Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Maybe he has selective blindness and literally cannot see the words "other" and "thread".

Or maybe he is just ducking like a quack*.







*I so rarely say anything witty or humorous that when I crack a joke I repeat it endlessly until someone laughs out of pity...

I was planning on nominating this, it was so good I assumed it was a well-known line already.

So apologies for making that assumption, and let me confirm how good a line it was.
 
Look, if even a tenth of the unsubstantiated anecdote had the slightest basis in fact, we wouldn't need trials like these. Strict placebo-controlled trials are for showing whether something works when there's some doubt about it. Not for proving the self-evident. (Think about the concept of a placebo-controlled trial of insulin for diabetes - unethical, anyone?) Even new, untested treatments can skip this part, if they're obvious enough. Ever heard of a trial being truncated early because the drug was so good that it was soon clear that it was unethical to deprive the placebo group of it? Yes, has happened several times in real medicine.

Tell you what, Dana, if you can find a trial of a homoeopathic treatment that was stopped early because the benefits were so clear that it was considered unethical to go on depriving the placebo group of the benefit, we'll capitulate right here and now.

Otherwise, take your dodgy statistics and marginal data-dredged benefits to the other thread, and concentrate on finding that one, elusive patient with a documented homoeopathic cure.
Rolfe.

Rolfe, I think this new challenge is a fantastic one. (Dana has failed to answer the previous one, will he give this one a go?) This is indeed a clear cut indicator of clinical benefit. Is there any trial of homeopathy where this has happened?

Dana Ullman:

Can you provide a single example (with reference) of a homeopathy trial which has been discontinued early because the independent Data Safety Monitoring Board concluded it would be unethical to deprive study participants of homeopathy, such was its obvious clinical benefit?
 
Last edited:
Jaana - I read your offer, and it sounds like a good idea - except I was a little worried by your offer to cease conventional treatment and didn't rally want to get involved with something like that.
 
I make similar offers to be a test subject when speaking to homeopaths and have not found it works yet! I suffered a pneumothorax, being very close to a homeopath was given remedy (or remedies) to relieve the pain giving me a comfortable ride to hospital. It didn't work!! No difference for the eczema "cure" I have had, nor cold remedies...

If only one had worked, then I could have been the subject of the answer...
 
Last edited:
I make similar offers to be a test subject when speaking to homeopaths and have not found it works yet! I suffered a pneumothorax, being very close to a homeopath was given remedy (or remedies) to relieve the pain giving me a comfortable ride to hospital. It didn't work!! No difference for the eczema "cure" I have had, nor cold remedies...

If only one had worked, then I could have been the subject of the answer...

None of those would count as eczema can remit without treatment and colds resolve without treatment. Even a pneumothorax will go away on its own (as well as pain).

Linda
 
You fell right into that trap that I placed for you.


Is it just me, or is anyone else picturing Dana sitting in his secret headquarters under the crater of an extinct volcano, stroking a long-haired white cat?
 
Last edited:
Jaana - I read your offer, and it sounds like a good idea - except I was a little worried by your offer to cease conventional treatment and didn't rally want to get involved with something like that.


Professor, I appreciate your concern for my wellbeing. I would certainly dissuade anyone else with a serious medical condition from stopping conventional treatment as well.

But this is the way I look at it:

Mr. Ullman/Gully appears to be very confident in his practices. If his homeopathy genuinely works, he would not hesitate to take my challenge because I am giving him the opportunity to be the very first person to prove the efficacy of homeopathic remedies on a non-self-limiting condition, in a well documented case, for which he certainly would be awarded the Nobel Prize --and I would receive immortality in history books as the very first test subject in the ground-breaking experiment that changed the meaning of physics and medicine forever. (Plus the bonus of being cured).

(See how selfish & egotistical I am? :wink8:)
​

Or, if he knows his remedies do not work, he would decline my offer (assuming he has a conscience and would not wish to be responsible for my premature death) --in which case this debate would be over (until the next duck comes quacking) because it either works or it doesn't.
 
But you have missed a third (and very common) result. The homeopath is supremely confident that they can cure you, but it doesn't work and your health suffers as a result of removing the conventional medicine. Remember at least one homeopath was so confident in their system of medicine that he allowed his child to die rather than get treatment with proven medicine.
 
OK, while accepting that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, I think we can draw some safe conclusions;

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

Can't.

Can you provide a single example (with reference) of a homeopathy trial which has been discontinued early because the independent Data Safety Monitoring Board concluded it would be unethical to deprive study participants of homeopathy, such was its obvious clinical benefit?

No.

Have you cured anyone of AIDS yet?

No.

It would have been better for these to have been answered directly, but I think we are used to those tactics by now.
 
It would have been better for these to have been answered directly, but I think we are used to those tactics by now.

Which is why I was not afraid to offer myself as a test subject. I knew he wouldn't bite (and wish i had placed a hefty bet on it). All practitioners of alternative "medicine" that i have known will only work on patients who believe.

Mr. Gully will never answer your questions because there are no such cases.

Ye of little faith... ;-)
 
The real story of Charles Darwin and homeopathy

If any of you have a sincere interest in personally testing homeopathy, you should do so in the way that others do that: go to a professional homeopath who is certified (DHt, RShom, or CCH in the US). Let's make this an objective thing, especially since any good homeopath must do a thorough interview with the patient, and I don't know how you would feel telling me about your personal health history, your emotional and mental state, let alone all of your varied and personal physical symptoms.

Some of you may remember our earlier discussion about Charles Darwin and homeopathy. I previously gave you only a portion of my chapter on Darwin from my book, "The Homeopathic Revolution," and predictably, some people (such as Mr. Quackometer, le canard noir) did a superficial investigation of the subject and came to many erroneous conclusions.

Because of the misinformation that the Quackometer posted and that many of you have reiterated, it is time to make some corrections in the truth of the history of our esteemed Charles Darwin, a poster child for the real benefits of homeopathy.

Let me also say that people who want to be more informed might benefit from reading the entire chapter on "Physicians and Scientists" in my new book, "The Homeopathic Revolution," or heck, some of you might be adventurous enough to read the entire book.

Although Charles Darwin was only 39 years old in November, 1848, he was so ill that he couldn't attend his own father's funeral. Ever since 1837, he suffered from persistent nausea and vomiting, heart palpitations, widespread boils, and trembling, and since 1847, he had fainting spells and spots before his eyes...and his symptoms were getting increasingly worse. My question is: could he have lived 10+ years longer to 1859 to have completed his book, and even if he did survive that long, would he have been as productive (remember: according to Darwin, he was unable to work one day in every three...and further, I should have quoted Darwin himself when he wrote:
"I was not able to do anything one day out of three, & was altogether too dispirited to write to you or to do anything but what I was compelled.* I thought I was rapidly going the way of all flesh." (He acknowledges that he may be dying...in 1849!)
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1236.html

Charles Darwin and family arrived in Malvern on March 10, 1849.

On March 19, 1849, Darwin acknowledges that he takes homeopathic medicines without an atom of faith, but the important point was that Gully prescribed these medicines to him immediately upon his arrival, while the water cure program is a many month process, and Darwin experienced that healing crisis (the skin eruption) just 8 days after treatment began...mentioned in the following link. This 1234 link notes that Gully is cautious in his use of homeopathic medicines in chronic diseases, and yet, obviously, he felt that they were indicated in Darwin's case. Gully prescribed them, and Darwin took them...
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1234.html

Actually, it was just 2 weeks after arriving that CD wrote "I much like and think highly of Dr. Gully" and more...
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1235.html

Please note that he wrote this BEFORE he began the "sweating process" (he was just at the beginning the hydrotherapy program). Darwin's improvement also occurred before Gully recommended that Darwin give up his snuff (which he recommended in May 1849).

On March 28, 1849, he had not have any vomiting for 10 days (a rare experience for him):
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1236.html
"I feel certain that the Water Cure is no quackery." Please note that I wrote that CD "had to admit that Gully's treatments were not quackery after all." That statement is correct.

By April 19, 1849, he had turned into an eating and walking machine!
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1240.html

On May 6, 1849, CD writes: "Dr. G., moreover, (and I hear he rarely speaks confidently) tells me he has little doubt but that he can cure me, in the course of time, time however it will take." Gully, like many homeopaths/hydrotherapists, do not tend of over-state their confidence. Although Gully seemed to be confident with Darwin and although one might stretch the truth to believe that Gully's "confidence" was the primary treatment of Darwin, the fact of the matter is that Gully didn't use his "confidence" as a common treatment strategy.
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1241.html

On September 4, 1850...
Mr. Quackometer (and others) like to make reference to PART of the quote below...but it is important, even essential, to note the entire quote. Even though CD acknowledges that homeopathy makes him "wrath," he notes that people seem to get better from the treatment (please also know that the "clairvoyance" seems to be diagnostic, not any type of "psychic" treatment).

"You speak about Homœopathy; which is a subject which makes me more wrath, even than does Clair-voyance: clairvoyance so transcends belief, that one's ordinary faculties are put out of question, but in Homœopathy common sense & common observation come into play, & both these must go to the Dogs, if the infinetesimal doses have any effect whatever. How true is a remark I saw the other day by Quetelet, in respect to evidence of curative processes, viz that no one knows in disease what is the simple result of nothing being done, as a standard with which to compare Homœopathy & all other such things. It is a sad flaw, I cannot but think in my beloved Dr Gully, that he believes in everything* when his daughter was very ill, he had a clair-voyant girl to report on internal changes, a mesmerist to put her to sleep*an homœopathist, viz Dr. Chapman; & himself as Hydropathist! & the girl recovered.*
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1352.html
One important reason that so many people are so passionate about homeopathy is that the results are often very rapid and very obvious, and because many people have tried many other treatments before homeopathy (treatments that might have just as likely to have tried to elicit a placebo effect), the homeopathic treatments often work because it is not simply a placebo effect.

Some people have referred to Gully as Darwin's "friend." There is no evidence that they were "friends." CD admired Gully, but I haven't seen any records of a personal relationship...have you?

People should stop the MYTH that my book is about "celebrities." Celebrities are but one group of people who are in this book. There are also physicians and scientists, politicians, corporate leaders, literary greats, and so many other smart and successful people.

Besides all of the above information, there is a lot more that I have in my book. I hope that people here do your homework. You may be shocked to find that your own cultural hero, Charles Darwin, has given us his personal story and some good research (yes, some excellent research) that has confirmed the power of nanopharmacology (once again, please remember, that "nano" does not simply mean one-billionth. Steve Jobs has proved that. In popular nomenclature, it means very small and very powerful, just like homeopathic medicines.

This is enough to chew on for a while. Please follow the links that I have provided and enjoy watching your paradigm transform...

Finally, as some of you begin to change your worldview, you will realize that homeopathic medicines are not just "diluted" but that the process of serial dilution and vigorous shaking, repeatedly done, is different than regular water or "small doses," just as atomic bomb is not a placebo and that is power when things bump into each other.
 
Sorry. That one doesn't count either. The state of medicine in the 19th century was such that one cannot tell what condition(s) Darwin suffered from, therefore one cannot determine the prognosis. That is, your example is not necessarily non-self-limiting.

Next?

Linda
 


Says nothing about homoeopathy.



I've already quoted this one for you here, after you had quoted, shall we say, rather selectively from it. This is the letter in which Darwin wrote about his "hydropathical" diary. As I observed before, the homoeopathy was only a very small component of the treatment. How do you know that it wasn't, for example, the diet and exercise regime that caused any improvement observed? How do you know it wasn't the "Water Cure", for that matter? How do you know that Darwin wouldn't just have got better without any treatment?

Actually, it was just 2 weeks after arriving that CD wrote "I much like and think highly of Dr. Gully" and more...
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1235.html

Please note that he wrote this BEFORE he began the "sweating process" (he was just at the beginning the hydrotherapy program). Darwin's improvement also occurred before Gully recommended that Darwin give up his snuff (which he recommended in May 1849).


I note also that there's no mention of homoeopathy there.

On March 28, 1849, he had not have any vomiting for 10 days (a rare experience for him):
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1236.html
"I feel certain that the Water Cure is no quackery." Please note that I wrote that CD "had to admit that Gully's treatments were not quackery after all." That statement is correct.


And note again that homoeopathy is not mentioned. He is talking about hydropathy.

By April 19, 1849, he had turned into an eating and walking machine!
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1240.html


And once again, homoeopathy is not mentioned, and there is nothing to indicate that any improvement was caused by homoeopathy.

On May 6, 1849, CD writes: "Dr. G., moreover, (and I hear he rarely speaks confidently) tells me he has little doubt but that he can cure me, in the course of time, time however it will take." Gully, like many homeopaths/hydrotherapists, do not tend of over-state their confidence. Although Gully seemed to be confident with Darwin and although one might stretch the truth to believe that Gully's "confidence" was the primary treatment of Darwin, the fact of the matter is that Gully didn't use his "confidence" as a common treatment strategy.
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1241.html


And, once again, Darwin is not writing about homoeopathy, but about the "Cold Water Cure".

On September 4, 1850...
Mr. Quackometer (and others) like to make reference to PART of the quote below...but it is important, even essential, to note the entire quote. Even though CD acknowledges that homeopathy makes him "wrath," he notes that people seem to get better from the treatment (please also know that the "clairvoyance" seems to be diagnostic, not any type of "psychic" treatment).

"You speak about Homœopathy; which is a subject which makes me more wrath, even than does Clair-voyance: clairvoyance so transcends belief, that one's ordinary faculties are put out of question, but in Homœopathy common sense & common observation come into play, & both these must go to the Dogs, if the infinetesimal doses have any effect whatever. How true is a remark I saw the other day by Quetelet, in respect to evidence of curative processes, viz that no one knows in disease what is the simple result of nothing being done, as a standard with which to compare Homœopathy & all other such things. It is a sad flaw, I cannot but think in my beloved Dr Gully, that he believes in everything* when his daughter was very ill, he had a clair-voyant girl to report on internal changes, a mesmerist to put her to sleep*an homœopathist, viz Dr. Chapman; & himself as Hydropathist! & the girl recovered.*
http://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/darwinletters/calendar/entry-1352.html


I think the letter you were after was this one. Admittedly, the letter sent to Charles Lyell on 2nd September 1850 is perhaps more favourable to homoeopathy than the one sent to Fox on the 4th by virtue of not mentioning it, but it doesn't really add anything to your argument, does it?

The letter shows Darwin's attitude towards homoeopathy. It doesn't tell us that homoeopathy (or any of the other quackery perpetrated) actually caused the recovery: you're falling into the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. There is certainly nothing there to indicate that Darwin thought that homoeopathy was responsible.

Oh, and by the way:
On September 4, 1850...
Mr. Quackometer (and others) like to make reference to PART of the quote below...


See: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2700512#post2700512

You may be shocked to find that your own cultural hero, Charles Darwin, has given us his personal story and some good research (yes, some excellent research) that has confirmed the power of nanopharmacology


Is that the stuff about the sensitivity of Drosera to dilute solutions of ammonium salts, published in Darwin's book on insectivorous plants? This work has nothing to do with homoeopathy. It just shows that the plants were sensitive to very small (but not non-existent) amounts of the salts.

You've provided evidence that Darwin thought that hydropathy was an effective treatment, but nothing to indicate that he considered homoeopathy to be anything other than quackery.

Oh, and by the way, the fact that Darwin believed in it doesn't mean that hydropathy isn't also quackery.

Now, to get the thread back on topic:

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."
 
Last edited:
Well, well, well. We are off to a bad start.

I finally figured Linda out. She must believe in reincarnation because it seems that everything is "non-self-limiting." The fact that Darwin thought he was dying is of no consequence. Persistent and intense nausea and vomiting and heart palpitations, both of which he had for over 12 years, and the fainting spells and spots before his eyes that he had for over 2 years are considered non-self-limiting. Cool.

Next thing that I will hear from you is that hydrotherapy cured him. Cool. Now all of the skeptics will be water-cure fanatics. See you all in the hot tub!

As for snuff...whooops...you're showing your lack of homework skills. Gully allowed him his snuff during the first couple of months of treatment...and because Darwin experienced significant relief within the first 8 days, you gotta do better than this.
 
The fact that Darwin thought he was dying is of no consequence. Persistent and intense nausea and vomiting and heart palpitations, both of which he had for over 12 years, and the fainting spells and spots before his eyes that he had for over 2 years are considered non-self-limiting.


What condition was he suffering from? Do you have evidence that it was not self limiting?
 
Last edited:
especially since any good homeopath must do a thorough interview with the patient, and I don't know how you would feel telling me about your personal health history, your emotional and mental state, let alone all of your varied and personal physical symptoms.

Interesting. Perhaps you could tell me how the homeopaths who performed the severe sepsis study that you are fond of mentioning conducted these in depth interviews? I would be keen to hear this , as 90% of these patients were on mechanical ventilation at the time of inclusion, and thus would have unable to engage in any form of communication.

As an aside, speaking for myself I fail to see the relevance of whether Charles Darwin believed in homeopathy. Who cares if he did or not? We accept his theory of evolution because it is supported by enormous amounts of evidence, and for no other reason. We do not accept homeopathy because the evidence is lacking. For all I know Charles Darwin believed in mermaids, leprechauns and the healing power of chocolate mousse. The fact I accept his theory of evolution doesn't mean I have to accept all of his beliefs.
 
Criticalist has brought up that severe sepsis study. Thanx. Is this another one of those self-limiting conditions too? Hmmm.

The point to "individualization of treatment" in homeopathy is that AFTER a homeopathic physician does a conventional diagnosis (or if a homeopath is not medically trained, after a patient gets a diagnosis from a physician), the homeopath seeks to observe whatever unique symptoms the sick person has. We see the disease as a part of an overall syndrome...and then, prescribe a medicine for the complex of symptoms, not just one symptom or one disease. I'm sure that this makes sense to some people.

To clarify, my note above that makes reference to being off to a bad start was written before Mojo's statement was posted. Mojo has at least done some of the reading, even though he has his feet firmly planted in mid-air, doing all he can to avoid the most obvious conclusion that homeopathy played an important role in the significant improvement in Darwin's health.

Mojo asked if Darwin might have experienced major improvement without ANY treatment. Hmmmm. Hey, Mojo...you gotta do better than that. Darwin tried no treatment for 12 years…and then, within 8 days of being under Dr. Gully’s treatment, Darwin begins to experience significant improvements. Are you all now becoming advocates for the powerful effects of water-cure? Cool.

If you cannot agree with the probability that homeopathic medicines play a role here, you are more than double-blind, you are deaf, dumb, and blind.

The point is that Darwin was smart enough to explore and personally use treatments with which he didn't understand or even didn't believe in is a part of his deep wisdom. The smartest of us have to stretch our own beliefs. The smartest of us have to continually explore. In THIS case, this use of Dr. Gully's treatment proved to be very helpful.

You can make all of the excuses and theories that you want, but you have to admit that one real possibility, if not probability, is that homeopathic medicines had a dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin...and further, we may not have even heard of him if not for going to Dr. Gully and receiving homeopathic medicines.

In the September 1850 letter, Darwin noted that the girl improved. Are you saying that Darwin assumed that diagnostic clairvoyance was therapeutically effective? Cool...you are much more metaphysical than I am.

And further, Darwin was not alone in his use of homeopathy, even if he was somewhat silent...and it was absolutely necessary for him to be silent about this (as he noted in his Drosera experiments, he was extremely embarrassed to have to report on them). What would have been the reception to his theories if he publically proclaimed that he benefited from homeopathy or even that he went to a homeopath?

This is a good reason that so many of the smartest and most successful people of the 19th century sought out and used homeopathic medicines...and there are equally good reasons that people do so today.

We all can agree that water-cure, if effective at all, rarely provides rapid improvement in chronic ailments like that of Darwin.

As for the Drosera (sundew) experiments...did you read how small of a dose Darwin (and his son) used in these experiments. Yes, there were trace (extremely extremely trace) amounts of ammonia salts remaining...but the results were very significant on these plants...and as Darwin noted, these plants don't even have a nervous system (imagine the sensitivity of living things that have one!).
 
FOR THE LAST TIME: WE DO NOT CARE ABOUT DARWIN. I DON'T CARE IF DARWIN THOUGHT HE COULD SHOOT SALT-FLAVORED MIND BULLETS BY THINKING OF THE EGYPTIAN PYRAMIDS. It is completely irrelevant. Prove that homeopathy works. That's all we care about. You are making yourself look like a complete fool.
 
Your best example of homeopathy is still from the mid-nineteenth century? Well, I can believe that, at least.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom