Dave_46
Graduate Poster
No, thanks. I always use Star Trek toilet tissue because it goes round Uranus and wipes out Klingons.
BSM, that really is a crap joke.
Dave
No, thanks. I always use Star Trek toilet tissue because it goes round Uranus and wipes out Klingons.
If YOU were a patient in this study, which group would you rather be in?
You would have to propose that the treatment has no effect whilst it is being given but only manifests after it is ceased.
If any of you have a sincere interest in personally testing homeopathy, you should do so in the way that others do that: go to a professional homeopath who is certified (DHt, RShom, or CCH in the US). ....
According to the Shang study, which people on this list love to harp on, the homeopathic studies that were found to be of a "high quality" were TWICE as many as the group of allopathic medical studies (21 vs. 9). Therefore, if you are going to assert that Shang's study is valid (and I don't), then you must also say that homeopathic research tends to be more scientifically valid than conventional medical studies. Ok...I'm waiting for someone to say this! Come on...
And speaking of these high quality studies, there has been a comparison of these trials which will be published in a GRADE A scientific journal shortly. Be prepared to whistle a different tune...
but I have a sneaking suspicion that you folks would rather think about the Shang study that primarily evaluated that trials in which only ONE medicine was given to HUNDREDS of patients, without any individualization. Although I will certainly admit that this type of treatment sometimes works, it is an EXCEPTION rather than the RULE. But you folks prefer to look at exceptions as though they are the rule. WRONG!
As for getting homeopathic research published in conventional journals, you have to KNOW that there is great prejudice against homeopathy and homeopathic research by YOU and by many medical editors (as well as by many members of editorial boards).
Prejudice is even more insidious when people think that they don't have it. Medical bigotry and medical chauvinsim is deep and wide, and this list is evidence of this.
Slam dunk.
CAN YOU CURE MY COPD?
HOW ABOUT MY COAGULATION DISORDER?
OR MY ARTHRITIS?
YES or NO?
If YES: Why are you withholding treatment from me?
He ain't not got none.
No wonder he won't answer questions aboutrealno clinical "successes".
James Gully said:And speaking of these high quality studies, there has been a comparison of these trials which will be published in a GRADE A scientific journal shortly. Be prepared to whistle a different tune...but I have a sneaking suspicion that you folks would rather think about the Shang study that primarily evaluated that trials in which only ONE medicine was given to HUNDREDS of patients, without any individualization. Although I will certainly admit that this type of treatment sometimes works, it is an EXCEPTION rather than the RULE. But you folks prefer to look at exceptions as though they are the rule. WRONG!
James Gully said:According to the Shang study, which people on this list love to harp on, the homeopathic studies that were found to be of a "high quality" were TWICE as many as the group of allopathic medical studies (21 vs. 9). Therefore, if you are going to assert that Shang's study is valid (and I don't), then you must also say that homeopathic research tends to be more scientifically valid than conventional medical studies. Ok...I'm waiting for someone to say this! Come on...
No, you're talking rubbish here. In the Shang paper, studies of 'complex homeopathy' (more than one remedy) made up 32% of the sample, and studies of 'classical homeopathy' made up 18% of the sample. So these types of homeopathy were tested. The main point to get from this is that THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE OF ANY DIFFERENCE IN OUTCOMES BETWEEN THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF HOMEOPATHY. That is, classical homeopathy and complex homeopathy were no more effective than clinical homeopathy, in which all patients received the same treatment. This is surely not difficult to understand.
You're talking rubbish here as well. Out of all the homeopathic literature, the authors could only find 165 trials that met the inclusion criteria. All the other ones were of inadequate quality. So the most you could say is that a highly selected subset of homeopathic trials are of better quality than a matched set of 'conventional' trials. This tells you nothing about the quality of homeopathic trials versus 'conventional' trials as a whole. Again, there isn't anything particularly difficult about this.
James Gully said:You conveniently used percentages rather than true numbers because you know the numbers in the Shang analysis were cherry-picked and minimal. 18% = 2 studies. One of the studies was by Jacobs on childhood diarrhea, and rather than include all 3 of her trials, including one published in PEDIATRICS, Shang only used one trial, not the one in that "junk" journal PEDIATRICS (how convenient). Once again, even though Jacobs had conducted 3 trials with the same design and even though they published a meta-analysis of these 3 trials in a major pediatrics journal, Shang selectively chose to only include 1 of these trials (how convenient).
The fact that you choose to call my analysis "rubbish" suggests that I am touching a nerve. Ouch.
Dana, HOW MANY AIDS PATIENTS HAVE YOU CURED?
I just think that you're talking rubbish, as myself and others have shown.