As an aside, I really thought, when pv suggested this challenge, that we would be inundated with claimed cures and we would be being forced to accept that there were some impressive stories out there that would give personal experiential support for a belief in homeopathy even though we know it fails under controlled condition, but it is looking increasingly likely that the homs can't even produce that n=1 anecdote for openers.
I think this is a remarkable discovery.
This clearly places homeopathy firmly in the realms of the Urban Myth, where everyone knows a good story that happened to their sister's aunt's first husband's best friend or someone in a village in India that we were told about once when in Goa.
Homeopathy: I never knew there was so little in it.
Yes, exactly.
Unexpected recoveries from things which are not normally self-limiting do occasionally occur. And homoeopathy is so widespread that it seems at least possible that once or twice this has happened when the patient was getting homoeopathic treatment.
BSM, you know I set up a screening scheme for persistent patent ductus venosus (portocaval shunt) in Irish Wolfhound puppies. My system can pick them out with 100% accuracy, so long as you follow the protocol. But I had one puppy, once, which bucked the odds.
The owner was a bit of an oddball, and I'd had trouble with her once previously when she'd refused to believe that her prospective new stud dog had the condition. That puppy died at 4 months old, not a surprise, but she always maintained that he died of something else and had never had a shunt. Yeah, right.
Anyway, the puppy I'm talking about had an absolutely conclusive test at 6 weeks. However, according to protocol we tested him again at 8 weeks, as much to make sure we had the right pup as anything else. Still a definite positive, but in fact less pronounced than the first test. I gave the owner the usual choice. If surgery is contemplated then the sooner the better, take him to a surgeon and get the final confirmation (e.g. portal angiography) done there. If not, then don't sell or rehome the pup, but let him run on until the development of clinical signs shows we're not mistaken, then put him down.
He didn't develop signs, and she had him tested again at 12 weeks. This time the result was equivocal. Not normal, but not a conclusive positive either. I expressed surprise, and suggested another test in another month. That test was negative.
The clear interpretation of these results was that the puppy's ductus venosus had done what it was supposed to do, close up, but at 4 months instead of 4 days. This is the only case I ever met where this happened.
None of the other positive-test puppies I identified ever had a late closure. The ones we let run on just to be sure, all developed encephalopathy and had to be put down. In fact, a fair proportion of them were showing signs of encephalopathy by the second test. I suppose it's possible that some of the pups that went for early surgery might have spontaneously closed up, but we could never know that - given the overwhelming benefits of early surgery and the apparent rarity of spontaneous late closure, I could never recommend it to a breeder who wanted the pup to live.
So, out of a huge number of puppies screened, and a fair old whack or positives, only that one.
As it happened, the owner was not into woo - or if she was, I never heard about it. Her reaction was to start a big fuss about how many possibly non-doomed puppies were we putting down by not taking this possibility into account. I pointed out to her that the protocol allowed for early surgery, pre-clinical-illness, but otherwise recommended waiting for clinical illness as the final confirmation before advising destruction, and she accepted that.
But what if she'd been into homoeopathy, and had tried that? Goodness knows, a lot of these dog breeders are pretty woo. The woman who helps my colleague who does the cardiology screening is always giving the owners homoeopathic remedies, and my colleague bites her tongue because she needs the help. But not apparently here.
If that pup had been given homoeopathic treatment, we'd never hear the end of it. I certainly wouldn't have another spontaneous late closure case to show. Even if there was never another "cure", we'd still be hearing about how homoeopathy can cure portocaval shunts.
I'm actually quite surprised that there seems to be no such case in the homoeopathy archives to be trotted out in this context.
Rolfe.