Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

With respect to HelenSan's infant medicating scenario, one other thing warrants pointing out:

Our philosophical positions in this are not symmetrical despite the fact that we do agree that the 'response' could be causally unrelated to the therapy given.

1. No one with rational scepticism would advance such an anecdote as demonstrative of anything.
2. It is one thing to use a conventional drug backed by normal science and proper data from the licensing process. It is quite another to use sugar that only has an unstable mountain of anecdote to support its use. Thus, I might be wrong in thinking that Calpol helps my child in any given circumstance, but the evidence is that most of the time I would be right even if part of the response is the MKIB effect. With homeopathic sugar I would always be wrong if I ascribed a causal effect to the remedy.

Not symmetrical. Not equivalent. That's the difference between right and wrong.
 
Blimey you folks are fast!

Many thanks, I'll have a leaf through those now.
 
Also, whilst I post; I'm curious as to homeopathy research. Once of the things I've seen mentioned repeatedly as an excuse for the effects "not showing" up in tests is that homeopathic remedies have to be targeted at individuals; you can't just group a load of people with a specific condition together, and give half of them the same remedy

Which, when debating whether it even works, seems to miss the point to me. Surely all you need is a group suffering from the same condition; if they want to use different remedies on each one - that's fine. All you're interested in is whether they get better quicker than the control, surely?

Your point is correct. What the more subtle homeopath then moves on to is to bleat that our view and their view of disease is not the same and so we cannot legitimately test it by tying what they do to 'allopathic disease categories'.

Homeopaths claim to cure people. They have therefore implicitly admitted using criteria to judge that success.

The fact that the patients put into a trial happen to have a disease state that conventional medicine regards as reasonably homogeneous should pose no problem to the homs. They claim to be able to cure anything. So it's quite fair to give them anything to cure whether that thing is defined tidily by conventional medicine or not.

The problem comes in finding endpoints in assessing responses that adequately capture that assessment. This is not easy and it does leave them room to manoeuvre.

This is also why they like trials of soft diseases with imprecise definitions. They can then claim that inappropriate end-points were used. These soft diseases are also their bread-and-butter case load so it matches their daily practice.

However, unless every study does a completely useless job of defining its endpoints, if homeopathy really worked, you should get some agreement between the trial's assessment of the patients' improvements and the homeopaths' claims to make those improvements.

What we see is that when cheating and bias are removed by proper blinding the homs can never produce any meaningful effects.

It has turned out that the question from the opening post is an absolute killer of homeopathy's main claims. If it really worked as advertised they'd be able to trot out loads of dramatic cures of serious diseases. Not being dead of AIDS or cancer or Type 1 Diabetes cuts through all that nonsense about debatable end-points. Unfortunately they can't parade these cases in front of us because it looks like they just don't exist. So homeopathy's main claims are busted and they are left piddling around in the margins of medicine parasitising the sick and the gullible.

But you can see there are problems, which is why it is much more important to recall that homeopathic 'provings', which are central to their philosophy have been disproved. If homeopaths cannot distinguish a 'real' remedy pill from a blank or 'real' remedy pills cannot be shown to produce symptoms over and above that reported after giving a placebo then their sugar tablets have no effects beyond placebo so there is nothing to trial.

The real purpose served by clinical trials is one and one only. It lends spurious credibility to homeopathy and homeopaths. That is why they are quite keen on them and provided they are done badly enough they can always call 'more work needs to be done' (just like real scientists always do) and once in a while they can fluke out a statistically 'significant' result that the twerps who appear in the media promoting homeopathy can then claim as 'proof'. For examples of these just look at literally any of the studies that JamesGully (= Dana Ullman) has cited. If you look at the discussions of those studies you will find that the effort taken to refute his claims is massively disproportionate to the effort required to pull the abstract out of MedLine and paste it into an internet forum without engaging in any intellectual effort or analysis whatsoever. It's a perpetual game of whack-a-mole.
 
Last edited:
Or did you dissolve a pill in some water to give him? Would you be able to make a dilution up ahead of time, or do you feel it must be fresh? This wouldn't be a real test, just something to fool around with.
I always dissolve the homeopathic pill in bottled water (same that we use as drinking water). In this instance, it was made fresh with only water, no alcohol.

I like your suggestion of blinding the remedy. I hesitate to try it on my kids, but I could certainly try it on myself and my husband. I don't know where to get plain sugar pills, but I could have my husband make a remedy for me, and ask him to substitute with one granule of sugar. And I could do the same for him. We both take remedies for chronic conditions. That would be interesting.
 
HelenSan - I could give you hundreds of conincidental things that occurred with my kids that are of a same level as your anecdote.
Yep, that is why I said it was a meaningless anecdote. And I included all your examples as possible alternative explanations. But hey, what the hell, it worked, it's cheap, and it has no potential side effects. Which puts it ahead of Calpol in my book, but that's just me. :)
 
BSM already addressed this, but I thought I'd make it more explicit. 5 seconds is not long enough for anything, homeopathic or otherwise, to have any effect at all.
Whatever action homeopathy has, if any, is definitely NOT pharmacological. I think that is pretty much undisputed. So our current understanding of pharmacology would not apply to homeopathy.

It is not uncommon at all for people who use homeopathy to claim effect within seconds. I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically. Electromagnetic effects on organisms have been known to occur within seconds. For example, animals have been anesthesized with magnets, falling asleep in seconds, and waking up in seconds. So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.
 
Yep, that is why I said it was a meaningless anecdote.

If it was a meaningless anecdote, why did you post it? This is one of the more irritating tactics of the unthinking believer: post something pointless as if you were making a point then pretend you had no reason for posting.

But hey, what the hell, it worked, it's cheap, and it has no potential side effects

Ah, but there you go again. This is why your "meaningless anecdote" is not really meaningless to you. The problem is that you are being logically fallacious in saying "it worked".

Typical hom claim: I took a pill and IT WORKED!
Reply: You have no basis for making that statement.
Hom: Oh, I didn't mean anything by it.
Reply: But you reported it to make a point.
Hom: No, I didn't.
Reply: So why did you post it?
Hom: Because the IT WORKED!!

(Reply goes to look for 2x4 to hit self on head because that would be more fun.)
 
So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.

I agree. You are right. The claims of homeopathy are infinitely malleable to suit the needs of the discussion at any point.

It is the claim that it works that is entirely implausible.
 
I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically.

And you'd be wrong. I have quite a lot of sensitive equipment in my lab which I could use to measure electric or magnetic fields - do you want me to have a go at measuring a homeopathic pill?
 
Whatever action homeopathy has, if any, is definitely NOT pharmacological. I think that is pretty much undisputed. So our current understanding of pharmacology would not apply to homeopathy.

It is not uncommon at all for people who use homeopathy to claim effect within seconds. I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically. Electromagnetic effects on organisms have been known to occur within seconds. For example, animals have been anesthesized with magnets, falling asleep in seconds, and waking up in seconds. So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.

Hmmm....if water is capable of generating electromagnetic fields all on its own, we're in a heap of trouble.

Linda
 
But it must work through electromagnetism - Why else would remedies become inactivated by security X-Ray machines?!
Errr....or maybe they don't on second thoughts, seeing as how even the homeopaths can't agree on this one.....

Oh, hell, can't we have a new theory for a change? I'm tired of quantum entanglement and memory of water. Why can't we propose homeopathy works by surface tension bonds or something?
 
Cyril Smith (not that one) reckons that homeopathic remedies can be neutralized if they are put into a steel box or filing cabinet.

As for surface tension bonds and all that, the letters regarding the Memory of Water should be published in Homeopathy soon I think.
 
It is not uncommon at all for people who use homeopathy to claim effect within seconds. I personally speculate that homeopathy works electromagnetically. Electromagnetic effects on organisms have been known to occur within seconds. For example, animals have been anesthesized with magnets, falling asleep in seconds, and waking up in seconds. So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.

Wise of you to reject quantum entanglement. When that wavefunction collapses, you may discover that instead of a baby, you've got a pig in a poke.

Linda
 
Your point is correct. What the more subtle homeopath then moves on to is to bleat that our view and their view of disease is not the same and so we cannot legitimately test it by tying what they do to 'allopathic disease categories'.

Homeopaths claim to cure people. They have therefore implicitly admitted using criteria to judge that success.

snip...

That's a great post; thankyou once again! Most of that was sort of jostling round in my head, but in a very nebulous, conceptual state. You've just managed to put it into words very nicely.

What you say about the time spent debunking studies etc is absolutely correct. My experience of debating with proponents online is that they tend to be incredibly slippery; picking and dropping positions almost at random. They're also happy to hold utterly contradictory stances, with no sense that both can't be true ("No, everyone knows you can't measure homeopathy via traditional means", followed straight up with a post saying "Ha! Look at this study in the BMJ! I TOLD you homeopathy worked" etc). I suppose that that degree of self-delusion must be necessary if you're going to try and hold a serious discussion on a topic there's no evidence for.

Tedious though *sigh*. I genuinely don't know how you muster the energy.
 
And you'd be wrong. I have quite a lot of sensitive equipment in my lab which I could use to measure electric or magnetic fields - do you want me to have a go at measuring a homeopathic pill?
Cool! How sensitive are those equipment? Cause as I understand it, if there are EM fields, they would be extremely small, as in the nanoGauss and nanoTesla range. But I would be curious to see if equipment measuring in the micro ranges can detect anything.

To measure it, you'd have to dissolve a pill in water, preferably 4 - 8 oz of distilled if you have it. If you do measure it and post the results here, please also email me at [email protected] . I may not check this board as often as I would like. Thanks!

fls said:
Hmmm....if water is capable of generating electromagnetic fields all on its own, we're in a heap of trouble.
Not if they're tiny, tiny ones. ;)
 
Electromagnetic effects on organisms have been known to occur within seconds. For example, animals have been anesthesized with magnets, falling asleep in seconds, and waking up in seconds. So for me, the speed at which homeopathy is claimed to work is not entirely implausible.

As far as I know this is complete nonsense. I am unaware of any studies suggesting that magnetism can induce anaesthesia, and the fact that people stay awake whilst in MRI scanners makes this seem rather unlikely. Would you like to provide some references?
 
As far as I know this is complete nonsense. I am unaware of any studies suggesting that magnetism can induce anaesthesia, and the fact that people stay awake whilst in MRI scanners makes this seem rather unlikely. Would you like to provide some references?

These guys are looking into it, without much success:

http://bja.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/aem129v1

Background: Pulsed magnetic field therapy (PMFT) is a non-invasive, simple technique used extensively for the treatment of muscle pain. However, evidence to support its use from well-designed, clinical, or experimental studies is sparse.

Methods: We have utilized an acute pain model to perform a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled, crossover-study on 10 male (18–40 yr) volunteers. Pain was elicited by infusion of hypertonic saline 5% into the brachioradialis muscle of the non-dominant arm on two occasions, at least 1 week apart. Subjects received active or sham PMFT for 30 min in a randomized order delivered by two identical, commercially available machines (PulsePack 6000, Quantum Techniks). The active machine delivered a M-wave magnetic pulse (1.25 Hz, 3 ms width, 600 Gauss); the sham device was deactivated and delivered no magnetic energy. Pain was assessed at 15-s intervals, and area under the visual analogue score (VAS) pain curve (AUCp) was calculated using the trapezoid method.

Results: There were no significant differences in mean VAS pain scores between the two machines at any time. In addition, there were no significant differences with respect to mean (SEM) maximum pain score [sham 60 (8), active 63 (9) mm; P=0.66, 95% CI –18 to 12 mm] or AUCp [sham 463 (50), active 499 (90); P=0.64, 95% CI –201 to 129].

Conclusions: We conclude that, using the electromagnetic characteristics of the machine in this study, the PMFT had no effect on pain in our experimental model. More work is required to provide an evidence base in support of the use of this technique for pain.

One of the reasons people probably don't fall asleep in MRI scanners is because they're so bloody loud!
 
Welcome to the forum.

Maybe you can answer my question, then. Do they actually sell the products, or do they let you get most of the way through the buying process before they let you in on the joke?

Linda

Oh yes, they send you your remedy*, along with information on homeopathy**. Real homeopathic pills*, in real little dinky bottles. I wouldn't work for frauds y'know!

Cheers,

Rich.

*"remedy" does not imply curative properties, guaranteed as effective as, and indistinguishable from all other homeopathic remedies
**Links to Ben Goldacre's Guardian articles
 
As far as I know this is complete nonsense. I am unaware of any studies suggesting that magnetism can induce anaesthesia, and the fact that people stay awake whilst in MRI scanners makes this seem rather unlikely. Would you like to provide some references?

The research was done on salamanders.
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/134/3472/101

I believe this is the paper where it was published, though I have not read it, so I can't say for sure. I read the details of the research in the author's book, The Body Electric.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom