Badly Shaved Monkey
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,363
With respect to HelenSan's infant medicating scenario, one other thing warrants pointing out:
Our philosophical positions in this are not symmetrical despite the fact that we do agree that the 'response' could be causally unrelated to the therapy given.
1. No one with rational scepticism would advance such an anecdote as demonstrative of anything.
2. It is one thing to use a conventional drug backed by normal science and proper data from the licensing process. It is quite another to use sugar that only has an unstable mountain of anecdote to support its use. Thus, I might be wrong in thinking that Calpol helps my child in any given circumstance, but the evidence is that most of the time I would be right even if part of the response is the MKIB effect. With homeopathic sugar I would always be wrong if I ascribed a causal effect to the remedy.
Not symmetrical. Not equivalent. That's the difference between right and wrong.
Our philosophical positions in this are not symmetrical despite the fact that we do agree that the 'response' could be causally unrelated to the therapy given.
1. No one with rational scepticism would advance such an anecdote as demonstrative of anything.
2. It is one thing to use a conventional drug backed by normal science and proper data from the licensing process. It is quite another to use sugar that only has an unstable mountain of anecdote to support its use. Thus, I might be wrong in thinking that Calpol helps my child in any given circumstance, but the evidence is that most of the time I would be right even if part of the response is the MKIB effect. With homeopathic sugar I would always be wrong if I ascribed a causal effect to the remedy.
Not symmetrical. Not equivalent. That's the difference between right and wrong.