Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Very simple. the alternative of a finite universe ( i.e. with a absolute beginning, thus needing a cause ) , is a eternal universe, which had no beginning, thus eternal. If it is eternal, time had no beginning as well. As long as the universe exists, time must exist as well.

Allow me to rephrase:

If a universe isn't infinite, then it's finite.

If a universe is finite, then must have an absolute beginning.
If a universe has an absolute beginning, then it must have a cause.

If a universe is eternal, then it must not have a beginning.
If a universe has no beginning, then time had no beginning.

"The" universe and time are intertwined (see also, some famous guy).

Sneaky how you're slipping that time thing in there. I went ahead and deleted your quote since you didn't write it yourself. I've found that if you can't restate something in your own words, chances are you don't understand it. Conversely, if you try to, you stand a better chance of learning it. Tough love. That's the polite interpretation, actually. Otherwise I'd just assume you were trying to argue from authority.

Now, let's return to that concept you seem not to be clear yet on:

You keep saying "the universe" when we should be specifying "our universe" versus "a given universe" versus "the omniverse". You can't just dismiss that. You can't just cite statements from Hawking and then ignore the context in which he said it. If our universe is but one of many possible universes appearing with the necessarily larger confines of an omniverse, then our universe, as such, can certainly be finite and have a cause. But that doesn't mean time didn't exist before it.

Also, I'd like to see you acknowledge that time is not understood. In fact, time cannot be shown to exist, period. I dare you to prove that it does. At its most basic, time is a unit of change. If we can say anything with regard to the relation between time and "the universe" (that which exists) it is that without it, nothing can change. Therefore, without it, nothing can begin.

I'd also like to see you acknowledge that you're horribly abusing the concept of infinity. I agree that, in general, when math or a theory calls for infinity there is trouble. But you persist in confusing it with a number. It's not a number. The very fact that it is not a number is why there are no points of "infinite" density. You then take this information and conflate it the concept of infinity and declare that infinity can't exist.

As mentioned previously, equivocation is a logical fallacy and if you want this discussion to be an honest one, you need to stop that. I understand that logic is hard, damned hard. It takes practice, years of practice, to even get an intuitive grasp on it. Equivocation is, however, relatively to spot once someone has called your attention to it. Surely the man you get all your ideas from has had this pointed out to him. That should tell you something about his honesty and about his motives. When you choose to uncritically quote the man's ideas, it says something about you as well, not to mention how you ignore points from others that are inconvenient to your argument.
 
"Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, "

Would it have to be a reason humans could understand?
Would it have to be a "good reason"?
Would it have to be driven by anything other than natural forces?
Would it have to agree with your own vision of the Universe?
Would it have to be powered by something at cares at all about human beings?

Further than all of that, I submit that at a basic level, a reason is as good as a cause.
 
Absolutely. He's still just playing the God of the Gaps card.

Fortunately, I have...

Image.ashx
 
Very simple. the alternative of a finite universe ( i.e. with a absolute beginning, thus needing a cause ) , is a eternal universe, which had no beginning, thus eternal.
GIBHOR, wrong. Having a beginning does not mean having a cause. If time began at T=0, why does this entail that time was caused? Especially since you have no information at all about creation ex nihilo?

In fact, virtual particles, mentioned by multiple people here, pop into existence uncaused all of the time. So in terms of evidence, the only things we see coming into existence, come into existence uncaused.

That's not to say that the universe is uncaused either--we simply have no information. But you're flunking at enumerating the possibilities--for the same reason that your number 3 in your previous post begged the question over and over and over.

What you have here GIBHOR is a false dichotomy. And again, I thought you said you were being rational?

Again. If you have no information, you have no truth. Speculation has exactly no value. To gain real knowledge it is necessary to obtain information related to the thing you're talking about. This isn't necessary, however, to fool yourself.

You're in the fool yourself category here.
If it is eternal, time had no beginning as well. As long as the universe exists, time must exist as well.
It's possible that the universe had a beginning, and that as long as the universe exists, time existed. You've been name dropping Einstein, so there's no excuse to forgo general and special relativity. Now collapse the universe to a point, and you make velocity meaningless--relative time goes out of the window. Collapse all mass to a point, and gravity goes through the roof--again making relative time undefined. Are you having problems grasping that the concept of time beginning at T=0 follows from the very shape of space-time?
But this is not possible, as shown prior:

www.thekeyboard.org.uk/What is infinity.htm
Infinity is irrelevant, and this is pure speculation. Nevertheless, the suggestion that there is no actual infinity works against you--what does there being no actual infinite say about God?
Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity.
You're making that up. No thing moves mathematically towards infinity in the formation of a black hole. You're left with exactly as much energy as you started with.
A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it.
Stars are not necessary. What about galactic black holes? Primordial black holes?
A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it.
This doesn't follow either. See here (wiki, black holes, Fuzzballs) We simply lack information to say.

And the way to figure this out is to ask the universe.
A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.
Your description is highly inaccurate regardless. Something which moves asymptotically towards infinity in a finite amount of time would become infinite. Furthermore, the only thing that could possibly be moving towards infinity would be density, not mass, and certainly not gravity. If a star (minus ejected material) collapses to form a black hole, and a planet were to somehow be orbiting this star, then once the black hole is formed, the planets orbit would not change.
The simplest answer is that as the universe is known to be expanding, it cannot possibly be infinite.
Here (cosmology faq, How can the Universe be infinite if it was all concentrated into a point at the Big Bang?)

And your method's holes are showing their ugly faces again in your phrase "the simplest answer".

The point isn't to get an answer. The point is to obtain a truth (aka, knowledge). And to gain knowledge, you necessarily need information. If you do not have sufficient information, you do not have knowledge. What you are constantly doing is trying to fake up knowledge in situations where you lack the information.

That's invalid. Speculating in the lack of information, especially when you're playing this constant black and white fallacy game with your own lack of imagination, will never lead to knowledge.

Again, information is required for knowledge. But it is not required to fool yourself. And you're definitely working in the latter category.
 
Last edited:
Possibly apocryphal story:

This Einstein you keep mentioning once famously said, "God does not play dice with the universe", speaking in terms of quantum mechanics, because he just couldn't deal with the fact that QM suggests a sort of fundamental randomness. To which Niels Bohr replied: "Einstein, do not tell God what to do".

By that, Bohr meant that Einstein was trying to prescribe a law of the universe based on his own intuition, rather than figure out what the real laws are and to accept them whatever they may be, as the evidence suggests.

Given this, we arrive at a particular irony, GIBHOR. You're here trying to tell us about God. But in doing so, you're telling God what to do.

Do not tell God what to do.
 
Originally Posted by GIBHOR
well, fact that you do not admit the presented facts are no evidence does not mean in fact they are no evidence. It just means you do ignore them. As they permit my presented explanation, they permit any other explanation as well. The quest remains however, which explanation is the best and most reasonable one.

daffyd:
A sky daddy is the most reasonable one?

It's funny, because this really sums up why I am a non-theist. (In one sentence!) Arguments like Gibhor's always end up sounding like bizarre parodies of scientific theories. There is nothing reasonable about the idea that a mysterious origin of the universe (or anything else mysterious, really) means that a very specific type of anthropomorphic God is sitting around up in heaven and waiting to answer our prayers if they're correctly addressed to him (but not anybody else's prayers, if they don't believe in just the right God.) Anyone who has this kind of faith also has a desperate fear that if they give it up, they must also give up everything that has represented a meaningful "God-experience" for them. This is not true. However, they will have to give up all of those illusions about a specific, anthropomorphic, personal, external God. Most people are just not willing to do this, and some of them even end up in places like the JREF forum, endlessly getting stuck on that particular point.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I'd fall over and play dead, and wait for a chance to escape. :D
.
Falling down won't work.
The leader of a squad is tasked with shooting the victim in the head just to be sure, marksmanship being what it is, in the usual way these things are done.
.
I could point you at a video of a real firing squad at work.. badly.. about 250 shots fired at 5 guys, with even the coup de grace(s) done poorly, but I won't.
 
For many people I think its a case of "My belief is so important to me that I can't imagine anyone else being happy without it. Therefor I assume that they are miserable".

It's like me saying "I love my wife and she makes me happy. Therefor everyone who isn't married to my wife is unhappy".


Actually, it is even worse than that and ties into GHIBOR's insistence on a cause for everything except, oddly enough, his/her god. Atheism truly doesn't lead anywhere. It isn't a cause or a reason in itself. Some people just aren't happy with loose ends and seem to be unable to accept them. To them, atheism would be the ultimate loose end.
 
yy2bggggs:There are absolutely no empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo.​

that was also not what i meant. There are absolutely no empirical observations in our world, that something would pop up out of nothing. Like a ferrari in front of you, for example.

Whether or not creation ex nihilo is baffling is beside the point. You said that Pure_Argent's claim goes against all empirical observations, and I claimed that there were no such empirical observations. Baffling or no, do you have empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo?

my point is that everything than begins to exist, has a cause. Everything around you had a cause. Since the universe had a beginning, it had a cause as well, God.

Who is this we? I know that the universe started with a big bang, but beyond that, there may or may not be some grander laws.

Laws, even greater ones, must be set to exist. They also do not pop up out of nothing.

The "we" on this side of the keyboard wants to know the actual, factual answer. And the "we" on this side of the keyboard knows that actual factual answers arise from asking questions of the universe. LHC is a very big, and expensive, question asker that's underway that just might get enough answers to at least ask the question correctly. Why not wait a few years to see what they dig up?

it will be able to answer SOME questions, but not the essential ones.

The universe is made of energy. That energy comes from the universe. The energy is the material cause of the universe.

of course not. The cause of the universe is external of it. The energy was created as well. It did not exist prior the Big Bang.

The second law of thermodynamics suggests that within a closed system the amount of usable energy decreases over time. But it does not say that energy decreases--only usable energy. That makes energy eternal.

but according the Big Bang theory, energy was also created at this event. Prior the Big Bang, no energy did exist.

Sure, but the current best scientific evidence suggests that there was no time at which there was nothing. Adding a god to create the universe through your line of logic doesn't even fit with this scientific evidence, as there would be no time for a causal act to occur.

God is timeless without creation and temporal subsequent to creation.
 
that was also not what i meant. There are absolutely no empirical observations in our world, that something would pop up out of nothing. Like a ferrari in front of you, for example.
There are empirical observations supporting that virtual particles appear from nowhere.
my point is that everything than begins to exist, has a cause. Everything around you had a cause. Since the universe had a beginning, it had a cause as well, God.
And your point is unrelated to the frame you're applying it to. You're talking creativity, not creation ex nihilo. To speak of the creation of matter is to speak of creation ex nihilo, about which we have no observations at all.

The artist paints, but he needs a paintbrush--pigments and ground. Medium. Those things he gets from pre-existing energy transformed into different forms. The composer composes, and needs ink to record it. He needs glucose for his brain to function. The musician plays it, but he needs an instrument. The party thrower has to get party supplies, games, etc. He has to plan, and fuel his brain that does the planning. Energy flows from one form to the other.

Every last bit of creativity is energy flowing from one form to another, and you're also leaving out other transformations which do not involve creativity--the formation of snow, the formation of diamonds, the formation of potassium--all of those transformations occur from natural processes.

And they are all of the form of energy being transformed from one form to another.

Now you're suddenly talking, as if it's the same thing, of the origin of energy--and not only can you not show that it's more like the painting than it is the snow, but it's an entirely different thing than both painting and snow.

This is formation ex nihilo you're talking about. It is not the same thing as energy transforming from one form to another. It's utterly different. You not only have to establish that formation ex nihilo of energy even occurs at all, but that formation ex nihilo is creation ex nihilo.

Furthermore, you're cherry picking your laws. Everything that is sentient has a brain. And only sentient things create. So to get creation ex nihilo, you need to have a brain to start with. Either that, or you have to make up your own rules.

That's what you're doing. You're making up the rules. You're telling God what to do.
Laws, even greater ones, must be set to exist. They also do not pop up out of nothing.
You're making this requirement up. How does one go about setting a law in the first place?
it will be able to answer SOME questions, but not the essential ones.
Any genuine knowledge you obtained must of necessity be obtained from information. What we lack the information to answer, we cannot answer. You're practicing the art of fooling youself.
of course not. The cause of the universe is external of it. The energy was created as well. It did not exist prior the Big Bang.
You have yet to establish that there was a prior to the Big Bang.

Time and space and related, and gravity bends this space. At T=0, all observable space was collapsed towards a single point. Gravity density increases without bound. This affects space time in the precise ways that relativity predict, and it makes T<0 meaningless.

Furthermore, this has absolutely nothing to do with material cause. Are you abusing terms? The material cause of the universe is the energy that it consists of. There is at yet no reason to believe this energy itself was created by anything, even external. It goes beyond the information we have, but all of the information we have has energy neither being created nor destroyed. You're inventing that energy needs to have been created. Which is mighty convenient, seeing as how that is what you're trying to show in the first place.
but according the Big Bang theory, energy was also created at this event. Prior the Big Bang, no energy did exist.
Wrong. According to Big Bang theory, time began at the BB singularity. There is no prior to T=0 within the context of BB.

You're asserting something that is absolutely not part of Big Bang theory, which leads me to believe you have no idea what you are talking about.
God is timeless without creation and temporal subsequent to creation.
Irrelevant. Nothing within the Big Bang theory gives you minimal context, or even a suggestion, that the universe was created. You don't have time before big bang. There's no such thing, within the Big Bang theory, as T<0.

There might be a T<0. That would be a grander theory. But there might not be. Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.
 
Last edited:
My point is that everything than begins to exist, has a cause. Everything around you had a cause. Since the universe had a beginning, it had a cause as well, God.

And my point is that that's an unsupported leap you're making from "cause" to "god". "Cause" can be an entirely unthinking and unintentional thing. "God" implies a lot of attributes more.

E.g., that the pond outside has frozen, has technically a "cause", namely that it's cold outside. But it's not a "cause" that has an intention or a plan or anything. It's not a "cause" you can equate with divinity.

Same with your rants about the universe, handwaving that there must be some "cause" does not support your then taking a leap to postulating "god".

Laws, even greater ones, must be set to exist. They also do not pop up out of nothing.

Bare assertion at best. If you actually have any evidence for such a postulate, please do provide it. Otherwise, colour me unimpressed.

it will be able to answer SOME questions, but not the essential ones.

Apparently as opposed to made up delusions and bullcrap, which you can do for any question, right? :p

of course not. The cause of the universe is external of it. The energy was created as well. It did not exist prior the Big Bang.

Again, if you actually have evidence of what happened before the Big Bang or that that energy was created, please do post that evidence.

But I really mean "evidence", not "wishful thinking" or "handwaving".

but according the Big Bang theory, energy was also created at this event. Prior the Big Bang, no energy did exist.

Huh? That must come as a big surprise to a lot of physicists.

God is timeless without creation and temporal subsequent to creation.

So we're back to the special pleading fallacy? Got it.
 
that was also not what i meant. There are absolutely no empirical observations in our world, that something would pop up out of nothing. Like a ferrari in front of you, for example.
Now I am certain that you quoted A Brief History of Time without reading it or, at best, you read it without comprehending it. Once more, the most likely current models of the universe do not involve the universe popping up out of nothing. That is not an accurate description of our best understanding of what the Big Bang involved. Perhaps you should obtain a copy of Hawking's book and actually read it.

my point is that everything than begins to exist, has a cause. Everything around you had a cause. Since the universe had a beginning, it had a cause as well, God.
And something had to steal my sock this morning, therefor it was a dragon.

of course not. The cause of the universe is external of it. The energy was created as well. It did not exist prior the Big Bang.
You're still stuck on that "prior to the Big Bang" thing. As you quoted Hawking in support of your argument you would be well served to learn what he actually says about the nature of the universe.

God is timeless without creation and temporal subsequent to creation.
As a construct of human imagination God can have most any properties you choose.
 
that was also not what i meant. There are absolutely no empirical observations in our world, that something would pop up out of nothing. Like a ferrari in front of you, for example.

What about virtual particles ?

my point is that everything than begins to exist, has a cause. Everything around you had a cause. Since the universe had a beginning, it had a cause as well, God.

1) I see no reason why everything that has a beginning would have a cause
2) The universe may not have had a beginning in the classical sense of the term.
3) Even if we were to concluce that it had a cause, you'd have to show that it was necessarily or at least probably (your) God.

Laws, even greater ones, must be set to exist. They also do not pop up out of nothing.

They may have been set at random, for all we know.

of course not. The cause of the universe is external of it.

Unless it is cyclical.
 
Actually, it is even worse than that and ties into GHIBOR's insistence on a cause for everything except, oddly enough, his/her god. Atheism truly doesn't lead anywhere. It isn't a cause or a reason in itself. Some people just aren't happy with loose ends and seem to be unable to accept them. To them, atheism would be the ultimate loose end.
.
Yeah, "I'm responsible for me" is a lot more terrorizing than "Goddit, I had no say".
 
And my point is that that's an unsupported leap you're making from "cause" to "god". "Cause" can be an entirely unthinking and unintentional thing. "God" implies a lot of attributes more.

If it is not a spirit, than it is not a personal being. Thus it could be the universe itself. But the universe is finite in time. And the origin cannot be material/energy, and bent to time, since all these did not exist. Therefor it had to be a bodyless, eternal spirit.

Same with your rants about the universe, handwaving that there must be some "cause" does not support your then taking a leap to postulating "god".

whatelse do you suggest ?

Again, if you actually have evidence of what happened before the Big Bang or that that energy was created, please do post that evidence.

The big bang theory is that evidence. Energy was created at the beginning of the Big Bang. Energy is not eternal.

But I really mean "evidence", not "wishful thinking" or "handwaving".

If my presented evidence is not evidence for you, i cannot help you....

Huh? That must come as a big surprise to a lot of physicists.

i don't think so.

Paul Charles William Davies AM (born 22 April 1946) is an English physicist, writer and broadcaster, currently a professor at Arizona State University as well as the Director of BEYOND: Center for Fundamental Concepts in Science.

elshamah.heavenforum.com/atheist-scientists-and-authors-f13/paul-davies-t201.htm

The balloon – space – has simply disappeared. Play this scenario in forward time and it represents the coming-into-being of a universe from literally nothing, with space itself appearing. So it’s not an explosion in a pre-existing space. Space itself appears. And so, for that matter, does time. Einstein taught us that space and time are intimately interwoven. Where one goes the other goes. There can be no time without space. If space comes into existence abruptly at the big bang, then time comes into existence abruptly, too.

What does this mean? It means that there was no time before the big bang. This is an absolutely fundamental point.

So we're back to the special pleading fallacy? Got it.

there is no special pleading. Simply , because the universe has a meta-physical origin anyway, or its a efficient cause, i.e. God, or its a unefficient one, absolutely no thing.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom