Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not necessarily. All changes could occur simultaneously.

Can you explain what you mean by this?

All I can think of is that either you have multiple 'versions' of the entity in question, or that there is some kind of QM-style 'superposition' of states. The first doesn't involve change, the second is vague and speculative...
 
Not necessarily. All changes could occur simultaneously.

You would have then a superposition of state, but not a change. To give you a more precise example you could have an atom which are in a superposition of ground and excited first state at t=0, but neither it is changing from ground or excited state. By definition a change would mean a different time.

So yes, you can all define the universe as a superposition of different eigenstate U1, U2, U3 ....Un, but you cannot say the universe is changing from a state to another "simultaneously" at the same time t.
 
On this no time thing.........

Stop it Belz...

4880489de0b480839.gif


You are wrong, get over it.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
You would have then a superposition of state, but not a change. To give you a more precise example you could have an atom which are in a superposition of ground and excited first state at t=0, but neither it is changing from ground or excited state. By definition a change would mean a different time.

I suppose you're right. Still, in a timeless place all states would occur simultaneously.
 
Nope, I can't imagine that at all. If there is no time, the thing must remain in a single state.
Why?
There may be multiple entities, each in a different state, but without time the states can't change.
Why - what does time do that allows things to change?
The universe would be 'stuck' at T0 with entity E at state S0. A change of state in E to S1 would effectively define a time T1.
But if it is atemporal, then there is no such thing as T0. It can't be stuck at something that doesn't exist.

So it comes down to how you define time. If you define time as change then clearly you can't have change without time.

If you define time as quantifiable change then you can (at least in theory).

Take my example, an entity is in state S0 and transitions to S1 and then to S2 (either smoothly or in a discrete step).

So how would you tell if it took longer to transition S0 to S1 than it did from S1 to S2. (Or alternatively how long was it in each state?) Clearly we have to quantify this in terms of another changing entity.

But if there is no other entity to which it can be related then there is no duration for the change, and it is not in a particular state for any duration.
 
You would have then a superposition of state, but not a change. To give you a more precise example you could have an atom which are in a superposition of ground and excited first state at t=0, but neither it is changing from ground or excited state. By definition a change would mean a different time.

So yes, you can all define the universe as a superposition of different eigenstate U1, U2, U3 ....Un, but you cannot say the universe is changing from a state to another "simultaneously" at the same time t.
But if you are speculating about atemporality you have got to stop talking temporally.

If there is an atemporal state it is not everything at the same t or everything at t0. In an atemporal environment there is no such thing as t.

And you keep saying "by definition", so what is this definition?
 
Last edited:
Why?

Why - what does time do that allows things to change?

But if it is atemporal, then there is no such thing as T0. It can't be stuck at something that doesn't exist.

So it comes down to how you define time. If you define time as change then clearly you can't have change without time.

If you define time as quantifiable change then you can (at least in theory).

Take my example, an entity is in state S0 and transitions to S1 and then to S2 (either smoothly or in a discrete step).

So how would you tell if it took longer to transition S0 to S1 than it did from S1 to S2. (Or alternatively how long was it in each state?) Clearly we have to quantify this in terms of another changing entity.

But if there is no other entity to which it can be related then there is no duration for the change, and it is not in a particular state for any duration.

If you are talking about an entity changing from one state to another, how are you not talking about a quantifiable change? I don't see where it matters if there is another entity to compare it to. The comparison is between the two states or three states and the states themselves are what is being quantified.

I really don't see how it is conceptually possible to talk about events and entities existing in an atemporal environment. It would be like saying that there is a space-less environment with a piece of paper in it. You would have to ask "where is the piece of paper," and the only sensical answer is that it is nowhere. But if it is nowhere, then it doesn't exist. That's the central problem. Nothing can exist in a space-less or atemporal (which are really the same thing) environment. How can you talk about a thing existing nowhere and at no time? It would be a logical contradiction. And just saying that a thing exists in an atemporal environment wouldn't explain how that is logically possible any more than saying that there is a bachelor who is married would explain how that is logically possible.
 
But if you are speculating about atemporality you have got to stop talking temporally.

If there is an atemporal state it is not everything at the same t or everything at t0. In an atemporal environment there is no such thing as t.

And you keep saying "by definition", so what is this definition?

A change by definition is transformation which make you go from one state , to a different state, (independently of spacial coordinate in the case which interest us).

You can try to posit that there can be change in atemporal environment but then I will immediately ask you : what is the non-spacial coordinate which change. otherwise you cannot have a change you have only a SUPERPOSITION of multiple state (think QM), but that state is FIX. There is no change, no variation to it, it stays the same superposition until time starts.

If you have *NO* other variable than space, there cannot be change. You cannot have two simulatenous state at the same time 1 "changing" into the other. At least with all the current knowledge and definition I know of. Change requires an additional non spacial variation.

So please define now your change in the atemporal environment. I am not accusing anybody of anything but up to now I did not see any consequential definition which could be applied except hand waving as in "think there is no time but still a change".

Well sorry, but consequently define your initial state your final state and what intern variable changed , if not time.
 
If you are talking about an entity changing from one state to another, how are you not talking about a quantifiable change? I don't see where it matters if there is another entity to compare it to. The comparison is between the two states or three states and the states themselves are what is being quantified.
No one wants to answer the question. Is there any way of telling whether the system described above was in state S0 longer than S1?
I really don't see how it is conceptually possible to talk about events and entities existing in an atemporal environment. It would be like saying that there is a space-less environment with a piece of paper in it. You would have to ask "where is the piece of paper," and the only sensical answer is that it is nowhere. But if it is nowhere, then it doesn't exist. That's the central problem. Nothing can exist in a space-less or atemporal (which are really the same thing) environment. How can you talk about a thing existing nowhere and at no time? It would be a logical contradiction.
That is not a logical contradiction - you are just assuming that only space-time can exist.

That is not necessarily the case.

Also, if you cannot talk of something existing nowhere and at no time, then where is space and when is time?
 
A change by definition is transformation which make you go from one state , to a different state, (independently of spacial coordinate in the case which interest us).

You can try to posit that there can be change in atemporal environment but then I will immediately ask you : what is the non-spacial coordinate which change.
And I will immediately answer that there is no coordinate.

There is one state and it becomes another state. Change. Where does the coordinate come in?
So please define now your change in the atemporal environment
You are also avoiding the question. In the system described above, could you tell whether it was in state S0 longer than it was in state S1?
Well sorry, but consequently define your initial state your final state and what intern variable changed , if not time.
I dont understand the question. Is that "internal" variable? "Interim" variable?

Why would there be a variable? Even in space time there is no "variable" as such - it isn't a computer program. Time is a quantity that we can measure because we can observe the change of one thing in relation to the change in another.

As I said before in the atemporal environment I am positing, there is one state and it becomes another state. Change.
 
If you have *NO* other variable than space, there cannot be change.
Actually I don't even have space.

I am taking it for granted that if there is no time then there is no space either, those things being inextricably linked.

So in order to posit an atemporal environment we have to posit one that is not space time. Something else entirely.

So a lot of your objections are not really on the mark because you keep talking about space.
 
No one wants to answer the question. Is there any way of telling whether the system described above was in state S0 longer than S1?

If you are right that it is conceptually possible to talk about things happening without time, then the answer is no. But I don't feel like it has been adequately explained how we can talk about things happening without time.

That is not a logical contradiction - you are just assuming that only space-time can exist.

That is not necessarily the case.

It's a logical contradiction because logic has temporality built right in. Why can't bachelors be married? Because someone cannot be two contradictory things at the same time. Why can't we both be taller than each other? Same reason. But what if you just remove the time variable? In an atemporal environment, there is no reason why bachelors can't be married or we can't be taller than each other. Because logical contradictions can happen there, an atemporal environment must be an impossible world (if logic really does constrain possibility).

Also, if you cannot talk of something existing nowhere and at no time, then where is space and when is time?

Space is everywhere and time is always. Asking when is time is like asking how fast is speed.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom