Now there is no doubt that creatio ex nihilo is deeply baffling.
You misunderstand GIBHOR. Back up.
Pure_Argent: There also wouldn't be any time outside the universe, and therefore no cause-effect relationships. Something could literally have come from nothing.
Gibhor: that goes agianst all empirical observations.
yy2bggggs:There are absolutely no empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo.
Whether or not creation ex nihilo is baffling is beside the point. You said that Pure_Argent's claim goes against all empirical observations, and I claimed that there were no such empirical observations. Baffling or no, do you have empirical observations supporting creation ex nihilo?
I well recall thinking, as I began to study the kalam cosmological argument, that all of the alternatives with respect to the universe's existence––the infinitude of the past, creation ex nihilo, spontaneous origination ex nihilo ––were so bizarre that the most reasonable option seemed to be that nothing exists!
Yes. And it makes sense that it would be baffling, because we've grown up and become familiar with all we have grown up around and become familiar with. And that only involves things behaving as we would consider "normal". But it doesn't involve anything being created ex nihilo. We just don't have the experience to draw upon.
Since our existence is, however, undeniable, we must settle, however uncomfortably, on one of the above three.
Or some other option you didn't think of. We're generally not as good at enumerating things as you think we are. Who in their right minds could have ever dreamed up with anything even remotely resembling QM without the evidence twisting his arms?
Since we assume for the sake of argument in the present discussion the finitude of the past, our choices are creation ex nihilo or an uncaused origination ex nihilo.
Who is this we? I know that the universe started with a big bang, but beyond that, there may or may not be some grander laws. The "we" on
this side of the keyboard wants to know the actual, factual answer. And the "we" on
this side of the keyboard knows that actual factual answers arise from asking questions of the universe. LHC is a very big, and expensive, question asker that's underway that just might get enough answers to at least ask the question correctly. Why not wait a few years to see what they dig up?
It seems to me that there is a very simple and yet decisive reason for preferring creation, namely, whereas creation ex nihilo is counter–intuitive in denying to the universe a material cause, it at least ascribes to it an efficient cause, whereas the spontaneous origination of the universe ex nihilo is doubly counter–intuitive in that it denies of the universe both a material and (especially) an efficient cause. Thus, even if one agrees with Morriston's observation, "When I do the relevant 'thought experiments,' I find the absence of a material cause at least as troubling as the absence of an efficient cause,"{10} one cannot agree with his objection, since an uncaused origin of the universe lacks both sorts of cause and so is doubly implausible.
I have no idea what you're trying to say here. Here's a toothpick. The material cause of this toothpick is wood. Someone chopped down a tree and carved this toothpick, in a factory perhaps, and put it into a box, and it went to a store, and I bought it, brought it here, and wound up with a wooden toothpick.
The universe is made of energy. That energy comes from the universe. The energy is the material cause of the universe. The energy was there at the big bang, when time started. What sense does it make to talk about the material cause of the universe? That's just the energy at t=0, if it happened that way at all. I'm going to have to guess that you mean for there to be a place where the universe "gets" its energy, but since we're talking about the beginning of time, you're going to have to demonstrate that this makes sense in the first place.
Regardless, it would appear to me that you're going about this thing backwards anyway. You seem to think that if you identify more causes, then it would make more sense. But what you're forgetting is that each cause you identify needs a new entity. And every time you add a new entity, you're extrapolating. To have a "material cause" in the sense of having "somewhere" where the energy comes from, we need the energy to be there and a mechanism. To have a material cause and an efficient cause, you need the energy to be there, a mechanism, and an agency.
The second law says that like us, all stars and all galaxies will eventually die. The cosmos is not eternal, and there had to be a specific point at which there was no energy in an unusable form in the cosmos--no entropy.
The second law of thermodynamics suggests that within a closed system the amount of usable energy decreases over time. But it does not say that energy decreases--only usable energy. That makes energy eternal.
The second law also has nothing to do with our particular brand of mortality. We are an open system. We gain energy when we eat. We generate entropy in the form of heat radiated to the environment. The second law of thermodynamics would not be violated if we lasted as long as the sun.
We die for other reasons.
The biblical statement that there was a beginning is strongly attested to by the second law.
Irrelevant. We know there was a beginning because we asked the universe. Truth is obtained by gathering information from the thing you're talking about. You claimed to be presenting a rational argument. Don't you think this is rational?
We would like to point out that it is incorrect to apply the second law to the earth or to anything on the earth.
What does this have to do with the argument? And who is
this we?
because all scientific evidence shows us , that the universe had a absolute beginning.
Sure, but the current best scientific evidence suggests that there was no time at which there was nothing. Adding a god to create the universe through your line of logic
doesn't even fit with this scientific evidence, as there would be no time for a causal act to occur. Furthermore, you would need that god to be there. Furthermore, you would need a mechanism for that god to create (he has to
do something to create, right?) Furthermore, that mechanism would have to be creation ex nihilo.
It's possible. But it's certainly not suggested, and it's certainly not intuitive. You yourself started this response trying to tell me how non-intuitive it was.
Strictly speaking, according to Einstein's Theory of Relativity, a singularity does not contain anything that is actually infinite,
This came out of nowhere. How is it relevant?
1. Whatever exists has a reason for its existence, either in the necessity of its own nature or in an external ground.
2. Whatever begins to exist is not necessary in its existence.
2 follows from nothing--especially if time itself had a beginning. Furthermore, if something is counter-intuitive, it's problematic to try to intuit your way around it. Your methods are doomed to fail from the get go.
Ask the universe!
3. If the universe has an external ground of its existence, then there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
You made that up. It certainly doesn't rationally follow that a universe having an external ground for its existence must therfore require a Creator. It follows even less that said creator must be Personal. It also does not follow that said creator would be beginningless. It also does not follow that said creator would be changeless. Or necessary. Or uncaused. Even enormously powerful doesn't follow, though granted it's probably difficult to see why at first--but picture the possibility that, for example, God did not create the universe ex nihilo, but diverted pre-existing energy.
Now, my objection is to each of the above
severally. And the fact that you're trying to put it all into play strongly suggests that your methods are not, as you proposed earlier, rational, but instead, that you're trying to pound your own specific idea of a god into the argument.
4. The universe began to exist.
That I'll grant you.
From (2) and (4) it follows that 5. Therefore, the universe is not necessary in its existence.
2 is in question.
From (1) and (5) it follows further that 6. Therefore, the universe has an external ground of its existence.
5 is in question due to 2 being in question.
From (3) and (6) it we can conclude that
6 is in question due to 5 and 2 being in question and, furthermore, due to 3 being in question, in each and all of its parts, severally.
7. Therefore, there exists a Personal Creator of the universe, who, sans the universe, is timeless, spaceless, beginningless, changeless, necessary, uncaused, and enormously powerful.
7 is in question due to 6, 5, and 2 being in question, and 3 being in question severally in each and all of its parts, severally.