Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Dana, what is it with you and reading comprehension? I have resisted thus far, but DullMan is becoming increasingly appropriate.

This thread is for you to answer this question,

GIVE ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION

There is a perfectly good thread here for you to trawl the murky waters of homeopathy's published research record.

It's almost like you don't want to answer the big question.

T = 06d 03h 55m 08s
 
It's not original, it's been posted elsewhere, but I beg indulgence:

Water, water, everywhere
(And nowt else in the vial)
It’s *special* water, let’s be fair,
With memory and guile.

In homeopathy, you know,
We hypnotise the water.
Each molecule of H2O
Then does just what it oughta.

When desperate, we make up stuff
(It *might* just play a role!)
My favourite’s the quantum fluff,
Which adds a bit of soul!

Some rotten spoilsport asked for facts:
“Do tinctures *really* work?”
He claimed that we’re just dodgy quacks -
I called the guy a jerk!

Of course, I couldn’t prove my case
(Who could? The Easter Bunny??)
But water, water, without trace,
Sure makes me lots of money.
 
Here’s an original from JREF member, Kieran…

In homeopathy, you'll be a hero,
If you can prove that zero isn't really zero.
That "it" is there, even if its not,
And it's not just a pile of bogus rot.
You'll be able to claim the JREF prize,
And to the top of your profession rise.
'Homeopath' will be a profession,
Instead of just a total pile of b@ll@cks duping gullable people out of money.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1457796&postcount=4


…which was inspired by this:

Poetry and homeopathy: an exploration

This paper explores a relationship between poetry and homeopathy. It proposes we expand and enlighten our knowledge of the patient and develop our consultation through our experience of poetry. Within each consultation is a poem. Heightened awareness of this and many other aspects can improve the sensibilities of the practitioner and enhance deeper healing of the patient. We are challenged to respond.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=bd5d05da4e94db0442770adc20b38cfa


From the conclusions section of the paper:

Through my exploration of poetry and homeopathy,
I have shown to understand further; we must be
attentive, be fully present for the patient. Daring to
wander the edges, we find a still centre of healing
possibility. As the consultation evolves, language and
forms of poem unfold, improving the dialogue and
relationship, expanding space. Remedies seethe and
seep through our consciousness, enlivened by poetic
images and their expression in patients. If not mermaids,
we can be taught to hear something of other
worlds as we practice in this heightened state, and can
assist the visualization of the full being of the patient
before us, taking care in the telling of the story, such
that this assists healing too. All this requires courage.
We share with the brave poet a sense of wonder; an
enriched practice of homeopathy emerges.


Maybe there’s something in those little pills after all.

[/derail]
 
Last edited:
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/denis_maceoin/2007/11/your_ignorance_is_showing.html

Unfortunately the time-gate has closed on that thread. I wonder whether JamesGully or his extremely close friend Dana Ullman will dare to show up here to keep it going.

It was getting to be fun.

I think we can assume he reads these forums, so I'll ask the question that he seems determined to overlook in his paranoid fantasies of " Big Pharma reps who are hired guns". Though, I should also like to know, if Big Pharma is hiring "guns" does anyone know what the pay is like and whether it can compete with the living that Mr Ullman is making for himself?

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."

Just one question, Monkey. Would it be possible that homeopathy doesn't do anything AND Big Pharma reps are hired guns? Or do the two issues have to be tied together, like school lunches and a new golf course in some congressman's neighborhood?
 
Blue Wode quoted from elsewhere (and my apologies for not seeing that defunct thread):

"Poetry and homeopathy: an exploration

This paper explores a relationship between poetry and homeopathy...Within each consultation is a poem."

Ye gods; it's even worse than I thought....they're not just nutters, but fluffy nutters....
 
...nor have there been knock-out blows to the severe sepsis study, also conducted at the University of Vienna.
.

I'd certainly like to comment on the severe sepsis study.(Adjunctive homeopathic treatment in patients with severe sepsis: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in an intensive care unit: Homeopathy 2005 (94) 75-80.) As background, I am a specialist in intensive care and treat patients with sepsis every day. I am therefore very familiar with the literature in this field and am a reviewer for several ICU journals.

Mr Gully whilst I do not wish to be rude, suggesting that this study is good positive evidence of homeopathy's efficacy suggests that either you have not read it or more likely you do not know enough about the subject.

First, this is a small study. Seventy patient were enrolled, which for a sepsis trial in particular is very low. The reason is that sepsis is a very heterogenous condition, and small trials are unlikely to have well matched patients. As comparisons, recent sepsis trials in the literature randomised 300-500 patients. (Annane et al, Effect of treatment with low doses of hydrocortisone and fludrocortisone on mortality in patients with septic shock, JAMA 2002; Corticus (not yet in press)).
What this means is we have to look very closely at the 2 groups at baseline, and here we see the second major problem. As I mentioned sepsis is very heterogenous. This means outcomes are different for different sites of infection. Urinary sepsis tends to have a good prognosis, whilst intra abdominal is less so. However, the authors do not present this data. Instead in Table 1 they simply give "reason for admission" In this category the majority of patients are classified as just "sepsis" which is meaningless, as all patients would have had sepsis by definition, in order to be included. Thus we have no idea how well the groups were matched in terms of site of infection.
Now we come onto the statistics. Mr Gully claims this study shows efficacy of homeopathic treatment over placebo. However, 28 day mortality was NOT
significantly different between the two groups (Survival at day 30: 81.8% vs 67.7%, P 0.19 Hom vs Plac). At day 180 there is a significant difference in survival (75.8% vs 50% P=0.043). Now this is rather odd. Why should there be no difference at 30 days, but one at 180 days? Sepsis tends to have an early effect on mortality. Most large scale trials will use 28 day mortality as a primary outcome measure, as by this time the majority of patients will either have died or got better. Average length of stay in ICU's is certainly well under 180 days, and is more in the range of 5-7 days for sepsis. In this trial the medication was ceased upon discharge. So how to interpret this strange finding? Well, the sort of standard data for a sepsis trial we need is simply not presented. There is no information on length of stay, time on mechanical ventilation, cumulative inotrope dose, time on dialysis -nothing apart from the baseline information is given. Without this the likeliest reason for the findings at 180 days is just a statistical aberration, in an underpowered study which we have no way of knowing was matched properly.

Frankly if this was a trial of a conventional drug, no reputable ICU journal would publish it in its current form. If a drug rep attempted to convince me to use a conventional med based on this study I would laugh them out of the office. Attempting to trumpet it as a triumph for homeopathy shows an astonishing lack of understanding of the subject and in my opinion highlights the paucity of your arguments.
 
Paul Wilson chose to "defend" the Shang/Egger comparison of homeopathic and allopathic studies in the Lancet (2005)...and here was my response...

My response is posted in the appropriate thread here.

Linda
 
<snip>

Now we come onto the statistics. Mr Gully claims this study shows efficacy of homeopathic treatment over placebo. However, 28 day mortality was NOT
significantly different between the two groups (Survival at day 30: 81.8% vs 67.7%, P 0.19 Hom vs Plac). At day 180 there is a significant difference in survival (75.8% vs 50% P=0.043). Now this is rather odd. Why should there be no difference at 30 days, but one at 180 days? Sepsis tends to have an early effect on mortality. Most large scale trials will use 28 day mortality as a primary outcome measure, as by this time the majority of patients will either have died or got better. Average length of stay in ICU's is certainly well under 180 days, and is more in the range of 5-7 days for sepsis. In this trial the medication was ceased upon discharge. So how to interpret this strange finding?

<snip>

A butterfly flaps its wings...
 
Come on, Dana! I'm beginning to believe that with all your experience and contacts you really don't know af any single case of someone recovering from something we know wouldn't have gone away on its own, with homoeopathic treatment.

The things I'd be happy declaring don't go away without treatment would include

Insulin-dependent diabetes (in man)
Addison's disease
Hypothyroidism
Primary hypoparathyroidism
AIDS
glioblastoma multiforme
metastatic prostate cancer
pulmonary carcinoma
pancreatic carcinoma
malignant melanoma
mesothelioma
(.... oh, let's just say quite a lot of carciomas and sarcomas, especially if metastatic, but not necessarily every single one)
dilated cardiomyopathy
hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
emphysema

I'm sure there are lots more, and the medics will list some. However, even serious, life-threatening conditions in which a proportion of the patients (even a small one) would be expected to recover spontaneously don't count.


And so on.

Nobody in that sepsis study could have been said to have been "cured" by homoeopathy, I don't see how you could possibly think so. Sepsis is quite often self-limiting, and in any case these people were also receiving conventional medicine. The presence of control patients is irrelevant, because of the size of the groups and the lack of information regarding clinical presentation, comparability and so on.

Come on, do you not have even one case of a patient diagnosed with one of the above conditions being cured by homoeopathy?

Will you continue to ignore the challenge?

Does your pride, smugness and intellectual dishonesty know no bounds?

Rolfe.
 
.
First, this is a small study. Seventy patient were enrolled, which for a sepsis trial in particular is very low. The reason is that sepsis is a very heterogenous condition, and small trials are unlikely to have well matched patients.

Thanks for that authoritative comment it reinforces with damning weight what I told him previously based on my non-expert reading of the situation.

The mere fact of only getting these published in crap journals is always a big clue.
 
Friends,
It is interesting to note that no one on this list chose to acknowledge that the Shang comparison article is a classic example of data dredging. The only way that Shang would have gotten a negative result against homeopathy is by selecting the parameters he established...and because he previously contacted the Lancet and formally told him that his hypothesis was to prove that homeopathic medicines have no effect, he self-selected his parameters and his data to prove it.
Is it interesting that he chose 98, not 100, subjects as his minimim definition for inclusion...just so that he could include a headache trial with a negative result.
At least one of you above acknowledged that s/he wondered why only 1 of the 3 studies with 300+ subjects was included in the trial. Linda asserted that the study in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine was granted a high rating than the trial in PEDIATRICS. That speaks volumes about the rating system that Shang used. Anyway, because the 3 trials were conducted with the same design, and even though this pooled data was published in a major pediatrics journal, Shang chose to ignore that (whooops).
I loved Dr. Peter Fisher's response to the Shang work:
http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/3/1/145
His assertion below is worthy:
"Shang et al. (1) state that ‘eight trials of homoeopathic remedies in acute infections of the upper respiratory tract ... indicated a substantial beneficial effect ... sensitivity analyses might suggest that there is robust evidence that the treatment under investigation works. However, the biases that are prevalent in these publications, as shown by our study, might promote the conclusion that the results cannot be trusted’. They state that eight studies is too few to question their conclusion about the whole set of publications. Their conclusion about the whole set, however, was also based on eight studies. Is eight enough for a conclusion or not? Or does it depend on what that conclusion is?"

And yet, Shang's final conclusion are based 8 homeopathic studies and 6 allopathic ones. Remember...the mission of this article was to compare MATCHED studies. Please someone tell me (us) how the final studies were matched in any way? Was one of the allopathic studies a test of a drug for weight-loss (as was done with the homeopathic studies)? Curious minds want to know...

Come on...you folks claim to be good in evaluating data, and you've barely started to provide an adequate review of this comparison article. Go for it...
 
More tedious diversionary tactics from DullMan

Yes, Dana, we can analyse data very well- much better than you and we have a thread for doing just that. This thread is for you to answer a simple question. Your tactics are just the usual pathetic attempt to try to deflect the discussion away from uncomfortable topics. Please take your problems with Shang to the other thread and answer the damn question that this thread was created for.

The funniest thing is that your avoidance of the issue shows just how frightened you are and how fragile your blusteing show really is.

Grade so far: DullMan must try harder.
 
I am by no means an expert in studying testing methods and results, which is why I wish to thank Criticalist for this very well written & readable analysis (and expertise) on this particular study. Well done!

.

I'd certainly like to comment on the severe sepsis study.(Adjunctive homeopathic treatment in patients with severe sepsis: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in an intensive care unit: Homeopathy 2005 (94) 75-80.) As background, I am a specialist in intensive care and treat patients with sepsis every day. I am therefore very familiar with the literature in this field and am a reviewer for several ICU journals.

Mr Gully whilst I do not wish to be rude, suggesting that this study is good positive evidence of homeopathy's efficacy suggests that either you have not read it or more likely you do not know enough about the subject.

First, this is a small study. Seventy patient were enrolled, which for a sepsis trial in particular is very low. The reason is that sepsis is a very heterogenous condition, and small trials are unlikely to have well matched patients. As comparisons, recent sepsis trials in the literature randomised 300-500 patients. (Annane et al, Effect of treatment with low doses of hydrocortisone and fludrocortisone on mortality in patients with septic shock, JAMA 2002; Corticus (not yet in press)).
What this means is we have to look very closely at the 2 groups at baseline, and here we see the second major problem. As I mentioned sepsis is very heterogenous. This means outcomes are different for different sites of infection. Urinary sepsis tends to have a good prognosis, whilst intra abdominal is less so. However, the authors do not present this data. Instead in Table 1 they simply give "reason for admission" In this category the majority of patients are classified as just "sepsis" which is meaningless, as all patients would have had sepsis by definition, in order to be included. Thus we have no idea how well the groups were matched in terms of site of infection.
Now we come onto the statistics. Mr Gully claims this study shows efficacy of homeopathic treatment over placebo. However, 28 day mortality was NOT
significantly different between the two groups (Survival at day 30: 81.8% vs 67.7%, P 0.19 Hom vs Plac). At day 180 there is a significant difference in survival (75.8% vs 50% P=0.043). Now this is rather odd. Why should there be no difference at 30 days, but one at 180 days? Sepsis tends to have an early effect on mortality. Most large scale trials will use 28 day mortality as a primary outcome measure, as by this time the majority of patients will either have died or got better. Average length of stay in ICU's is certainly well under 180 days, and is more in the range of 5-7 days for sepsis. In this trial the medication was ceased upon discharge. So how to interpret this strange finding? Well, the sort of standard data for a sepsis trial we need is simply not presented. There is no information on length of stay, time on mechanical ventilation, cumulative inotrope dose, time on dialysis -nothing apart from the baseline information is given. Without this the likeliest reason for the findings at 180 days is just a statistical aberration, in an underpowered study which we have no way of knowing was matched properly.

Frankly if this was a trial of a conventional drug, no reputable ICU journal would publish it in its current form. If a drug rep attempted to convince me to use a conventional med based on this study I would laugh them out of the office. Attempting to trumpet it as a triumph for homeopathy shows an astonishing lack of understanding of the subject and in my opinion highlights the paucity of your arguments.
 
To clarify, the title of THIS dialogue is having fun with me...it is not what you say it is...and thus, I have the privilege of writing about what I consider to be important.

For starters, I cannot help but notice that no one answers the substantative questions that I've raised about the Shang article. Do you or do you not defend it and if so, why?

As for studies, the critique of the COPD study is simply too weak to have been published in a peer-review journal.

The worst thing that was said about the allergy research by David Reilly et al was that it was "isopathic" rather than homeopathic. For those of you who don't know, homeopathic makes reference to the principle of SIMILARS and isopathic to the principle of SAMENESS. Thus, Reilly and others conducted 4 separate trials on various types of allergic conditions, including asthma, usually using homeopathic doses of the same substance to which the person was allergic.

Though techinically, Rolfe is correct in calling this method of prescribing to be isopathic, the bottomline is that these medicines were homeopathically prepared to the 30C potency (a dose that should have no remaming molecules of the original substance).

After the 4th trial, Reilly concluded that either homeopathic medicines work or randomized double-blind placebo controlled studies don't. Are you going to be so cynical about science to assume the latter now? I hope not.

Others have criticized this set of studies because these conditions are self-limiting. Hmmm. Asthma? Really? Actually, there's an increase in death rates from asthma these days...does a disease that can kill you still make it self-limiting? Hmmm.

I hope that SOME of the people who read this are not so antagonistic to homeopathy to see something might be going on with homeopathy beyond the placebo effect...but the attitude on this list probably scares people from admiting it. My condolences...
 
After the 4th trial, Reilly concluded that either homeopathic medicines work or randomized double-blind placebo controlled studies don't. Are you going to be so cynical about science to assume the latter now? I hope not.

4th trial is missleading they were not equiv.

Others have criticized this set of studies because these conditions are self-limiting. Hmmm. Asthma? Really? Actually, there's an increase in death rates from asthma these days...does a disease that can kill you still make it self-limiting? Hmmm.

In a number oif cases the diagnosis was questionable.
 
To clarify, the title of THIS dialogue is having fun with me...it is not what you say it is...and thus, I have the privilege of writing about what I consider to be important.

Indeed, there is nothing in the rules of the Forum to stop you looking like a chump, just as there is nothing in the rules of the Forum to stop other readers to see how you want to avoid one very simple question but only want to pick about in the entrails of homeopathy's pathetic research record looking for tiny effects obscured by the statistical noise. Your misconceptions about the Shang paper have been addressed in the appropriate place and I will remind you, yet again, that you have a problem with it only and precisely because the effects you are claiming to exist are utterly trivial.

But, homeopathy claims big impressive effects so;

GIVE ONE INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom