A fundamental point that you as yet do not grasp the significance of. There is no "before" the Big Bang. According to Stephen Hawking, whom you quoted in an attempt to support your argument, the universe can be analogized as the surface of a sphere, finite and boundless. There is no creation, it simply is.
if it is boundless, it HAS a absolute beginning.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/3925361/Strobel-Lee-The-Case-for-a-Creator
page 78
HAWKING'S CHALLENGE
Most developments in cosmology live an obscure existence within the pages of arcane scientific journals, with only a few-often, the most outlandish ones-receiving even the briefest mention in the popular press. Luminaries in the field, such as Linde and Guth, are hardly household names. But when Stephen William Hawking speaks, the public listens.
A theoretical physicist who is currently the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University, a post once held by Sir Isaac Newton, Hawking has become a science icon. He has sold millions of copies of A Brief History of Time, although Business Week once quipped that the book is "the least-read best-seller ever."40 His celebrity status was validated when he achieved cartoon form on The Simpsons and played a cameo role on Star Trek, where he challenged a holographic Einstein to a game of chess.
Hawking, who uses a wheelchair for mobility and a synthesizer for speech due to a progressive neuromuscular disease, has been on a quest for the elusive Theory of Everything, which would unify general relativity with quantum theory. Along the way, he has proposed a quantum gravity model for the universe that he says eliminates the need for a singularity-that is, the Big Bang.
When actress Shirley MacLaine asked Hawking whether he believes God created the universe, he replied simply, "No.”41 He told the BBC: "We are such insignificant creatures on a minor planet of a very average star in the outer suburbs of one of a hundred thousand million galaxies. So it is difficult to believe in a God that would care about us or even notice our existence."42
In a chapter called "The Origin and Fate of the Universe" in A Brief History of Time, Hawking says: "So long as the universe had a beginning, we could suppose it had a creator. But if the universe is really completely self-contained, having no boundary or edge, it would have neither beginning nor end: it would simply be. What place, then, for a creator?"43
I broached Hawking's theory to Craig. "It sure sounds like he has finally managed to put God out of business," I said. "Not quite," replied Craig.
When I asked him to explain why not, Craig pulled a piece of paper and pen out of his top drawer. "Let me draw you two pictures that will clarify what I mean," he said.
"The standard Big Bang theory can be represented by a cone," he said, drawing what looked like an empty sugar cone from BaskinRobbins. "The point of the cone represents the beginning of the universe-the singularity where the Big Bang occurred. It's the beginning point, and it has a sharp edge to it.44 The expansion of the universe, as it gets older and grows, is represented by the cone's overall expanding shape."
I nodded that I was tracking with him. Then he took a second sheet of paper and began drawing a picture of Hawking's theory. "Hawking's model is like a cone, too, except it doesn't come to a point." He drew a picture of what resembled a badminton birdie; instead of coming to a sharp point, the end of the cone was rounded.
"As you can see, there's no singularity. There's no sharp edge. If you were to start at the mouth of the cone and go backward in time," he said, his pencil tracing the long side of the cone, "you would not come back to a beginning point. You would simply follow the curveand suddenly you would find yourself heading forward in time again."
This was consistent with the way Hawking's biographers envisioned his theory. They said it would be like walking northward until you reach the North Pole, and then suddenly, if you keep
walking, you find yourself heading south.45 "There is no beginning and no endno boundaries," one writer explained. "The universe always was, always is, and always shall be."46
Craig put down his pencil. "Presto!" I exclaimed as I looked at his drawing. "No beginning, no singularity, no Big Bang-no need for God."
Craig grimaced. "Let's think about this for a minute before you come to that conclusion," he said.
THE WORLD OF IMAGINARY NUMBERS
"Has Hawking made a mistake?" I asked. The mere suggestion sounded impossible!
"I think he has made a philosophical error by thinking that having a beginning entails having a beginning point. And that's simply not the case," Craig replied.
He pointed toward his rendering of Hawking's model. "Granted, there isn't any singular point here, but notice this: the universe is still finite in its past. It still has a beginning in the sense that something has a finite past duration. In other words, pick an interval of timesay, a second, a minute, or a year. For any finite interval of time you pick, there are only a finite number of equal intervals prior to that time. And in that sense, Hawking's model has a beginning. Even he says that the universe has an origin out of nothing in the sense that there's absolutely nothing that comes before it.
"So this would be an example of a model that has a beginning but doesn't involve a singularity. That's what many scientists are trying to come up with, because the laws of physics would apply all the way back. They don't break down in a singularity. And that's more palatable to them."
Before I could ask another question, Craig added: "Now, I've been taking Hawking's model at face value, but it's also important to note that he is only able to achieve this rounding-off effect by substituting `imaginary numbers' for real numbers in his equations."
"What are imaginary numbers?"
"They are multiples of the square root of negative one," he said. "In this model, they have the effect of turning time into a dimension of space. The problem is that when imaginary numbers are employed, they're just computational devices used to grease the equations and get the result the mathematician wants. That's fine, but when you want to get a real, physical result, you have to convert the imaginary numbers into real ones. But Hawking refuses to convert them. He just keeps everything in the imaginary realm."
"What happens if you convert the numbers into real ones?"
"Presto, the singularity reappears!" Craig said. "In fact, the singularity is really there the whole time; it's just hidden behind the device of so-called imaginary time. Hawking concedes this in a subsequent book he co-authored with Roger Penrose.47 He said he doesn't pretend to be describing reality, because he says he doesn't know what reality is.
So Hawking himself recognizes that this is not a realistic description of the universe or its origin; it's merely a mathematical way of modeling the beginning of the universe in such a manner that the singularity doesn't appear."