Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are empirical observations supporting that virtual particles appear from nowhere.

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/quantum-fluctuations-t65.htm

Even if the total energy is not zero, matter could still be created spontaneously - but only for a very short time. According to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, we cannot determine energy and time precisely. Therefore, it is possible for a group of particles with non-zero total energy appear spontaneously and then disappear within a short time. The more the total energy is created, the shorter the lifetime. This process is known as the quantum fluctuation, which has been well confirmed by experiments.

In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested that our universe might originate from the quantum fluctuation. This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.

And your point is unrelated to the frame you're applying it to. You're talking creativity, not creation ex nihilo. To speak of the creation of matter is to speak of creation ex nihilo, about which we have no observations at all.

but we know the universe had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.

Energy flows from one form to the other.

energy is not eternal. it was created at the big bang event.... so it has a cause.

Any genuine knowledge you obtained must of necessity be obtained from information. What we lack the information to answer, we cannot answer. You're practicing the art of fooling youself.

we have that information. the universe itself tells us a lot about itself.

You have yet to establish that there was a prior to the Big Bang.

according to the big bang theory , there was no energy,matter,space, and time prior the big bang. .

Furthermore, this has absolutely nothing to do with material cause. Are you abusing terms? The material cause of the universe is the energy that it consists of.

of course not. the energy in our universe was created as well, at the big bang event. prior the big bang, no energy existed.

There is at yet no reason to believe this energy itself was created by anything, even external.

of course it is. the energy existing in our universe is not eternal, otherwise our universe would be already in a state of heath death.

It goes beyond the information we have, but all of the information we have has energy neither being created nor destroyed. You're inventing that energy needs to have been created. Which is mighty convenient, seeing as how that is what you're trying to show in the first place.

of course not.

http://doesgodexist.org/JulAug09/TheLawsofThermodynamics.html

The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die. The cosmos is not eternal, and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy. The biblical statement, that there was a beginning, is strongly attested to by the second law.


Wrong. According to Big Bang theory, time began at the BB singularity. There is no prior to T=0 within the context of BB.

i agree.

Irrelevant. Nothing within the Big Bang theory gives you minimal context, or even a suggestion, that the universe was created. You don't have time before big bang. There's no such thing, within the Big Bang theory, as T<0.

There might be a T<0. That would be a grander theory. But there might not be. Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.

thus, since you agree there was no time before the big bang, you agree that our universe had a absolute beginning. Thus, it must have had a cause.

http://www.everystudent.com/journeys/who2.html

(1) Absolutely Nothing never existed. If it had, there would still be Absolutely Nothing now. But Something Else exists. You, for example.

(2) Since Absolutely Nothing never existed, there was always a time when there was something in existence. This something we can call the Eternal Something. The Eternal Something has no beginning and no end, has no needs that It Itself cannot meet, can do whatever is possible that can be done, and will always be superior to anything It produces.

(3) The Eternal Something is not a machine, controlled or programmed by any force outside Itself. And the Eternal Something will not produce out of necessity, since It has no needs. Therefore, if It produces Something Else, It must decide to do so. That means that the Eternal Something has a will; thus, It is personal. Therefore, the Eternal Something must actually be an Eternal Someone (or Someones).
 
Last edited:
Even if the total energy is not zero, matter could still be created spontaneously - but only for a very short time. According to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, we cannot determine energy and time precisely. Therefore, it is possible for a group of particles with non-zero total energy appear spontaneously and then disappear within a short time. The more the total energy is created, the shorter the lifetime. This process is known as the quantum fluctuation, which has been well confirmed by experiments.

In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested that our universe might originate from the quantum fluctuation. This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.


You have posted this before. It was wrong then and it continues to be wrong now.
 
GIBHOR, wrong. Having a beginning does not mean having a cause. If time began at T=0, why does this entail that time was caused? Especially since you have no information at all about creation ex nihilo?

In fact, virtual particles, mentioned by multiple people here, pop into existence uncaused all of the time. So in terms of evidence, the only things we see coming into existence, come into existence uncaused.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/3925361/Strobel-Lee-The-Case-for-a-Creator

Quantum theory ... holds that a vacuum ... is subject to quantum uncertainties. This means that things can materialize out of the vacuum, although they tend to vanish back into it quickly... . Theoretically, anything-a dog, a house, a planet-can pop into existence by means of this quantum quirk, which physicists call a vacuum fluctuation. Probability, however, dictates that pairs of subatomic particles ... are by far the most likely creations and that they will last extremely briefly.... The spontaneous, persistent creation of something even as large as a molecule is profoundly unlikely. Nevertheless, in 1973 an assistant professor at Columbia University named Edward Tryon suggested that the entire universe might have come into existence this way.... The whole universe may be, to use [MIT physicist Alan] Guth's phrase, "a free lunch."20
I closed the magazine and tossed it on Craig's desk. "Maybe Tryon was right when he said, `I offer the modest proposal that our universe is simply one of those things which happen from time to time.' “
Craig was listening intently. "Okay, that's a good question," he replied. "These subatomic particles the article talks about are called `virtual particles.' They are theoretical entities, and it's not even clear that they actually exist as opposed to being merely theoretical constructs.
"However, there's a much more important point to be made about this. You see, these particles, if they are real, do not come out of nothing. The quantum vacuum is not what most people envision when they think of a vacuum-that is, absolutely nothing. On the contrary, it's a sea of fluctuating energy, an arena of violent activity that has a rich physical structure and can be described by physical laws. These particles are thought to originate by fluctuations of the energy in the vacuum.
"So it's not an example of something coming into being out of nothing, or something coming into being without a cause. The quantum vacuum and the energy locked up in the vacuum are the cause of these particles. And then we have to ask, well, what is the origin of the whole quantum vacuum itself? Where does it come from?"
He let that question linger before continuing. "You've simply pushed back the issue of creation. Now you've got to account for how this very active ocean of fluctuating energy came into being. Do you see what I'm saying? If quantum physical laws operate within the domain described by quantum physics, you can't legitimately use quantum physics to explain the origin of that domain itself. You need something transcendent that's beyond that domain in order to explain how the entire domain came into being. Suddenly, we're back to the origins question."

That's not to say that the universe is uncaused either--we simply have no information. But you're flunking at enumerating the possibilities--for the same reason that your number 3 in your previous post begged the question over and over and over.

that is, frankly spoken, a shameless and willfullingly ignorant position.

http://www.doesgodexist.org/Pamphlets/Mansproof.html

If we know the creation has a beginning, we are faced with another logical question--was the creation caused or was it not caused? The Bible states, "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth." Not only does the Bible maintain that there was a cause (a creation) but it also tells us what the cause was. It was God. The atheist tells us that "matter is self-existing and not created." If matter had a beginning and yet was uncaused, one must logically maintain that something would have had to come into existence out of nothing. From empty space with no force, no matter, no energy, and no intelligence, matter would have to become existent. Even if this could happen by some strange new process unknown to science today, there is a logical problem.

In order for matter to come out of nothing, all of our scientific laws dealing with the conservation of matter/energy would have to be wrong, invalidating all of chemistry. All of our laws of conservation of angular momentum would have to be wrong, invalidating all of physics. All of our laws of conservation of electric charge would have to be wrong, invalidating all of electronics and demanding that your TV set not work! Your television set may not work, but that is not the reason! In order to believe matter is uncaused, one has to discard known laws and principles of science. No reasonable person is going to do this simply to maintain a personal atheistic position.

The atheist's assertion that matter is eternal is wrong. The atheist's assertion that the universe is uncaused and selfexisting is also incorrect. The Bible's assertion that there was a beginning which was caused is supported strongly by the available scientific evidence.

Infinity is irrelevant, and this is pure speculation. Nevertheless, the suggestion that there is no actual infinity works against you--what does there being no actual infinite say about God?

its very clear. The universe had a absolute beginning, thus God.
 
GIBHOR:

If, for the sake of argument, we accept your answer for the origin of the universe (to wit: God), what, if anything, does that tell us regarding the universe?

What knowledge does it add to our understanding of how things work?
What processes does it shed light on?
What new areas of research does it lead us into?
What new knowledge do we gain?

Why should we just stop and answer "God" just because the origin of the universe prior to 10-43 seconds in currently unknown?



And a further question, which has been asked:

How do you wind up at a specific (in this case, the Christian) god from an unknown hypothesized first cause?

It's a non-sequitur (look that term up).

You assert that is must be a non-material (why?) and a spirit (why?) with no supporting arguments except for our ignorance of what came before Planck time.


Go back, and read the post I quoted.

Please respond.
 
What makes it so sure to you, the God i believe in, is a illusion ?

I don't think that your god is an illusion,just an irrational belief.I've just never seen any evidence of his/her/it's existence.You have provided none so far.
 
Quantum theory ... holds that a vacuum ... is subject to quantum uncertainties. This means that things can materialize out of the vacuum, although they tend to vanish back into it quickly... . Theoretically, anything-a dog, a house, a planet-can pop into existence by means of this quantum quirk, which physicists call a vacuum fluctuation. Probability, however, dictates that pairs of subatomic particles ... are by far the most likely creations and that they will last extremely briefly.... The spontaneous, persistent creation of something even as large as a molecule is profoundly unlikely. Nevertheless, in 1973 an assistant professor at Columbia University named Edward Tryon suggested that the entire universe might have come into existence this way.... The whole universe may be, to use [MIT physicist Alan] Guth's phrase, "a free lunch."20
I closed the magazine and tossed it on Craig's desk. "Maybe Tryon was right when he said, `I offer the modest proposal that our universe is simply one of those things which happen from time to time.' “
Craig was listening intently. "Okay, that's a good question," he replied. "These subatomic particles the article talks about are called `virtual particles.' They are theoretical entities, and it's not even clear that they actually exist as opposed to being merely theoretical constructs.
"However, there's a much more important point to be made about this. You see, these particles, if they are real, do not come out of nothing. The quantum vacuum is not what most people envision when they think of a vacuum-that is, absolutely nothing. On the contrary, it's a sea of fluctuating energy, an arena of violent activity that has a rich physical structure and can be described by physical laws. These particles are thought to originate by fluctuations of the energy in the vacuum.
"So it's not an example of something coming into being out of nothing, or something coming into being without a cause. The quantum vacuum and the energy locked up in the vacuum are the cause of these particles. And then we have to ask, well, what is the origin of the whole quantum vacuum itself? Where does it come from?"
He let that question linger before continuing. "You've simply pushed back the issue of creation. Now you've got to account for how this very active ocean of fluctuating energy came into being. Do you see what I'm saying? If quantum physical laws operate within the domain described by quantum physics, you can't legitimately use quantum physics to explain the origin of that domain itself. You need something transcendent that's beyond that domain in order to explain how the entire domain came into being. Suddenly, we're back to the origins question."


Wildly incorrect. The "quantum vacuum" is not a "sea of energy". As far as is observable, it truly is nothing, hence the term vacuum.

You can measure the effect caused by quantization (Casimir Effect), but you cannot measure the virtual particles nor the energy involved in their creation and destruction. They are simply mathematical/theoretical constructs set up to be easier for the layman to visualize.

However, these interactions can generate real subatomic particles and anti-particles or observable effects. In other words, you can get something from nothing. Just because we can slap a fancy label/equation/model on that nothing, doesn't make it a thing.
 
but we know the universe had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.

We do? I thought that we knew the history of the universe from now to when it was very very young.. before that our current knowledge breaks down. So no, we don't know this, unless you have something to substantiate that.

energy is not eternal. it was created at the big bang event.... so it has a cause.

Evidence that the energy was created at the big bang? Since we don't know what the conditions were that led to the big bang, this is an assumption.

according to the big bang theory , there was no energy,matter,space, and time prior the big bang.

Please show where the big bang theory says this. Your idea of BBT might say this...

It seems that you are basing a lot of what you are saying on a flawed view of big bang theory.
 
HA!

[qimg]http://gatherer.wizards.com/Handlers/Image.ashx?multiverseid=110504&type=card[/qimg]

See you next game, mate.

Don't count your DCI points until the game is over, buddy. As it stands, the Pact of Negation left me with sufficient mana reserves to be able to cast:

mindbreak.jpg


Which should put paid to your delusions of victory.

If it is not a spirit, than it is not a personal being. Thus it could be the universe itself. But the universe is finite in time. And the origin cannot be material/energy, and bent to time, since all these did not exist. Therefor it had to be a bodyless, eternal spirit.

So... it can't be the universe, so it must be intelligent? :s

whatelse do you suggest ?

Either an unintelligent cause or no cause.
 
If it is not a spirit, than it is not a personal being. Thus it could be the universe itself. But the universe is finite in time. And the origin cannot be material/energy, and bent to time, since all these did not exist. Therefor it had to be a bodyless, eternal spirit.

Or it could be something else just as mindless. A crunch of the previous universe. A collision of two other previous universes. A fluctuation in a universe with more than 4 dimension, where the energy in ours simply came from a different place in that one. Whatever. E.g., a commonly used phrasing from the string theory camp is that our universe is what happens when two multi-dimensional branes collide. (Which actually sounds a lot less awesome when you understand what a brane is, but I digress;))

At any rate, if you want to claim you know what or who did it, you get to present evidence of exactly that. Where is it?

whatelse do you suggest ?

The question is not what I suggest, since science isn't a "who invents the nicest story" contest. The question is what is supported by evidence. And if you have any actual evidence of a _god_, please do provide it.

The big bang theory is that evidence. Energy was created at the beginning of the Big Bang. Energy is not eternal.

1. "Energy is not eternal" is just one of your unsupported postulates. What science has is, on the contrary, conservation of energy. Sure, you must count matter too in the total, but the total is, by all evidence we have, a constant. There is no energy created, ever, and there is no energy destroyed, ever.

Now if you can prove that energy can be created, go for it. You'd probably get a Nobel prize.

But you don't get to use it as a premise before you show that it's true.

2. The Big Bang isn't as clear cut as you seem to think. It's an extrapolation backwards, and supported by good data too, but it gets awfully fuzzy around that moment zero. I don't think anyone can support an extrapolation all the way to zero, or show that that energy was created or where it came from. Or not more than a personal opinion.

At any rate, there is still a valid field of study around that moment zero.

3. None of the Big Bang models actually postulate the creation of energy. The whole "problem" that gave rise to the Big Bang is that you end up with the whole energy of the present one, in a zero-sized space. You get infinite temperature and density, at a finite time in the past. There is no moment where there is zero energy, or not in this universe.

4. And again, nobody can tell if such a zero size universe actually existed, or there was a finite non-zero minimum size that always existed, or what. Our extrapolations only go to the (tiny, dense and damn hot) moment when the universe cooled down enough to stop being opaque. We're separated the hard way from observing anything from before that point, background microwave radiation included.

3. There is an even newer theory (as in: brand new) that actually decouples space from time at high energies, and it actually seems to predict orbits marginally better than GR _and_ explain universe expansion without dark energy: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=splitting-time-from-space

A consequence of it also seems to be that the universe _will_ bounce back into a small (but non-zero) space eventually, contrary to what the current accelerated expansion seems to indicate.

And if that proves true (and again, it looks promising so far), then there was no moment zero at all. We're back to a pulsing universe model. The universe has essentially always existed, only periodically it collapses and expands. There is no start, any more than you could say there is a start to a sine wave.

If my presented evidence is not evidence for you, i cannot help you....

It`s not a matter of "for me", but rather of how logic works.

Paul Charles William Davies AM (born 22 April 1946) is an English physicist, writer and broadcaster, currently a professor at Arizona State University as well as the Director of BEYOND: Center for Fundamental Concepts in Science.

elshamah.heavenforum.com/atheist-scientists-and-authors-f13/paul-davies-t201.htm

The balloon – space – has simply disappeared. Play this scenario in forward time and it represents the coming-into-being of a universe from literally nothing, with space itself appearing. So it’s not an explosion in a pre-existing space. Space itself appears. And so, for that matter, does time. Einstein taught us that space and time are intimately interwoven. Where one goes the other goes. There can be no time without space. If space comes into existence abruptly at the big bang, then time comes into existence abruptly, too.

What does this mean? It means that there was no time before the big bang. This is an absolutely fundamental point.

While that _is_ a valid hypothesis,

A) It doesn't mean what you seem to think. Essentially it means the same as "the universe always existed". There is no point in time where the universe didn't exist, any more than there is a point on Earth north of the North Pole.

B) For that matter, it makes the question of a God that existed _before_ the start of the universe, completely senseless. A God that existed before time is a nice metaphor, but there is no such thing as a "before time" for that god to be in. It's akin to having a number of teeth less than zero, or a Santa whose workshop is north of the North Pole, or a room that's darker than zero light, or a point deeper than the centre of the Earth. Just because you can construct a meaningless extrapolation or metaphor, doesn't mean you can use it as a fact.

C) Again, I don't think he can actually support extrapolating all the way to exactly zero with any degree of certainty either.

D) Well, you still get to present evidence if you want to squeeze God in there. He at least has a valid extrapolation based on measured data, even though past a point it's really fundamentally just an extrapolation. I don't think you have even that much data to support squeezing God in there.

there is no special pleading. Simply , because the universe has a meta-physical origin anyway, or its a efficient cause, i.e. God, or its a unefficient one, absolutely no thing.

Hmm? How'd you get metaphysics in there anyway? Plus, is it just me, or is that supporting the special pleading by a false dichotomy?
 
If that pi result came up -every time-, there could be a significance to that, but once in a jabillion attempts, it means nothing, other than being one of the jabillion ways a result could be obtained.
And I get fooled a lot more times than 1/10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0?

Actually, given the age of the universe, it's physically impossible to roll ten D10's enough times to where a Pi result is even remotely likely. If the dice were rolled a trillion times a year for 14 billion years, the odds of a Pi toss would still be. 1/1000000000000000000000000000 (give or take a zero). A Pi result is so much more probable on the theory of loaded dice (or a biased toss, or some other interference from some mathematically minded agent), that believing the dice were fair would make belief in the FSM downright rational.

This might be a good topic for a new thread: are sufficiently improbable results less believable than miracles? Are some odds so long that it's always irrational to believe they happened by chance?
 
Actually, given the age of the universe, it's physically impossible to roll ten D10's enough times to where a Pi result is even remotely likely. If the dice were rolled a trillion times a year for 14 billion years, the odds of a Pi toss would still be. 1/1000000000000000000000000000 (give or take a zero). A Pi result is so much more probable on the theory of loaded dice (or a biased toss, or some other interference from some mathematically minded agent), that believing the dice were fair would make belief in the FSM downright rational.

This might be a good topic for a new thread: are sufficiently improbable results less believable than miracles? Are some odds so long that it's always irrational to believe they happened by chance?

Given the age of the universe, it would be physically impossible to roll ten d10s enough times to where ANY result is even remotely likely.
 
The chances of any given flip are 50/50, so the chances of the 101st toss being heads after the previous 100 being tails are still 50/50. The chances of coming up with 100 consecutive tails followed by 1 head are another thing altogether. The odds of any given configuration of coin toss results are the same as any other set of results of the same number of iterations. This still assumes a fair coin and flipping process. Again, whatever the odds, it is more implausible for it never to happen at all than to occur.

The thing about plausibility and odds is, you need to know what goes into it to assess them. Toss a double headed coin and your chances of coming up with a head are 100%. If you're trying to make some sort of statement about the universe, you should bear in mind that if you don't know what went into it, you cannot speak of whether the event or parameter is "plausible" or not, or what the odds are.

I never said anything about a fair coin or fair toss. If the only information you have is that coin X has landed heads 100 times in a row, would you really think the coin (or toss) was fair?

That's what's at stake with the FT argument: was the beginning of the universe a "fair toss", or were the constants "loaded" to favor life?
 
I never said anything about a fair coin or fair toss. If the only information you have is that coin X has landed heads 100 times in a row, would you really think the coin (or toss) was fair?

That's what's at stake with the FT argument: was the beginning of the universe a "fair toss", or were the constants "loaded" to favor life?

You've got it backwards. Life is "loaded" to favor the constants.
 
Given the age of the universe, it would be physically impossible to roll ten d10s enough times to where ANY result is even remotely likely.

All specific outcomes are equally probable, but some outcomes are significant in that they are more plausible based on loaded dice (or an unfair toss).

5381171934857268493364748536411956727 has the same chance of coming up as
3333333333333333333333333333333333333

However, the string of 3's is much more probable on the theory that the dice are loaded or the person knows how to roll a 3 every time than on chance alone. I always use poker for an example:
2d, 2s, 4h, Jh, Kc has the same chance of occuring as
10s, Js, Ks, Qs, As
Right?
Would you stay in a poker game if the dealer deals himself five royal flushes in a row? After all, those five royal flushes have the same odds of occuring as five particular junk hands. But the royal flushes are much more probable on the theory "the dealer is cheating" than chance alone.
 
You've got it backwards. Life is "loaded" to favor the constants.

So life could occur no matter what the constants are? Life with no stars ever forming? Non-molecular life? Life in a universe with nothing but hydrogen atoms? You can take that approach, but there is no evidence to support your position, and there is plenty of evidence to contradict it.
 
So life could occur no matter what the constants are? Life with no stars ever forming? Non-molecular life? Life in a universe with nothing but hydrogen atoms? You can take that approach, but there is no evidence to support your position, and there is plenty of evidence to contradict it.


Such as?

I would have said there is no evidence either way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom