Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

As fls pointed out I posted in the wrong thread, I'll respond to you about the clinical studies here

As for assertion of spin, I've just done a search for 'stop' and 'close' in Le Canard Noir's blog and can only find that on the 6thJan08 he threatened to close it if you had nothing else to say that was new and when you just regurgitated the trial that had been dealt with in Orac's blog he did so on that day. Are we talking about the same post?
 
Thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura: a case report from an intensive care unit
M Frass
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute For Homeopathy, Dept. of Internal Medicine I, Universität Wien, Wien, Austria

The patient (33 years, female) was admitted to intensive care in her 22nd week of pregnancy because of a HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzyms, low platelet count). A c-section was performed resulting in a stillbirth. Subsequently a thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) developed, which necessitated daily plasma separations. Owing to a hypertensive pleural edema the patient had to be intubated and required artificial respiration.


After 4 weeks she could breathe independently for a few days but had to be intubated again. The thrombopenia did not improve, so splenektomy became necessary. Subsequently she got a fever due to an infection with Candida albicans and Aspergillus. She recovered under antimycotic therapy but again the number of thrombocytes decreased. Then her relatives started her on an additional homeopathic therapy giving Lachesis C200 twice a day. Thrombocytes increased from 24 G/l to over 400 G/l. The therapy was continued with Phosphorus C200; thrombocytes went up to 800 G/l. Because of her depressive mood Natrum Muriaticum C12 was added for 10 days. 5 weeks after beginning the homeopathic therapy the patient could leave hospital, getting Crataegus C12 for some more days until her total recovery.

Although I do not have access to the full text, from the abstract it is quite clear that the patient received at least the following conventional treatments:

1. Plasma Exchange
2. Intubation and mechanical ventilatory support
3. Splenectomy
4. Antimicrobial treatment with antifungals.

Given she was in intensive care she would have also recieved:

5.Nutrition, either enteral or parenteral
6.Gastric mucosal protection
7. Intravenous fluid therapy
8. Electrolyte managemant as appropriate
9. Analgesia
10.Sedation
11.Nursing care
12. Physiotherapy
13 Radiological imaging

And probably many others. Current best evidence is using these modalities the survival rate from TTP requiring ICU admission is 65%.(Outcome of severe adult thrombotic microangiopathies in the intensive care unit, Intensive Care Medicine, 2005.)

Your case report means nothing. Frankly, its an embarrassment to the authors and to the editors of the journal that elected to publish it.
 
As for assertion of spin, I've just done a search for 'stop' and 'close' in Le Canard Noir's blog and can only find that on the 6thJan08 he threatened to close it if you had nothing else to say that was new and when you just regurgitated the trial that had been dealt with in Orac's blog he did so on that day. Are we talking about the same post?


Acleron...
I began to provide links to Dr. Gully's book on December 28th, and I continued to provide more info on it through early January, when on January 3rd, Mr. Duck first threatened to cut off discussion.

The interesting NEW news is that I recently uncovered evidence that Gully became a member of the British Homoeopathic Society in 1848, the year before he began to treat Darwin. One does not become a member of that Society unless one defines oneself as a homeopath, whether one has written a book on water-cure or not.
 
Mr. Duck first threatened to close off discussion just after I posted a link to the famous book that Dr. James Manby Gully wrote (in 5 editions). My link was to the 5th edition, where he stated quite emphatically that homeopathic medicines were effective in various chronic ailments, either alone or with water-cure.


Edit: response posted here, in a more appropriate thread.
 
Last edited:
Acleron...
I began to provide links to Dr. Gully's book on December 28th, and I continued to provide more info on it through early January, when on January 3rd, Mr. Duck first threatened to cut off discussion.
No he didn't.
 
Here’s a new site for Dana to visit:

FairDeal Homeopathy – Truthfulness in Alternative Medicine
http://www.fdhom.co.uk/products.asp

Homeopathy works through a complicated interaction with the human body and mind known as the "placebo effect". Many homeopaths will try and explain any health improvements through made-up science such as "memory of water", "nano-particles" or other non-existant molecular interaction. The truth is that the human mind and body is a remarkable combination, and is perfectly capable of healing itself. If you think a remedy is helping you, it may well actually do so, especially in the case of self-limiting illnesses (ones that, if left alone will get better anyway). For some reason, many homeopaths feel they have to tell their patients lies and fairy stories, and try to baffle them with pseudo-science. Here at FairDeal Homeopathy, we treat you like adults, and only tell you the truth.


Contact details here:
http://www.fdhom.co.uk/contact.asp
 
This is the guy who wrote the web pages. Be interesting if it's genuine, just look at the price.
 
Thanks Linda. I'll contact the cancer website and see what I can get from them.

As an aside, I'd like to share a meaningless anecdote. This is just to show you guys a glimpse of why I (and others) use homeopathy.

Last night, my 5 month old baby woke up in the middle of the night, crying in pain. He was inconsolable and was waking the whole family up. He's my third child, so I guessed from experience that he probably had a stomach ache of some kind. I gave him a remedy, and within 5 seconds, he stopped crying and went to sleep. Maybe it was placebo (though in a 5 month old baby is less likely), maybe it was sheer coincidence, maybe he was thirsty and became content with the spoonful of water. But it "worked" well enough for ME to return to sleep, so it's worth its weight in good, clean water.

Anyway, I just wanted to share that so you know why people like it. We're not all ignorant, superstitious freaks.
 
I gave him a remedy, and within 5 seconds, he stopped crying and went to sleep. Maybe it was placebo (though in a 5 month old baby is less likely), maybe it was sheer coincidence, maybe he was thirsty and became content with the spoonful of water. But it "worked" well enough for ME to return to sleep, so it's worth its weight in good, clean water.
Have you thought about getting someone to make you up some blinded remedies, just to play around with?
I don't know how easy it is to get blank sugar pills, which would be one approach. The other is to have a liquid version. Did you give your son a remedy that was in liquid form? If so, you'd have to see what the base liquid was and make a control liquid with a similar ethanol percent if it had alcohol. Or did you dissolve a pill in some water to give him? Would you be able to make a dilution up ahead of time, or do you feel it must be fresh?
This wouldn't be a real test, just something to fool around with.
 
A patient received medical treatment for small-cell lung cancer and survived for 5 years. This has happened before. In this study it happened in 91 out of 471 patients, or 22 percent.

Linda

This patient did receive radiotherapy, but he specifically refused chemotherapy. Please show me what stats you have for patients ONLY using radiotherapy for small cell lung cancer. How many people survive 5 years?

Are you now going to say that this type of cancer is self-limiting? Once anyone doesn't fit within your worldview, you simply redefine your parameters. How convenient.
 
Have you thought about getting someone to make you up some blinded remedies, just to play around with?
I don't know how easy it is to get blank sugar pills, which would be one approach. The other is to have a liquid version. Did you give your son a remedy that was in liquid form? If so, you'd have to see what the base liquid was and make a control liquid with a similar ethanol percent if it had alcohol. Or did you dissolve a pill in some water to give him? Would you be able to make a dilution up ahead of time, or do you feel it must be fresh?
This wouldn't be a real test, just something to fool around with.

It would need to be HelenSan who was blind as to the contents.

Linda
 
This patient did receive radiotherapy, but he specifically refused chemotherapy. Please show me what stats you have for patients ONLY using radiotherapy for small cell lung cancer. How many people survive 5 years?

I'll look for something, but does it really matter? Even if it cuts the survival by one order of magnitude, down to 2%, that's still thousands of people living 5 years or more with small cell lung cancer. It's almost inevitable that at least a few of them co-incidentally also tried homeopathy for their cancer.

Are you now going to say that this type of cancer is self-limiting?

When have I ever said that?

Once anyone doesn't fit within your worldview, you simply redefine your parameters. How convenient.

When have I ever done that?

Linda
 
As an aside, I'd like to share a meaningless anecdote. This is just to show you guys a glimpse of why I (and others) use homeopathy.

Last night, my 5 month old baby woke up in the middle of the night, crying in pain. He was inconsolable and was waking the whole family up. He's my third child, so I guessed from experience that he probably had a stomach ache of some kind. I gave him a remedy, and within 5 seconds, he stopped crying and went to sleep. Maybe it was placebo (though in a 5 month old baby is less likely), maybe it was sheer coincidence, maybe he was thirsty and became content with the spoonful of water. But it "worked" well enough for ME to return to sleep, so it's worth its weight in good, clean water.

I've been there. It's really hard to let go of the idea that your actions are doing something. I think the process of letting go is against our inclinations and most people don't make the attempt.

Anyway, I just wanted to share that so you know why people like it. We're not all ignorant, superstitious freaks.

I knew that already.

Linda
 
This patient did receive radiotherapy, but he specifically refused chemotherapy. Please show me what stats you have for patients ONLY using radiotherapy for small cell lung cancer. How many people survive 5 years?

Looking at this and the two meta-analyses referenced in the article, it looks like radiotherapy adds 5 percent to the survival (compared to chemotherapy alone). Otherwise the results should be similar to surgery. If he had Stage I or II disease, the 5-year survival from surgery is more like 20 to 30 percent. So, I don't have an exact answer, but it seems to be around 1 in 20 to 1 in 3, which makes the case report not unexpected.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Last night, my 5 month old baby woke up in the middle of the night, crying in pain. He was inconsolable and was waking the whole family up. He's my third child, so I guessed from experience that he probably had a stomach ache of some kind. I gave him a remedy, and within 5 seconds, he stopped crying and went to sleep. Maybe it was placebo (though in a 5 month old baby is less likely), maybe it was sheer coincidence, maybe he was thirsty and became content with the spoonful of water. But it "worked" well enough for ME to return to sleep, so it's worth its weight in good, clean water.

and we reach for Calpol (paracetamol liquid) in the same circumstances and I have seen my offspring respond at a speed that is biologically impossible if we were solely dependent on that actual biological effect of the drug instead of the ''mummy-kiss-it-better effect". The difference is that there is no question of Calpol being capable of having genuine effects in addition to the MKIB effect.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom