Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

This patient did receive radiotherapy, but he specifically refused chemotherapy. Please show me what stats you have for patients ONLY using radiotherapy for small cell lung cancer. How many people survive 5 years?

Are you now going to say that this type of cancer is self-limiting? Once anyone doesn't fit within your worldview, you simply redefine your parameters. How convenient.

You are making the amateur's error of confusing 5-year survival with cure. 5-year survival rates are a handy basis for comparison they are not the same as genuine cures. This is a fact that is often obscure (and I suspect sometimes obscured deliberately) in lay coverage of cancer care. Dead at 6 years from cancer is still dead. Homeopathy however is a "complete system of medicine" that regularly claims "cures" that are inaccessible to real medicine.
 
Nice. I like the slogan "Nothing acts as well as FairDeal Homeopathy". The Office Address on the "contact" page also happens to be the address of the Horseshoe inn.
Um - as the guy who wrote the site for them, I've had to apologise for the address cock-up. It was simply a placeholder and should've only been on the development site, not the live site. The address should now have been changed.

Oops,

Rich.
 
and we reach for Calpol (paracetamol liquid) in the same circumstances and I have seen my offspring respond at a speed that is biologically impossible if we were solely dependent on that actual biological effect of the drug instead of the ''mummy-kiss-it-better effect". The difference is that there is no question of Calpol being capable of having genuine effects in addition to the MKIB effect.

The explanation is quite simple. The child is training you.
 
Last edited:
....yeah, they should make those mixtures taste horrible again.

(then we would see what was really making the child feel better - and at lower cost!)
 
Last edited:
HelenSan - I could give you hundreds of conincidental things that occurred with my kids that are of a same level as your anecdote. For example, My 18 month old recently had black poo not long after starting antibiotics which went away not long after he stopped taking them. My immediate thought was that the antibiotics had caused it. But I looked into it and black poo is not a known side effect of the drug he was on. After a bit of worry (that it was caused by bleeding) and a bit of googling, I eventually found out that it can be caused by eating blueberries and liquorice, both of which he had eaten rather a lot of in the same time frame.

When my oldest son was just a baby, he vomited all the time. Some times it was better than others so i would try to work out what external thing might be causing it. I was absolutely convinced it was several things in my diet, like orange juice, because the times I drank it seemed to fit when he was being sick (he was breastfed) and it got better for a while after I stopped drinking it. Turns out he was milk protein intolerant, and the OJ thing was just a conincidence - it was me eating things with milk in them that were making him vomit (and giving him eczema - which I hadn't realised was related until I stopped the milk and his eczema disappeared).

When my kids have woken up as babies, and wouldn't stop crying, a sip of water is often the thing that settles them down again. Other times they would be crying for hours and nothing would seem to settle them, but then you just do something randomly different and all of a sudden they go to sleep. It would be easy to put their sleep down to whatever you specifically did at that time, but itwas usually just doing something (anything) different just at the right time when they were ready to call it a day.

ETA: They also have the same reaction to calpol that BSM mentioned.
 
Last edited:
Um - as the guy who wrote the site for them, I've had to apologise for the address cock-up. It was simply a placeholder and should've only been on the development site, not the live site. The address should now have been changed.

Oops,

Rich.

Welcome to the Randi forums. Hope you stay around.
 
Turns out he was milk protein intolerant, and the OJ thing was just a conincidence - it was me eating things with milk in them that were making him vomit (and giving him eczema - which I hadn't realised was related until I stopped the milk and his eczema disappeared).


I don't get that. If you consumed the milk protein, your baby showed signs of intolerance? But milk protein you consume would be reduced to its component amino acids, or at least short polypeptides, before being absorbed by your intestine. It would certainly be reduced to its component amino acids before any of these amino acids appeared in your breast milk - as native human milk proteins. At least as I understand it. I don't see how any component of the milk you ingested could survive all the way to your breast milk secretions in a way that would still allow any intolerance to be displayed by the infant.

Unless someone can explain this to me in a differnt way, I suppose.

Rolfe.
 
Um - as the guy who wrote the site for them, I've had to apologise for the address cock-up. It was simply a placeholder and should've only been on the development site, not the live site. The address should now have been changed.

Oops,

Rich.


The site is priceless. Maybe not quite dihydrogen monoxide, but in the same category.

Rolfe.
 
Last night, my 5 month old baby woke up in the middle of the night, crying in pain. He was inconsolable and was waking the whole family up. He's my third child, so I guessed from experience that he probably had a stomach ache of some kind. I gave him a remedy, and within 5 seconds, he stopped crying and went to sleep. Maybe it was placebo (though in a 5 month old baby is less likely), maybe it was sheer coincidence, maybe he was thirsty and became content with the spoonful of water. But it "worked" well enough for ME to return to sleep, so it's worth its weight in good, clean water.

BSM already addressed this, but I thought I'd make it more explicit. 5 seconds is not long enough for anything, homeopathic or otherwise, to have any effect at all. The box jellyfish has one of the most deadly poisons known. When injected directly into the bloodstream, it can take just a couple of minutes to kill an adult human. That's minutes, not seconds, and for something injected into your blood, not having to go all the way to the stomach, into the intestines and slowly be absorbed and spread around the body.

Whether you'd given the baby something homeopathic, Calpol, morphine or pretty much anything else, it could not possibly have done anything. Add to that that it is not actually possible for a homeopathic remedy to do anything because there isn't anything in it. Finally, we all know that babies regularly stop crying when they get some attention from their parents. Sure, it could have been thirsty, it could have been pure coincidence, it could have been any number of things that don't require breaking most of the laws of physics, but why bother worrying about any of these when the most likely answer is obvious to anyone who has ever seen a baby, let alone actually had one.
 
Um - as the guy who wrote the site for them, I've had to apologise for the address cock-up. It was simply a placeholder and should've only been on the development site, not the live site. The address should now have been changed.

Oops,

Rich.

Welcome to the forum.

Maybe you can answer my question, then. Do they actually sell the products, or do they let you get most of the way through the buying process before they let you in on the joke?

Linda
 
IIRC, smoking acts fast:

http://www.rcplondon.ac.uk/pubs/books/nicotine/2-physical.htm

When nicotine from cigarette smoke reaches the small airways and the alveoli of the lung, it is buffered to physiological pH and rapidly absorbed into the pulmonary alveolar capillary and venous circulation, and hence directly into systemic arterial blood. From here, nicotine is distributed quickly throughout the body. It takes about 10-19 seconds for nicotine to reach the brain.

Not that I'm suggesting anyone tries to stop their kid from crying quickly by giving them a cigarette.:)
 
I did hear one homoeopath claim that the "goodness" of the remedy was absorbed from the mucous membranes of the mouth. Another blatant assertion for which there is no evidence, and in fact just "make up what sounds good to explain whatever point you've just been challenged on". Which is why so much of their alleged theory is internally self-contradictory.

Rolfe.
 
I did hear one homoeopath claim that the "goodness" of the remedy was absorbed from the mucous membranes of the mouth. Another blatant assertion for which there is no evidence, and in fact just "make up what sounds good to explain whatever point you've just been challenged on". Which is why so much of their alleged theory is internally self-contradictory.
NO. It actually through quantum mechanically released vibrations that connect to the healing power of the body that forces the miasms to leave.

There is no reason why healing should not be instantaneous from the moment the pill is taken out of the bottle, and the theory is internally consistent, inasmuch as all nonsense is internally rubbish.
:)
 
W
Maybe you can answer my question, then. Do they actually sell the products, or do they let you get most of the way through the buying process before they let you in on the joke?
I want to know that too! I was very tempted to buy a remedy called Ambrosia, but I backed out when my paypal account was about to get charged $10 for the remedy plus shipping. I decided $10 was too much to spend on parody (although maybe worthwhile if it has a great label?) The paypal process looked serious at that point.
 
Hello - new member alert! I just wanted to thank everyone on here for some fascinating (and at time hilarious) reading between this and the other Ullman thread. It's quite compelling watching someone who doesn't know what they're talking about getting slowly ripped to shred by a load of people that do. I probably shouldn't have enjoyed it so much, TBH.

Anyway, to those who have taken the time to analyse, research, explain and dismantle - thankyou.

Also, whilst I post; I'm curious as to homeopathy research. Once of the things I've seen mentioned repeatedly as an excuse for the effects "not showing" up in tests is that homeopathic remedies have to be targeted at individuals; you can't just group a load of people with a specific condition together, and give half of them the same remedy

Which, when debating whether it even works, seems to miss the point to me. Surely all you need is a group suffering from the same condition; if they want to use different remedies on each one - that's fine. All you're interested in is whether they get better quicker than the control, surely?

Has this experiment ever been carried out, does anyone know? By someone reputable, obv.
 
Last edited:
I don't get that. If you consumed the milk protein, your baby showed signs of intolerance? But milk protein you consume would be reduced to its component amino acids, or at least short polypeptides, before being absorbed by your intestine. It would certainly be reduced to its component amino acids before any of these amino acids appeared in your breast milk - as native human milk proteins. At least as I understand it. I don't see how any component of the milk you ingested could survive all the way to your breast milk secretions in a way that would still allow any intolerance to be displayed by the infant.

Unless someone can explain this to me in a differnt way, I suppose.

Rolfe.

To be honest I'm not sure - I hadn't thought about the proteins being broken down, so I would like an explanation too. Pretty much everything I read at the time indicated that cows milk protein could be expressed in the milk and cause a reaction in a sensitive child. While he was still breastfeeding, I pretty much worked out that me eating milk products was the problem, so I cut all of them out. So at that point I didn't know exactly what in the milk was the problem - it could have been lactose intolerance. But after he was weaned I discovered he was fine with cheese, it was only the whey portion of the milk that he was sensitive too (and that he was fine with goat's milk too) which led me to cow's milk protein intolerance. No health professionals I mentioned it to questioned the breastfeeding thing either.

Maybe I'll start a new thread on this, to see if anyone knows and prevent derailing this thread further.
 
Hello - new member alert! I just wanted to thank everyone on here for some fascinating (and at time hilarious) reading between this and the other Ullman thread. It's quite compelling watching someone who doesn't know what they're talking about getting slowly ripped to shred by a load of people that do. I probably shouldn't have enjoyed it so much, TBH.

Anyway, to those who have taken the time to analyse, research, explain and dismantle - thankyou.

Also, whilst I post; I'm curious as to homeopathy research. Once of the things I've seen mentioned repeatedly as an excuse for the effects "not showing" up in tests is that homeopathic remedies have to be targeted at individuals; you can't just group a load of people with a specific condition together, and give half of them the same remedy

Which, when debating whether it even works, seems to miss the point to me. Surely all you need is a group suffering from the same condition; if they want to use different remedies on each one - that's fine. All you're interested in is whether they get better quicker than the control, surely?

Has this experiment ever been carried out, does anyone know? By someone reputable, obv.

Yes, a few ofthese trials have been done. here's the first one I found:

http://thorax.bmj.com/cgi/content/abstract/58/4/317
 
Hello - new member alert! I just wanted to thank everyone on here for some fascinating (and at time hilarious) reading between this and the other Ullman thread. It's quite compelling watching someone who doesn't know what they're talking about getting slowly ripped to shred by a load of people that do. I probably shouldn't have enjoyed it so much, TBH.

Anyway, to those who have taken the time to analyse, research, explain and dismantle - thankyou.

Also, whilst I post; I'm curious as to homeopathy research. Once of the things I've seen mentioned repeatedly as an excuse for the effects "not showing" up in tests is that homeopathic remedies have to be targeted at individuals; you can't just group a load of people with a specific condition together, and give half of them the same remedy

Which, when debating whether it even works, seems to miss the point to me. Surely all you need is a group suffering from the same condition; if they want to use different remedies on each one - that's fine. All you're interested in is whether they get better quicker than the control, surely?

Has this experiment ever been carried out, does anyone know? By someone reputable, obv.

I provided this example earlier in this thread - Individualised homeopathy as an adjunct in the treatment of childhood asthma: a randomised placebo controlled trial.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom