Most of the times they are cherry picking the studies. Sometimes they are going on just the abstract, without realizing the study had no relation to what your discussion is about. They often try to baffle with bovine excrement, pushing a bunch of cites without really checking the contents (or even lying about the results as noted in this
website).
Several years ago on Usenet I had someone reply to me with a list of medical journal articles trying to prove that the reason my son had seizures was because I drank milk (he had frightened another parent whose child had the same disability of mine because he would post on the misc.kids.health his theory anytime a parent would ask about disabilities). I actually went through the infant version of
www.pubmed.gov and sent him a long email (on dial-up!) showing how they did not say what he wanted them to say! As it turns out, he really was not a crank, but a nice guy trying to deal with his own lactose intolerance (something my sister has). He stopped posting that any and every disability was due to drinking milk (I was not the only one to react to him). But he is the rare bird. The true believers never let facts get in the way of their "truths".