Rolfe
Adult human female
Has Dana left the building?
I gave a detailed example (the Addison's case) of the type of documentation that would support a claim to have cured (or stabilised on maintenance treatment) a definitely-diagnosed non-self-limiting condition.
HelenSan's only response was that homoeopaths don't do diagnostic workups on their patients, so they would not have that type of documentation.
The obvious conclusion from that statement is that homoeopaths are a bunch of dangerous charlatans, if they are "treating" patients with potentially life-threatening illnesses but are taking no steps to establish what's actually wrong with them.
However, let's leave that aspect for the moment.
I pointed out that many patients choose to consult a homoeopath after they have already had a full diagnostic workup from conventional healthcare. That would provide the documentation, if any of these patients were subsequently to recover against all the odds.
However, I also pointed out that there are quite a lot of homoeopaths who are themselves qualified physicians. These people must be carrying out a proper diagnostic workup on their patients, otherwise they would be liable for negligence. Don't any of these homoeopaths have any well-documented case reports showing the sort of information I outlined?
This is where Dana comes in. He maintains that the majority of homoeopaths are actually qualified physicians. This isn't actually true, nevertheless it demonstrates his understanding that thre are many homoeopaths who are in fact physicians. These people are in an ideal position to provide documented case records of any of these amazing miracle cures we keep hearing about.
So, where are they?
Any doctor, and any vet, could if asked readily provide numerous sets of documented case reports, just like my Addison's one, showing that their treatment had saved the life of a patient.
All these homoeopathic doctors, Dana.
And not a single one has anything that even might fit the bill?
Rolfe.
I gave a detailed example (the Addison's case) of the type of documentation that would support a claim to have cured (or stabilised on maintenance treatment) a definitely-diagnosed non-self-limiting condition.
HelenSan's only response was that homoeopaths don't do diagnostic workups on their patients, so they would not have that type of documentation.
The obvious conclusion from that statement is that homoeopaths are a bunch of dangerous charlatans, if they are "treating" patients with potentially life-threatening illnesses but are taking no steps to establish what's actually wrong with them.
However, let's leave that aspect for the moment.
I pointed out that many patients choose to consult a homoeopath after they have already had a full diagnostic workup from conventional healthcare. That would provide the documentation, if any of these patients were subsequently to recover against all the odds.
However, I also pointed out that there are quite a lot of homoeopaths who are themselves qualified physicians. These people must be carrying out a proper diagnostic workup on their patients, otherwise they would be liable for negligence. Don't any of these homoeopaths have any well-documented case reports showing the sort of information I outlined?
This is where Dana comes in. He maintains that the majority of homoeopaths are actually qualified physicians. This isn't actually true, nevertheless it demonstrates his understanding that thre are many homoeopaths who are in fact physicians. These people are in an ideal position to provide documented case records of any of these amazing miracle cures we keep hearing about.
So, where are they?
Any doctor, and any vet, could if asked readily provide numerous sets of documented case reports, just like my Addison's one, showing that their treatment had saved the life of a patient.
All these homoeopathic doctors, Dana.
And not a single one has anything that even might fit the bill?
Rolfe.