Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Mojo asked if Darwin might have experienced major improvement without ANY treatment. Hmmmm. Hey, Mojo...you gotta do better than that. Darwin tried no treatment for 12 years…and then, within 8 days of being under Dr. Gully’s treatment, Darwin begins to experience significant improvements.


What condition was Darwin suffering from? Please give references to a reliable diagnosis.

Are you all now becoming advocates for the powerful effects of water-cure?

Try reading what I posted:
Oh, and by the way, the fact that Darwin believed in it doesn't mean that hydropathy isn't also quackery.


The point is that Darwin was smart enough to explore and personally use treatments with which he didn't understand or even didn't believe in is a part of his deep wisdom. The smartest of us have to stretch our own beliefs. The smartest of us have to continually explore. In THIS case, this use of Dr. Gully's treatment proved to be very helpful.


Can you provide a single quotation from Darwin in which he writes approvingly of homoeopathy (not hydropathy)?

You can make all of the excuses and theories that you want, but you have to admit that one real possibility, if not probability, is that homeopathic medicines had a dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin...and further, we may not have even heard of him if not for going to Dr. Gully and receiving homeopathic medicines.


The evidence shows that homoeopathy does not have this sort of dramatic effect. The best (from your point of view) results from meta analysis of controlled trials just say things like "the results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition." This makes it highly unlikely that the "dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin" was caused by homoeopathy. Why would it have worked any better in the 19th century?

In the September 1850 letter, Darwin noted that the girl improved. Are you saying that Darwin assumed that diagnostic clairvoyance was therapeutically effective?


It is clear from the letter that Darwin considered homoeopathy to be utter nonsense. That you are using such a letter as evidence that he was a supporter of homoeopathy is quite astonishing, and shows how desperately you are clutching at straws in your attempt to portray him as a supporter of homoeopathy.


And further, Darwin was not alone in his use of homeopathy, even if he was somewhat silent...and it was absolutely necessary for him to be silent about this (as he noted in his Drosera experiments, he was extremely embarrassed to have to report on them). What would have been the reception to his theories if he publically proclaimed that he benefited from homeopathy or even that he went to a homeopath?


What sort of reception did he think his theory of evolution by natural selection would receive? He was highly concerned about the reception this work would get, and delayed publishing. This didn't, however, prevent him from discussing it in his private correspondence.

This is a good reason that so many of the smartest and most successful people of the 19th century sought out and used homeopathic medicines...and there are equally good reasons that people do so today.


If all these "smartest and most successful" people sought out homoeopathy, why would Dawrin be so scared to mention it?

Have you found any evidence that Darwin "sought out" homoeopathic medicine yet?

We all can agree that water-cure, if effective at all, rarely provides rapid improvement in chronic ailments like that of Darwin.


And anyone who looks honestly at the evidence from properly controlled trials can agree that we can say the same about homoeopathy.

As for the Drosera (sundew) experiments...did you read how small of a dose Darwin (and his son) used in these experiments. Yes, there were trace (extremely extremely trace) amounts of ammonia salts remaining...but the results were very significant on these plants


All it showed was that the plants were sensitive to extremely small doses of the salts.

...and as Darwin noted, these plants don't even have a nervous system (imagine the sensitivity of living things that have one!).


What has having a nervous system got to do with the sensitivity of receptors?

Enough with appeals to 19th century authorities.

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."
 
Last edited:
This whole Darwin thing is just bizarre. Even if Darwin thought homeopathy worked (and there seems to be little evidence for this), that wouldn't change the fact that modern placebo controlled trials show no effect for homeopathy. Honestly, what's it got to do with anything? Let alone the subject of the thread?
 
Gordon bennett he's at it again. Dana, please try to get it through your shiny thick skull that we don't care about 150-year old anecdotes relating to Charles Darwin. It does not matter one iota to your case whether he was an arch-sceptic of homeopathy's claims or a dyed in the wool True Bleever. Homeopathy has millions of misguided anecdotal believers.

As to the sepsis study you have been told repeatedly that that study is irrelevant because of its flaws. Never mind the actual flaws in the study it is irrelevant because the patients were in an ICU receiving conventional medicine. The interference of the homeopath was just another piece of background noise that cannot be said to have any material effect on the outcome.

Will you please stop repeating the same things after you have been shown why they should be discounted. You keep on doing this, whether it's Rustum Roy's inept wanderings into spectroscopy or the "silica hypothesis". Once one of your Big Ideas has been busted it doesn't miraculously become unbusted 5 minutes later allowing you to rehearse the same tired arguments another time.

Why do you find this so hard?

You have been asked over and again to come up with
ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

This is like arguing with a stubborn and stupid 2-year old who keeps insisting his toy is lost behind the sofa when you have already found it and tidied it away hours ago.
 
This whole Darwin thing is just bizarre. Even if Darwin thought homeopathy worked (and there seems to be little evidence for this), that wouldn't change the fact that modern placebo controlled trials show no effect for homeopathy. Honestly, what's it got to do with anything? Let alone the subject of the thread?

He's written his book and he can't bear to see it pulped. It must be hard to see the "greatest work" of your life being torn to shreds and left tattered in the dust. But, heck, he's had plenty of opportunity to alter his views and I don't have much sympathy.

I just noticed this line on one of his web pages;

"Numerous sports greats have bragged about their use of homeopathic medicines including David Beckham"

and we should takes lessons in medicine from a footballer who can't even grow realistic hair??!!

I mean to say, argument from authority is always fallacious, but it there comes a point where it just becomes silly.

So, the other questions remain;

HAS HE CURED ANYONE OF AIDS?

Can he provide a single example (with reference) of a homeopathy trial which has been discontinued early because the independent Data Safety Monitoring Board concluded it would be unethical to deprive study participants of homeopathy, such was its obvious clinical benefit?
 
Well, well, well. We are off to a bad start.

I finally figured Linda out. She must believe in reincarnation because it seems that everything is "non-self-limiting."

I dunno. You seem to be under the impression that every time someone came down with a headache or a twinge in their toe, it was invariably progressive and fatal. Until homeopathy came on the scene, of course.

Almost everything that happens to us is self-limiting. Otherwise our average lifespan would be about two years.

The fact that Darwin thought he was dying is of no consequence. Persistent and intense nausea and vomiting and heart palpitations, both of which he had for over 12 years, and the fainting spells and spots before his eyes that he had for over 2 years are considered non-self-limiting. Cool.

You misunderstand. You simply do not have enough information to determine why he had those symptoms. Which means you do not know whether or not it was self-limiting.

Again, your example fails because it is too poorly documented, and there is no way to get around that. You've reached the point where you're dredging through 150 year old cases, desperate for an example? Sheesh. Thanks for the ongoing demonstration that you are unable to find a single example where homeopathy actually cured someone.

Linda
 
This may be dangerously close to derailing my own thread, but it is relevant and Dana does not seem to see what is going on in the forum elsewhere so I'll post it here;

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/mai...AVCBQWIV0?xml=/news/2007/12/07/nhpathy107.xml

Jayne Thomas, the vice-chairman of the Society of Homeopaths, said: "If a patient was seriously ill, any genuine homeopathic practitioner would encourage them to visit a GP."

Is it the use of Lachesis that causes homeopaths so frequently to speak with a forked tongue? It may be politically expedient to pass the buck to conventional medicine for any real diseases and that is certainly the official stance of the SoH and other public hom bodies, but yet again it contrasts with the general belief that homeopathy can cure everything as embodied in the claim on the SoH website

http://www.homeopathy-soh.org/

"About Homeopathy
Homeopathy is a complete system of medicine, suitable for everyone."

Their definition of the word "complete" must be different from the rest of the English-speaking world.
 
What condition was Darwin suffering from? Please give references to a reliable diagnosis.

Again, you haven't done your homework. There are various theories about his diagnosis, but that is not the point. Are you or anyone saying that Darwin's 12+ serious ailment "just happened" to get better 8 days after visiting Dr. Gully's clinic and had nothing to do with the treatment he received. Once again, skeptics tend to be much more metaphysical than I am. Thank you for making your position clear.

The evidence shows that homoeopathy does not have this sort of dramatic effect. The best (from your point of view) results from meta analysis of controlled trials just say things like "the results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition." This makes it highly unlikely that the "dramatically beneficial effect on Charles Darwin" was caused by homoeopathy. Why would it have worked any better in the 19th century?

It is interesting to note that skeptics love to mention that the above meta-analysis said, "we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition." However, do they ever mention what the authors of that meta-analysis say was their definition of "sufficient evidence?" They said that there must be 3 clinical trials conducted by independent investigators.

In 1998 (a year after that meta-analysis published in the LANCET was published), a third such trial on Oscillococcinum was published. And by the way, this meta-analysis showed that patients given a homeopathic medicine had a 2.45 times greater chance of experiencing a therapeutically beneficial effect than those patients given a placebo.

Skeptics can no longer say that homeopathic medicines are proven to be effective in treating a specific condition.

If anyone is asked, does Oscillococcinum have an effect on influenza or influenza-like syndrome, one must say YES. I'll say it for Linda: but this is a self-limiting condition. Sure...but it is worthwhile to reduce the time YOU have the flu to make a cheap medicine without side effects? Yes...except for some of you who like to suffer.

As for that sepsis study...it is a tad ironic (again) that Mr Monkey says that this study doesn't count because the patients were also given conventional drugs. Yeah, Mr. Monkey that is right, but those patients who got individually chosen homeopathic medicines (chosen according to their own unique syndrome of severe sepsis) had a 50% (!) reduced mortality rate. Hey Linda, is this a "self-limiting condition?" Believing in reincarnation doesn't make it such.

All it showed was that the plants were sensitive to extremely small doses of the salts.

Thank you. Yes...plants do have this hypersensitivity, and plants are so much more sophisticated that humans, so there is no way that humans can have this type or any type of hypersensitivity. Hmmm.

The irony here is that homeopathy is said to be based on SIMILARS, when a better term might be RESONANCE...and there is hypersensitivity from resonance (any music appreciators out there?).
 
This may be dangerously close to derailing my own thread, but it is relevant and Dana does not seem to see what is going on in the forum elsewhere so I'll post it here;

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/mai...AVCBQWIV0?xml=/news/2007/12/07/nhpathy107.xml

Jayne Thomas, the vice-chairman of the Society of Homeopaths, said: "If a patient was seriously ill, any genuine homeopathic practitioner would encourage them to visit a GP." {snip}
A question for J. Thomas- how would a homeopath know if a person was seriously ill? Some serious illnesses are preceded by seemingly trivial symptoms (leukemia may be presaged by a sore throat). Homeopaths have no clinical experience that would allow them to recognize true illness; this is generally true for sCAM providers.
 
Are you or anyone saying that Darwin's 12+ serious ailment "just happened" to get better 8 days after visiting Dr. Gully's clinic and had nothing to do with the treatment he received.
Well, I guess your point is that there would be a very low probability of this happening, but I hope that you do agree on that the chance actually is there. (Linda/fls mentioned that only a few posts ago, and argued that the chance is much greater that you seems to think).

Given that this is the only case you have presented in this thread (that specifically asks for cases), and this case happened some 150 years ago, could you please show us the calculation that this is unreasonable. I mean, surely there has been more visits to homeopaths that this one during the last 150 years?
 
As for that sepsis study...it is a tad ironic (again) that Mr Monkey says that this study doesn't count because the patients were also given conventional drugs. Yeah, Mr. Monkey that is right, but those patients who got individually chosen homeopathic medicines (chosen according to their own unique syndrome of severe sepsis) had a 50% (!) reduced mortality rate. Hey Linda, is this a "self-limiting condition?" Believing in reincarnation doesn't make it such.

Here we go again. It's that reading comprehension problem again.

I chose not to repeat, yet again, the reasons why the study itself was invalid. So, instead of pointing out why it was an inherently poor study (remember it only got published in a crap journal and that should have been your first clue) and to add a little variety I saying why it was irrelevant to the question that you are supposed to be answering. But since you tediously keep failing to get the point I shall tediously repeat it- sepsis is a highly heterogeneous condition, that fact is contained in the original statement that it has a 40-70% mortality rate. Such a wide range should tell you something about the inherent variation in the condition. Indeed you have also been told this by Criticalist who actually works in the field whereas you only hand out coffee and sympathy in between reading other people's research and misunderstanding it. He/she told you that studies in this field require much larger numbers to allow any valid conclusions to be drawn because otherwise the study groups will be too heterogeneous. Got that now?

So, be a good chap and please strike that from your list and don't raise the topic again. Thank you.
 
Again, you haven't done your homework. There are various theories about his diagnosis, but that is not the point. Are you or anyone saying that Darwin's 12+ serious ailment "just happened" to get better 8 days after visiting Dr. Gully's clinic and had nothing to do with the treatment he received. Once again, skeptics tend to be much more metaphysical than I am. Thank you for making your position clear.

The documentation is inadequate to say whether his complaints were serious and to what degree they were present or not at any given time. You have filled in the blanks with a story that fits your particular desire, but it is still just a fiction.

The remainder of your post is dealt with here.

Linda
 
Mr. Monkey claims that the severe sepsis trial is not valid because it deals with a condition in which different studies have found a 40-70% mortality rate. Heck...this is true for a lot of serious illnesses... Your wiggle factors grow and grow and grow.

I can't remember if Linda has considered severe sepsis as "self-limiting," as she does with virtually everything else...even Darwin's chronic illness. Please read some history about Darwin and then you'll learn how much of a sick puppy he was. According to his own letters, he said that he was DYING ("going the way of all fresh") just BEFORE seeking Dr. Gully's care.

The fact of the matter is that in THIS study 50% of the people given conventional medicine and a placebo died, while only 25% of the people given a conventional medicine and a homeopathic medicine died.

As for JJM's statement about diagnosis...jeez, I wish that some of you would do your homework and stop shooting from the hip. The vast majority of homeopaths in Europe are MDs who are quite qualified to diagnosis. The vast majority of patients who go to homeopaths who are not MDs have previously gone to MDs, have gotten their diagnosis, and have not gotten effective treatment.

In India where 100 million people rely entirely upon homeopathic treatment, there are over 100,000 homeopathic physicians who have graduated from 4 or 5-year homeopathic medical schools and who are also able to diagnose, or they refer to specialists who do.

Please stop the simplistic thinking that tends to pervade this site.

What I also find so interesting is that total resistance of people on this site to even consider the possibility that you may be wrong or that you may have misinterpreted something.
 
Please read some history about Darwin and then you'll learn how much of a sick puppy he was. According to his own letters, he said that he was DYING ("going the way of all fresh") just BEFORE seeking Dr. Gully's care.

...

What I also find so interesting is that total resistance of people on this site to even consider the possibility that you may be wrong or that you may have misinterpreted something.


have you considered the possibility that Darwin was wrong, or that your interpretation of his comments about Gully's treatments may be mistaken?
 
Mr. Monkey claims that the severe sepsis trial is not valid because it deals with a condition in which different studies have found a 40-70% mortality rate. Heck...this is true for a lot of serious illnesses... Your wiggle factors grow and grow and grow.

Right. If there's a 30 to 60 percent chance someone will survive, how is the survival of an individual such an amazing event that it can only be attributed to receiving a homeopathic treatment?

I can't remember if Linda has considered severe sepsis as "self-limiting,"

I answered your question here. I said that individuals recover even when not given homeopathic therapy.

as she does with virtually everything else...even Darwin's chronic illness. Please read some history about Darwin and then you'll learn how much of a sick puppy he was. According to his own letters, he said that he was DYING ("going the way of all fresh") just BEFORE seeking Dr. Gully's care.

But if you know anything at all about medicine, you know that people frequently think they are dying when they are not. And the state of knowledge at that point in time was such that even a medical opinion wasn't particularly useful on that point. And you certainly don't have enough information to tell 150 years after the fact whether any of them were correct in their assessment.

The fact of the matter is that in THIS study 50% of the people given conventional medicine and a placebo died, while only 25% of the people given a conventional medicine and a homeopathic medicine died.

So what? That's what you'd expect to see any time you take small groups of people who were in the ICU and follow them for months and months. In fact, this is a problem I have run into before when analyzing data from a database that includes patients with a high mortality rate. When my groups are small (and 35 is small), the mortality rates in my groups often diverge and become significantly different even if all I've done is randomly divide them into two groups and followed them for a long time.

Linda
 
As for JJM's statement about diagnosis...jeez, I wish that some of you would do your homework and stop shooting from the hip. The vast majority of homeopaths in Europe are MDs who are quite qualified to diagnosis.


And if French homeopathic MDs are typical of those throughout the rest of Europe, they’re hardly treating serious ailments with their magic potions:

It emerged that the type of patients who consult homeopathic GPs are chiefly women, between the ages of 20 and 54, living in an urban environment, not in employment, covered by National Health Insurance for Salaried Workers, and belonging to a Mutual Benefit Association. The most common reasons for consultation were ENT disorders, stress and anxiety. The homeopathic GPs mainly used homeopathy to treat these disorders. On average, four medicinal products per patient were prescribed per 2-month course of treatment, for an average reimbursed cost of 3.78€.

Study of the practice of homeopathic General Practitioners in France
http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=fa175feac3d492926bc354fad92036b3


Dana, don't the 'worried well' tend to suffer from fluctuating ENT disorders (colds), stress and anxiety?
 
Last edited:
The fact of the matter is that in THIS study 50% of the people given conventional medicine and a placebo died, while only 25% of the people given a conventional medicine and a homeopathic medicine died.

Let me go through this again, though I suspect it will do little good. Forgetting for the moment the other serious methodological and reporting flaws which I have already described, the actual figures are as follows. Day 30 survival rates:
Homeopathy 81.8%, placebo 67.7%. p=0.19 non significant. This is a NEGATIVE result. Sepsis outcomes are routinely given at 28 days as after this the survival curves do not change. From the literature we see that ICU, 28 day and hospital mortality rates are of the order of 26.5, 32.4 and 37.5% respectively. (Adult-population incidence of severe sepsis in Australian and New Zealand Intensive Care Units, Finfer et al Intensive Care Medicine 2004)
and that average ICU length of stay is 7 days (same ref.). Remember that in this study the homeopathic treatment was only given for the duration of the ICU stay. You cannot take figures of 180 day mortality and claim they are significant - its laughable.

Seeing how Mr Gully is fond of mentioning this paper I have a question for him.
How did the researchers go about obtaining the detailed symptomatology and background information he maintains is necessary if their patients were unable to communicate? How does he reconcile this with the information presented in table 4 of the study?
 
Mr. Monkey claims that the severe sepsis trial is not valid because it deals with a condition in which different studies have found a 40-70% mortality rate. Heck...this is true for a lot of serious illnesses... Your wiggle factors grow and grow and grow.

Criticalist has been through this again. I'm sorry, Dana, that you are one of those people who could perform a t-test given a book and a calculator but will never have any meaningful grasp of the principles that determine how and when to draw reasonable inferences from data. I am sure you are familiar with the old line that there are "lies, damned lies and statistics". The reason that cliche has some validity is because people like you have so little grasp of the principles and discipline of good data analysis. I'm afraid that your persistence in defending this paper simply disqualifies you from having an opinion on it.

The odd thing is that you are the only person impressed by this sepsis study. Even the authors cannot think very highly of it because, as I have pointed out before, they only managed to get it published in one of the in-house homeopathic magazines not in a proper journal. These are people who managed to get a poor paper past the reviewers of a good journal, so they know what a good journal is. What's the betting that they hawked this one to a respectable journal first, but had to settle for having it printed on the toilet tissue that is Homeopathy?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom