Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
.
HAHA! I like those too. I especially liked the second one - the one with Alice.

Thanks, thats my favorite too. I had fun making it, and this is the first time I've had an excuse a chance to show it off.
 
doesgodexist.org/JulAug06/TheLawsofThermodynamics.html
The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die. The cosmos is not eternal, and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy. The biblical statement that there was a beginning is strongly attested to by the second law. We would like to point out that it is incorrect to apply the second law to the earth or to anything on the earth.

You're making a category error here. The universe is all the matter/energy and space that exists, not the transitory forms that this matter and energy takes on at various points over time. The suns and stars may "die", but the stuff they're made of cannot "die". The cosmos probably is eternal, even if suns, stars and people aren't.

because all scientific evidence shows us , that the universe had a absolute beginning.

What evidence? There isn't any. All we have is theoretical models of what might have happened before the Planck point. We have no evidence at all. Are you just making this up?

1. Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, either in the necessity of its own nature or in an external ground.

That's just supposition. We can trace back events within the universe to work out the cause or reason for things existing within the universe, but we have no empirical basis for determining whether or not the universe itself (ie. "everything") ultimately has a reason or cause for its existence or not.

In fact, as I and several others have pointed out to you, virtual particles do pop into existence without cause.

2. Whatever begins to exist is not necessary in its existence.

This is a very vague and ambiguous statement. I can's make any sense of it. Are you saying that whatever will begin to exist doesn't necessarily exist at this moment in time, or are you trying to say something else altogether?

3. If the universe has an external ground of its existence, then there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.

Wow... eight non-sequiturs in a single sentence. This has to be some kind of logical fallacy world record. :clap:

Everything after this point in your post can only be anti-climatic.
 
"Suppose you are dragged before a firing squad consisting of 100 marksmen. You hear the command to fire and the crashing roar of the rifles. You then realize you are still alive, and that not a single bullet found its mark. How are you to react to this rather unlikely event?"

Personally, I'd fall over and play dead, and wait for a chance to escape. :D
 
well, fact that you do not admit the presented facts are no evidence does not mean in fact they are no evidence. It just means you do ignore them. As they permit my presented explanation, they permit any other explanation as well. The quest remains however, which explanation is the best and most reasonable one.

A sky daddy is the most reasonable one?
 
based on what explanation should i admit the cosmological argument is not valid ?


Pick any explanation you want, we've all provided plenty for you to choose from. For example, in my first post on this thread, I gave you three different reasons why the cosmological argument is not valid, but you never responded to any of them.
 
Last edited:
For the same reason you wouldn't bet heads coming up on a coin that's landed tails 100 times in a row or stay in a poker game after the dealer's dealt himself a fifth royal flush. The Pi result (and the coin result and the royal flushes) are both much more plausible on the theory of loaded dice (or coins or cards) than chance alone.

But let's backtrack a second: Is there anyone that would bet even money on a coin coming up heads on the 101st toss after its landed tails 100 times in a row?

Again, what's so important about life?
 
And why are we talking about time, anyway?

Very simple. the alternative of a finite universe ( i.e. with a absolute beginning, thus needing a cause ) , is a eternal universe, which had no beginning, thus eternal. If it is eternal, time had no beginning as well. As long as the universe exists, time must exist as well. But this is not possible, as shown prior:

www.thekeyboard.org.uk/What is infinity.htm

Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite, only things that MOVE MATHEMATICALLY TOWARDS infinity. A black hole is formed when large stars collapse and their mass has been compressed down to a very small size and the powerful gravitational field so formed prevents anything, even light, from escaping from it. A black hole therefore forms a singularity at its centre from the concentrated mass of the collapsed star itself and from the accumulated mass that is sucked into it. A singularity's mass is therefore finite, the 'infinity' refers only to the maths.

Can we have an infinite universe for example? The answer is no, the universe is finite. Stephen Hawking in 'A Brief History of Time' (1989 page 44) describes the universe as being "finite but unbounded". The simplest answer is that as the universe is known to be expanding, it cannot possibly be infinite.
 
Everything that had a beginning, must have a cause, i.e. our universe.

How do you know the universe had a beginning ?

Since God had no beginning, he needs no cause.

How do you know God has had no beginning ?

No special pleading here.

Why not save a step and simply declare that the universe had no beginning and therefore no cause ?
 
You contradict yourself. If the evidence suggests, the universe is finite, than it is based on this that we shall base our reasoning. And so : If the universe is finite, it had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.

That conclusion does not follow from the premises.
 
The Pr of any event (or evidence) that has already happened is 1. Again, I ask you if you could conclude anything from watching a video of a die landing 3 a hundred times in a row. Of course. You would conclude the die was biased, even though the event has already happened. This is because, counterfactually, you assign low odds to any fair die landing that many times in a row, even though it's already happened.



Is it possible for Mercury not to have an eccentric orbit? If Pr Mercury's eccentric orbit = 1, then relatavity theory receieves no confirmation for "predicting" Mercury's orbit. But relatavity theory was confirmed by a tremendous degree by predicting evidence that had been known for many years. You're getting hung up on old evidence.

I don't think you understand his point. No matter how many universes there are or have been, we could ever only exist in one that bears life i.e. us. Any universe in which this could happen would "appear fine-tuned for life", so obviously if we're here the universe appears fine-tuned. It doesn't follow that it is.
 
To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life.

Neither does nuclear physics, but then it's not supposed to.

While this does not disprove atheism by itself

You can say that, again.

if the logical outworking of a belief system fails to account for what we instinctively know to be true, it ought to be discarded.

1) How do you know it to be true ?
2) Haven't you learned anything about intuition, yet ?
3) What about other religions and what they "know" ?

Without God there would be no objective basis for morality, no life, and no reason to live it. Yet all these things do exist, and so does God. Thus, the moral argument for the existence of God.

Circular reasoning. You ASSUME that god is necessary for life and then backtrack from the fact that life exist to show that god does, as well. You have not proven that god is necessary for life and therefore your argument fails.
 
"Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, "

Would it have to be a reason humans could understand?
Would it have to be a "good reason"?
Would it have to be driven by anything other than natural forces?
Would it have to agree with your own vision of the Universe?
Would it have to be powered by something at cares at all about human beings?
 
It is almost as if those who make the claim that atheism must lead to despair are terrified of where it might truly lead.

For many people I think its a case of "My belief is so important to me that I can't imagine anyone else being happy without it. Therefor I assume that they are miserable".

It's like me saying "I love my wife and she makes me happy. Therefor everyone who isn't married to my wife is unhappy".
 
For the same reason you wouldn't bet heads coming up on a coin that's landed tails 100 times in a row or stay in a poker game after the dealer's dealt himself a fifth royal flush. The Pi result (and the coin result and the royal flushes) are both much more plausible on the theory of loaded dice (or coins or cards) than chance alone.

But let's backtrack a second: Is there anyone that would bet even money on a coin coming up heads on the 101st toss after its landed tails 100 times in a row?

I would, assuming that it could be shown that there was no trickery going on.

You still don't understand the point. It isn't that the universe is fine-tuned for life. It's that we could never see any universe - or even any part of the universe - that doesn't fit the conditions necessary for life to exist. The odds of life existing in any given area of the universe are actually microscopic. But the universe itself is mind-bogglingly huge. At some point, probability states that there has to be at least one place capable of supporting life. So that's the only place there could be life, and therefore the conditional probability of us observing the conditions in that specific area are 100%.
 
Can we have an infinite universe for example? The answer is no, the universe is finite. Stephen Hawking in 'A Brief History of Time' (1989 page 44) describes the universe as being "finite but unbounded". The simplest answer is that as the universe is known to be expanding, it cannot possibly be infinite.
Have you read the book or are you merely quote mining it? I ask because you seem to fail to grasp the fact that Hawking's conclusion in the book is that the universe is unbounded in space and time (no beginning, no end) yet also finite. Your notion that time continues beyond the Big Bang is erroneous. There most likely simply is no before the Big Bang any more than there is a north of the North Pole.

From Carl Sagan's introduction to A Brief History of Time:

"Hawking is attempting, as he explicitly states, to understand the mind of God. And this makes all the more unexpected the conclusion of the effort, at least so far: a universe with no edge in space, no beginning or end in time, and nothing for a Creator to do."
 
Have you read the book or are you merely quote mining it? I ask because you seem to fail to grasp the fact that Hawking's conclusion in the book is that the universe is unbounded in space and time (no beginning, no end) yet also finite. Your notion that time continues beyond the Big Bang is erroneous. There most likely simply is no before the Big Bang any more than there is a north of the North Pole.

From Carl Sagan's introduction to A Brief History of Time:

"Hawking is attempting, as he explicitly states, to understand the mind of God. And this makes all the more unexpected the conclusion of the effort, at least so far: a universe with no edge in space, no beginning or end in time, and nothing for a Creator to do."

Even aside from this, though, even assuming that the universe has a definite beginning, GIBHOR's argument falls apart.
 
This whole thing is kind of an argument by lack of imagination. There's more than one proposal describing a finite universe that has no beginning.

One of my faves is a cute idea from the physicist J. Richard Gott, who posits a small time loop at the “beginning” of the universe. This is a bit like Robert Oz's story upthread, except Gott models his mathematically (see Time Travel in Einstein's Universe). There's no “absolute beginning,” no infinite regression, no creator, no problem.

GIBHOR, if any portion of your faith rests on science not being able to figure something out, or on science's imagination being as limited as your own (or any one person's), then your faith rests on eggshells, my friend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom