Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
And a further question, which has been asked:

How do you wind up at a specific (in this case, the Christian) god from an unknown hypothesized first cause?

It's a non-sequitur (look that term up).

You assert that is must be a non-material (why?) and a spirit (why?) with no supporting arguments except for our ignorance of what came before Planck time.


Go back, and read the post I quoted.

Please respond.

i will copy the whole page of

http://www.everystudent.com/journeys/who2.html

since it explains it all.

This is the final installment in a series that began with Was There Ever Nothing?, followed by Something, then followed by Who. The primary points made in those studies are as follows:

(1) Absolutely Nothing never existed. If it had, there would still be Absolutely Nothing now. But Something Else exists. You, for example.

(2) Since Absolutely Nothing never existed, there was always a time when there was something in existence. This something we can call the Eternal Something. The Eternal Something has no beginning and no end, has no needs that It Itself cannot meet, can do whatever is possible that can be done, and will always be superior to anything It produces.

(3) The Eternal Something is not a machine, controlled or programmed by any force outside Itself. And the Eternal Something will not produce out of necessity, since It has no needs. Therefore, if It produces Something Else, It must decide to do so. That means that the Eternal Something has a will; thus, It is personal. Therefore, the Eternal Something must actually be an Eternal Someone (or Someones).

Edited by Locknar: 
Edited; please do not post entire passages (see your Membership Agreement, Rule 4)


6. When God untranscends, this is not the whole of Him, and yet it is still Him.

"The Father is greater than I." (John 14:28)

"I and the Father are one." (John 10:30)

"Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father." (John 14:9)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've skipped out on this since I realised that Gibhor doesn't have anything new and went into retard circular reasoning mode, that was around page 3, can anyone tell me, has he provided any evidence at all yet ?
thanks
 
I don't think that your god is an illusion,just an irrational belief.I've just never seen any evidence of his/her/it's existence.You have provided none so far.

So what or who do you think designed our universe ?
 
Wildly incorrect. The "quantum vacuum" is not a "sea of energy". As far as is observable, it truly is nothing, hence the term vacuum.

You can measure the effect caused by quantization (Casimir Effect), but you cannot measure the virtual particles nor the energy involved in their creation and destruction. They are simply mathematical/theoretical constructs set up to be easier for the layman to visualize.

However, these interactions can generate real subatomic particles and anti-particles or observable effects. In other words, you can get something from nothing. Just because we can slap a fancy label/equation/model on that nothing, doesn't make it a thing.

to create a vacuum you need space.
Space did only exist AFTER the big bang.
 
"You've got it backwards. Our life is "loaded" to favor the constants."
Fixt that fer ya.
Next time around, maybe not.
 
to create a vacuum. To have a vacuum you need space. Space did only exist AFTER the big bang.


To have quantum mechanics at all, you need space-time. However, space and time aren't "things", they are dimensions. In other words, without a reference frame in which to make measurements, it makes no sense to talk about quantization in the first place.

So are you now calling dimensions something as opposed to nothing? Vacuum is something as opposed to nothing?
 
Okay, to trace this particular argument to date....

Originally Posted by Maia
However, they will have to give up all of those illusions about a specific, anthropomorphic, personal, external God.

Gibhor:
What makes it so sure to you, the God i believe in, is a illusion ?

Originally Posted by dafydd
I don't think that your god is an illusion,just an irrational belief.I've just never seen any evidence of his/her/it's existence.You have provided none so far.

Gibhor:
So what or who do you think designed our universe ?

Gibhor, the answer is the same for both questions: just go and start reading the complete works of John Shelby Spong. Better get started. He's up to twenty books by now. (Hmmm, that seems to be pretty much my answer to everything lately... sometimes it makes more sense than others, such as when I'm asked "What's for breakfast?" ;) Life is accidental. The anthropomorphic God is an illusion. Humans stand alone, responsible for ourselves, for each other. Christianity is not for sissies.
 
what else do you suggest ?:rolleyes:
Bel Marduk, better than YHWH because

1. he didn't try to kill everyone on earth
2. he isn't vengeful (against humans)
3. he's way more virile an gets all the chicks and his son isn't a virgin
4. doesn't have a concept of hell
5. has a cool great red dragon as a pet which terrifies YHWH followers
6. didn't plagiarise large parts of his holy book from the Babylonians
7. enslaved YHWH's followers en masse proving YHWH is a big poof
8. he built the earth way faster than anyone else
9. his heaven is still attached to the planet and you can go visit
10. he is actually reliable

these are just tens reasons why my God is better than your god, if you require say another 50,000,000,000,000 reasons I could post some more
:D
 
Which only tells us how life can form, not how it can't.

Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun? On the surface of Pluto? In the rings of Saturn? No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth? If Pluto-based life is very improbable (which it is), than non-molecular/non-stellar based life is extremely improbable. It's a fairy tale, in other words.


To paraphrase, the problem with studying the universe is that there isn't anything we can compare it to.

There are models we can generate based on the values of the physical constants. These models can be compared to the universe.
 
Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun? On the surface of Pluto? In the rings of Saturn? No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth? If Pluto-based life is very improbable (which it is), than non-molecular/non-stellar based life is extremely improbable. It's a fairy tale, in other words.


How do you know there isn't life in those locations? And improbable = impossible. Hmm...

There are models we can generate based on the values of the physical constants. These models can be compared to the universe.


Which again only tells us something about life as we know it, not life as we do not know it.

For example, there are many people who believe in a god that exists "outside the universe". Does this mean by your comments here that such a god cannot possibly be alive?
 
I've skipped out on this since I realised that Gibhor doesn't have anything new and went into retard circular reasoning mode, that was around page 3, can anyone tell me, has he provided any evidence at all yet?

Not in the slightest -- just quotes dubious sources as if they made sense.
 
All specific outcomes are equally probable, but some outcomes are significant in that they are more plausible based on loaded dice (or an unfair toss).

5381171934857268493364748536411956727 has the same chance of coming up as
3333333333333333333333333333333333333

However, the string of 3's is much more probable on the theory that the dice are loaded or the person knows how to roll a 3 every time than on chance alone.

<snip>

But you are committing the circular logic fallacy. You are trying to show that the universe is fine-tuned; as part of your argument, you are saying that the string of 3s is a fine-tuned throw. Why would the string of 3s be any more likely to be a loaded throw than the random combination? Both are equally likely combinations.

So life could occur no matter what the constants are? Life with no stars ever forming? Non-molecular life? Life in a universe with nothing but hydrogen atoms? You can take that approach, but there is no evidence to support your position, and there is plenty of evidence to contradict it.

That's not what I was saying. I was saying that life, if it does grow to exist, can only ever see a set of circumstances which allowed it to come into being. I was making the sentient puddle argument.

Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun? On the surface of Pluto? In the rings of Saturn? No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth? If Pluto-based life is very improbable (which it is), than non-molecular/non-stellar based life is extremely improbable. It's a fairy tale, in other words.

Why do you believe that improbable equals impossible? Life could very well exist in these conditions. It does not, however, have to be life similar to us.
 
We do? I thought that we knew the history of the universe from now to when it was very very young.. before that our current knowledge breaks down. So no, we don't know this, unless you have something to substantiate that.

wrong.

http://www.thekeyboard.org.uk/What is infinity.htm

Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity. A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it. A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it. A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.

Can we have an infinite universe for example? The answer is no, the universe is finite.

Evidence that the energy was created at the big bang? Since we don't know what the conditions were that led to the big bang, this is an assumption.

we know nothing physical existed.

http://www.thekeyboard.org.uk/The Big Bang Theory.htm

An overwhelming weight of evidence has convinced cosmologists that the universe came into existence at a definite moment in time, some 13 billion years ago, in the form of a superhot, superdense fireball of energetic radiation. This is known as the Big Bang theory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom