Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but in an atemporal environment, there would be no way to determine what caused what, one way or anoter. As far as anybody was concerned, it would make no difference if causality existed or not, since it all "happens" simultaneously, and it would appear as though there wasn't any causality. So how could there BE causality ?
 
@robin a better translation from variable would be coordinate.
Why is co-ordinate any better than variable?
If you exclude the spacial coordinate (we are specifically examinating a single point in space for its property), then change can only happen if there is an additional coordinate.
I am excluding space altogether.
Be it w (some sort 4th spacial coordinate) or time, there need to be a 4th coordinate or internal variable.
Again - why?
If there isn't you automatically run into a contradiction that you define a change without any relationship to any internal coordinate of the system.
Where exactly is the contradiction?

Don't accuse others of hand waving if that is all you have yourself.

Demonstrate, explicitly, what this contradiction is.
 
A last word on that topic :

Robin and other, you say there is a change and a state S0 and S1. But without that additional coordinate, you will NOT be able to define what is the initial state to what is the final state. In other word you come and say S0 initial and S1 final, and we can just say you are wrong and it was S1 initial and S0 final.
You can't get away from this idea you have that the states are simultaneous or a superposition can you?

They are not simultaneous or a superposition. They change.
 
Nice try. I said they happen simultaneously
Nice try yourself, but here is what you actually said " Without time, things would pretty much have to happen all at once, no ?"

So what do you mean "all at once" if not all at the same time?.

And Merriam Webster tells me that simultaneous means "at the same time"
 
Last edited:
The grammar of the English language allows for sentences to have the same meaning even though the words may be in a different order. It also allows for the use of synonyms.
So if you claim that both your Q's mean the same thing and both your P's mean the same thing then can I just arbitrarily pick one of each and build up your "Modus Ponens" from that?
That was a secondary example which I withdrew and later I presented a different one.
Did you provide a definition for change after you withdrew the first one?
 
If "no need to posit a source" does not = "does not have a source" then I guess you meant that sometimes you just don't need to think about things.
There are some things you don't need to think about.

For example there is no point in wondering whether Sarah Palin's lesbian lover rides a Harley if you have no reason to suppose that Sarah Palin is a lesbian in the first place.

Similarly there does not seem to be any point in the police wondering whether the murderer is right or left handed when they have no reason to suppose a murder has taken place.

Similarly there does not seem to be any point in wondering what the source of the Universe is like if we have no reason to suppose it has a source.
 
Last edited:
The contingency may simply be an ordering of object properties.
1) Object A has property x.
2) Object A has property y.

We have change without time.
This would seem to suggest that you are now defining change as having more than one property
 
Bill Thompson 75 said:
If you are talking about an entity changing from one state to another, how are you not talking about a quantifiable change? I don't see where it matters if there is another entity to compare it to. The comparison is between the two states or three states and the states themselves are what is being quantified.

I really don't see how it is conceptually possible to talk about events and entities existing in an atemporal environment. It would be like saying that there is a space-less environment with a piece of paper in it. You would have to ask "where is the piece of paper," and the only sensical answer is that it is nowhere. But if it is nowhere, then it doesn't exist. That's the central problem. Nothing can exist in a space-less or atemporal (which are really the same thing) environment. How can you talk about a thing existing nowhere and at no time? It would be a logical contradiction. And just saying that a thing exists in an atemporal environment wouldn't explain how that is logically possible any more than saying that there is a bachelor who is married would explain how that is logically possible.

We only have words to describe a space-time environment and that makes it difficult to form ideas about non-temporal/non-spatial concepts.

Just because an object cannot be located in space or time does not mean that it does not exist. Those ideas are not equivalent.
Part of the difficulty is that in a non-temporal/non-spatial environment you should avoid words that indicate time or space, such as age, duration, frequency, size, shape, density, etc. We use those words to describe observations in our universe. Maybe not all environments are structured the same as ours.

You are still just saying it is possible, but not explaining how. Would you agree that logical contradictions are possible in a non-spacetime environment? Can there be married bachelors there? If no, then why not?
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but in an atemporal environment, there would be no way to determine what caused what, one way or anoter. As far as anybody was concerned, it would make no difference if causality existed or not, since it all "happens" simultaneously, and it would appear as though there wasn't any causality. So how could there BE causality ?

Try to describe your ideas without any references to time (e.g. "simultaneously") and some of the incongruencies may disappear.
 
This would seem to suggest that you are now defining change as having more than one property

In an atemporal environment (which could possibly still be spatial), if an object has multiple states, but the sets of properties for those states are not identical then the object has changed.

In an atemporal/non-spatial environment I do not know what properties of an object could be measured to discern any difference.
 
There are some things you don't need to think about.

For example there is no point in wondering whether Sarah Palin's lesbian lover rides a Harley if you have no reason to suppose that Sarah Palin is a lesbian in the first place.

Similarly there does not seem to be any point in the police wondering whether the murderer is right or left handed when they have no reason to suppose a murder has taken place.

Similarly there does not seem to be any point in wondering what the source of the Universe is like if we have no reason to suppose it has a source.

I have pointed out that I believe our universe is not infinite. The boundary between non-existence and existence is the beginning of our universe. That there is a boundary indicates that there is a source of our universe, our universe on one side of the boundary and the source of our universe on the other.
 
bluskool said:
It would be like saying that there is a space-less environment with a piece of paper in it. You would have to ask "where is the piece of paper," and the only sensical answer is that it is nowhere. But if it is nowhere, then it doesn't exist.

In an atemporal/non-spatial environment it would not be rational to ask "where?" or "when?" or to reply "nowhere" or "no time."

You are still just saying it is possible, but not explaining how. Would you agree that logical contradictions are possible in a non-spacetime environment? Can there be married bachelors there? If no, then why not?

It is possible for a thing to exist in such an environment because there is nothing to prevent it. Existence is not equivalent to time and space.
In our universe existence occurs within time and space but they are not equivalent.

I don't see that logical contradictions are possible, but I do see that definitions are different so that logical contradictions in our universe may not have counterparts in other environments.
 
You are defining change as equivalent to time, which works in our universe, but consider a different universe.
I live in this one, a different universe has no meaning to me, because you can make up any rules for it that you want and they can't be tested and therefore you learn nothing. Like with having a so-called god.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I live in this one, a different universe has no meaning to me, because you can make up any rules for it that you want and they can't be tested and therefore you learn nothing. Like with having a so-called god.

Paul

:) :) :)

Once I met someone who lived in this universe. He bumped his head and his imagination fell out. He couldn't learn anything either.
 
In an atemporal/non-spatial environment it would not be rational to ask "where?" or "when?" or to reply "nowhere" or "no time."



It is possible for a thing to exist in such an environment because there is nothing to prevent it. Existence is not equivalent to time and space.
In our universe existence occurs within time and space but they are not equivalent.

I don't see that logical contradictions are possible, but I do see that definitions are different so that logical contradictions in our universe may not have counterparts in other environments.

Okay, now that you have stated the same thing for the 50th time, please explain how. I never said that existence is equivalent to spacetime. I am saying that spacetime is required for there to be existing things. You are claiming that things can exist without a place to exist in, so I don't think it is unreasonable to ask you to offer an argument in support of this idea, but I have my doubts that one will be forthcoming.
 
I have pointed out that I believe our universe is not infinite.
No disagreements, but I don't see how that implies that anything besides the Universe exists.
The boundary between non-existence and existence is the beginning of our universe.
Do you have any reasoning behind that assertion?
That there is a boundary indicates that there is a source of our universe, our universe on one side of the boundary and the source of our universe on the other.
Again, reasoning?

And this is exactly the sort of thinking that the article by Callender that you supplied brings even further into question.

If the Universe is essentially static then it brings raises the question of in what sense does it have a beginning. And it certainly highlights the huge gap between "begins" and "begins to exist".

Earlier you agreed with the reasoning in the Kalam Cosmological Argument. But that reasoning depends upon the premiss that an actual infinity is impossible.

So if every possible entity is finite and finity implies a source that implies that every possible object has a source.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom