Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Excuse me if I am wrong, but an atemporal environment is static by definition. That is, nothing which imply a change of state , can be defined. You can define an initial state, but you can't define a condition or a change within that dirac of time. From that initial condition, then you have time starting, but those initial condition are by definition static. When you look at the universe state for U(x,y,z,t) with t=0 , the function can vary in x,y,z but for the same x,y,z it will always be a *constant*.

With x,y,z being the only variable varying and t=0, U1(x0,y0,z0,0)<>U2(x0,y0,z0,0) is impossible. The only way to do that would be to have an additional variable. If somebody pretend to have such a condition, then he better clearly define what that additional non temporal variable is.
 
I think Mr. Thompson is trying to prove that it makes sense to say "Before the Big Bang" by showing that stuff could happen even in an atemporal environment. Therefore an atemporal God could create the earth.

But I haven't been completely paying attention, so I could be wrong.
Bill is an atheist, he's just very confused about time. Nobody's perfect.
 
Neither actually qualifies as miraculous. Cultural groups can survive without the help of supernatural powers.

States can be created without the help of supernatural powers.

A miracle is normally defined as something that could not have a naturalistic explanation.
When it is prophecy specifically fulfilled, it is deserving of and worth greater attention.
 
"For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:

Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened.

Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools,"
 
Excuse me if I am wrong, but an atemporal environment is static by definition. That is, nothing which imply a change of state , can be defined. You can define an initial state, but you can't define a condition or a change within that dirac of time. From that initial condition, then you have time starting, but those initial condition are by definition static. When you look at the universe state for U(x,y,z,t) with t=0 , the function can vary in x,y,z but for the same x,y,z it will always be a *constant*.

With x,y,z being the only variable varying and t=0, U1(x0,y0,z0,0)<>U2(x0,y0,z0,0) is impossible. The only way to do that would be to have an additional variable. If somebody pretend to have such a condition, then he better clearly define what that additional non temporal variable is.
In the past I have speculated a few times in this forum about how there could be an environment in which there was change but no time.

You can imagine a case in which only one thing exists and that thing changes. So suppose it goes through the states s1,s2,s3.

In this case it would be meaningless to ask whether the change from s1 to s2 took longer than the change from s2 to s2 because there is nothing to compare it to.

So that might be considered change without time.

Then you could have another case where two things exist and each of them change but there is no way of relating the states in the first object to the states of the second.

In this case it is still meaningless to ask if the transition from s1 to s2 took longer than the transition from s2 to s3 for each object.

However if there are two objects that change and there is some sort of contingency between the states of the first and the second, then the change in one object can be quantified with respect to the changes in the second object.

In this case we have time.

So in order to have change without time we could have just one thing, or a number of things that change independently from each other.

I don't think Bill means either of those things.
 
I have been wondering about that whole cross and jesus story where god sacrifices himself to himself.
It was only 3 days, and a small prick from a spear, right?

Odin hang for 9 days in Yggdrasil with his spear all through him.
It was a sacrifice of Odin to Odin to let him gain wisdom.

It also means that my religion is 3 times as true as christianity.
Right?
 
When it is prophecy specifically fulfilled, it is deserving of and worth greater attention.


You have very low, self-serving standards for 'specifically fulfilled' (i.e. none at all).

You believe in nonsense and insist upon inflicting it upon the the rest of us.
 
@robin, I am pretty sure one can define that a bit better than things, and what is exactly changing. In your example even if tehre is only one things changing, time is happening even if there is no other reference object to comapre to.

To give you an example : imagine a universe where there is absolutely nothing. No atom, no molecule, no photon. But time is going on. There is no object of reference to see it, but time is going on.

So my question is still the same, under what scenario you have a universal state U(x,y,z,t) for which at identical x,y,z and t, you have a change between the two states such as that U1(x0,y0,z0,t0)<>U2(x0,y0,z0,t0) where t0=0 and x0,y0,z0 constant.
 
... consider the changing scenes of a motion picture. The apparent motion is actually the rapid timed display of static images. In an atemporal environment there is no time to separate the display of those static images, although the scenes that they capture indicate change.

They are just multiple images in an atemporal context. Change is only apparent when they are compared, which involves a comparison operation, which takes time. We can specify that the images concerned differ slightly from one to the next when setting up our thought experiment, but once set up any perceived change is in the eye of the (temporal) beholder.
 
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.

Where was the Jewish god during the Holocaust?
 
He/it must have found the local deli closed. He/it had to travel to another solar system to buy his crisps and fags because he was away for over ten years.
 
I did see a homepage somewhere about the great man-lover in the sky. :D
More often than not, people who speak out about not liking something are the same ones doing what they say they don't like. This so-called god only likes men, only talks to men, there doesn't seem to be any women in his life, except for one that he doesn't have sex with, get my drift.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
In the past I have speculated a few times in this forum about how there could be an environment in which there was change but no time.

You can imagine a case in which only one thing exists and that thing changes. So suppose it goes through the states s1,s2,s3.

Nope, I can't imagine that at all. If there is no time, the thing must remain in a single state. There may be multiple entities, each in a different state, but without time the states can't change. The universe would be 'stuck' at T0 with entity E at state S0. A change of state in E to S1 would effectively define a time T1.

In a temporal universe, you could have a quantum superposition of two states at one instant of time, but I suspect it becomes meaningless in an atemporal context.
 
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.

No. They aren't.

In fact, nothing in there violates reality as we know it. Why are they miraculous signs, then, if nothing points to a miracle ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom