Think about this. Anecdote is the weakest form of evidence. Not wholly useless, but if there is any real truth behind the anecdote, stronger evidence will inevitably emerge.
Homoeopathy has tons of unsubstantiated anecdotes - every single one of which is open to an alternative interpretation. If indeed the interpretation "homoeopathic remedies work" were valid, we'd expect to have seen some stronger evidence by now. (They've had 200 years, dammit!)
What is the next most reliable form of evidence? Why, it's the well-documented case report! Even before people start designing and executing full-scale trials, there have usually been a handful of these pubished as support for the proposition that the treatment involved is effective. It's not a hard thing to do. Any general practitioner can do it. All that's needed is comprehensive documentation of the case, with supporting x-rays, lab results, biopsy results and so on. In fact a single one of these doesn't weigh all that heavily in the scales of evidence, because odd coincidences do happen, however once a handful have been presented, preferably by different people, it starts to get quite compelling.
Pharmacotherapeutic medical literature is absolutely stuffed with such case reports.
All we've asked Dana is that he produce one such case report, even one not published before if he has the relevant supporting data, as a start in this direction. And remember, this isn't a single treatment for a single condition we're focussing on (like, say, asking specifically for a case report showing that penicillin has cured a life-threatening infection), he has the entire scope of what he claims to be a complete system of medicine to choose from.
He can't do it.
Instead he obfuscates desperately, picking around in the borders of statistical significance of crap trials set up be people trying frantically to cover up the fact that self-evident cures just don't actually happen in homoeopathy.
Look, if even a tenth of the unsubstantiated anecdote had the slightest basis in fact, we wouldn't need trials like these. Strict placebo-controlled trials are for showing whether something works when there's some doubt about it. Not for proving the self-evident. (Think about the concept of a placebo-controlled trial of insulin for diabetes - unethical, anyone?) Even new, untested treatments can skip this part, if they're obvious enough. Ever heard of a trial being truncated early because the drug was so good that it was soon clear that it was unethical to deprive the placebo group of it? Yes, has happened several times in real medicine.
Tell you what, Dana, if you can find a trial of a homoeopathic treatment that was stopped early because the benefits were so clear that it was considered unethical to go on depriving the placebo group of the benefit, we'll capitulate right here and now.
Otherwise, take your dodgy statistics and marginal data-dredged benefits to the other thread, and concentrate on finding that one, elusive patient with a documented homoeopathic cure.
Rolfe.