Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Cool! How sensitive are those equipment? Cause as I understand it, if there are EM fields, they would be extremely small, as in the nanoGauss and nanoTesla range. But I would be curious to see if equipment measuring in the micro ranges can detect anything.

So what you are saying is that the strength of the fields are much, much, much smaller than that of the earth's magnetic field? Wouldn't turning 180 degrees while holding your baby then have a much more powerful effect than any homeopathic remedy? That's probably what did the trick.

Linda
 
Oh yes, they send you your remedy*, along with information on homeopathy**. Real homeopathic pills*, in real little dinky bottles. I wouldn't work for frauds y'know!

Cheers,

Rich.

*"remedy" does not imply curative properties, guaranteed as effective as, and indistinguishable from all other homeopathic remedies
**Links to Ben Goldacre's Guardian articles

Thanks. Yanno, that's kind of a cool idea. I think it would get my attention if I was a woo and that showed up in the mail.

Linda
 
The research was done on salamanders.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/134/3472/101

I believe this is the paper where it was published, though I have not read it, so I can't say for sure. I read the details of the research in the author's book, The Body Electric.

No, I am afraid not. That paper absolutely does not say anything about magnetic fields inducing anaesthesia, as even a cursory reading will reveal. It describes differing observed voltages in nerves placed in a magnetic fields. The salamanders were under anaesthesia to allow the measurement to take place.

I have to say I find it interesting that someone who has been berating contributors on this forum for their lack of understanding of scientific rigour and principles, is quite happy to post meaningless anecdotes and make unfounded assertions based on papers they haven't read.
 
So what you are saying is that the strength of the fields are much, much, much smaller than that of the earth's magnetic field? Wouldn't turning 180 degrees while holding your baby then have a much more powerful effect than any homeopathic remedy? That's probably what did the trick.

Linda
Yes, it really works. My brother takes an iron/viagra supplement. Whenever he sees a beautiful woman, he turns to face north.
 
Last edited:
So what you are saying is that the strength of the fields are much, much, much smaller than that of the earth's magnetic field?

IF those fields existed, yes.

Wouldn't turning 180 degrees while holding your baby then have a much more powerful effect than any homeopathic remedy? That's probably what did the trick.

I tried holding him in all sorts of positions for a few minutes before trying the remedy. (I'm pretty sure I tried turning all sorts of positions myself. When I say he was inconsolable, I mean I tried everything I knew to console him.)
 
Last edited:
No, I am afraid not. That paper absolutely does not say anything about magnetic fields inducing anaesthesia, as even a cursory reading will reveal.
Did you read the paper or just the abstract?

... make unfounded assertions based on papers they haven't read.
I made an assertion that "animals were anesthesized by magnets in seconds" because that is what Robert Becker said he did. I don't know if those details are in this particular paper, but I have no reason to think he was lying.

Is that an unfounded assertion? Perhaps I could have qualified my statement more carefully, such as "One researcher has claimed that he anesthesized animals...." But that level of precision doesn't really change the point I was trying to make, so I'm not going to lose any sleep over it.
 
I see we're off on another tangent.

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

and I'd like to see that photo of a cured AIDS patient waving their HIV-ve test certificate.
 
HelenSan, if you're claiming that your remedies are holding information allegedly indefinitely without degradation and that electromagnetic fields are involved, you are going to have to have a serious conversation with my friend here, the Big Stick labelled: Third Law of Thermodynamics.

You may duck a coupla times, but it will smack you upside the head after a few swings.

p.s. I wouldn't bother with Arnica for the inevitable bruising.
 
Last edited:
Did you read the paper or just the abstract?

I made an assertion that "animals were anesthesized by magnets in seconds" because that is what Robert Becker said he did. I don't know if those details are in this particular paper, but I have no reason to think he was lying.
Is that an unfounded assertion? Perhaps I could have qualified my statement more carefully, such as "One researcher has claimed that he anesthesized animals...." But that level of precision doesn't really change the point I was trying to make, so I'm not going to lose any sleep over it.

In this case just reading the abstract reveals the paper has nothing to do with magnet induced anaesthesia. I also read papers which reference this one http://www.biolbull.org/cgi/reprint/159/3/681
which confirm it. I assume you did neither.

Seeing as there is no reference to this in the the literature, yes this is an unfounded assertion. As this was the only factual content in your post, and it appears to be demonstrably false Im not sure how you can say it doesn't change the point of your post. Perhaps your point doesn't rely on facts or evidence? It also highlights the point I was trying to make which is that you have criticised medical research in its entirety as being "cargo cult science", and claimed you distrust medical research trials because of a lack of scientific rigor, yet your own arguments are strikingly lacking in these qualities.
 
Did you read the paper or just the abstract?

I made an assertion that "animals were anesthesized by magnets in seconds" because that is what Robert Becker said he did. I don't know if those details are in this particular paper, but I have no reason to think he was lying.
That paper makes it clear that the salamanders were anesthetized, and not by the magnets. But the article didn't say what the anesthetic was, or the dose. Surprising to me, especially in Science, although the space was limited. (I did look at the paper, not just the abstract.)

You'll have to look through your book and see if you can track down another reference.
 
Last edited:
As this was the only factual content in your post, and it appears to be demonstrably false....

Just because something doesn't have scientific rigor doesn't mean it is demonstrably false; it just means it is not scientifically proven. I believe I explained this concept at great length in a previous post to Linda.

I made the assertion to illustrate that getting an effect in seconds is not entirely implausible. The assertion wasn't made to prove anything.

However, I have to apologize that upon closer reading, I did misrepresent the facts according to Becker. The animals were gradually, not quickly, anesthesized with a magnet. They were not anesthesized within seconds, as I said, but only awaken within seconds (with no grogginess by decreasing the strength of the magnetic field). Again, I am sorry for this error.

flume said:
You'll have to look through your book and see if you can track down another reference.

The book doesn't have any references at all. That is the problem. The guy's published dozens of papers in journals big and small, and sometimes it is hard to tell which paper matches which experiment described in the book. He described part of the experiment in the book thus:

We tranquilized a salamander lightly, placed it on a plastic shelf between the poles of a strong electromagnet, and attached electrodes to measure the EEG. As we gradually increased the magnetic field strength, we saw no change--until delta waves appeared at 2,000 gauss. At 3,000 gauss, the entire EEG was composed of simple delta waves, and the animal was motionless and unresponsive to all stimuli. Moreover, as we decreased the strength of the magnetic field, normal EEG patterns returned suddenly, and the salamander regained consciousness within seconds. This was in sharp contrast to other forms of anesthesia. With direct currents [my note: referring to previous experiments], the EEG continued to show delta waves for as long as a half hour after the current was turned off, and the animals remained groggy and unresponsive just as after chemical anesthesia.

He used the Hall effect to substitute the use of electromagnets for the previous use of direct currents to anesthesize the salamanders. For that reason, I thought this paper on the Hall effect might be about this experiment. It is possible he didn't publish these results, or I haven't found the paper yet.

I tire of having to qualify myself every single time, but again, this is not scientific proof of anything and is not presented to prove anything. It was simply an illustration that it is not entirely implausible for mechanisms other than pharmacological ones to produce biological effects within seconds. I don't know how much more tentatively I can phrase it.

This is just a conversation. I am not making official claims to prize money. I hope some of you can relax.
 
Last edited:
...Homeopaths claim to cure people. They have therefore implicitly admitted using criteria to judge that success.

The fact that the patients put into a trial happen to have a disease state that conventional medicine regards as reasonably homogeneous should pose no problem to the homs. They claim to be able to cure anything. So it's quite fair to give them anything to cure whether that thing is defined tidily by conventional medicine or not.

The problem comes in finding endpoints in assessing responses that adequately capture that assessment. This is not easy and it does leave them room to manoeuvre.

This is also why they like trials of soft diseases with imprecise definitions. They can then claim that inappropriate end-points were used. These soft diseases are also their bread-and-butter case load so it matches their daily practice.

....
It has turned out that the question from the opening post is an absolute killer of homeopathy's main claims. If it really worked as advertised they'd be able to trot out loads of dramatic cures of serious diseases. Not being dead of AIDS or cancer or Type 1 Diabetes cuts through all that nonsense about debatable end-points. Unfortunately they can't parade these cases in front of us because it looks like they just don't exist......

But in the Organon Hahnemann claimed to cure syphilis! He has several paragraphs explaining that particular miasm and how "allopathy" has a dreadful record with syphilis. So I have asked homeopaths over and over and over again what the actual success rate of homeopathy with syphilis, and I have yet to get any kind of actual answer (you can do a search for my posts on "syphilis" to find the threads).

I have also asked a simple chemistry/algebra problem to many homeopaths. I ask them to tell me how many sodium and chlorine atoms are in one cubic centimeter of Nat Mur 30C. Ullman answered with some silliness about water acting like a CD-rom. Um, yeah right... the problem with that is I wanted a NUMBER!

Whatever action homeopathy has, if any, is definitely NOT pharmacological. I think that is pretty much undisputed. So our current understanding of pharmacology would not apply to homeopathy.

It is not uncommon at all for people who use homeopathy to claim effect within seconds. I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically. ....

Read this book.

...What you say about the time spent debunking studies etc is absolutely correct. My experience of debating with proponents online is that they tend to be incredibly slippery; picking and dropping positions almost at random. They're also happy to hold utterly contradictory stances, with no sense that both can't be true ("No, everyone knows you can't measure homeopathy via traditional means", followed straight up with a post saying "Ha! Look at this study in the BMJ! I TOLD you homeopathy worked" etc). ....

Most of the times they are cherry picking the studies. Sometimes they are going on just the abstract, without realizing the study had no relation to what your discussion is about. They often try to baffle with bovine excrement, pushing a bunch of cites without really checking the contents (or even lying about the results as noted in this website).

Several years ago on Usenet I had someone reply to me with a list of medical journal articles trying to prove that the reason my son had seizures was because I drank milk (he had frightened another parent whose child had the same disability of mine because he would post on the misc.kids.health his theory anytime a parent would ask about disabilities). I actually went through the infant version of www.pubmed.gov and sent him a long email (on dial-up!) showing how they did not say what he wanted them to say! As it turns out, he really was not a crank, but a nice guy trying to deal with his own lactose intolerance (something my sister has). He stopped posting that any and every disability was due to drinking milk (I was not the only one to react to him). But he is the rare bird. The true believers never let facts get in the way of their "truths".

Oh, read the book I suggested for HelenSan, it is reviewed here:
http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=4

Oh yes, they send you your remedy*, along with information on homeopathy**. Real homeopathic pills*, in real little dinky bottles. I wouldn't work for frauds y'know!
...

Awesome! I am trying to figure out a way to get news about that truth dealing homeopathic service to my niece. Her way of dealing with my skepticism is to not let me talk:
Woo Way: Response is NOT allowed!

Yes, it really works. My brother takes an iron/viagra supplement. Whenever he sees a beautiful woman, he turns to face north.

:lolsign:
 
It was simply an illustration that it is not entirely implausible for mechanisms other than pharmacological ones to produce biological effects within seconds.


Here's another one:

 
Last edited:
I tire of having to qualify myself every single time, but again, this is not scientific proof of anything and is not presented to prove anything

If you are not prepared to defend the things you say (or admit errors and withdraw mistaken assertions), don't say them.
 
Cool! How sensitive are those equipment? Cause as I understand it, if there are EM fields, they would be extremely small, as in the nanoGauss and nanoTesla range.

Which? Teslas are 10000 times stronger than gausses. I can't measure nanoteslas anyway (and I don't have a way of screening out the Earth's field) but only milliteslas. That would certainly be strong enough to detect the fields apparently required to knock out the salamanders or the fields involved in TMS. I also have a cryomagnetic system which can generate fields of up to 7.5T.

To measure it, you'd have to dissolve a pill in water, preferably 4 - 8 oz of distilled if you have it.

In our lab we have a source of ultrapure "18MΩ" water, is that good enough?

If you do measure it and post the results here, please also email me at [email protected] . I may not check this board as often as I would like. Thanks!

I'll see what I can do.
 
Just because something doesn't have scientific rigor doesn't mean it is demonstrably false; it just means it is not scientifically proven. I believe I explained this concept at great length in a previous post to Linda.

I made the assertion to illustrate that getting an effect in seconds is not entirely implausible. The assertion wasn't made to prove anything.

You will have to excuse us. Once you get used to speculating on the basis of things that could possibly be true, it's hard to break the habit.

Linda
 
I tire of having to qualify myself every single time, but again, this is not scientific proof of anything and is not presented to prove anything. It was simply an illustration that it is not entirely implausible for mechanisms other than pharmacological ones to produce biological effects within seconds. I don't know how much more tentatively I can phrase it.

This is just a conversation. I am not making official claims to prize money. I hope some of you can relax.

I have a suggestion - go with dark matter and dark energy. You can give it all kinds of attributes that we wouldn't be able to demonstrate were wrong.

Linda
 
But in the Organon Hahnemann claimed to cure syphilis! He has several paragraphs explaining that particular miasm and how "allopathy" has a dreadful record with syphilis. So I have asked homeopaths over and over and over again what the actual success rate of homeopathy with syphilis, and I have yet to get any kind of actual answer (you can do a search for my posts on "syphilis" to find the threads).

Syphilis is a good choice for homeopaths, since most people are asymptomatic most of the time. It's those pesky blood tests that have screwed them up.

Most of the times they are cherry picking the studies. Sometimes they are going on just the abstract, without realizing the study had no relation to what your discussion is about. They often try to baffle with bovine excrement, pushing a bunch of cites without really checking the contents (or even lying about the results as noted in this website).

Several years ago on Usenet I had someone reply to me with a list of medical journal articles trying to prove that the reason my son had seizures was because I drank milk (he had frightened another parent whose child had the same disability of mine because he would post on the misc.kids.health his theory anytime a parent would ask about disabilities). I actually went through the infant version of www.pubmed.gov and sent him a long email (on dial-up!) showing how they did not say what he wanted them to say! As it turns out, he really was not a crank, but a nice guy trying to deal with his own lactose intolerance (something my sister has). He stopped posting that any and every disability was due to drinking milk (I was not the only one to react to him). But he is the rare bird. The true believers never let facts get in the way of their "truths".

I've done that as well. I don't expect to persuade the believer (DUllman is still pushing studies that actually had negative results, after all), but it dulls the impact of a citation list for someone sitting on the fence (at least, that's what I hope).

Linda
 
Yes, it really works. My brother takes an iron/viagra supplement. Whenever he sees a beautiful woman, he turns to face north.

All I can say is...what a visual!!

:eek:

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom