Cynic
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2009
- Messages
- 1,329
Very simple. the alternative of a finite universe ( i.e. with a absolute beginning, thus needing a cause ) , is a eternal universe, which had no beginning, thus eternal. If it is eternal, time had no beginning as well. As long as the universe exists, time must exist as well.
Allow me to rephrase:
If a universe isn't infinite, then it's finite.
If a universe is finite, then must have an absolute beginning.
If a universe has an absolute beginning, then it must have a cause.
If a universe is eternal, then it must not have a beginning.
If a universe has no beginning, then time had no beginning.
"The" universe and time are intertwined (see also, some famous guy).
Sneaky how you're slipping that time thing in there. I went ahead and deleted your quote since you didn't write it yourself. I've found that if you can't restate something in your own words, chances are you don't understand it. Conversely, if you try to, you stand a better chance of learning it. Tough love. That's the polite interpretation, actually. Otherwise I'd just assume you were trying to argue from authority.
Now, let's return to that concept you seem not to be clear yet on:
You keep saying "the universe" when we should be specifying "our universe" versus "a given universe" versus "the omniverse". You can't just dismiss that. You can't just cite statements from Hawking and then ignore the context in which he said it. If our universe is but one of many possible universes appearing with the necessarily larger confines of an omniverse, then our universe, as such, can certainly be finite and have a cause. But that doesn't mean time didn't exist before it.
Also, I'd like to see you acknowledge that time is not understood. In fact, time cannot be shown to exist, period. I dare you to prove that it does. At its most basic, time is a unit of change. If we can say anything with regard to the relation between time and "the universe" (that which exists) it is that without it, nothing can change. Therefore, without it, nothing can begin.
I'd also like to see you acknowledge that you're horribly abusing the concept of infinity. I agree that, in general, when math or a theory calls for infinity there is trouble. But you persist in confusing it with a number. It's not a number. The very fact that it is not a number is why there are no points of "infinite" density. You then take this information and conflate it the concept of infinity and declare that infinity can't exist.
As mentioned previously, equivocation is a logical fallacy and if you want this discussion to be an honest one, you need to stop that. I understand that logic is hard, damned hard. It takes practice, years of practice, to even get an intuitive grasp on it. Equivocation is, however, relatively to spot once someone has called your attention to it. Surely the man you get all your ideas from has had this pointed out to him. That should tell you something about his honesty and about his motives. When you choose to uncritically quote the man's ideas, it says something about you as well, not to mention how you ignore points from others that are inconvenient to your argument.