Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, it does. Is there life in the core of the sun?
I see no way there could be.

On the surface of Pluto?
Unlikely.

In the rings of Saturn?
Probably not, though it's a perfectly plausible habitat. I don't know how life might have evolved in the rings themselves, but it could have migrated there, perhaps from a geologically active moon.

No... but how do we know this, other than by studying life on Earth?
Physics and chemistry.
 
I think I'm going to skip out on this thread until GIBHOR stops regurgitating nonsense with complete disregard to other people's responses and objections.

I'll check back in around 50 years.

:slp:
 
I've read several very good science fiction novels involving sun-based life forms. Can you give us any reason why there couldn't be some kind of exotic form of life existing in a sun, other than that it would be fundamentally different from the kind of life we are familiar with?
In the core of our Sun, as opposed to any star? The core of our Sun is too hot to maintain complex physical structures. Life also needs an energy gradient in order to do work.

In a small brown dwarf, though, maybe.
 
In the core of our Sun, as opposed to any star? The core of our Sun is too hot to maintain complex physical structures. Life also needs an energy gradient in order to do work.

In a small brown dwarf, though, maybe.


Hmm, I wonder what the time constraints are on life. Existence can be measured in milliseconds.

Can life?
 
http://elshamah.heavenforum.com/astronomy-cosmology-and-god-f15/quantum-fluctuations-t65.htm

Even if the total energy is not zero, matter could still be created spontaneously - but only for a very short time. According to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, we cannot determine energy and time precisely. Therefore, it is possible for a group of particles with non-zero total energy appear spontaneously and then disappear within a short time. The more the total energy is created, the shorter the lifetime. This process is known as the quantum fluctuation, which has been well confirmed by experiments.
Nevertheless, HUP isn't what you think it is. Leonard Susskind (one of the fathers of string theory) points this out in the very first lecture of his online Quantum Mechanics course:

To get the full context, you'll want to start at about 7:20 and play through (yes, start that far back--he explains things):
Susskind @~12:15 In other words energy would not be exactly conserved in a world in which the laws of motion included a little bit of classical randomness. ... :38 In quantum mechanics prepare a system ... you let it go for a while, and then you look at it, and indeed you discover at the end of it that what you measure is a little bit unpredictable but you also find that energy is exactly conserved.​
In 1973, Edward Tryon suggested ...
Good for him. I am not Edward Tryon. And I already stated that I do not agree with him. So why are you bringing this up?

Do you simply not understand what's going on here? In which case, aren't you being dishonest by pretending that you do?
This requires extremely accurate cancellation between matter energy and gravitational energy. If the matter energy is just slightly (within 1 part in 1050) greater than the gravitational energy, the uncertainty principle would dictate the matter to disappear in a time period that is too short to have any physical meaning. For such gigantic fluctuation to occur spontaneously is almost impossible.
Actually, we've yet to establish what the laws of quantum gravity are, if they even make sense, which are critical to bring into play to discuss this properly. Until then everything you quote from a source you don't understand is speculation. Why can't you just wait for the LHC to bang out some theories?
but we know the universe had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.
I explained this one in the last reply, but I'll rephrase it.

The rule that ontological entities which come into being must have a cause never applies to anything we observe. The only thing we observe that comes into being is virtual particles, and they are uncaused.

The fact that this is a general rule with a global qualifier is actually falsified by virtual particles.

It is possible, however, for the energy in the universe to have come from some other place, by some grander laws. But it is not supported by any current evidence.

And trying to support it by speculation is impotent.
Energy flows from one form to the other.
energy is not eternal. it was created at the big bang event.... so it has a cause.
What you are objecting to is a statement of the law of conservation of energy, which is supported by all evidence.

What you are asserting--that energy is not eternal--is not supported by any evidence we currently have.
Any genuine knowledge you obtained must of necessity be obtained from information. What we lack the information to answer, we cannot answer. You're practicing the art of fooling youself.
we have that information. the universe itself tells us a lot about itself.
But you are not working according to the evidence. You've stated that everything that begins to exist has a cause, when the only evidential information we have about things concerning formulation ex nihilo do not, in fact, come into being caused. You stated that energy is not eternal, when the only information we have about the nature of energy across time is the observation that it is exactly conserved, even in quantum mechanics.

You're working in the wrong direction to establish legitimate knowledge. You have a conclusion, and you're trying to figure out how to get the universe to tell you what you want it to say. This is your flawed method.
according to the big bang theory , there was no energy,matter,space, and time prior the big bang.
But if time began at the big bang, then there was never a time at which there was no energy.
of course not. the energy in our universe was created as well, at the big bang event. prior the big bang, no energy existed.
This is a reification of zero. If there was no time before the big bang, you cannot speak of there being no energy prior the big bang, because there would be no such thing as prior the big bang.

If there were such a thing as prior the big bang, there would be time before the big bang.
of course it is. the energy existing in our universe is not eternal, otherwise our universe would be already in a state of heath death.
That does not follow. If energy existed for as long as there was time, and time began, the universe would not be in a state of heat death.
The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die.
The second law of thermodynamics does not contradict the law of conservation of energy. The reason it's called "heat death" is because everything turns into heat energy, which is a form of energy. And you have exactly as much energy as you started with.
The cosmos is not eternal,
Bare assertion.
and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy.
By what law? The Big Bang has the universe starting at T=0. The second law of thermodynamics doesn't have heat death occurring until many orders of magnitude of multiples of the current age of the universe. And the law of conservation of energy states that energy is neither created or destroyed.

You're inventing this.
The biblical statement, that there was a beginning, is strongly attested to by the second law.
The bible is irrelevant. Truth is obtained by asking questions of the universe. If the bible is true, the universe will support it. If the universe does not support it, the bible is false. Either way, the gold standard of truth is reality, not your bible.
And yet, you reify zero in this very post when you try to support your claim that energy must have been created. If there was no prior to the big bang, you cannot speak of energy not existing prior to the big bang. You don't have a prior to the big bang to speak of.
thus, since you agree there was no time before the big bang,
Tentatively, but close enough.
you agree that our universe had a absolute beginning.
Yes.
Thus, it must have had a cause.
No. It does not follow that it must have had a cause.

It might have a cause. But it is not a consequence that it had a beginning, that it must have a cause. You're literally ignoring every other possibility.
(1) Absolutely Nothing never existed. If it had, there would still be Absolutely Nothing now. But Something Else exists. You, for example.
Sure.
(2) Since Absolutely Nothing never existed, there was always a time when there was something in existence.
Sure, but this is a tautology. Time in itself would be something. So if time existed at all, absolute nothing wouldn't exist.
This something we can call the Eternal Something.
Why do we need to give it a leading name?
The Eternal Something has no beginning and no end,
Why does it follow that it has no end?
has no needs that It Itself cannot meet,
Why is it anthropomorphic? Oh, and by the way, isn't this theologically unsound? If God had no needs, why did he create humans?
can do whatever is possible that can be done,
Why does this follow?
and will always be superior to anything It produces.
...and why does this follow? Wouldn't this be a limitation of power? Doesn't it contradict the previous assertion?
(3) The Eternal Something is not a machine,
Why not?
controlled or programmed by any force outside Itself. And the Eternal Something will not produce out of necessity, since It has no needs.
Why? This is extremely speculative.
Therefore,
What could possibly follow from a bunch of bare assertions?
if It produces Something Else, It must decide to do so.
Why is it anthropomorphic?
That means that the Eternal Something has a will;
No, it has a will because you put one there. You're working backwards from your conclusions, and such methods are incapable of producing legitimate knowledge.
thus, It is personal. Therefore, the Eternal Something must actually be an Eternal Someone (or Someones).
Nothing but assertions.

I thought you said you were going to present a rational argument. What's with the constant stream of obviously not connected, obviously a priori, bare assertions? That's not how you construct a rational argument--that's how you trick yourself into thinking you have one.

If you care about truth, you need to start caring about what the universe actually tells you when you ask it, and stop worrying about trying to get the universe to tell you what you want it to say. When you're working backwards from the thing you want to believe like you're doing, you're only going to doom yourself to believe it.
 
Unfortunately, Marduk did not become men , did not die for the sins of all humanity on the cross, and did not prove to be God through ressurrection.
therefore, i prefere to believe in Jesus Christ as the alpha and omega, creator of heavens, and the earth. :)

Pfft. Real gods don't die. Odin spent 9 days hanged from the world tree and pierced by his own spear and lived just fine. Your "god" popped his clogs before even the two humans next to him.

Besides, what kind of an impotent god gets nailed by a couple of Roman backwater-town militia? Odin and the gang fight giants and live just fine.
 
Regarding your quantum theory, play about 20 minutes into the first linked coarse on Quantum Mechanics.
"So it's not an example of something coming into being out of nothing, or something coming into being without a cause.
It is exactly the sort of thing we're talking about, though--that substance... actual, real live matter--should appear when before there was none. This is what you are claiming must be the case with all of the energy in the universe.

And the only observations we have about this is that said things arise uncaused. You want to argue that this does not apply? I actually agree, which is why I disagree with Tryon--but it's the best thing you have to work with. And I phrased that correctly... it's the best thing you have to work with.

...because this is your claim that you have to back up.
that is, frankly spoken, a shameless and willfullingly ignorant position.
...
If we know the creation has a beginning, we are faced with another logical question--was the creation caused or was it not caused? The Bible states,
Begging the questionWP
You have not established that the bible is a reliable source of information.
The atheist tells us that "matter is self-existing and not created." If matter had a beginning and yet was uncaused, one must logically maintain that something would have had to come into existence out of nothing.
This is incorrect. You are flunking at enumerating the possibilities. Furthermore, this is a straw man argument.
From empty space with no force, no matter, no energy, and no intelligence, matter would have to become existent.
This is incorrect. You have not established that there ever was empty space with no force, no matter, no energy, and no intelligence. Furthermore, "empty space" is not nothing.
Even if this could happen by some strange new process unknown to science today, there is a logical problem.

In order for matter to come out of nothing, all of our scientific laws dealing with the conservation of matter/energy would have to be wrong, invalidating all of chemistry.
That is not a logical problem. Laws of science are discovered by studying the universe.

Besides, it follows that the laws would be incorrect regardless, even if you added your god in. Your god violates the law of conservation of energy.

Now, it is a logical problem to try to support your position by building a straw man and attacking what you presume is the opposition, if that's what you mean. But that's not my problem.
All of our laws of conservation of angular momentum would have to be wrong, invalidating all of physics.
That does not follow. If there were a grander law discovered that could account for the creation of energy, why would it follow that it invalidates angular momentum?

You're making this one up.
All of our laws of conservation of electric charge would have to be wrong, invalidating all of electronics and demanding that your TV set not work!
This definitely does not follow. This is about the most extreme case of straw man argument I can imagine. You're literally arguing that it should logically follow that a new discovered law, unspecified, should lead to a television not working.

...and that follows exactly why?

To formulate a rational argument, you have to actually form premises that logically follow each other.
In order to believe matter is uncaused, one has to discard known laws and principles of science.
The laws of science are discovered by the principles of science. This argument makes a mockery of both science and logic. Where is the rational argument?
No reasonable person is going to do this simply to maintain a personal atheistic position.
This is a projection. The atheistic position has absolutely no value. But an intellectually honest search for truth has ultimate value. It is obvious from the straw man positions, the lack of imagination, the disrespect for legitimate avenues of inquiry, and the blatant disregard to even try to assemble a rational argument, that the real goal behind this isn't an intellectual search for truth, but rather, is a base attempt at self flattery.
The atheist's assertion that matter is eternal is wrong.
The law of conservation of energy is one of the very things you tried to use in your illogical rantings above. And that law states that energy can neither be created nor destroyed.

It's sophistry of the most illogical form to suggest that a law stating that energy can neither be created nor destroyed is violated by suggesting that energy is neither created nor destroyed.

The irony is that it is this atheist who recognizes that the law isn't set in stone, but that laws of science are discovered, and subject to modification in the face of better evidence (and only evidence--not assertions or myths--only the universe is the legitimate source of truth about itself), thus allowing for a potential discovery of a grander law creating energy.

Yet, the law is the law we have, and that is the law that is best supported at the moment.

And that law only states what it states.

And what it states is that energy is neither created nor destroyed--whether you like it or not.
The atheist's assertion that the universe is uncaused and selfexisting is also incorrect.
Begging the questionWP
The Bible's assertion that there was a beginning which was caused is supported strongly by the available scientific evidence.
The creation mythos in the bible is not consistent with the evidence.
its very clear. The universe had a absolute beginning, thus God.
Working backwards as you are doing, you're only dooming yourself to believe.
 
Last edited:
Actually, given the age of the universe, it's physically impossible to roll ten D10's enough times to where a Pi result is even remotely likely. If the dice were rolled a trillion times a year for 14 billion years, the odds of a Pi toss would still be. 1/1000000000000000000000000000 (give or take a zero). A Pi result is so much more probable on the theory of loaded dice (or a biased toss, or some other interference from some mathematically minded agent), that believing the dice were fair would make belief in the FSM downright rational.

This might be a good topic for a new thread: are sufficiently improbable results less believable than miracles? Are some odds so long that it's always irrational to believe they happened by chance?

Humans invented math.
 
In many cultures it is customary to answer that God created the universe out of nothing. But this is mere temporizing. If we wish courageously to pursue the question, we must, of course ask next where God comes from? If we answer that God always existed, why not save a step and declare that the universe always existed? And if we decide the existence of God to be an unanswerable question, why not save a step and conclude that the existence of the Universe is unanswerable?- Sagan

Love you Carl!
 
Then, again, please tell me where the beginning of the surface of a sphere is.

It's curious that you would first cite Hawking in support of your argument and then turn to refuting him in support of your argument. At any rate, William Lane Craig doesn't seem to understand Hawking any better than you do. Even if there is a singularity at the Big Bang it does not follow that the universe came from nothing. A singularity is not nothing.

http://www.big-bang-theory.com/

Another misconception is that we tend to image the singularity as a little fireball appearing somewhere in space. According to the many experts however, space didn't exist prior to the Big Bang. Back in the late '60s and early '70s, when men first walked upon the moon, "three British astrophysicists, Steven Hawking, George Ellis, and Roger Penrose turned their attention to the Theory of Relativity and its implications regarding our notions of time. In 1968 and 1970, they published papers in which they extended Einstein's Theory of General Relativity to include measurements of time and space.1, 2 According to their calculations, time and space had a finite beginning that corresponded to the origin of matter and energy."3 The singularity didn't appear in space; rather, space began inside of the singularity. Prior to the singularity, nothing existed, not space, time, matter, or energy - nothing.
 
You have proof that Jeshua ben Joseph rose from the dead?

without the ressurrection of christ, there would not be any christianity, as we know it today.

http://www.tektonics.org/lp/nowayjose.html

That a god would descend to the realm of matter and suffer in this ignominious fashion "ran counter not only to Roman political thinking, but to the whole ethos of religion in ancient times and in particular to the ideas of God held by educated people." (10, 4) Announcing a crucified god would be akin to the Southern Baptist Convention announcing that they endorsed pedophilia. >{?If Jesus had truly been a god, then by Roman thinking, the Crucifixion should never have happened. Celsus, an ancient pagan critic of Christianity, writes:

But if (Jesus) was really so great, he ought, in order to display his divinity, to have disappeared suddenly from the cross.
This comment represents not just some skeptical challenge, but is a reflection of an ingrained socio-theological consciousness. The Romans could not envision a god dying like Jesus - period. Just as well to argue that the sky is green, or that pigs fly, only those arguments, at least, would not offend sensibilities to the maximum. We need to emphasize this (for the first but not the last time) from a social perspective because our own society is not as attuned as ancient society to the process of honor.

http://www.thinkingchristian.net/C278308471/E20060628222403/index.html

1. After his crucifixion Jesus was buried by Joseph of Arimathea in a tomb.
2. On the Sunday after the crucifixion, Jesus' tomb was found empty by a group of his women followers.
3. On different occasions and under various circumstances different individuals and groups of people experienced appearances of Jesus alive from the dead. [Not all of these scholars accept these as experiences of an embodied and glorified Christ, in accord with Biblical theology; some would view them as hallucination or as spiritual visions.]
4. The original disciples suddenly and sincerely came to believe that Jesus was risen from the dead despite their having every predisposition to the contrary.

These are accepted by scholars for basically the same two reasons in each case: they are multiply-attested by independent sources; and they are unexpected, even embarrassing facts for the early church, unlikely to have been made up as part of a Christ story.
 
Last edited:
Don't count your DCI points until the game is over, buddy. As it stands, the Pact of Negation left me with sufficient mana reserves to be able to cast:

[qimg]http://ihatemtg.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/mindbreak.jpg[/qimg]

Which should put paid to your delusions of victory.

So you can cast this spell OVER split second ? Interesting :p
 
The second law of thermodynamics does not contradict the law of conservation of energy. The reason it's called "heat death" is because everything turns into heat energy, which is a form of energy. And you have exactly as much energy as you started with.
Bare assertion.

It seems you don't get the point. If energy is eternal, we would at this moment already be in a state of heath death, because of the second law of thermodynamics. The energy would be there, since it cannot be destroyed, but it would not be able to fuel our universe in the way we could live in. The energy would be already transformed in heath, which is not usable to sustain life.
 
Last edited:
So life could occur no matter what the constants are? Life with no stars ever forming? Non-molecular life? Life in a universe with nothing but hydrogen atoms? You can take that approach, but there is no evidence to support your position, and there is plenty of evidence to contradict it.

No, I don't think that's what he meant. Life is fine-tuned to the universe, not the other way around. It doesn't follow from that statement that life could evolve anywhere. Quite the opposite, in fact.
 
what about virtual particles ?



1) i see no reason why everything that has a beginning would have a cause
2) the universe may not have had a beginning in the classical sense of the term.
3) even if we were to concluce that it had a cause, you'd have to show that it was necessarily or at least probably (your) god.



They may have been set at random, for all we know.



Unless it is cyclical.

Gibhor ??
 
It seems you don't get the point. If energy is eternal, we would at this moment already be in a state of heath death, because of the second law of thermodynamics. The energy would be there, since it cannot be destroyed, but it would not be able to fuel our universe in the way we could live in. The energy would be already transformed in heath, which is not usable to sustain life.
No, GIBHOR. If time began 14 billion years ago, then there has only been 14 billion years of time before this moment.

If that's the case, and if energy is eternal, then energy has existed, and will exist, for as long as there is time, by definition of eternal. This means that energy has existed for 14 billion years before this moment.

14 billion years is not enough time for heat death.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom