Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

To clarify, the title of THIS dialogue is having fun with me...it is not what you say it is...and thus, I have the privilege of writing about what I consider to be important.


Correct. I could also create a thread talking about how monkeys fly out of my butt, but I wouldn't be doing a very good job of convincing anyone of that now would I?
 
To clarify, the title of THIS dialogue is having fun with me...it is not what you say it is...and thus, I have the privilege of writing about what I consider to be important.
That's funny, I don't see you mentioned here.

Anyway, the subject of the thread is clearly stated in the first post, in the capital letters you seem so fond of. You still seem to be having comprehension problems.

I've replied to a couple of other points from your post in the appropriate thread.
 
Think about this. Anecdote is the weakest form of evidence. Not wholly useless, but if there is any real truth behind the anecdote, stronger evidence will inevitably emerge.

Homoeopathy has tons of unsubstantiated anecdotes - every single one of which is open to an alternative interpretation. If indeed the interpretation "homoeopathic remedies work" were valid, we'd expect to have seen some stronger evidence by now. (They've had 200 years, dammit!)

What is the next most reliable form of evidence? Why, it's the well-documented case report! Even before people start designing and executing full-scale trials, there have usually been a handful of these pubished as support for the proposition that the treatment involved is effective. It's not a hard thing to do. Any general practitioner can do it. All that's needed is comprehensive documentation of the case, with supporting x-rays, lab results, biopsy results and so on. In fact a single one of these doesn't weigh all that heavily in the scales of evidence, because odd coincidences do happen, however once a handful have been presented, preferably by different people, it starts to get quite compelling.

Pharmacotherapeutic medical literature is absolutely stuffed with such case reports.

All we've asked Dana is that he produce one such case report, even one not published before if he has the relevant supporting data, as a start in this direction. And remember, this isn't a single treatment for a single condition we're focussing on (like, say, asking specifically for a case report showing that penicillin has cured a life-threatening infection), he has the entire scope of what he claims to be a complete system of medicine to choose from.

He can't do it.

Instead he obfuscates desperately, picking around in the borders of statistical significance of crap trials set up be people trying frantically to cover up the fact that self-evident cures just don't actually happen in homoeopathy.

Look, if even a tenth of the unsubstantiated anecdote had the slightest basis in fact, we wouldn't need trials like these. Strict placebo-controlled trials are for showing whether something works when there's some doubt about it. Not for proving the self-evident. (Think about the concept of a placebo-controlled trial of insulin for diabetes - unethical, anyone?) Even new, untested treatments can skip this part, if they're obvious enough. Ever heard of a trial being truncated early because the drug was so good that it was soon clear that it was unethical to deprive the placebo group of it? Yes, has happened several times in real medicine.

Tell you what, Dana, if you can find a trial of a homoeopathic treatment that was stopped early because the benefits were so clear that it was considered unethical to go on depriving the placebo group of the benefit, we'll capitulate right here and now.

Otherwise, take your dodgy statistics and marginal data-dredged benefits to the other thread, and concentrate on finding that one, elusive patient with a documented homoeopathic cure.

Rolfe.
 
Monkey prefers to call me a "chump" rather than deal with substantative issues (again). Name-calling says so much about a person.

The fact that I'm here at all trying to talk with fundamentalists should be appreciated...but heck, you folks are (ironically) religious in your points of view. You believe that homeopathy cannot work and then interpret everything to fit that assumption into your reality. This strongly-held subjective view colors your thinking...and creates a bias and (ironically again) an unscientific attitude.

My reference to the Reilly work is another classic example. I mention the 4 studies, and one person gives a critique of the 4th study. Ok...although I haven't yet re-reviewed that study to determine if what he said was true or not, but I couldn't help but notice that he choose to ignore the 3 previous studies...such as the 1986 trial in the Lancet for starters. For the record, this study has consistently been described as well-designed, well-controlled, and with strong comparative results.
 
Try to find the other thread, Dana. Shouldn't be beyond someone with your research skills.
 
You I believe that homeopathy cannot work and then interpret everything to fit that assumption into your my reality. This strongly-held subjective view colors your my thinking...and creates a bias and (ironically again) an unscientific attitude.
I corrected the errors in your post.

My reference to the Reilly work is another classic example. I mention the 4 studies, and one person gives a critique of the 4th study.
Are you trying to build up a martyr case for yourself by claiming that your studies have not been taken up, when in fact they have been taken up in their very own thread, for which you have been supplied with links repeatedly? Your homoeopath friends will probably believe you without you going through the charade of actually posting here, but nobody on this forum will regard you more highly for wilfully ignoring tons of posts written for your benefit.
 
Last edited:
Maybe he has selective blindness and literally cannot see the words "other" and "thread".

Or maybe he is just ducking like a quack*.







*I so rarely say anything witty or humorous that when I crack a joke I repeat it endlessly until someone laughs out of pity...
 
Last edited:
As for studies, the critique of the COPD study is simply too weak to have been published in a peer-review journal.

Letters aren't usually published critiquing an article long after the fact, unless that article turns out to have ongoing importance. Since that COPD trial made no impression on the practice of medicine, making sure that critiques of it are published is of relatively little importance.

The worst thing that was said about the allergy research by David Reilly et al was that it was "isopathic" rather than homeopathic. For those of you who don't know, homeopathic makes reference to the principle of SIMILARS and isopathic to the principle of SAMENESS. Thus, Reilly and others conducted 4 separate trials on various types of allergic conditions, including asthma, usually using homeopathic doses of the same substance to which the person was allergic.

Though techinically, Rolfe is correct in calling this method of prescribing to be isopathic, the bottomline is that these medicines were homeopathically prepared to the 30C potency (a dose that should have no remaming molecules of the original substance).

After the 4th trial, Reilly concluded that either homeopathic medicines work or randomized double-blind placebo controlled studies don't. Are you going to be so cynical about science to assume the latter now? I hope not.

It is not necessary for us to accept the conclusions of the author. Especially if other conclusions can be drawn from the data. His individual study was an example of data dredging, as well as his meta-analysis using the other studies. It is just as reasonable to come to the conclusion that data dredging allows one to come up with invalid conclusions.

Others have criticized this set of studies because these conditions are self-limiting. Hmmm. Asthma? Really? Actually, there's an increase in death rates from asthma these days...does a disease that can kill you still make it self-limiting? Hmmm.

Asthma is characterized by exacerbations and remissions; remissions that can occur in the absence of any treatment.

I hope that SOME of the people who read this are not so antagonistic to homeopathy to see something might be going on with homeopathy beyond the placebo effect...but the attitude on this list probably scares people from admiting it. My condolences...

What you mean is that you hope that some of the people who read this will be fooled by your posturing into failing to notice the vacuity of your arguments.

Linda
 
Maybe he has selective blindness and literally cannot see the words "other" and "thread".

Or maybe he is just ducking like a quack.

He has obviously found the other thread and is reading it; he makes references to statements made in that thread.

That last line is frickin' hilarious. Can I borrow it?

Linda





(apologies for editing your post, but I didn't think you'd mind)
 
Monkey prefers to call me a "chump" rather than deal with substantative issues (again).

I have not called you a chump. I only pointed out that forum rules could not prevent you from looking like a chump. Forgive me if I am wrong and you can find a forum rule that prevents you from making yourself look like a chump or indeed a buffoon. Though, I am afraid you may be in for a disappointment if you read the rules again.

But really, so much better than looking like a chump or a buffoon, would be answering a simple question, the substantive question that this thread was created for;

GIVE ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION

You seem to have missed the fact that there is a whole thread specially devoted to dealing with the substantive issues raised by your diversionary tactics, evasions, misrepresentations and apparent confusion in examining the published record of homeopathy.

It must be because you are so busy curing AIDS patients that you have simply overlooked that thread. Obviously there can be no other explanation.
 
My reference to the Reilly work is another classic example. I mention the 4 studies, and one person gives a critique of the 4th study. Ok...although I haven't yet re-reviewed that study to determine if what he said was true or not, but I couldn't help but notice that he choose to ignore the 3 previous studies...such as the 1986 trial in the Lancet for starters. For the record, this study has consistently been described as well-designed, well-controlled, and with strong comparative results.

Great research, that! And you want us to take you seriously? You have serious problems, my friend.
 
Or maybe he is just ducking like a quack*.
c_laugh.gif
 
He has obviously found the other thread and is reading it; he makes references to statements made in that thread.

That last line is frickin' hilarious. Can I borrow it?

Linda





(apologies for editing your post, but I didn't think you'd mind)

Indeed you may borrow it*. My dream is that it will spread across the internet so that one day I will be idly reading a blog and someone will use it. And I will smile smugly to myself and think "That was MY idea" in full Vic Reeves accent.

*However as payment I require one nomination for the December pith awards. I have never been nominated before and I am profoundly jealous of those who are nominated each month without fail.
 
Dana impersonating Monty python's black knight. I liked the original better.

Hans
 
Others have criticized this set of studies because these conditions are self-limiting. Hmmm. Asthma? Really? Actually, there's an increase in death rates from asthma these days...does a disease that can kill you still make it self-limiting? Hmmm.

My son had asthma as a child, but has not had an asthmatic episode since he was 12 years old. (He is now almost 20yrs old).

I have asthma, but I have not had an asthmatic episode in years. Perhaps it was the cigarette I smoked on New Years eve 2002.... "Like cures like?"


I hope that SOME of the people who read this are not so antagonistic to homeopathy to see something might be going on with homeopathy beyond the placebo effect...but the attitude on this list probably scares people from admiting it. My condolences...


Mr Gully (and the rest of the readers here): Did any of you read my offer a few pages back to be Mr. Gully's test subject?

What I would like more than anything is for Mr. Gully to cure my COPD, since it will most likely be the cause of my early death --unless my coagulation disorder (FVL & PCD genetic mutations) gets me first.

If Mr. Gully holds a cure --or more effective treatment-- for my ailments, it seems rather cruel to deny me of that treatment. (I am only 40 years old!) :rs:

I'm making an offer to help Mr. Gully respond to the ultimate question of this thread (GIVE ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION).

Mr. Gully, can your homeopathy treat any of my conditions? If so, will you please prove it???
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom