Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
E.g., there are tribes in which being a murderer actually increases one's social status and likelihood to find a mate. And the Spartans had it as a rite of passage into adulthood to be sent off to murder a Helot or two (slaves) to keep them in line.

that does not mean automatically their conscience was agreeing with that procedure. that applies to all other presented examples.
 
based on what explanation should i admit the cosmological argument is not valid ?

Maybe you missed, oh, I don't know, EVERY POST IN THIS THREAD.

well, fact that you do not admit the presented facts are no evidence does not mean in fact they are no evidence. It just means you do ignore them. As they permit my presented explanation, they permit any other explanation as well. The quest remains however, which explanation is the best and most reasonable one.

The fact that you maintain that they are evidence doesn't mean that they are, either.
 
If you tossed 50 D10's, and they landed in this order:
314159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510

Would you think it an accident?
.
If not an accident, what would be another reason?
Would there be some sort of purpose to getting those results?
 
I notice Zsa Zsa Gibhor ;) has not answered my points. I wonder why.

Haven't you learned a thing? If you believed in some God you could easily make sense of it.

(Or at least be under the illusion that saying "God" makes sense of it.)
 
Why wouldn't it be? Because it's improbable?

For the same reason you wouldn't bet heads coming up on a coin that's landed tails 100 times in a row or stay in a poker game after the dealer's dealt himself a fifth royal flush. The Pi result (and the coin result and the royal flushes) are both much more plausible on the theory of loaded dice (or coins or cards) than chance alone.

But let's backtrack a second: Is there anyone that would bet even money on a coin coming up heads on the 101st toss after its landed tails 100 times in a row?
 
.
If not an accident, what would be another reason?
Would there be some sort of purpose to getting those results?

Are the odds of someone playing a trick on you 1/100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000?
 
And lastly, Big Bang theory does not state that our universe or any other universe (let alone the omniverse!) came from nothing. Big Bang theory, being based on observations and understood laws of physics, concerns itself only with the moments after the big bang in question and afterward. It is predicted that the initial starting point was maybe the size of a basketball, or an apple, or a grape, or whatever, but it most certainly is stated that it was and thing, because currently understood physics isn't up to the task of understand what that might have been. (And making deductions based on ignorance isn't logical.)

regarding your mentioning of multiverse, omniverse etc. Even if they exist ( and there is no evidence for that, its juts pure speculation based on any empirical observations ) they must as well have a absolute beginning, as Vilenkin clearly states :

elshamah.heavenforum.com/atheist-scientists-and-authors-f13/alexander-vilenkin-t230.htm

Alexander Vilenkin is Professor of Physics and Director of the Institute of Cosmology at Tufts University. A theoretical physicist who has been working in the field of cosmology for 25 years, Vilenkin has written over 150 papers and is responsible for introducing the ideas of eternal inflation and quantum creation of the universe from nothing.

It is said that an argument is what convinces reasonable men and a proof is what it takes to convince even an unreasonable man. With the proof now in place, cosmologists can no longer hide behind the possibility of a past-eternal universe. There is no escape, they have to face the problem of a cosmic beginning (Many Worlds in One [New York: Hill and Wang, 2006], p.176).

to your second argument : its not valid in face of the second law of thermodynamics. Based on that law alone, we can conclude the universe had a absolute beginning. Otherwise we would not exist anymore.
secondly, any real thing can be infinite in our universe and dimension, as shown prior. Another example is Hilberts Hotel.

Hilbert's Hotel is even stranger than the German mathematician gave it out to be. For suppose some of the guests start to check out. Suppose the guest in room #1 departs. Is there not now one less person in the hotel? Not according to the mathematicians-but just ask the woman who makes the beds! Suppose the guests in room numbers 1, 3, 5, . . . check out. In this case an infinite number of people have left the hotel, but according to the mathematicians there are no less people in the hotel-but don't talk to that laundry woman! In fact, we could have every other guest check out of the hotel and repeat this process infinitely many times, and yet there would never be any less people in the hotel. But suppose instead the persons in room number 4, 5, 6, . . . checked out. At a single stroke the hotel would be virtually emptied, the guest register reduced to three names, and the infinite converted to finitude. And yet it would remain true that the same number of guests checked out this time as when the guests in room numbers 1, 3, 5, . . . checked out. Can anyone sincerely believe that such a hotel could exist in reality? These sorts of absurdities illustrate the impossibility of the existence of an actually infinite number of things.

elshamah.heavenforum.com/philosophy-and-god-f14/philosophy-of-time-t178.htm

Let us begin with Craig's own summary of the argument.

A collection formed by successive addition cannot be actually infinite.

The temporal series of past events is a collection formed by successive addition.

Therefore, the temporal series of past events cannot be actually infinite.

It is important to see that when Craig says that the series of past events is "formed by successive addition" he does not mean merely that it is constituted by a series of events located at earlier and later temporal positions as defined by some temporal metric. If that were all Craig meant, then an actually infinite temporal series of distinct events would be no more objectionable to him than an actually infinite spatial series of distinct objects, and the truth of premise (2.21) would be wholly dependent on the soundness of Craig’s general argument against the actual infinite. But Craig thinks there is something especially objectionable about the claim that the series o f past events is infinite–something having to do with the nature of time itself.

Premiss (2.22) presupposes a dynamical view of time according to which events are actualized in serial fashion, one after another. The series of events is not a sort of timelessly subsisting world-line which appears successively in conscio usness. Rather becoming is real and essential to temporal process. [EGBU]

Why does this matter? What difference does a "dynamical view of time" make? The answer appears to be that if time really "passes" then an infinite series of events ending in the present would actually have been traversed, one at a time. In this process, an infinite series would have reached completion–something Craig believes to be absurd. "Since one can always add one more before arriving at infinity," he says, "it is impossible to reach actual infinity." [EGBU]
 
If that pi result came up -every time-, there could be a significance to that, but once in a jabillion attempts, it means nothing, other than being one of the jabillion ways a result could be obtained.
And I get fooled a lot more times than 1/10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0?
 
For the same reason you wouldn't bet heads coming up on a coin that's landed tails 100 times in a row or stay in a poker game after the dealer's dealt himself a fifth royal flush. The Pi result (and the coin result and the royal flushes) are both much more plausible on the theory of loaded dice (or coins or cards) than chance alone.

But let's backtrack a second: Is there anyone that would bet even money on a coin coming up heads on the 101st toss after its landed tails 100 times in a row?

The chances of any given flip are 50/50, so the chances of the 101st toss being heads after the previous 100 being tails are still 50/50. The chances of coming up with 100 consecutive tails followed by 1 head are another thing altogether. The odds of any given configuration of coin toss results are the same as any other set of results of the same number of iterations. This still assumes a fair coin and flipping process. Again, whatever the odds, it is more implausible for it never to happen at all than to occur.

The thing about plausibility and odds is, you need to know what goes into it to assess them. Toss a double headed coin and your chances of coming up with a head are 100%. If you're trying to make some sort of statement about the universe, you should bear in mind that if you don't know what went into it, you cannot speak of whether the event or parameter is "plausible" or not, or what the odds are.
 
Last edited:
Because it is a tool, a good tool, the best one we have.
Yes, it is a great tool for obtaining empirical knowledge, no doubt. But, many of the arguments presented are not empirical. The word "evidence" in the title probably refers to its common usage among non-scientists as "things that feel right".

Because of that, science comes up to show the religious that their religion is merely a philosophy and not factually true, as they would like to (also) believe.
Is that the intention of the claims being made here? I have not read most of the opening posters posts, yet, so maybe I missed that part.

Umm, so, in a talk about the origins of the universe, and when asked what other explanation than God makes sense of it... you can't see why science entered the thread? :p
Oh, I see why science entered the thread. Science helps us make sense of the Universe in ways that are much more reliable than religion. But, as far as I can tell GIBHOR is not arguing reliability or empirical deduction. He is arguing what seems to feel right to him.

Sometimes, it might be best to address his philosophy on philosophical grounds, first.

Now that I have had more time to respond, I will flesh out my previous post in here, a little more:

five good reasons to think that God exists:

1. God makes sense of the origin of the universe.

2. God makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

(item 3 removed from quote for reasons explained below)

4. God makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.
These three are all philosophical arguments. (Item #3 will be discussed separately.) They are not scientific arguments. They do not constitute "evidence of God" in a scientific manner. But, they could all seem reasonable to some people's philosophical models of the Universe. (They "feel true" in the person's mind.) And are not even trying to make scientific claims. So arguing against them with science is futile, unless the arguer is trying to claim otherwise.

Granted, one could demonstrate:
1. Alternative origins of the Universe that do not include God, but could make very good sense of cosmological observations. And...
2. That fine-tuning is not really necessary for life: That life forms could have evolved from a wide variety of different environmental conditions, very much unlike ours, and make the same claim that the Universe was finely-tuned for them.

But, that would be science, not philosophy.

Four is a specific reference to a religious legend. But, still something some folks can use in their philosophical modeling.

I might be able to develop some philosophical arguments against those, later. But, for now, I can put better effort into another one:

Let us take a closer look at Number 3:

3. God makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

GIBHOR later explained this further:

...Right and wrong imply a higher standard or law, and law requires a lawgiver. Because the Moral Law transcends humanity, this universal law requires a universal lawgiver. This, it is argued, is God...

This is a philosophical argument. But, I can argue that it is a bad one. Unlike the three I mentioned so far, it is instantly destroyed on a moment's reflection. Either:

A. There are no objective moral values: Most religions endorsed slavery throughout most of history, and today most of them (in developed countries, at least) do not. Most people who attend church or synagogue regularly can probably remember specific moments when their own preachers adjusted their moral sense over time.

OR

B. There were moral objectives, but no one can tell what they are supposed to be, because we keep changing our sense of objectives over time, based on subjective measures of human needs and interests. And, most of such decisions have been brutally violent throughout most of history. So, God does not seem to help us "make sense" of them.

I argue that it is stronger philosophy to recognize that our moral values are developed by the community around us. They are molded and shaped over time, as our needs and interests change over time, especially for survival. This can be true if God exists or not. And, I think it feels more realistic and natural, in a philosophical sense.

They might seem "objective", but only because of how well they have been driven into the heritage of our ancestral history.

Of course I could be wrong. I wonder if the original poster would like to list some specific examples of objective morals.

If you agree with me or not, #3 is ripe for philosophical arguing. Not mere scientific analysis. Unlike, perhaps, the next one:

5. God can be immediately known and experienced.
This one, unlike all the others, is on the verge of being a scientific claim. Either you truly are experiencing God, and we should be able to isolate and measure His being scientifically. OR, this is an argument from delusion: One might think they are knowing and experiencing God, much like one can think they are experiencing sliding down rainbows while on drugs, but they would be wrong.

Therefore, it is more appropriate for the science section, and less so for the philosophy one.

But, I could be wrong about that, too. I might develop some philosophy-based arguments for it, later.

To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life.
I argue that atheists acquire their morality from the same place religious people do: From the community around them.

God is not the only way for altruism and other positive moral concepts to emerge. Perhaps you did not realize that, before. But, that could help explain why many countries with high populations of atheists also have low rates of crime.

So it is not logical to argue that there is no basis for morality, hope, or meaning of life, for atheists. It is bad philosophy.
 
Last edited:
You contradict yourself. If the evidence suggests, the universe is finite, than it is based on this that we shall base our reasoning. And so : If the universe is finite, it had a absolute beginning, thus, a cause.

The surface of a sphere is finite. Tell me, where is its beginning?
 
Regarding your mentioning of multiverse, omniverse etc. Even if they exist ( and there is no evidence for that, its juts pure speculation based on any empirical observations ) they must as well have a absolute beginning, as Vilenkin clearly states:

It is said that an argument is what convinces reasonable men and a proof is what it takes to convince even an unreasonable man. With the proof now in place, cosmologists can no longer hide behind the possibility of a past-eternal universe. There is no escape, they have to face the problem of a cosmic beginning (Many Worlds in One [New York: Hill and Wang, 2006], p.176).

Argument from authority. If you want to prove this point, do so. I'm not going to take Vilenkin's or anyone else's word for it. You are free to consider those concepts wild speculation, but unless you can prove that those speculations are impossible, theories that operate on the requirement that such things are impossible do not follow logically.


To your second argument: its not valid in face of the second law of thermodynamics. Based on that law alone, we can conclude the universe had an absolute beginning. Otherwise we would not exist anymore. secondly, any real thing can be infinite in our universe and dimension, as shown prior.

And based on the law of conservation of energy alone, you're wrong. Try to understand that while you're Googling "cherry picking". Feel free to cut-n-paste what you find, like everything else. I don't know what you're referring to in your second statement, but if you're suggesting you've already proved something to me, I'm suggesting you've ignored my refutation to it. Address that. Repetition != argument.

http://www.origins.org/articles/craig_existencegodbeginning.html

William Lane Craig said:
Another example is Hilberts Hotel. Hilbert's Hotel is even stranger than the German mathematician gave it out to be. For suppose some of the guests start to check out. Suppose the guest in room #1 departs. Is there not now one less person in the hotel? Not according to the mathematicians-but just ask the woman who makes the beds! Suppose the guests in room numbers 1, 3, 5, . . . check out. In this case an infinite number of people have left the hotel, but according to the mathematicians there are no less people in the hotel-but don't talk to that laundry woman! In fact, we could have every other guest check out of the hotel and repeat this process infinitely many times, and yet there would never be any less people in the hotel. But suppose instead the persons in room number 4, 5, 6, . . . checked out. At a single stroke the hotel would be virtually emptied, the guest register reduced to three names, and the infinite converted to finitude. And yet it would remain true that the same number of guests checked out this time as when the guests in room numbers 1, 3, 5, . . . checked out. Can anyone sincerely believe that such a hotel could exist in reality? These sorts of absurdities illustrate the impossibility of the existence of an actually infinite number of things.

Infinity is not a number. :rolleyes:

Because infinity is not a number, it cannot be used like a number, as "your" argument relies upon. Of course you can't "reach" infinity -- it's not a number. This is what happens when you let someone else do your thinking for you, dude. I'm not asking you to believe me -- prove it to yourself. Imagine an infinite set that only runs in one direction.

Hint: it can't be done -- the labels are arbitrary. In the Hilbert hotel example, the mistake was in assuming you could bump anyone down into the next room. There are no open rooms, so you can't bump anyone into an open room, therefore "bumping" is ruled out. Don't take my word for it, try it yourself.

And why are we talking about time, anyway? No one understands time or can even show that it exists at all. Why are you going around quoting people's assertions that things are or are not possible due to the nature of something they cannot possibly understand?

If you want to conduct this discussion honestly, I'm all ears. If you just want to parrot nonsense at me that you yourself do not comprehend, let me know.
 
Last edited:
Now there is no doubt that creatio ex nihilo is deeply baffling.
You misunderstand GIBHOR. Back up.

Pure_Argent: There also wouldn't be any time outside the universe, and therefore no cause-effect relationships. Something could literally have come from nothing.​
Gibhor: that goes agianst all empirical observations.​
yy2bggggs:There are absolutely no empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo.​

Whether or not creation ex nihilo is baffling is beside the point. You said that Pure_Argent's claim goes against all empirical observations, and I claimed that there were no such empirical observations. Baffling or no, do you have empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo?
I well recall thinking, as I began to study the kalam cosmological argument, that all of the alternatives with respect to the universe's existence––the infinitude of the past, creation ex nihilo, spontaneous origination ex nihilo ––were so bizarre that the most reasonable option seemed to be that nothing exists!
Yes. And it makes sense that it would be baffling, because we've grown up and become familiar with all we have grown up around and become familiar with. And that only involves things behaving as we would consider "normal". But it doesn't involve anything being created ex nihilo. We just don't have the experience to draw upon.
Since our existence is, however, undeniable, we must settle, however uncomfortably, on one of the above three.
Or some other option you didn't think of. We're generally not as good at enumerating things as you think we are. Who in their right minds could have ever dreamed up with anything even remotely resembling QM without the evidence twisting his arms?
Since we assume for the sake of argument in the present discussion the finitude of the past, our choices are creation ex nihilo or an uncaused origination ex nihilo.
Who is this we? I know that the universe started with a big bang, but beyond that, there may or may not be some grander laws. The "we" on this side of the keyboard wants to know the actual, factual answer. And the "we" on this side of the keyboard knows that actual factual answers arise from asking questions of the universe. LHC is a very big, and expensive, question asker that's underway that just might get enough answers to at least ask the question correctly. Why not wait a few years to see what they dig up?
It seems to me that there is a very simple and yet decisive reason for preferring creation, namely, whereas creation ex nihilo is counter–intuitive in denying to the universe a material cause, it at least ascribes to it an efficient cause, whereas the spontaneous origination of the universe ex nihilo is doubly counter–intuitive in that it denies of the universe both a material and (especially) an efficient cause. Thus, even if one agrees with Morriston's observation, "When I do the relevant 'thought experiments,' I find the absence of a material cause at least as troubling as the absence of an efficient cause,"{10} one cannot agree with his objection, since an uncaused origin of the universe lacks both sorts of cause and so is doubly implausible.
I have no idea what you're trying to say here. Here's a toothpick. The material cause of this toothpick is wood. Someone chopped down a tree and carved this toothpick, in a factory perhaps, and put it into a box, and it went to a store, and I bought it, brought it here, and wound up with a wooden toothpick.

The universe is made of energy. That energy comes from the universe. The energy is the material cause of the universe. The energy was there at the big bang, when time started. What sense does it make to talk about the material cause of the universe? That's just the energy at t=0, if it happened that way at all. I'm going to have to guess that you mean for there to be a place where the universe "gets" its energy, but since we're talking about the beginning of time, you're going to have to demonstrate that this makes sense in the first place.

Regardless, it would appear to me that you're going about this thing backwards anyway. You seem to think that if you identify more causes, then it would make more sense. But what you're forgetting is that each cause you identify needs a new entity. And every time you add a new entity, you're extrapolating. To have a "material cause" in the sense of having "somewhere" where the energy comes from, we need the energy to be there and a mechanism. To have a material cause and an efficient cause, you need the energy to be there, a mechanism, and an agency.
The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die. The cosmos is not eternal, and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy.
The second law of thermodynamics suggests that within a closed system the amount of usable energy decreases over time. But it does not say that energy decreases--only usable energy. That makes energy eternal.

The second law also has nothing to do with our particular brand of mortality. We are an open system. We gain energy when we eat. We generate entropy in the form of heat radiated to the environment. The second law of thermodynamics would not be violated if we lasted as long as the sun.

We die for other reasons.
The biblical statement that there was a beginning is strongly attested to by the second law.
Irrelevant. We know there was a beginning because we asked the universe. Truth is obtained by gathering information from the thing you're talking about. You claimed to be presenting a rational argument. Don't you think this is rational?
We would like to point out that it is incorrect to apply the second law to the earth or to anything on the earth.
What does this have to do with the argument? And who is this we?
because all scientific evidence shows us , that the universe had a absolute beginning.
Sure, but the current best scientific evidence suggests that there was no time at which there was nothing. Adding a god to create the universe through your line of logic doesn't even fit with this scientific evidence, as there would be no time for a causal act to occur. Furthermore, you would need that god to be there. Furthermore, you would need a mechanism for that god to create (he has to do something to create, right?) Furthermore, that mechanism would have to be creation ex nihilo.

It's possible. But it's certainly not suggested, and it's certainly not intuitive. You yourself started this response trying to tell me how non-intuitive it was.
Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite,
This came out of nowhere. How is it relevant?
1. Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, either in the necessity of its own nature or in an external ground.
2. Whatever begins to exist is not necessary in its existence.
2 follows from nothing--especially if time itself had a beginning. Furthermore, if something is counter-intuitive, it's problematic to try to intuit your way around it. Your methods are doomed to fail from the get go.

Ask the universe!
3. If the universe has an external ground of its existence, then there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
You made that up. It certainly doesn't rationally follow that a universe having an external ground for its existence must therfore require a Creator. It follows even less that said creator must be Personal. It also does not follow that said creator would be beginningless. It also does not follow that said creator would be changeless. Or necessary. Or uncaused. Even enormously powerful doesn't follow, though granted it's probably difficult to see why at first--but picture the possibility that, for example, God did not create the universe ex nihilo, but diverted pre-existing energy.

Now, my objection is to each of the above severally. And the fact that you're trying to put it all into play strongly suggests that your methods are not, as you proposed earlier, rational, but instead, that you're trying to pound your own specific idea of a god into the argument.
4. The universe began to exist.
That I'll grant you.
From (2) and (4) it follows that 5. Therefore, the universe is not necessary in its existence.
2 is in question.
From (1) and (5) it follows further that 6. Therefore, the universe has an external ground of its existence.
5 is in question due to 2 being in question.
From (3) and (6) it we can conclude that
6 is in question due to 5 and 2 being in question and, furthermore, due to 3 being in question, in each and all of its parts, severally.
7. Therefore, there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
7 is in question due to 6, 5, and 2 being in question, and 3 being in question severally in each and all of its parts, severally.
 
To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life.

Atheism is not a belief system. It is simply a lack of belief in gods. It is not intended to serve as a basis for morality. The lack of belief in gods does not preclude other belief systems that can provide a basis for morality, hope, and even meaning for life. If you care to read what the atheists on this forum have to say on the matter you will find that virtually all of them subscribe to a moral system and that they experience great beauty and wonder as well as love in their lives.
 
Is that the intention of the claims being made here? I have not read most of the opening posters posts, yet, so maybe I missed that part.

I can't speak for anyone else, but of course that doesn't mean that isn't the reason, even if that wasn't how anyone would state it. The OP started it by invoking cosmology. While it's certainly an iffy proposition to suggest that cosmology is science, per se, they're certainly common bedfellows. If there is one thing cosmology is guaranteed to produce, it's a war between science and philosophy and an infinite (!) "number" of blurry lines between them. By invoking it, GIBHOR pretty much begs to be shown what side of what line he's on.
 
Last edited:
Atheism is not a belief system. It is simply a lack of belief in gods. It is not intended to serve as a basis for morality. The lack of belief in gods does not preclude other belief systems that can provide a basis for morality, hope, and even meaning for life. If you care to read what the atheists on this forum have to say on the matter you will find that virtually all of them subscribe to a moral system and that they experience great beauty and wonder as well as love in their lives.


It is almost as if those who make the claim that atheism must lead to despair are terrified of where it might truly lead.
 
that does not mean automatically their conscience was agreeing with that procedure. that applies to all other presented examples.

Their conscience was disagreeing with their consciousness?
 
Mm. Chess fudge pie. With meringue. Enough for everybody! :) (Starts to pass plates and forks.)

Mmm.

Whipped cream?

Us poor humans so close to god and so far from pi.
 
For the same reason you wouldn't bet heads coming up on a coin that's landed tails 100 times in a row or stay in a poker game after the dealer's dealt himself a fifth royal flush. The Pi result (and the coin result and the royal flushes) are both much more plausible on the theory of loaded dice (or coins or cards) than chance alone.

But let's backtrack a second: Is there anyone that would bet even money on a coin coming up heads on the 101st toss after its landed tails 100 times in a row?

I suggest you quit the game as it is obviously rigged.

Oh, that's your point that god is the ultimate fixer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom