Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Has Dana left the building?

I gave a detailed example (the Addison's case) of the type of documentation that would support a claim to have cured (or stabilised on maintenance treatment) a definitely-diagnosed non-self-limiting condition.

HelenSan's only response was that homoeopaths don't do diagnostic workups on their patients, so they would not have that type of documentation.

The obvious conclusion from that statement is that homoeopaths are a bunch of dangerous charlatans, if they are "treating" patients with potentially life-threatening illnesses but are taking no steps to establish what's actually wrong with them.

However, let's leave that aspect for the moment.

I pointed out that many patients choose to consult a homoeopath after they have already had a full diagnostic workup from conventional healthcare. That would provide the documentation, if any of these patients were subsequently to recover against all the odds.

However, I also pointed out that there are quite a lot of homoeopaths who are themselves qualified physicians. These people must be carrying out a proper diagnostic workup on their patients, otherwise they would be liable for negligence. Don't any of these homoeopaths have any well-documented case reports showing the sort of information I outlined?

This is where Dana comes in. He maintains that the majority of homoeopaths are actually qualified physicians. This isn't actually true, nevertheless it demonstrates his understanding that thre are many homoeopaths who are in fact physicians. These people are in an ideal position to provide documented case records of any of these amazing miracle cures we keep hearing about.

So, where are they?

Any doctor, and any vet, could if asked readily provide numerous sets of documented case reports, just like my Addison's one, showing that their treatment had saved the life of a patient.

All these homoeopathic doctors, Dana.

And not a single one has anything that even might fit the bill?

Rolfe.
 
It is not uncommon at all for people who use homeopathy to claim effect within seconds. I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically. Electromagnetic effects on organisms have been known to occur within seconds. For example, animals have been anesthesized with magnets, falling asleep in seconds, and waking up in seconds. So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.

Other peple have already addressed the technical details of why this is complete and utter cow poo. However, there are also some severe logical problems with it as well. What you are saying is that water has an electromagnetic field that somehow cures stomachs (or anything else, but you mentioned your child's stomach earlier). Now, aside from the fact that it's bollocks, what you have failed to consider is that everything else has an electromagnetic field as well, including ordinary water. If such an effect were possible from some shaken water or a sugar pill every single thing you put in your mouth would have some kind of effect. Since many of the things you eat and drink have fairly high quantities of magnetic materials, the fields you eat during your normal day must have a far bigger effect than any homeopathic remedy ever could.

You see why nobody takes homeopathy seriously? It's not just that you don't understand basic physic, chemistry or biology, it's that you don't even seem to have thought about your ideas for even a second. Even if all your speculations were true, even if everything had magic fields that could cure people, homeopathy would still just be water and sugar pills.
 
They were not anesthesized within seconds, as I said, but only awaken within seconds (with no grogginess by decreasing the strength of the magnetic field).

Not really related to the science, but how does one gauge the grogginess of a Salamander?
 
Not really related to the science, but how does one gauge the grogginess of a Salamander?

It's quite simply, really. Run a high voltage, low current through it. Gauge the reaction time of said salamander.
 
Last edited:
So, where are they?
They aren't here, that's for sure. Hehe.

No, seriously. Dana is the only homeopath I see on this board. Everyone else who practices homeopathy isn't here and doesn't care. Hell, I don't even know why I'm here.
 
Since many of the things you eat and drink have fairly high quantities of magnetic materials, the fields you eat during your normal day must have a far bigger effect than any homeopathic remedy ever could.
This assumes bigger is more effective. What if it is not when dealing with electromagnetic fields?
 
This assumes bigger is more effective. What if it is not when dealing with electromagnetic fields?
The field strength that you are thinking of will be drowned in general noise from myriads of sources. After all, every atom and electron have their tiny field.

In order for homoeopathy to work with electromagnetism, you also need to encode some kind of signal that is different for each remedy and each potency (or you would only need a single remedy in a single potency). This signal will have to be picked up and acted upon by the body so that it has the exact effect desired, and no side effect, according to the homoeopathic theory.

That is a tall order to encode in water molecules that are among the simplest molecules known, and you even believe that this effect can be transferred to lactose when the magic water evaporates. Amazing!

Well, if only it worked, then we would give it some more thought ...
 
Not really related to the science, but how does one gauge the grogginess of a Salamander?

1) Fill in a form describing how groggy you are.

2) Stir the salamander into a tall glass of Cap'n Morgan.

3) Drink said cocktail.

4) Repeat form (1).

In my experience the third salamander is way more groggy than the first.

Also please note the use of solid homeopathy technique for assessing how ill I am.
 
They aren't here, that's for sure. Hehe.

No, seriously. Dana is the only homeopath I see on this board. Everyone else who practices homeopathy isn't here and doesn't care. Hell, I don't even know why I'm here.

The same question/challenge has been posted on numerous blogs and forums where other homeopaths post. The silence on the matter is still deafening.
 
He seems to be busy elsewhere at the moment...
http://www.otherhealth.com/homeopathy-list-discussion/

Friends,
Someone wrote that the important study used Kali carb 30C. That is NOT correct. They used KALI BIC 30C.

--Dana Ullman


Like that's going to make a difference at 30C.

Incidentally, any idea why he starts a new thread rather than just replying to the post in which the mistake was made? ETA: The first post in his "Hitler did NOT use homeopathy" thread also seems to be replying to another post.
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, any idea why he starts a new thread rather than just replying to the post in which the mistake was made? ETA: The first post in his "Hitler did NOT use homeopathy" thread also seems to be replying to another post.
Dilutions?
 
No, seriously. Dana is the only homeopath I see on this board. Everyone else who practices homeopathy isn't here and doesn't care.

But they have been here. Frequently. They tend to give up when they are proven to be talking bollocks.

This assumes bigger is more effective. What if it is not when dealing with electromagnetic fields?

As I already said, you do not understand the most basic parts of physics. Please just give up speculating.
 
They aren't here, that's for sure. Hehe.

No, seriously. Dana is the only homeopath I see on this board. Everyone else who practices homeopathy isn't here and doesn't care. Hell, I don't even know why I'm here.


I meant, where are the records of the cases?

I don't have to be Howard Flory to be able to find and reference the records of the first patients to be cured of previously incurable illnesses by penicillin. The information is in the public domain, and can be found by anyone who looks for it.

Not so, any similar achievements of homoeopathy.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom