, but have not referred to time. If we say "the tomato doubled in size in seven days" we are talking about change and time.

So when we talk about time we don't just talk about change, we talk about change of one thing in relation to change in another, for example with the tomato we quantified the change in size of the to the change in the relative positions of the Earth and the Sun.

So my first example suggested a Universe that had only one thing which change. With that entity it's change can be quantified in terms of it's prior state, like the tomato doubling in size.

But it's change cannot be quantified in terms of other changing entities - because there are none.

Hence my conclusion that a Universe that contained only one thing that changed would have change, but no time.

So, I am assuming that you take the view that spacetime is not an actual entity, but, roughly speaking, the concept of objects in relation to one another (which I would agree with). Given this, the problem I have with what you said above is with the concept of one object changing. The concept of one object is tricky to begin with. A tomato wouldn't cut it because a tomato is made up of many individual objects interacting with each other. The one object must be an elementary particle (or else something completely unknown to us). So, let's say the object is a single elementary particle. Exactly what change could a single particle in isolation go through since there are no other particles for it to interact with? I can't think of any. Even if the particle just went through decay, the result is still going to be another particle and thus another object, because a particle couldn't just lose mass (it must go somewhere.) But let's say, for the sake of argument, that there is an elementary particle that can change without interacting with or creating another particle. Let's say this particle is isolated outside of the universe and the change it undergoes is bending in half. It seems to me that the particle is in a new position, but how can that be? Doesn't the concept of position only make sense in space?
The bottom line is that I cannot think of one example of change that doesn't involve spacetime in some way, but I will change my mind if you can provide one.
 
I think that you should offer an argument for why you think that spacetime is required for things to exist.

That seems to be entirely an assumption on your part.

Perhaps, but in order to show the assumption wrong, you only need to explain how an object can exist without a place to exist in.

If you want I could find a quote from a fairly well respected physicist who conjectures that space and time may turn out to be concepts that are meaningful only in certain contexts.

Sure.

Or I could refer you the multiverse conjecture or M-theory - surely these ideas suggest the possibility of things existing apart from Universes.

What about the multiverse or M-theory implies that things exist apart from spacetime? The extra dimensions in M-theory are dimensions of space, right? And the extra universes of the multiverse would still have some kind of spacetime or all be contained within one spacetime, right?
 
No disagreements, but I don't see how that implies that anything besides the Universe exists.

This is an assumption that since our universe exists there is no obstacle to existence.

Bill Thompson 75 said:
The boundary between non-existence and existence is the beginning of our universe.
Do you have any reasoning behind that assertion?

If a thing can exist and not exist then it necessarily begins and/or ends.

Bill Thompson 75 said:
That there is a boundary indicates that there is a source of our universe, our universe on one side of the boundary and the source of our universe on the other.
Again, reasoning?

The source of the universe would simply to refer to the environment within which an object obtains existence.

So if every possible entity is finite and finity implies a source that implies that every possible object has a source.

Yes.
 
Bill Thompson 75,

In the atemporal environment you posit - suppose that there are two entities:

A has the properties {p1...p8}
B has the properties {q1...q4}

And these are properties that, as discussed earlier, are such that having pi implies that the same entity does not have pj, j not equal to i.

In other words they both exhibit atemporal change according to your definition.

So suppose that p1 is the reason for q1 and p4 was the reason for q2 and p8 was the reason for q3.

Wouldn't that imply that an observer can quantify the change in B in terms of the change in A?

Yes, I would think so.
 
So, I am assuming that you take the view that spacetime is not an actual entity, but, roughly speaking, the concept of objects in relation to one another (which I would agree with). Given this, the problem I have with what you said above is with the concept of one object changing. The concept of one object is tricky to begin with. A tomato wouldn't cut it because a tomato is made up of many individual objects interacting with each other. The one object must be an elementary particle (or else something completely unknown to us). So, let's say the object is a single elementary particle. Exactly what change could a single particle in isolation go through since there are no other particles for it to interact with? I can't think of any. Even if the particle just went through decay, the result is still going to be another particle and thus another object, because a particle couldn't just lose mass (it must go somewhere.)

Conservation of mass is a law in our universe, but not necessarily a law in an environment without space-time.

But let's say, for the sake of argument, that there is an elementary particle that can change without interacting with or creating another particle. Let's say this particle is isolated outside of the universe and the change it undergoes is bending in half. It seems to me that the particle is in a new position, but how can that be? Doesn't the concept of position only make sense in space?

You seem to be using position to mean both shape and location. In an environment that is non-spatial both shape and location would have no meaning.

The bottom line is that I cannot think of one example of change that doesn't involve spacetime in some way, but I will change my mind if you can provide one.

You need to separate the idea of existence from the ideas of space and time.

Think of an environment that is spatial but atemporal. Change occurs in discrete transitional jumps between states. An observer would discern the spatial separation of states without temporal intervals.
 
Bill Thompson 75 said:
So, I am assuming that you take the view that spacetime is not an actual entity, but, roughly speaking, the concept of objects in relation to one another (which I would agree with). Given this, the problem I have with what you said above is with the concept of one object changing. The concept of one object is tricky to begin with. A tomato wouldn't cut it because a tomato is made up of many individual objects interacting with each other. The one object must be an elementary particle (or else something completely unknown to us). So, let's say the object is a single elementary particle. Exactly what change could a single particle in isolation go through since there are no other particles for it to interact with? I can't think of any. Even if the particle just went through decay, the result is still going to be another particle and thus another object, because a particle couldn't just lose mass (it must go somewhere.)

Conservation of mass is a law in our universe, but not necessarily a law in an environment without space-time.

So, mass can vanish in your magical environment? Care to explain how that would work?

Bill Thompson 75 said:
But let's say, for the sake of argument, that there is an elementary particle that can change without interacting with or creating another particle. Let's say this particle is isolated outside of the universe and the change it undergoes is bending in half. It seems to me that the particle is in a new position, but how can that be? Doesn't the concept of position only make sense in space?

You seem to be using position to mean both shape and location. In an environment that is non-spatial both shape and location would have no meaning.

Position and location are synonymous. The shape is of no consequence. A non-spatial environment with objects in it is meaningless, so of course talking about the location of the objects is meaningless. Now, instead of continuing to wave your hands, please explain how it is possible for objects to exist without a position. You seem to not understand the difference between making a statement and offering an argument.

Bill Thompson 75 said:
The bottom line is that I cannot think of one example of change that doesn't involve spacetime in some way, but I will change my mind if you can provide one.

You need to separate the idea of existence from the ideas of space and time.

Think of an environment that is spatial but atemporal. Change occurs in discrete transitional jumps between states. An observer would discern the spatial separation of states without temporal intervals.

Yes, Bill, you already said this. You want me to imagine an environment with change, but no change. The only problem with me doing that is that I am a reasonable person.
 
Robin, I was with you for the majority of your discussion of time, but I'm going to have to start disagreeing with you. I'll get into more detail later, but as for now, let me ask you this:

We use the word "week" to describe the amount of time it takes the earth to move around the sun a given distance. How is it any less valid to define "week" as the time it took the tomato in your example to double in size?
 
So, mass can vanish in your magical environment? Care to explain how that would work?

Random chance could explain it. What would prevent it?

Position and location are synonymous. The shape is of no consequence. A non-spatial environment with objects in it is meaningless, so of course talking about the location of the objects is meaningless. Now, instead of continuing to wave your hands, please explain how it is possible for objects to exist without a position. You seem to not understand the difference between making a statement and offering an argument.

You won't be able to understand until you realize that existence is not equivalent to space and time. "Without a position" has no meaning in a non-spatial environment.

Yes, Bill, you already said this. You want me to imagine an environment with change, but no change. The only problem with me doing that is that I am a reasonable person.

Also, time is not equivalent to change. I want you to "imagine an environment with change, but no change" time.
 
Last edited:
Bill and Robin, if change is possible without time, please tell me which definition of the word "change" you are using. Furthermore, please use the word "change" in a sentence that does not reference time. The flowers have changed since I last saw them would not qualify since it references two points in time.

Bill, in regards to your analogy of the printer creating an idea: Let's imagine that this printer, for no particular reason, prints out a string of characters. These characters, when interpreted in one language states the claim, "All roses are red." However, when these characters are interpreted in another language, they state the claim, "Some roses are not red." If this printer has indeed created an idea, is it a true or false proposition?
 
Bill and Robin, if change is possible without time, please tell me which definition of the word "change" you are using. Furthermore, please use the word "change" in a sentence that does not reference time. The flowers have changed since I last saw them would not qualify since it references two points in time.


Definition: Change is a variation in the set of properties which describe an object.

Example: The name of the object changed as it discretely transitioned between states A and B.

Bill, in regards to your analogy of the printer creating an idea: Let's imagine that this printer, for no particular reason, prints out a string of characters. These characters, when interpreted in one language states the claim, "All roses are red." However, when these characters are interpreted in another language, they state the claim, "Some roses are not red." If this printer has indeed created an idea, is it a true or false proposition?

Within this context I would say that the symbols contain enough information for one true and one false claim.
 
This is an assumption that since our universe exists there is no obstacle to existence.
No, it is an assumption that something exists apart from our Universe.
If a thing can exist and not exist then it necessarily begins and/or ends.
You are missing a step here. Are you saying that finity implies contingency. Why?

Where is the contradiction is saying "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?
Robin said:
So if every possible entity is finite and finity implies a source that implies that every possible object has a source.
Yes.
So "every possible object" would naturally include the source.

So if every possible object is finite then every source has a source - an infinite regress of sources - yes?
 
No, it is an assumption that something exists apart from our Universe.

I choose a less restrictive assumption.

You are missing a step here. Are you saying that finity implies contingency. Why?
Where is the contradiction is saying "X is finite and X cannot not exist"?

Could you rephrase to clarify these two questions?

So "every possible object" would naturally include the source.

So if every possible object is finite then every source has a source - an infinite regress of sources - yes?

No, not if the source is an environment of nothingness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom