Mojo
Mostly harmless
Mojo asked if Darwin might have experienced major improvement without ANY treatment. Hmmmm. Hey, Mojo...you gotta do better than that. Darwin tried no treatment for 12 years…and then, within 8 days of being under Dr. Gully’s treatment, Darwin begins to experience significant improvements.
What condition was Darwin suffering from? Please give references to a reliable diagnosis.
Are you all now becoming advocates for the powerful effects of water-cure?
Try reading what I posted:
Oh, and by the way, the fact that Darwin believed in it doesn't mean that hydropathy isn't also quackery.
The point is that Darwin was smart enough to explore and personally use treatments with which he didn't understand or even didn't believe in is a part of his deep wisdom. The smartest of us have to stretch our own beliefs. The smartest of us have to continually explore. In THIS case, this use of Dr. Gully's treatment proved to be very helpful.
Can you provide a single quotation from Darwin in which he writes approvingly of homoeopathy (not hydropathy)?
You can make all of the excuses and theories that you want, but you have to admit that one real possibility, if not probability, is that homeopathic medicines had a dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin...and further, we may not have even heard of him if not for going to Dr. Gully and receiving homeopathic medicines.
The evidence shows that homoeopathy does not have this sort of dramatic effect. The best (from your point of view) results from meta analysis of controlled trials just say things like "the results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition." This makes it highly unlikely that the "dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin" was caused by homoeopathy. Why would it have worked any better in the 19th century?
In the September 1850 letter, Darwin noted that the girl improved. Are you saying that Darwin assumed that diagnostic clairvoyance was therapeutically effective?
It is clear from the letter that Darwin considered homoeopathy to be utter nonsense. That you are using such a letter as evidence that he was a supporter of homoeopathy is quite astonishing, and shows how desperately you are clutching at straws in your attempt to portray him as a supporter of homoeopathy.
And further, Darwin was not alone in his use of homeopathy, even if he was somewhat silent...and it was absolutely necessary for him to be silent about this (as he noted in his Drosera experiments, he was extremely embarrassed to have to report on them). What would have been the reception to his theories if he publically proclaimed that he benefited from homeopathy or even that he went to a homeopath?
What sort of reception did he think his theory of evolution by natural selection would receive? He was highly concerned about the reception this work would get, and delayed publishing. This didn't, however, prevent him from discussing it in his private correspondence.
This is a good reason that so many of the smartest and most successful people of the 19th century sought out and used homeopathic medicines...and there are equally good reasons that people do so today.
If all these "smartest and most successful" people sought out homoeopathy, why would Dawrin be so scared to mention it?
Have you found any evidence that Darwin "sought out" homoeopathic medicine yet?
We all can agree that water-cure, if effective at all, rarely provides rapid improvement in chronic ailments like that of Darwin.
And anyone who looks honestly at the evidence from properly controlled trials can agree that we can say the same about homoeopathy.
As for the Drosera (sundew) experiments...did you read how small of a dose Darwin (and his son) used in these experiments. Yes, there were trace (extremely extremely trace) amounts of ammonia salts remaining...but the results were very significant on these plants
All it showed was that the plants were sensitive to extremely small doses of the salts.
...and as Darwin noted, these plants don't even have a nervous system (imagine the sensitivity of living things that have one!).
What has having a nervous system got to do with the sensitivity of receptors?
Enough with appeals to 19th century authorities.
"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."
Last edited: