Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, you commit so many logical fallacies it's hard to keep up. But we try.

It was a non-sequitur. Now it's just gibberish. Care to try again?

My argument is that your argument is invalid. Isn't that obvious?

I cannot refute assertions that have no content.
It is pointless to refute assertions with content that I have disproved.
 
Until someone reads it and interprets it as an idea with a truth value, it is just characters on paper. You can communicate ideas using written language (e.g. characters on paper), but the the character sequences themselves are not ideas, they are just character sequences. A reader is necessary to decode or translate them and interpret them into ideas. Different readers may interpret the sequences differently, so constructing different ideas from them, so the character sequences really are just character sequences. The map is not the territory.

Suppose a printer, only printing small dots, creates a photo of a small animal.
The photo is placed next to a real identical animal. Two large birds fly towards them, one targeting the real animal, one targeting the photo.
Maybe it's a child running up to hug a photo-realistic picture of a parent.
The symbol cannot be distinguished from the thing it symbolizes?
How would you interpret this?

I think symbols can actually contain information.
 
That does not seem to be anything remotely like your argument.

Here is the argument that you claim is Modus Ponens..

Premise 1: The properties are restricted from coexisting temporally.
Premise 2: The properties are not restricted from coexisting atemporally.

Therefore, what appeared to be a restriction is not a restriction.
​

Now show me what P is and what Q is.

If P, then Q:
"IF there is a temporal restriction, which is not also an atemporal restriction,
THEN there is not a restriction in all environments"

P: "The properties are restricted from coexisting temporally" AND
"The properties are not restricted from coexisting atemporally"

Q: "What appeared to be a restriction is not a restriction"
 
So, in answer to my question, are you saying that there is no such thing as:

a is the reason for b or
a results in b​

in an atemporal environment?

No, I am just saying that you can create statements that if true would be contradictory.
Which is to say, you can line up a bunch of statements that are not logical.
 
Mr. Thompson 75, I've read this thread from the beginning but haven't commented in some time. Here is my perception of the portion of the discussion in which you've taken part:

(Bolding mine.)

You seem to want to apply new definitions to standard words -- to arbitrarily declare that for the purposes of your discussion, the old definitions, "Praise, honor, or distinction" and "great beauty and splendor" no longer apply, because you use "glory" to mean "a nice knock-down argument".

The fact is that when most people use "glory", they usually mean "praise, honor, or distinction" or "great beauty and splendor", and exactly which they mean is usually clear from context.

But when other users point this out -- arguing, like Alice, "But 'glory' doesn't mean 'a nice knock-down argument'" -- you complain that they are "send{ing} the debate off in irrelevant directions".

When I was about seven, Mr. Thompson 75, my teacher read the class a story about a little boy who decided to make up his own version of English. (I remember his decision that "stairs" was a silly word and they should be called "hop-ons".) When a family with several little boys moved in across the street, he was very eager to meet them -- and chagrined that they laughed at him just because he greeted them in his language, saying (IIRC) "Who are your whats?" rather than "What are your names?"

Mr. Thompson 75, words mean things. It's unfair at best to declare by personal fiat, "When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less" -- and then complain that Alice is "sending the debate off in irrelevant directions" when she politely asks of a term you've used, "Would you tell me, please, what that means?"

Read the online slang dictionary if you don't think people do this everyday.

If the usage of a word is made explicitly clear there is no problem. Some think it is more appropriate to use a 20-word description every time you would rather use a single word that means those 20 words. I disagree.

Here is an example I have used before:

What do these words mean to you: flavor, up, down, charm, strange, top, and bottom.

Up, down, charm, strange, top, and bottom are the flavors of quarks.
 
Seriously Bill, if you haven't quite followed some of my admittedly mysterious posts yet, let me break it down for you.

The photographs of which you speak are not actual moments in time. They are however symbolic representations of a moment in time and serve essentially the same purpose as memory (whether human memory or mechanized, it's basically the same thing). They are not the actual objects which they depict... or even an accurate recording of those objects, but rather a chemical or digital recording of light patterns. It is a symbolic memory tool, basically -- essentially no different than writing things down.

You are specifically describing time as recorded by the mechanism of memory (if I understood your posts correctly). Does it say something about time itself, or does it say something about the relationship between time and memory? Exactly what are you proposing all this means? I have absolutely no idea what you mean by an "atemporal environment," since I have no memories which suggest that such a thing exists. Even the process of taking the photo requires time, because the light which provides the record requires time in order to travel, and the device which makes the record is recording light waves over a specific, though admittedly small, increment of time. As far as I can tell, no degree of awareness is possible in an atemporal environment. All of our senses and the mechanisms we use to extend them are wired to temporal activity.
 
Last edited:
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.
 
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.

Evidence? I don't see the connection. Please be more specific.
 
Suppose a printer, only printing small dots, creates a photo of a small animal.
The photo is placed next to a real identical animal. Two large birds fly towards them, one targeting the real animal, one targeting the photo.
Maybe it's a child running up to hug a photo-realistic picture of a parent.
The symbol cannot be distinguished from the thing it symbolizes?
How would you interpret this?

I interpret this as moving the goalposts. A photograph is a two dimensional image - it's not abstract symbolic, it's representational.

I think symbols can actually contain information.

Oh please, information is what is gleaned when symbols are interpreted. Symbols are data with semantic content, but require interpretation.

"Data is not information. Information is not knowledge. Knowledge is not understanding. Understanding is not wisdom. Wisdom is not truth. Truth is not beauty. Beauty is not love. Love is not music. Music is THE BEST!" [Clifford Stoll/Frank Zappa]
 
Last edited:
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.


When one has nothing to say, one could simply be quiet and listen.

One might learn something.

Your non-sequitor posts are akin to farting just so you can feel that you've contributed something, however unwelcome.

Stop it.
 
How is the temporal discussion relevant to God's existence, anyway ?

I think Mr. Thompson is trying to prove that it makes sense to say "Before the Big Bang" by showing that stuff could happen even in an atemporal environment. Therefore an atemporal God could create the earth.

But I haven't been completely paying attention, so I could be wrong.
 
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.

The posting of non-sequitur drivel on the internet using a computer is evidence of science at work and the ingenuity of evolved human beings.

Do you see the difference between faith based religion and evidence based knowledge yet?
 
If P, then Q:
"IF there is a temporal restriction, which is not also an atemporal restriction,
THEN there is not a restriction in all environments"

P: "The properties are restricted from coexisting temporally" AND
"The properties are not restricted from coexisting atemporally"


Q: "What appeared to be a restriction is not a restriction"
So if P is the the part between "IF" and "THEN" then you have two different versions of P above (I have highlighted these two in blue).

And if Q is the part after "THEN" and also the conclusion, then you have two different versions of Q (I have highlighted these two in green).

You should rephrase with only one version of each or these.

Also, you appear to have completely abandoned your original conclusion - which was about "change" as you will recall.
 
I think Mr. Thompson is trying to prove that it makes sense to say "Before the Big Bang" by showing that stuff could happen even in an atemporal environment. Therefore an atemporal God could create the earth.

But I haven't been completely paying attention, so I could be wrong.
No, in fact he is arguing the opposite, he is saying that the Kalam Cosmological Argument is sound, but that the cause is not God.

Now I agree that if the KCA is sound then there are much better candidates for the cause than God. But I do not think that the KCA is sound in any case.

There might be a cause of the Universe and there might not be.

Neither case is would be any evidence for God.
 
So, in answer to my question, are you saying that there is no such thing as:

a is the reason for b or
a results in b​

in an atemporal environment?
No, I am just saying that you can create statements that if true would be contradictory.
Which is to say, you can line up a bunch of statements that are not logical.
That still does not answer my question (and you have been not answering this question for some time now)

Is there such a thing as:

a is the reason for b or
a results in b​

in an atemporal environment?
 
This is really a non sequitur. If a thing doesn't change, then it doesn't come from anywhere?
That would be non-sequitur if I had said that. But of course I didn't.

I said :

If the Universe is essentially static then there is no need to posit a source for it.​

and you interpreted it as:

If the Universe is essentially static then it does not have a source.​

Do you really think those statements are equivalent?

If you will recall one of your earlier premisses was that things which begin must have a source.

But even if the premiss were true then it would be redundant if it is not even clear that the Universe began.
Right, speculation is just plain wrong.
More misrepresentation.
Can YOU even believe that you wrote this?
I didn't write that. I wrote something else, then you cut out some of the words to make it sound like I said something else.

Can YOU even believe that you resorted to that pathetic deception?

I thought that sort of thing was reserved for theatres trying to make bad reviews sound good. You know the sort of thing "This show was the greatest ... in the history of theatre."
 
Last edited:
The capital letters denote sets, the small letters denote non-set elemental members.
And presumably "=" denotes assignation rather than equality?

But are you saying that the members of the set are not themselves sets?
If the ordering is maintained then set C = {a,b}
So order is significant in non-temporal change?
 
Last edited:
The survival of a distinct Jewish people and the existence of the State of Israel

are miraculous signs from God declaring His Supernatural Existence and the Truth of His Word.
Neither actually qualifies as miraculous. Cultural groups can survive without the help of supernatural powers.

States can be created without the help of supernatural powers.

A miracle is normally defined as something that could not have a naturalistic explanation.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom