Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

A homeopath's favourite son:


chocolate.jpg
(WARNING: The spoiler tag is there for a reason)
 
Last edited:
In the severe sepsis study, the survival rate at day 30 was 81.8% for homeopathic patients and 67.7% for those given a placebo. At day 180, 75.8% of homeopathic patients survived and only 50.0% of the placebo patients survived (p=0.043). One patient was saved for every four who were treated.

The long-term benefits that are typical from homeopathic treatment are again observed in this study, and the probability of these statistics happening by change are extremely small...but you know that.

If YOU were a patient in this study, which group would you rather be in?

But then again, if you squint your eyes tightly enough and narrow your definitions of what works and what doesn't work so that you blind yourself to real life situations (real life tends to go beyond 30 days!), you will successful not see reality ... but this is your choice.

Homeopaths do not simply do a diagnosis (as I previously mentioned), but also observe the patient (not every sepsis patient looks exactly alike)...and although there are many common symptoms of sepsis, the homeopath looks to observe any unique characteristics...plus they learn something about their health history... Homeopaths then prescribe according to both objective and subjective symptoms that they observe. This isn't really mysterious, except to those who don't want to understand.

It is amazing that you have to be taught this stuff. I would have thought that you knew something about homeopathy...but once again, you don't...you just are against it, despite never trying it (by going to a professional homeopath) or even trying to figure out how to treat yourself for a common acute ailment or injury.

According to the Shang study, which people on this list love to harp on, the homeopathic studies that were found to be of a "high quality" were TWICE as many as the group of allopathic medical studies (21 vs. 9). Therefore, if you are going to assert that Shang's study is valid (and I don't), then you must also say that homeopathic research tends to be more scientifically valid than conventional medical studies. Ok...I'm waiting for someone to say this! Come on...

And speaking of these high quality studies, there has been a comparison of these trials which will be published in a GRADE A scientific journal shortly. Be prepared to whistle a different tune...but I have a sneaking suspicion that you folks would rather think about the Shang study that primarily evaluated that trials in which only ONE medicine was given to HUNDREDS of patients, without any individualization. Although I will certainly admit that this type of treatment sometimes works, it is an EXCEPTION rather than the RULE. But you folks prefer to look at exceptions as though they are the rule. WRONG!

As for getting homeopathic research published in conventional journals, you have to KNOW that there is great prejudice against homeopathy and homeopathic research by YOU and by many medical editors (as well as by many members of editorial boards).

Prejudice is even more insidious when people think that they don't have it. Medical bigotry and medical chauvinsim is deep and wide, and this list is evidence of this.

Slam dunk.
 
Mr Gully you just do not seem to understand. The majority of deaths in sepsis occur within the first 28 days. This is an established fact. The homeopathic treatment was given only for the duration of the patients stay in ICU. Length of stay was not reported in the study (one of its many failings) but we know average length of stay in ICU for septic patients is around 7 days (ref ICM 2004 in my previous post). You would have to propose that the treatment has no effect whilst it is being given but only manifests after it is ceased.
THIS IS A NEGATIVE STUDY.
Once more please answer my questions as to how the authors obtained detailed subjective symptomatology from unconscious patients, and how you reconcile this with the information presented in Table 4 of the paper.
 
Statistics 101 for Dana

You would have to propose that the treatment has no effect whilst it is being given but only manifests after it is ceased.

I wouldn't worry about that. The typical pattern of homeopaths is to develop a convenient hypothesis post hoc then test that on the data already obtained and carefully neglect ever to do a follow-up study in which this hypothesis is part of the study design.

Provided you write your paper carefully you can even make that look like part of the original study design.

So, of course, Ullman will be happy to accept your offer of a post hoc hypothesis that he can retrofit to his data. :)
 
Last edited:
Statistics 101 for Dana

I've just created a nice little spreadsheet to try to educate our friend in some statistics.

Just follow these instructions and make your own. It's a bit time-consuming, but not difficult.

A1 "Death Rate per interval"
B1 Death rate for Group A
B2 Death rate for Group B
A3:A37 =IF(RAND()>$B$1,1,0)
B3 =IF(AND(A3=1,RAND()>$B$1),1,0)
copy this to fill B3:j37

A38:A72 =IF(RAND()>$B$2,1,0)
B38 =IF(AND(A38=1,RAND()>$B$2),1,0)
copy this to fill B38:j72

A74 =SUM(A3:A37)
A75 =SUM(A38:A72)
copy across to fill the cells to J74:J75

This gives you a list of survivals at each of 10 intervals.

Here is an online contingency table calculator.

Enter 2 for rows and 2 for columns, where columns are treatments and rows are live and dead respectively.

Now simply ask Excel to recalculate your spreadsheet over and over again.

You will find that for quite modest differences in group death rates (due in our real-world example to the heterogeneity of the condition of these patients that results from small group sizes) you can elicit loads of statistically "significant" treatment differences especially in the later time intervals where survival rates in the two arms can frequently be seen to have diverged.

Putting values for "Death Rate" around 0.1 and varying it by even 10% between the groups produces very impressive differences in group survival as the trial proceeds in about 50% of trial runs.

Independently of wanting to show Dana why he is so foolish to cling to this paper, I've found this exercise quite interesting so should be grateful to him for the opportunity.

So, Dana, do you see now why this could only get itself published in a rubbish journal?

But this is all yet more of a derail from the purpose of this thread;

Dana, HOW MANY AIDS PATIENTS HAVE YOU CURED?
 
Last edited:
If any of you have a sincere interest in personally testing homeopathy, you should do so in the way that others do that: go to a professional homeopath who is certified (DHt, RShom, or CCH in the US). ....

Mr. Gully, I have been to certified Homeopaths. I am surrounded by them out here. (Even my very best friend is a Homeopathic Veterinarian!) I used to have great faith in alternative medicine for many years despite the fact that not a single homeopathic (or other alternative) remedy/treatment worked for any of my ailments (self-limiting and non-self-limiting).

For those conditions that are serious: the Homeopaths I went to were at least decent enough to finally admit that my case should be directed to conventional medicine (although only after trying various remedies for the various misdiagnoses they made + collecting hundreds -or perhaps even thousands- of dollars from me.)

I suffered for 2 very long years under their care before I finally went for proper medical attention & was propertly diagnosed --and have since then been on a treatment plan that enables me to lead a reasonably "normal" life and hold a job again.

So, I *have* tried homeopathy (and during that time, I even held faith in it! But obviously not enough faith, because I did not even experience the placebo effect in any of the treatments).


CAN YOU CURE MY COPD?
HOW ABOUT MY COAGULATION DISORDER?
OR MY ARTHRITIS?

YES or NO?
​


If YES: Why are you withholding treatment from me?


If your homeopathy works, my lack of faith in it should not be an issue.

Is it money? Are you avoiding me because I have not offered money? Sorry, I vowed not to spend another dime on non-evidence-based medicine again. But you do have a Nobel Prize to win if you can cure me.

Let me guess: You are not interested in a Nobel Prize or winning Randi's Million dollar challenge? I have heard that excuse too many times.

Or, you know deep down that your remedies do not work?

My offer is still open on the terms that everything is carefully monitored and documented by a team of unbiased professionals.

And your treatment would be terminated if my INR should drop to a dangerous level. I was very lucky to survive a horrifying Pulmonary Embolism (as well as 2 mini-strokes/TIAs), and refuse to subject myself to the danger of going through that again. Being that I would stop all conventional care while under your treatment, I expect you to be capable of maintaining my PT within safe ranges with your homeopathy or the deal is off.

Lastly: if your remedies cannot keep my pain at a tolerable enough level that would enable me to continue working & attending college as I have been, then I would also expect that you -or someone- cover all my costs of living, while i am forced to take a leave of absence.
 
According to the Shang study, which people on this list love to harp on, the homeopathic studies that were found to be of a "high quality" were TWICE as many as the group of allopathic medical studies (21 vs. 9). Therefore, if you are going to assert that Shang's study is valid (and I don't), then you must also say that homeopathic research tends to be more scientifically valid than conventional medical studies. Ok...I'm waiting for someone to say this! Come on...

I've already trashed your criticism of the Shang study here.

And speaking of these high quality studies, there has been a comparison of these trials which will be published in a GRADE A scientific journal shortly. Be prepared to whistle a different tune...

I'm all aquiver, considering that you did such a grand job of predicting our reaction the last time you made this claim...

but I have a sneaking suspicion that you folks would rather think about the Shang study that primarily evaluated that trials in which only ONE medicine was given to HUNDREDS of patients, without any individualization. Although I will certainly admit that this type of treatment sometimes works, it is an EXCEPTION rather than the RULE. But you folks prefer to look at exceptions as though they are the rule. WRONG!

As for getting homeopathic research published in conventional journals, you have to KNOW that there is great prejudice against homeopathy and homeopathic research by YOU and by many medical editors (as well as by many members of editorial boards).

Prejudice is even more insidious when people think that they don't have it. Medical bigotry and medical chauvinsim is deep and wide, and this list is evidence of this.

Slam dunk.

I know you are, but what and I?

Linda
 

CAN YOU CURE MY COPD?
HOW ABOUT MY COAGULATION DISORDER?
OR MY ARTHRITIS?

YES or NO?
​


If YES: Why are you withholding treatment from me?


Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.
Nice catch!
 
Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.

:eggshocked:

Woah...

I withdraw my proposal/request.

Thank you, Mojo!​
 
Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.


"I have not done much practice since
then, even though I won this case, because I've been working on educating
people and health/medical professionals about homeopathy."



Completely hilarious.

No wonder he won't answer questions about real clinical "successes". He ain't not got none.
 
James Gully said:
And speaking of these high quality studies, there has been a comparison of these trials which will be published in a GRADE A scientific journal shortly. Be prepared to whistle a different tune...but I have a sneaking suspicion that you folks would rather think about the Shang study that primarily evaluated that trials in which only ONE medicine was given to HUNDREDS of patients, without any individualization. Although I will certainly admit that this type of treatment sometimes works, it is an EXCEPTION rather than the RULE. But you folks prefer to look at exceptions as though they are the rule. WRONG!

No, you're talking rubbish here. In the Shang paper, studies of 'complex homeopathy' (more than one remedy) made up 32% of the sample, and studies of 'classical homeopathy' made up 18% of the sample. So these types of homeopathy were tested. The main point to get from this is that THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE OF ANY DIFFERENCE IN OUTCOMES BETWEEN THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF HOMEOPATHY. That is, classical homeopathy and complex homeopathy were no more effective than clinical homeopathy, in which all patients received the same treatment. This is surely not difficult to understand.

James Gully said:
According to the Shang study, which people on this list love to harp on, the homeopathic studies that were found to be of a "high quality" were TWICE as many as the group of allopathic medical studies (21 vs. 9). Therefore, if you are going to assert that Shang's study is valid (and I don't), then you must also say that homeopathic research tends to be more scientifically valid than conventional medical studies. Ok...I'm waiting for someone to say this! Come on...

You're talking rubbish here as well. Out of all the homeopathic literature, the authors could only find 165 trials that met the inclusion criteria. All the other ones were of inadequate quality. So the most you could say is that a highly selected subset of homeopathic trials are of better quality than a matched set of 'conventional' trials. This tells you nothing about the quality of homeopathic trials versus 'conventional' trials as a whole. Again, there isn't anything particularly difficult about this.

You complain that people harp on about the Shang study. This is not surprising, as it is at present the best evidence available on the efficacy or otherwise of homeopathy. Despite your huffing and puffing, you've yet to come up with any convincing criticism of it.
 
No, you're talking rubbish here. In the Shang paper, studies of 'complex homeopathy' (more than one remedy) made up 32% of the sample, and studies of 'classical homeopathy' made up 18% of the sample. So these types of homeopathy were tested. The main point to get from this is that THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE OF ANY DIFFERENCE IN OUTCOMES BETWEEN THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF HOMEOPATHY. That is, classical homeopathy and complex homeopathy were no more effective than clinical homeopathy, in which all patients received the same treatment. This is surely not difficult to understand.



You're talking rubbish here as well. Out of all the homeopathic literature, the authors could only find 165 trials that met the inclusion criteria. All the other ones were of inadequate quality. So the most you could say is that a highly selected subset of homeopathic trials are of better quality than a matched set of 'conventional' trials. This tells you nothing about the quality of homeopathic trials versus 'conventional' trials as a whole. Again, there isn't anything particularly difficult about this.

You conveniently used percentages rather than true numbers because you know the numbers in the Shang analysis were cherry-picked and minimal. 18% = 2 studies. One of the studies was by Jacobs on childhood diarrhea, and rather than include all 3 of her trials, including one published in PEDIATRICS, Shang only used one trial, not the one in that "junk" journal PEDIATRICS (how convenient). Once again, even though Jacobs had conducted 3 trials with the same design and even though they published a meta-analysis of these 3 trials in a major pediatrics journal, Shang selectively chose to only include 1 of these trials (how convenient).

The only other trial in the Shang comparison that individualized medicines was a headache trial. I bet that no one here read that trial, but people in this trial on average had had chronic headaches for 20+ years. Although I was surprised that homeopathy didn't provide improvement, the fact that it didn't in THIS trial is not big whoop because nothing has helped these people for the past 20 years. Sometimes, some people have ailments that may be resistant to all treatment.

The bottomline is that the Shang trial evaluated only LARGE trials, a total of 6 of the 8 trials used 1 medicine for everyone. I am still waiting for someone (!) to explain how a total preliminary "weight-loss trial" that was a part of this analysis. Sometimes, larger trials create their own bias due to their design.

The fact that you choose to call my analysis "rubbish" suggests that I am touching a nerve. Ouch.
 
James Gully said:
You conveniently used percentages rather than true numbers because you know the numbers in the Shang analysis were cherry-picked and minimal. 18% = 2 studies. One of the studies was by Jacobs on childhood diarrhea, and rather than include all 3 of her trials, including one published in PEDIATRICS, Shang only used one trial, not the one in that "junk" journal PEDIATRICS (how convenient). Once again, even though Jacobs had conducted 3 trials with the same design and even though they published a meta-analysis of these 3 trials in a major pediatrics journal, Shang selectively chose to only include 1 of these trials (how convenient).

We've been through all of this already. I did make a mistake here: In fact it was 16% of the trials that were of classical homeopathy. That is, 18 trials, not 2. AND THE ANALYSIS SHOWED THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE THAT CLASSICAL HOMEOPATHY WAS BETTER THAN ANY OTHER FORM OF HOMEOPATHY TESTED. I don't think I can be any clearer than that.

The fact that you choose to call my analysis "rubbish" suggests that I am touching a nerve. Ouch.

Not particularly. I just think that you're talking rubbish, as myself and others have shown.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom