Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
wrong.

http://www.thekeyboard.org.uk/What is infinity.htm

Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity. A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it. A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it. A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.

Can we have an infinite universe for example? The answer is no, the universe is finite.

Wasn't this word-for-word post refuted earlier in the thread?

we know nothing physical existed.

http://www.thekeyboard.org.uk/The Big Bang Theory.htm

An overwhelming weight of evidence has convinced cosmologists that the universe came into existence at a definite moment in time, some 13 billion years ago, in the form of a superhot, superdense fireball of energetic radiation. This is known as the Big Bang theory.

We can trace the history of our universe back until the Big Bang. How that singularity came into existence it doesn't say. It could be the first time one like that has happened, or it could be the result of a Big Crunch in an earlier universe (the universe may be cyclical).
 
What does this mean? It means that there was no time before the big bang. This is an absolutely fundamental point.

A fundamental point that you as yet do not grasp the significance of. There is no "before" the Big Bang. According to Stephen Hawking, whom you quoted in an attempt to support your argument, the universe can be analogized as the surface of a sphere, finite and boundless. There is no creation, it simply is.
 
Or it could be something else just as mindless. A crunch of the previous universe. A collision of two other previous universes. A fluctuation in a universe with more than 4 dimension, where the energy in ours simply came from a different place in that one. Whatever. E.g., a commonly used phrasing from the string theory camp is that our universe is what happens when two multi-dimensional branes collide. (Which actually sounds a lot less awesome when you understand what a brane is, but I digress;))

At any rate, if you want to claim you know what or who did it, you get to present evidence of exactly that. Where is it?

Even if we assume there was a other universe prior to ours, it could not be infinite. It had to be finite. Thus the same scenario will apply again. What cause it ?

The question is not what I suggest, since science isn't a "who invents the nicest story" contest. The question is what is supported by evidence. And if you have any actual evidence of a _god_, please do provide it.

I have united a lot of evidence at my personal virtual library.

Arguments for the Existence of God

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/doe...f10/arguments-for-the-existence-of-god-t5.htm

1. "Energy is not eternal" is just one of your unsupported postulates.
What science has is, on the contrary, conservation of energy. Sure, you must count matter too in the total, but the total is, by all evidence we have, a constant. There is no energy created, ever, and there is no energy destroyed, ever.

then it would be eternal. thus, we would not exist, but our universe would be in a state of heath death.

http://doesgodexist.org/JulAug09/TheLawsofThermodynamics.html

This statement of the second law is known as the Clausius statement, and what it describes is heat death. In any closed system, things tend to move toward a condition of disorder--called entropy. The law does not say that energy is destroyed--that would violate the first law. It simply says that there is always some energy that cannot be recovered in any physical process. Things always move toward a condition of disorder.

A consequence of it also seems to be that the universe _will_ bounce back into a small (but non-zero) space eventually, contrary to what the current accelerated expansion seems to indicate.

And if that proves true (and again, it looks promising so far), then there was no moment zero at all. We're back to a pulsing universe model. The universe has essentially always existed, only periodically it collapses and expands. There is no start, any more than you could say there is a start to a sine wave.

http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/ast...tiong-model-of-the-universe-possible-t119.htm

pg.76 a case for a creator

in order for the universe to oscillate, it has to contract at some point. For this to happen, the universe would have to be dense enough to generate sufficient gravity that would eventually slow its expansion to a halt and then, with increasing rapidity, contract it into a big crunch. But estimates have consistently indicated that the universe is far below the density needed to contract, even when you include not only its luminous matter, but also all of the invisible dark matter as well.
"Recent tests, run by five different laboratories in 1998, calculated a ninety-five-percent certainty that the universe will not contract, but that it will expand forever. In fact, in a completely unexpected development, the studies indicated that the expansion is not decelerating, but it's actually accelerating. This really puts the nails in the coffin for the Oscillating Model.
"And one more problem: even if physics allowed the universe to contract, scientific studies have shown that entropy would be conserved from one cycle to the next. This would have the effect of each expansion getting bigger and bigger and bigger. Now, trace that backwards in time and what do you get? They get smaller and smaller and smaller, until you finally come to the smallest cycle-and then the beginning of the universe. So Joseph Silk, in his book The Big Bang, estimates that even if the universe were oscillating, it could not have gone through more than a hundred previous oscillations prior to today."37
All of this did, indeed, seem to doom this theory.

Hmm? How'd you get metaphysics in there anyway? Plus, is it just me, or is that supporting the special pleading by a false dichotomy?

since the physical universe started with the big bang, whatever caused it to come into being, had to be meta-physical anyway.
 
Last edited:
Bel Marduk, better than YHWH because

1. he didn't try to kill everyone on earth
2. he isn't vengeful (against humans)
3. he's way more virile an gets all the chicks and his son isn't a virgin
4. doesn't have a concept of hell
5. has a cool great red dragon as a pet which terrifies YHWH followers
6. didn't plagiarise large parts of his holy book from the Babylonians
7. enslaved YHWH's followers en masse proving YHWH is a big poof
8. he built the earth way faster than anyone else
9. his heaven is still attached to the planet and you can go visit
10. he is actually reliable

these are just tens reasons why my God is better than your god, if you require say another 50,000,000,000,000 reasons I could post some more
:D

Unfortunately, Marduk did not become men , did not die for the sins of all humanity on the cross, and did not prove to be God through ressurrection.
therefore, i prefere to believe in Jesus Christ as the alpha and omega, creator of heavens, and the earth. :)
 
A fundamental point that you as yet do not grasp the significance of. There is no "before" the Big Bang. According to Stephen Hawking, whom you quoted in an attempt to support your argument, the universe can be analogized as the surface of a sphere, finite and boundless. There is no creation, it simply is.

if it is boundless, it HAS a absolute beginning.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/3925361/Strobel-Lee-The-Case-for-a-Creator

page 78

HAWKING'S CHALLENGE

Most developments in cosmology live an obscure existence within the pages of arcane scientific journals, with only a few-often, the most outlandish ones-receiving even the briefest mention in the popular press. Luminaries in the field, such as Linde and Guth, are hardly household names. But when Stephen William Hawking speaks, the public listens.
A theoretical physicist who is currently the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University, a post once held by Sir Isaac Newton, Hawking has become a science icon. He has sold millions of copies of A Brief History of Time, although Business Week once quipped that the book is "the least-read best-seller ever."40 His celebrity status was validated when he achieved cartoon form on The Simpsons and played a cameo role on Star Trek, where he challenged a holographic Einstein to a game of chess.
Hawking, who uses a wheelchair for mobility and a synthesizer for speech due to a progressive neuromuscular disease, has been on a quest for the elusive Theory of Everything, which would unify general relativity with quantum theory. Along the way, he has proposed a quantum gravity model for the universe that he says eliminates the need for a singularity-that is, the Big Bang.
When actress Shirley MacLaine asked Hawking whether he believes God created the universe, he replied simply, "No.”41 He told the BBC: "We are such insignificant creatures on a minor planet of a very average star in the outer suburbs of one of a hundred thousand million galaxies. So it is difficult to believe in a God that would care about us or even notice our existence."42
In a chapter called "The Origin and Fate of the Universe" in A Brief History of Time, Hawking says: "So long as the universe had a beginning, we could suppose it had a creator. But if the universe is really completely self-contained, having no boundary or edge, it would have neither beginning nor end: it would simply be. What place, then, for a creator?"43
I broached Hawking's theory to Craig. "It sure sounds like he has finally managed to put God out of business," I said. "Not quite," replied Craig.
When I asked him to explain why not, Craig pulled a piece of paper and pen out of his top drawer. "Let me draw you two pictures that will clarify what I mean," he said.
"The standard Big Bang theory can be represented by a cone," he said, drawing what looked like an empty sugar cone from BaskinRobbins. "The point of the cone represents the beginning of the universe-the singularity where the Big Bang occurred. It's the beginning point, and it has a sharp edge to it.44 The expansion of the universe, as it gets older and grows, is represented by the cone's overall expanding shape."
I nodded that I was tracking with him. Then he took a second sheet of paper and began drawing a picture of Hawking's theory. "Hawking's model is like a cone, too, except it doesn't come to a point." He drew a picture of what resembled a badminton birdie; instead of coming to a sharp point, the end of the cone was rounded.
"As you can see, there's no singularity. There's no sharp edge. If you were to start at the mouth of the cone and go backward in time," he said, his pencil tracing the long side of the cone, "you would not come back to a beginning point. You would simply follow the curveand suddenly you would find yourself heading forward in time again."
This was consistent with the way Hawking's biographers envisioned his theory. They said it would be like walking northward until you reach the North Pole, and then suddenly, if you keep
walking, you find yourself heading south.45 "There is no beginning and no endno boundaries," one writer explained. "The universe always was, always is, and always shall be."46
Craig put down his pencil. "Presto!" I exclaimed as I looked at his drawing. "No beginning, no singularity, no Big Bang-no need for God."
Craig grimaced. "Let's think about this for a minute before you come to that conclusion," he said.

THE WORLD OF IMAGINARY NUMBERS

"Has Hawking made a mistake?" I asked. The mere suggestion sounded impossible!
"I think he has made a philosophical error by thinking that having a beginning entails having a beginning point. And that's simply not the case," Craig replied.
He pointed toward his rendering of Hawking's model. "Granted, there isn't any singular point here, but notice this: the universe is still finite in its past. It still has a beginning in the sense that something has a finite past duration. In other words, pick an interval of timesay, a second, a minute, or a year. For any finite interval of time you pick, there are only a finite number of equal intervals prior to that time. And in that sense, Hawking's model has a beginning. Even he says that the universe has an origin out of nothing in the sense that there's absolutely nothing that comes before it.
"So this would be an example of a model that has a beginning but doesn't involve a singularity. That's what many scientists are trying to come up with, because the laws of physics would apply all the way back. They don't break down in a singularity. And that's more palatable to them."
Before I could ask another question, Craig added: "Now, I've been taking Hawking's model at face value, but it's also important to note that he is only able to achieve this rounding-off effect by substituting `imaginary numbers' for real numbers in his equations."
"What are imaginary numbers?"
"They are multiples of the square root of negative one," he said. "In this model, they have the effect of turning time into a dimension of space. The problem is that when imaginary numbers are employed, they're just computational devices used to grease the equations and get the result the mathematician wants. That's fine, but when you want to get a real, physical result, you have to convert the imaginary numbers into real ones. But Hawking refuses to convert them. He just keeps everything in the imaginary realm."
"What happens if you convert the numbers into real ones?"
"Presto, the singularity reappears!" Craig said. "In fact, the singularity is really there the whole time; it's just hidden behind the device of so-called imaginary time. Hawking concedes this in a subsequent book he co-authored with Roger Penrose.47 He said he doesn't pretend to be describing reality, because he says he doesn't know what reality is. So Hawking himself recognizes that this is not a realistic description of the universe or its origin; it's merely a mathematical way of modeling the beginning of the universe in such a manner that the singularity doesn't appear."
 
Last edited:
I never said anything about a fair coin or fair toss. If the only information you have is that coin X has landed heads 100 times in a row, would you really think the coin (or toss) was fair?

That's what's at stake with the FT argument: was the beginning of the universe a "fair toss", or were the constants "loaded" to favor life?

There isn't enough information known to even properly ask a question like that, let alone answer it.

To examine the "fair toss" aspect, we'd need to understand what sides of the dice there are (if any!), how they're weighted, and what factors influence the outcome, both in terms of other universal parameters and possibly (IMO, likely) environmental parameters in the external environment. All that we know, however, is what we observe. And of course, if we can't say anything about those parameters other than what we can observe about them, how can we determine if they're loaded?

Your coin toss scenario has its merits in that sure, it's only natural to question the strange and unusual. But you've failed to establish that the apparent "fine-tuning" we see is strange and unusual.

First there is the obvious point that we should not be surprised to see that the universe supports us, because if it didn't, we wouldn't be observing it to begin with. Assuming that there are a billion different configurations of all the universal parameters and only one of them supported us, the only one we would ever observe is that very one. Why would we be amazed to see it? You coin example is a poor analogy to the universe because it divides the possibilities into the universe being variable, and thus we're lucky, or the universe's variables being rigged so that they favor our existence. But reality isn't necessarily like that. So in addition to the very correct fact that we'll never be in a position to ponder a universe that cannot support us, for all we know, the universe isn't variable at all and the one we have is the only one we could have had -- as if the coins only had heads on them, not rigged, but by their nature. Your argument is a false analogy, false dichotomy, and begs the question as well by suggesting that if any positive result is rigged, the result was positive, and therefore it was rigged.

Further, you suggest this as if there were only a single iteration. If I show you a video of a guy tossing a coin 100 times and getting heads on each flip, you're naturally suspicious. If I show you a few million videos of that same guy attempting that same trick and only one of those videos has a success, you won't be. In stating this coin analogy, you're making the assumption that there aren't currently or haven't been the equivalent of these million iterations of universes.

And what has been said about basic probability still stands in addition to everything above: the odds of any given result from a set of possible permutations is as likely as any other. If five coins are flipped in succession, the result sets...

HHHHH

is as likely as

TTTTT

is as likely as

HTHHT

is as likely as

THTTH

and so on. We shouldn't be surprised to see any of these combinations, no matter how "unlikely" our arbitrary biases lead us to question them. What's more, they are as likely to appear in any order. So, back to the universe, even if there were only one iteration of a universe and there are a multitude of permutations incapable of supporting life, it could very well happen on the first try.

But the major theme here, Malerin, is that your argument relies on multiple lines of major, unwarranted assumption.
 
if it is boundless, it HAS a absolute beginning.

Then, again, please tell me where the beginning of the surface of a sphere is.

It's curious that you would first cite Hawking in support of your argument and then turn to refuting him in support of your argument. At any rate, William Lane Craig doesn't seem to understand Hawking any better than you do. Even if there is a singularity at the Big Bang it does not follow that the universe came from nothing. A singularity is not nothing.
 
Unfortunately, Marduk did not become men , did not die for the sins of all humanity on the cross, and did not prove to be God through ressurrection.
therefore, i prefere to believe in Jesus Christ as the alpha and omega, creator of heavens, and the earth. :)

You have proof that Jeshua ben Joseph rose from the dead?
 
i will copy the whole page of

http://www.everystudent.com/journeys/who2.html

since it explains it all.


What a load of ill-supported non-sequitur-riddled rubbish.

And that is my considered opinion after actually reading that tripe.




Now that you've tried and failed* to answer my second question, how about addressing the first one?

What does the "god" bandaid explain?
What knowledge do we gain from it?
Why should we accept the "god of ignorance" argument this time, when it's been tried before for many things and failed each and every time to provide knowledge, understanding, or explanation?



I leave you with an ear worm:
If this uncaused creator, existing before time, caused the time and the universe to come into being, and if time is a requirement of causality (it is), how did this creator cause anything to happen without time to enable cause and effect?
This includes, of course, creating time.

But please, don't answer this until you've considered my earlier post, here





* I say failed not only because the arguments provided were pathetic and invalid, but also because you didn't even try to answer it yourself. Instead, you quoted an inane piece of drivel, rather than state anything in your own words.
 
Last edited:
I have united a lot of evidence at my personal virtual library.

You know, I have labored through reading the 10 pages and your tourtured logic..
and many people have been kind enough to address you're more complex ramblings,

But I keep going back to this simple statement above.

You see, the problem IS that, based on your posts regarding the word EVIDENCE -


Well Inigo Montoya said it better than I
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2y8Sx4B2Sk
 
Last edited:
You know, I have labored through reading the 10 pages and your tourtured logic..
and many people have been kind enough to address you're more complex ramblings,

But I keep going back to this simple statement above.

You see, the problem IS that, based on your posts regarding the word EVIDENCE -


Well Inigo Montoya said it better than I
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2y8Sx4B2Sk
.
:D
There's a herd of words Zsa Zsa doesn't understand, yet fills up pages with them.:p
Over and over and over and over and over...
 

Not wrong, nothing in that link proves that the universe had a beginning with a cause and "before" that beginning there was nothing.

You said BBT says this, please show where big bang theory actually says what you claim. An actual scientific source, since you are saying science is saying something.

Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity. A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it. A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it. A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.

1) We know the theory of relativity is incomplete. If you work GR and the universe backwards through time to t=0 you get a singularity; which is doesn't mean something with infinite density, it means "undefined". Which means that the current theories are inadequate to describe the universe at its initial state and how it came to be at that initial state. So to claim that BBT says something about the universe's initial state or "before" that state is false, because the math clearly doesn't.

2) I don't know why you are giving an example of a black hole, no one claims that a black hole's mass is infinite, even in "the maths". That doesn't have any relevance to the universe.

Can we have an infinite universe for example? The answer is no, the universe is finite.

Could be either, GR is no limitation to this. You haven't provided any good reason for it to not be infinite, and BBT certainly allows for a finite or an infinite universe.


Nothing in that link says we know nothing physical existed before the big bang. Again it's an extremely simplistic overview, I'm asking for scientific evidence to support your position. Should be easy since you say science says it.

An overwhelming weight of evidence has convinced cosmologists that the universe came into existence at a definite moment in time, some 13 billion years ago, in the form of a superhot, superdense fireball of energetic radiation. This is known as the Big Bang theory.

No, there's an overwhelming weight of evidence that has convinced cosmologists that the universe was very small and very dense 13 billion years ago and then expanded rapidly.

These other things you claim cosmologists say though are false, you just use them because they happen to support your position.

In fact here's a cosmologist explicitly saying that science currently does NOT know what happened:

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2007/04/27/how-did-the-universe-start/

I’m on record as predicting that we’ll understand what happened at the Big Bang within fifty years. Not just the “Big Bang model” — the paradigm of a nearly-homogeneous universe expanding from an early hot, dense, state, which has been established beyond reasonable doubt — but the Bang itself, that moment at the very beginning.
 
Your coin toss scenario has its merits in that sure, it's only natural to question the strange and unusual. But you've failed to establish that the apparent "fine-tuning" we see is strange and unusual.

There's a very long thread devoted to that, probably before you arrived. You can use forum search for it.
 
And what has been said about basic probability still stands in addition to everything above: the odds of any given result from a set of possible permutations is as likely as any other. If five coins are flipped in succession, the result sets...

HHHHH

is as likely as

TTTTT

is as likely as

HTHHT

is as likely as

THTTH

and so on. We shouldn't be surprised to see any of these combinations, no matter how "unlikely" our arbitrary biases lead us to question them. What's more, they are as likely to appear in any order. So, back to the universe, even if there were only one iteration of a universe and there are a multitude of permutations incapable of supporting life, it could very well happen on the first try.

Sorry didn't see this.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_significance

Take your coin toss for example, but add a few more trials.

HTHTTHHHT is just as likely as HHHHHHHHH, but it is not significant in any way because if we toss a fair coin fairly, we expect a somewhat random distribution of heads and tails. That's what fair coins usually do. HHHHHHHHH, however, is not what fair coins usually do. It's what loaded or two-headed coins do. That many heads in a row has a much less than 1% chance of occuring, so we attach significance to it. You can show it easily enough with Bayes Theorem: Pr(E/H) >> Pr(E/~H) where E is the evidence of 9 heads in a row and H is the hypothesis "The coin is biased". As long as
Pr(H) isn't outrageously low (and two-headed coins aren't exactly rare), it will be more reasonable to believe the coin is loaded than fair. As the number of heads in a row increases, the confidence in the loaded coin hypothesis grows until it becomes irrational to believe a fair coin is being fairly tossed.
 
Whoah, back up a second.

Anyone else think there's life in the core of the sun?
[crickets]


[/crickets]


I've read several very good science fiction novels involving sun-based life forms. Can you give us any reason why there couldn't be some kind of exotic form of life existing in a sun, other than that it would be fundamentally different from the kind of life we are familiar with?
 
Sorry didn't see this.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_significance

Take your coin toss for example, but add a few more trials.

HTHTTHHHT is just as likely as HHHHHHHHH, but it is not significant in any way because if we toss a fair coin fairly, we expect a somewhat random distribution of heads and tails. That's what fair coins usually do. HHHHHHHHH, however, is not what fair coins usually do. It's what loaded or two-headed coins do. That many heads in a row has a much less than 1% chance of occuring, so we attach significance to it. You can show it easily enough with Bayes Theorem: Pr(E/H) >> Pr(E/~H) where E is the evidence of 9 heads in a row and H is the hypothesis "The coin is biased". As long as
Pr(H) isn't outrageously low (and two-headed coins aren't exactly rare), it will be more reasonable to believe the coin is loaded than fair. As the number of heads in a row increases, the confidence in the loaded coin hypothesis grows until it becomes irrational to believe a fair coin is being fairly tossed.
Your objection was completely addressed and refuted by the rest of the post that you just responded to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom