Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Blah, blah, blah...

You are redefining "scientific" and "proof" to a private version that does not match that of any scientists I know.

The uselessness of most of the homeopathic literature does not constitute the main plank of the arguments against it. We mention it only because it gives rise to considerable humorous comment and because it reveals the general incompetence of homeopaths and their transparent desire to adopt the clothing of science without accepting its discipline. Science for homeopaths is just window-dressing for PR and an exercise in misdirection.

Please answer the question given in the opening post.
 
There has never been any scientific proof (evidence of causation obtained through rigorous scientific experimentation) that smoking causes lung cancer, that blood transfusions saves lives, and restarting the heart of a cardiac arrest victim is useful. That doesn't mean these 3 statements aren't true. It just means there isn't any scientific proof.

You are mistaken in your interpretation of scientific proof.
In the case of the cardiac arrest we know that know that living people have beating hearts and dead people don't. This has been measured just a few times. We also know the mechanism by which cardiac resuscitation works. We know through careful analysis why a beating heart is required. This is all science and has been proven. These days it is stating the bleedin' obvious that resuscitation works, but the underlying science was all proven.

The different standards applied to homeopathy are because there is no mechanism of action which doesn't require the suspension of several other well proven parts of science. Homeopathy makes extraordinary claims, the evidence so far does not support these claims. All we have are practitioners of homeopathy making fraudulent claims of effectiveness, appeals to authority, anecdotal evidence of no value, ad hominem attacks on people who disagree with them and obfuscation.

The only proof that the scientific community will accept are examples which BSM has repeatedly asked for followed up by well designed studies showing effectiveness. Arguing badly about the philosophy of science will not do.

BTW One of the areas of science you would have to disprove for homeopathy to work is QED, for which Richard Feynman was awarded a Nobel Prize.
 
There has never been any scientific proof (evidence of causation obtained through rigorous scientific experimentation) that smoking causes lung cancer, that blood transfusions saves lives, and restarting the heart of a cardiac arrest victim is useful. That doesn't mean these 3 statements aren't true. It just means there isn't any scientific proof.

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Absence of scientific proof is even less meaningful as evidence of absence. Scientific proof of causation is so tediously obtained and has such extraordinarily high standards that scientists usually don't even speak of researching causation. (They talk about investigating and understanding mechanisms.)

In absence of scientific proof, we do our best with observations, correlations, and plain common sense. (These are what medical research consists of.) You don't need scientific proof to have useful information. Sometimes very high correlations, especially high temporal correlations, provide sufficient evidence (even if it is not scientific evidence) to act.

When medical research claims to have scientific evidence of efficacy (or any other type of causation), it does so by lowering the standards of science to its inferior, less rigorous level. It is what real scientists call "pseudo-science" or "junk science" or "cargo cult science." I don't think physicians are out to deceive people with these studies. I think they simply don't see their own biases. As I said before, I am not judging, because it is a real danger all scientists have to watch out for.

"The first principle is that you must not fool yourself -- and you are the easiest person to fool. So you have to be very careful about that. After you've not fooled yourself, it's easy not to fool other scientists. You just have to be honest in a conventional way after that." -- Richard Feynman on cargo cult science.
http://wwwcdf.pd.infn.it/~loreti/science.html

Of course, some junk science papers are worse than others. But in my view, medicine criticizing the scientific rigor of a DB-PC-RCT in homeopathy is like the pot calling the kettle black.

Oh well, I tried. :)

If we're the idiots letting you stack the deck in your favour, why complain? I'm just interested in seeing some examples in this thread.

Linda
 
This case report may be of interest to you:

Thorax. 1989 Dec;44(12):1047-8.
Apparent response of small cell lung cancer to an extract of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment.Bradley GW, Clover A.
William Harvey Hospital, Ashford, Kent.

A patient with small cell lung carcinoma was treated initially with extracts of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment and appeared to respond. Subsequently radiotherapy was given and the patient lived for five years seven months, which is much longer than is usual with this type of tumour.


And so will this case report from this peer review German medical journal...

AHZ 2005; 250
DOI: 10.1055/s-2005-868629

Thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura: a case report from an intensive care unit
M Frass
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute For Homeopathy, Dept. of Internal Medicine I, Universität Wien, Wien, Austria

The patient (33 years, female) was admitted to intensive care in her 22nd week of pregnancy because of a HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzyms, low platelet count). A c-section was performed resulting in a stillbirth. Subsequently a thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) developed, which necessitated daily plasma separations. Owing to a hypertensive pleural edema the patient had to be intubated and required artificial respiration.


After 4 weeks she could breathe independently for a few days but had to be intubated again. The thrombopenia did not improve, so splenektomy became necessary. Subsequently she got a fever due to an infection with Candida albicans and Aspergillus. She recovered under antimycotic therapy but again the number of thrombocytes decreased. Then her relatives started her on an additional homeopathic therapy giving Lachesis C200 twice a day. Thrombocytes increased from 24 G/l to over 400 G/l. The therapy was continued with Phosphorus C200; thrombocytes went up to 800 G/l. Because of her depressive mood Natrum Muriaticum C12 was added for 10 days. 5 weeks after beginning the homeopathic therapy the patient could leave hospital, getting Crataegus C12 for some more days until her total recovery.
 
This case report may be of interest to you:

Thorax. 1989 Dec;44(12):1047-8.
Apparent response of small cell lung cancer to an extract of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment.Bradley GW, Clover A.
William Harvey Hospital, Ashford, Kent.

A patient with small cell lung carcinoma was treated initially with extracts of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment and appeared to respond. Subsequently radiotherapy was given and the patient lived for five years seven months, which is much longer than is usual with this type of tumour.

A patient received medical treatment for small-cell lung cancer and survived for 5 years. This has happened before. In this study it happened in 91 out of 471 patients, or 22 percent.

And so will this case report from this peer review German medical journal...

AHZ 2005; 250
DOI: 10.1055/s-2005-868629

Thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura: a case report from an intensive care unit
M Frass
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute For Homeopathy, Dept. of Internal Medicine I, Universität Wien, Wien, Austria

The patient (33 years, female) was admitted to intensive care in her 22nd week of pregnancy because of a HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzyms, low platelet count). A c-section was performed resulting in a stillbirth. Subsequently a thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) developed, which necessitated daily plasma separations. Owing to a hypertensive pleural edema the patient had to be intubated and required artificial respiration.


After 4 weeks she could breathe independently for a few days but had to be intubated again. The thrombopenia did not improve, so splenektomy became necessary. Subsequently she got a fever due to an infection with Candida albicans and Aspergillus. She recovered under antimycotic therapy but again the number of thrombocytes decreased. Then her relatives started her on an additional homeopathic therapy giving Lachesis C200 twice a day. Thrombocytes increased from 24 G/l to over 400 G/l. The therapy was continued with Phosphorus C200; thrombocytes went up to 800 G/l. Because of her depressive mood Natrum Muriaticum C12 was added for 10 days. 5 weeks after beginning the homeopathic therapy the patient could leave hospital, getting Crataegus C12 for some more days until her total recovery.

Eighty to ninety percent of patients with TTP are expected to recover with the medical treatment she received.

Linda
 
Last edited:
This case report may be of interest to you:

Thorax. 1989 Dec;44(12):1047-8.
Apparent response of small cell lung cancer to an extract of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment.Bradley GW, Clover A.
William Harvey Hospital, Ashford, Kent.

A patient with small cell lung carcinoma was treated initially with extracts of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment and appeared to respond. Subsequently radiotherapy was given and the patient lived for five years seven months, which is much longer than is usual with this type of tumour.

From the National Cancer Institute on Small Cell Lung Carcinoma
Because of its propensity for distant metastases, localized forms of treatment, such as surgical resection or radiation therapy, rarely produce long-term survival

Note its says rare, not non-existent.
Radiation therapy combined with chemotherapy, which does produce long time survival, had been in use from the beginning of the 80s, why wasn't it used here?

And so will this case report from this peer review German medical journal...

AHZ 2005; 250
DOI: 10.1055/s-2005-868629

Thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura: a case report from an intensive care unit
M Frass
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute For Homeopathy, Dept. of Internal Medicine I, Universität Wien, Wien, Austria

The patient (33 years, female) was admitted to intensive care in her 22nd week of pregnancy because of a HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzyms, low platelet count). A c-section was performed resulting in a stillbirth. Subsequently a thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) developed, which necessitated daily plasma separations. Owing to a hypertensive pleural edema the patient had to be intubated and required artificial respiration.


After 4 weeks she could breathe independently for a few days but had to be intubated again. The thrombopenia did not improve, so splenektomy became necessary. Subsequently she got a fever due to an infection with Candida albicans and Aspergillus. She recovered under antimycotic therapy but again the number of thrombocytes decreased. Then her relatives started her on an additional homeopathic therapy giving Lachesis C200 twice a day. Thrombocytes increased from 24 G/l to over 400 G/l. The therapy was continued with Phosphorus C200; thrombocytes went up to 800 G/l. Because of her depressive mood Natrum Muriaticum C12 was added for 10 days. 5 weeks after beginning the homeopathic therapy the patient could leave hospital, getting Crataegus C12 for some more days until her total recovery.

Your quote says that giving lactose/water was started, was all other treatment then immediately stopped? In an intensive care unit? :jaw-dropp
 
This case report may be of interest to you:

Thorax. 1989 Dec;44(12):1047-8.
Apparent response of small cell lung cancer to an extract of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment.Bradley GW, Clover A.
William Harvey Hospital, Ashford, Kent.

A patient with small cell lung carcinoma was treated initially with extracts of mistletoe and homoeopathic treatment and appeared to respond. Subsequently radiotherapy was given and the patient lived for five years seven months, which is much longer than is usual with this type of tumour.


And so will this case report from this peer review German medical journal...

AHZ 2005; 250
DOI: 10.1055/s-2005-868629

Thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura: a case report from an intensive care unit
M Frass
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute For Homeopathy, Dept. of Internal Medicine I, Universität Wien, Wien, Austria

The patient (33 years, female) was admitted to intensive care in her 22nd week of pregnancy because of a HELLP syndrome (hemolysis, elevated liver enzyms, low platelet count). A c-section was performed resulting in a stillbirth. Subsequently a thrombotic-thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) developed, which necessitated daily plasma separations. Owing to a hypertensive pleural edema the patient had to be intubated and required artificial respiration.


After 4 weeks she could breathe independently for a few days but had to be intubated again. The thrombopenia did not improve, so splenektomy became necessary. Subsequently she got a fever due to an infection with Candida albicans and Aspergillus. She recovered under antimycotic therapy but again the number of thrombocytes decreased. Then her relatives started her on an additional homeopathic therapy giving Lachesis C200 twice a day. Thrombocytes increased from 24 G/l to over 400 G/l. The therapy was continued with Phosphorus C200; thrombocytes went up to 800 G/l. Because of her depressive mood Natrum Muriaticum C12 was added for 10 days. 5 weeks after beginning the homeopathic therapy the patient could leave hospital, getting Crataegus C12 for some more days until her total recovery.

Well, at least you're trying. (And I assume you're back here because the Black Duck closed his last topic because he was bored of your posts: but anyway, welcome again to JREF where the forums never close, they just collapse occasionally due to technical faults)

But no prizes for either. 1. Not cured. 2. Not an unexpected outcome regardless of the shake'n'lac therapy.

What's wrong with finding us a few cured AIDS patients?

(Ooh, I like that one, I think I'll say it again: shake'n'lac therapy)
 
Last edited:
p.s does it not worry you in the least that you are having to scrape quite so hard at the bottom of the barrel to come up with these inadequate specimens?
 
Well, I would reply but Linda and Acleron already said it.

Dana, which part of "Two patients were given standard medical treatment and had outcomes expected from standard medical treatment" do you find a compelling argument for homeopathy?
 
Linda,
You wrote that 22% of people with small cell lung carcinoma survived 5 years, but that is with conventional treatment. According to Acleron's posting and link to the National Cancer Institute on Small Cell Lung Carcinoma, it is written:


"Without treatment, small cell carcinoma of the lung has the most aggressive clinical course of any type of pulmonary tumor, with median survival from diagnosis of only 2 to 4 months. Compared with other cell types of lung cancer, small cell carcinoma has a greater tendency to be widely disseminated by the time of diagnosis, but is much more responsive to chemotherapy and irradiation."

Because you folks insist that homeopathy is "no treatment," the median survival is only 2-4 months.

And I'm still waiting for somebody's statistical analysis of the COPD study that showed substantial differences in the homeopathic group and the control group, even though there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups.

The one "critique" of this study that was published in CHEST was a weak critique that made NO reference to this invalid statistical analysis.

And yeah...the duck closed off that discussion after I raised this question about the CHEST study. What a coincidence.
 
Linda,
You wrote that 22% of people with small cell lung carcinoma survived 5 years, but that is with conventional treatment.

But the report you provided said the fellow received radiotherapy. Are you saying they lied?

Linda
 
Linda,
You wrote that 22% of people with small cell lung carcinoma survived 5 years, but that is with conventional treatment. According to Acleron's posting and link to the National Cancer Institute on Small Cell Lung Carcinoma, it is written:

"Without treatment, small cell carcinoma of the lung has the most aggressive clinical course of any type of pulmonary tumor, with median survival from diagnosis of only 2 to 4 months. Compared with other cell types of lung cancer, small cell carcinoma has a greater tendency to be widely disseminated by the time of diagnosis, but is much more responsive to chemotherapy and irradiation."

Because you folks insist that homeopathy is "no treatment," the median survival is only 2-4 months.
If you bother to read beyond that one statistic you have grasped at (like a drowning man clutching a straw), you will see that they quote a 5 year survival of 5-10%.

(Do you have the slightests idea what a median is?)

With combination chemotherapy and limited stage disease, they quote complete response rates of 45-75%.
Where are all the homeopathy trials demonstrating responses like that?
 
Last edited:
According to Acleron's posting and link to the National Cancer Institute on Small Cell Lung Carcinoma, it is written:


"Without treatment, small cell carcinoma of the lung has the most aggressive clinical course of any type of pulmonary tumor, with median survival from diagnosis of only 2 to 4 months. Compared with other cell types of lung cancer, small cell carcinoma has a greater tendency to be widely disseminated by the time of diagnosis, but is much more responsive to chemotherapy and irradiation."


http://cancerguide.org/median_not_msg.html


Because you folks insist that homeopathy is "no treatment," the median survival is only 2-4 months.


I didn't realise we had such power.
 
And I'm still waiting for somebody's statistical analysis of the COPD study that showed substantial differences in the homeopathic group and the control group, even though there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups.

The one "critique" of this study that was published in CHEST was a weak critique that made NO reference to this invalid statistical analysis.

1) The numbers, 25 in each group group are small for a clinical trial.
2) Because they are small statistics are more likely to show a 'significant' difference just due to random chance.
3) The authors claimed that all patients had mild COPD. COPD scores range from 0-4. Mild is defined as COPD Stage 1. Both groups were described as having mild COPD so the average score in each group should be 1. However it was reported as being 1.2 +/-0.5 and 1.08 +/-0.4 respectively. Some of the patients must have moderate to severe scores.
4) 36% of the control group and 20% of the treatment group were on home oxygen, that is 9 and 5 respectively. Home oxygen is usually an indicator of moderate to severe COPD or another pulmonary disease. It is worrying that this was not reflected in the COPD scores.

These points may or may not invalidate the trial but are not addressed by the authors. They do indicate there were significant clinical differences between the two groups. If they missed these points how much of the conclusions may be similarly misrepresented by the authors.

All of this was reported byORAC. Look at the post and especially the comment by qetzal.
Oh, of course, you did look at it but didn't respond showing what was wrong with the analysis.
I've repeated it here to give you another chance.

And yeah...the duck closed off that discussion after I raised this question about the CHEST study. What a coincidence.

Le Canard Noir closed the discussion not because you raised the study but because you had nothing new to say.
 
<snip analysis of COPD study>

I don't mean to be critical, but we shouldn't let DUllman pull his usual tricks. Any response on this topic should be moved to the other thread.

Also, even though all of his points have been more than adequately addressed multiple times, he simply repeats his initial statement as though they haven't. Can we come up with some better way to short-circuit this particular tactic?

Linda
 
Last edited:
Here are two websites with cure stories. If any of them seems like a likely candidate for meeting your challenge if the appropriate documentation were presented, let me know. I'll write them to ask for documentation. (Or you guys can do that too, you know.)

http://www.drramakrishnan.com/cancer.php
http://www.recoveredfromautism.com/ourstory.htm

The first website is a possible candidate, although the information he presents is inadequate, even if the veracity can be confirmed. A few screening questions would let you know whether it is worthwhile pursuing. The first case of the fellow with the prostate ca: did he receive the treatment that was recommended (surgery and radiation), or any other therapies other than homeopathy? The second and third cases: were the diagnoses confirmed with pathological specimens obtained through biopsy?

If no other treatments were received, and the diagnoses were confirmed through biopsy, it may be worthwhile pursuing those cases, as they are of the type we would be interested in.

I don't know about the autism case. It isn't even clear that he ever received a formal diagnosis of autism, so I suspect that once you start digging into it, it will quickly pan out. And it may not be worth your while even if, for some reason, the available information is way better than what the mother describes, just because the variation in outcomes may not put the result outside of what can be expected (disclaimer: we would need to get the input of someone with expertise on autism to make that determination - there may be a few here).

Linda
 
I don't mean to be critical, but we shouldn't let DUllman pull his usual tricks. Any response on this topic should be moved to the other thread.

Also, even though all of his points have been more than adequately addressed multiple times, he simply repeats his initial statement as though they haven't. Can we come up with some better way to short-circuit this particular tactic?

Linda

Apologies, you are quite right, not thinking as usual:o
 
Mr. Duck first threatened to close off discussion just after I posted a link to the famous book that Dr. James Manby Gully wrote (in 5 editions). My link was to the 5th edition, where he stated quite emphatically that homeopathic medicines were effective in various chronic ailments, either alone or with water-cure.

Your statement that the duck-meister closed off discussion because there was "nothing new to say" was his and your clever spin, but not the truth. It IS that simple. And then, when I begun to discuss this excellent study in CHEST, Mr. Duck got more worried.

You folks spin so much and so often that you get yourselves dizzy.

As for the CHEST trial, why do you reference statistical significance when it works for you and ignore it when it doesn't? Please show me where there was a statistically significant difference in the treatment and control groups?

But heck, let's agree that there were some (non-significant differences). Let's look at the results. Let's assume that everyone who had home oxygen were at Grade 3 prior to treatment (that's 5 treatment people and 9 control people)...and yet, after treatment, there was one ONE treatment person in Grade 3 and now 13 people of the control group in Grade 3.

Remember...COPD is a progressive disease, and yet, the treated group improve substantially (not just significantly).

Please explain this...

And yet, I do continually go back to this study because THIS disease is a serious one; it is not self-limiting; it was conducted at the University of Vienna Hospital; it was published in a major journal. That's more than 3 strikes...you're out...

That said, the challenge to homeopaths is that we have to replicate this study, and I have heard that it is presently being replicated.

As for studies that have been replicated in homeopathy, there are those studies to which I have referred in the past that you love to ignore or minimize their real data...but all of your critiques of them are left wanting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom