Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
If there is no time then how could everything happen at the same time?

Nice try. I said they happen simultaneously; in this case atemporally. The lack of time does not preclude things from happening. They just can't follow one another and therefore there can't be causal relations between them.
 
Seriously Bill, if you haven't quite followed some of my admittedly mysterious posts yet, let me break it down for you.

The photographs of which you speak are not actual moments in time. They are however symbolic representations of a moment in time and serve essentially the same purpose as memory (whether human memory or mechanized, it's basically the same thing). They are not the actual objects which they depict... or even an accurate recording of those objects, but rather a chemical or digital recording of light patterns. It is a symbolic memory tool, basically -- essentially no different than writing things down.

Consider the photographs symbolic representations..oh, we did that. Then consider them representations of objects rather than moments. Oh, they are.

You are specifically describing time as recorded by the mechanism of memory (if I understood your posts correctly). Does it say something about time itself, or does it say something about the relationship between time and memory? Exactly what are you proposing all this means? I have absolutely no idea what you mean by an "atemporal environment," since I have no memories which suggest that such a thing exists. Even the process of taking the photo requires time, because the light which provides the record requires time in order to travel, and the device which makes the record is recording light waves over a specific, though admittedly small, increment of time. As far as I can tell, no degree of awareness is possible in an atemporal environment. All of our senses and the mechanisms we use to extend them are wired to temporal activity.

The existence of a thing, even a symbolic representation, does not depend upon memory nor awareness.
It is interesting that you think that memory can be mechanical. Do you also think that thought can be mechanical?
 
I interpret this as moving the goalposts. A photograph is a two dimensional image - it's not abstract symbolic, it's representational.

How does an image composed of a pattern of dots differ from a symbol composed of a pattern of dots?.

Oh please, information is what is gleaned when symbols are interpreted. Symbols are data with semantic content, but require interpretation.

How does information differ from semantic content?
 
The hardest-hitting evidence of Myself being in existence is made of stones and it is called the churches. Those lazy speaking monkeys wouldn't move a finger if there was no reason for it.
God
 
So if P is the the part between "IF" and "THEN" then you have two different versions of P above (I have highlighted these two in blue).

And if Q is the part after "THEN" and also the conclusion, then you have two different versions of Q (I have highlighted these two in green).

You should rephrase with only one version of each or these.

The grammar of the English language allows for sentences to have the same meaning even though the words may be in a different order. It also allows for the use of synonyms.

Also, you appear to have completely abandoned your original conclusion - which was about "change" as you will recall.

That was a secondary example which I withdrew and later I presented a different one.
 
I said :
If the Universe is essentially static then there is no need to posit a source for it.​
and you interpreted it as:
If the Universe is essentially static then it does not have a source.​
Do you really think those statements are equivalent?

If "no need to posit a source" does not = "does not have a source" then I guess you meant that sometimes you just don't need to think about things.

If you will recall one of your earlier premisses was that things which begin must have a source.
But even if the premiss were true then it would be redundant if it is not even clear that the Universe began.

Maybe "redundant" wasn't the word you meant to use there.

Robin said:
Why make speculations about the source of the Universe when we don't even know that it has a source? Or that anything besides the Universe exists?

My interpretation is "Why speculate about something that may not exist?"

Now you interpret your statement so that is doesn't sound ridiculous.
 
However if there are two objects that change and there is some sort of contingency between the states of the first and the second, then the change in one object can be quantified with respect to the changes in the second object.

In this case we have time.

The contingency may simply be an ordering of object properties.
1) Object A has property x.
2) Object A has property y.

We have change without time.
 
They are just multiple images in an atemporal context. Change is only apparent when they are compared, which involves a comparison operation, which takes time. We can specify that the images concerned differ slightly from one to the next when setting up our thought experiment, but once set up any perceived change is in the eye of the (temporal) beholder.

Change does not need to be observed for it to occur.
 
@robin a better translation from variable would be coordinate. If you exclude the spacial coordinate (we are specifically examinating a single point in space for its property), then change can only happen if there is an additional coordinate. Be it w (some sort 4th spacial coordinate) or time, there need to be a 4th coordinate or internal variable. If there isn't you automatically run into a contradiction that you define a change without any relationship to any internal coordinate of the system.

You can certainly define a 4th dimensional atemporal universe, and have a 3D plane transform into another 3D plane with identical X,Y,Z.

Basically change imply such coordinate change. Otherwise semantically you won't be able to define change in your universe: you will not be able to demonstrate the existence of an inital status and a final status which is by definition a change.

And basically :
There is one state and it becomes another state. Change. Where does the coordinate come in?

As I said before in the atemporal environment I am positing, there is one state and it becomes another state. Change.

Emphasis mine.

THIS is hand waving. Think of the consequence of having an initial and a final state, and a change. You are implying the varying coordinate, without explicitly admitting its existence.

The bottom line is that the only way to have such a system is by having a SUPERPOSITION of state, which is definitively NOT a state change.
 
The contingency may simply be an ordering of object properties.
1) Object A has property x.
2) Object A has property y.

We have change without time.
There can't be change without time, time only happens with change.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Nope, I can't imagine that at all. If there is no time, the thing must remain in a single state. There may be multiple entities, each in a different state, but without time the states can't change. The universe would be 'stuck' at T0 with entity E at state S0. A change of state in E to S1 would effectively define a time T1.

Consider a theoretical construct, such as a Turing machine. It is a "discrete state machine" because it jumps from one specific state to another. In an atemporal environment this jump does not involve time.
 
If you prefer to use a lower number of dimension, imagine our universe is only 1 dimension plus time, and we have only 1 type function f(x,t) however complicated they are. Now you define that Atemporaly you supress the time coordinate. That come to only consider t constant t=t0. For example when the universe began t=0.

Now you say that there exists a function f, which for identical X=X0, you have before the change f(X0,0)=F1 and after the change f(X0,0)=F2 with F1<>F2. Without an additional coordinate or some very weird mathematical definition (*) , you won't be able to define such a function and will always come into F1=F2.

(*) I have only done math until 2 years into uni, enough for QM physic but not enough to understand what "non hilbertian quaternion space" might mean;)
 
If you are talking about an entity changing from one state to another, how are you not talking about a quantifiable change? I don't see where it matters if there is another entity to compare it to. The comparison is between the two states or three states and the states themselves are what is being quantified.

I really don't see how it is conceptually possible to talk about events and entities existing in an atemporal environment. It would be like saying that there is a space-less environment with a piece of paper in it. You would have to ask "where is the piece of paper," and the only sensical answer is that it is nowhere. But if it is nowhere, then it doesn't exist. That's the central problem. Nothing can exist in a space-less or atemporal (which are really the same thing) environment. How can you talk about a thing existing nowhere and at no time? It would be a logical contradiction. And just saying that a thing exists in an atemporal environment wouldn't explain how that is logically possible any more than saying that there is a bachelor who is married would explain how that is logically possible.

We only have words to describe a space-time environment and that makes it difficult to form ideas about non-temporal/non-spatial concepts.

Just because an object cannot be located in space or time does not mean that it does not exist. Those ideas are not equivalent.
Part of the difficulty is that in a non-temporal/non-spatial environment you should avoid words that indicate time or space, such as age, duration, frequency, size, shape, density, etc. We use those words to describe observations in our universe. Maybe not all environments are structured the same as ours.
 
We only have words to describe a space-time environment and that makes it difficult to form ideas about non-temporal/non-spatial concepts.

Such ideas are formed with the usage of specialized symbolism, but they are very hard to verbalize in order to prove to a lay person that such ideas are conceptually sound.

I wonder if Higgs boson, sometimes dubbed the "God's particle," is temporal object or not.
 
A last word on that topic :

Robin and other, you say there is a change and a state S0 and S1. But without that additional coordinate, you will NOT be able to define what is the initial state to what is the final state. In other word you come and say S0 initial and S1 final, and we can just say you are wrong and it was S1 initial and S0 final. That alone should show you that there is a problem with either your premise or your conclusion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom