Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

So let me get this straight. Are you saying that RCT's are not relevant unless "you're teasing out effects that aren't overwhelmingly obvious"? If I compare mortality rates of two different groups of people from two different studies, and the difference is ten-fold or more, I don't need to present an RCT?

I'm saying that RCT's are not always necessary to unequivocably demonstrate an effect. Information from a study designed to tell you what to expect in a group of people with a particular condition can be used to tell you whether what is happening in another group of people, under similar conditions, is expected or unexpected. Realistically though, most of the questions that are currently researched show enough variation and heterogeneity that control groups are necessary to reliably discover the presence or absence of an effect.

Just double checking to make sure I understand your standard.

Okay.

Oh, are you scientists? Because you guys sound a lot like medical doctors. (I can't imagine a scientist saying something like "control groups only become relevant when you're teasing out effects that aren't overwhelmingly obvious"--but it is something that a medical doctor is likely to say.)

Some people here are medical doctors. Others come from different backgrounds. Medical doctors can be scientists, too. There are many scientists that are not medical doctors that would say something like "control groups only become relevant when you're teasing out effects that aren't overwhelmingly obvious", but it would probably depend upon just what they are talking about.

Linda
 
But while we're on the subject of AIDS, I found this little paper. I have no attachment to it, and it is NOT submitted as proof of anything.

I just would like to see what your criticisms of this study would be.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10335412?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2


It is impossible to evaluate a study for methodological flaws based merely on an abstract of that study. We need the full report.


For example, the study is said to be a "randomised double blind clinical trial". We need the full report in order to determine it there was true:
- randomisation.
- double blinding.

In order to confirm that homoeopathic treatments were given, we also need to full report to determine what were the actual:
- treatments.

We also need the full study to tell us the number and nature of the endpoints of the study in order to determind if there was any
- cherrypicking.

Without the full study, we do not know if the conclusion of the authors matches the actual results of the trial, because all we have is the conclusions which could have been subject to the authors':
- bias.


There are probably many more reasons, but that is a start.

BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
But while we're on the subject of AIDS, I found this little paper. I have no attachment to it, and it is NOT submitted as proof of anything.

I just would like to see what your criticisms of this study would be.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10335412?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2

A separate thread was started in order to discuss specific research articles here. This was partly to avoid the use of thread derails as a distraction from the purpose of this thread. And, as you can see, this was a valid concern, since we are now on page 10 without a whiff of an example. Even you have taken three pages already getting ready to come up with something. Imagine how much worse it would be if the various derails that Ullman already tried were thrown into the mix.

However, we do ask that the full text of the study be available online before providing a critique. Abstracts represent the biases of their authors and it cannot be assumed that the conclusions are supported by the results (they often aren't). In evidence-based medicine, it is the results that we are interested in. The conclusions of the authors aren't really taken into consideration.

I have copied this post into the other thread, so that it will be easy for you to pick it up there if you are interested in a critique.

Linda
 
Helensan,
Regarding the HIV study:
I have posted my thoughts on this in the homeopathy study thread (linked to in Linda's post, above - I can't post links yet.)
I think it justifies the previous comments that reading a full version of the study is necessary before commenting on it - I do note that you had made no claims for this work personally. I would also like to say that any criticisms I have made are not homeopathy dependant - I would have said the same had this been a trial of a conventional treatment, and I do not believe any respectable peer reviewed journal would have accepted it - homeopathy or no.

The study also highlights a common failing in this literature, the bias of the researchers. This is not restricted to homeopaths but they are especially flagrant offenders. Just citing from 3 papers that homeopaths like to produce as proof of efficacy, the sepsis trial, the fibromylagia trial and this one (Im sorry, I dont have the references to hand but they are all discussed in the research trial thread) the authors draw totally unjustified conclusions from data that any independant observer would count as negative. It is clear that they passionately believe their interventions work and approach the subject with this as a given.

Finally, to comment on your interesting exercise with the breast cancer paper.There have been a number of well thought out responses to this but here is an additional one. I think you have missed an important point - you cannot simply compare a paper that describes a well recognised and validated intervention with one that does not. The management of cancers is based solidly on a huge framework of basic science and observational data - the role of surgery and chemotherapy is well understood and have their basis on solid scientific principles. The same is not true for homeopathy, and so we would expect a higher standard of evidence given the mountain of conflicting data that exists. This is not treating homeopathy differently, or unfairly, as I have often seen homeopathists complain - this is a basic part of understanding the use of evidence. If I conduct a well performed experiment that shows the effectiveness of an antibiotic against a microorganism my results are likely to be accepted as they do not contradict everything we currently understand about the material world. If I perform an experiment that purported to show the same thing with a homeopathic remedy, I would expect it be gone over with a fine tooth comb, every potential confounder examined, and repeated several times by different researchers before it was accepted. Thats not discrimination, thats science.
 
The difficulty of inding a well-documented homoeopathic case of actual cure is surprising, but mostly because it says something about the amateurishness of homoeopathic research. The Catholic Church has, as far as I know, a few examples of well-documented cures out of the millions of supposed cures from the Lourdes spring. A few self-healing cases out of several millions is to be expected as possible, and that the church has found, scrutinized, and published them, shows how a professional organization works compared to homoeopathy which is clearly less well organized.
 
The management of cancers is based solidly on a huge framework of basic science and observational data - the role of surgery and chemotherapy is well understood and have their basis on solid scientific principles. The same is not true for homeopathy, and so we would expect a higher standard of evidence given the mountain of conflicting data that exists. This is not treating homeopathy differently, or unfairly, as I have often seen homeopathists complain - this is a basic part of understanding the use of evidence. ...Thats not discrimination, thats science.


Well, it is discrimination. You are simply saying the discrimination is justified. You are saying that it isn't you who has the double standard; it is science. It is science that has one standard for old information, and a higher standard for new information.

Thank you, though, for being honest enough to admit that there is a double standard. You do expect "higher standard of evidence" from homeopathy than from conventional medicine. What remains to be argued is whether this double standard is justified.

Here is my response. Bad methodology is bad methodology. Bad methodology doesn't magically get better because there is a mountain of papers, linked to mountains more, cited in its bibliography. That is not how science works. The bibliography helps support finer points of methodology such as which type of lumpectomy to use. But it can't erect a phantom untreated control group where there was none.

The higher standard for new information is called replication. Take Benveniste's paper in Nature. It was a relatively good study; Nature doesn't usually publish utter crap. But skeptics are right to approach it cautiously. Science requires replication of new information, even if the study had been perfect. Until it is replicated with good methodology, preferably hundreds of times, it remains in limbo. That is the higher standard by which science screens new information.

Science doesn't say the methodology for old information can be sloppy, while methodology for new information has to be airtight. No matter what paradigm you're in, established or avant-garde, methodology and design have to meet minimum requirements of scientific rigor. All new papers, even with good methodology, have to be replicated to be accepted. If science has a double standard, it would be that new papers in established paradigm research generally have to be replicated less times and under less variations than new papers in novel paradigms. That's all.
 
The bibliography helps support finer points of methodology such as which type of lumpectomy to use. But it can't erect a phantom untreated control group where there was none.

This is getting really tedious.

Listen, and please try to take this in once and for all. You are not making sensible comparisons. The paper you cited compared treatments when the common feature was that the cancer had been removed. We know that untreated cancers will generally kill people and we don't need that control group to compare adjunctive therapies. Homeopathy has failed to show that it can do the equivalent of that initial excision.

Studies are bad studies if they fail to answer the question they seek to address. Homeopaths repeatedly ask the wrong questions: hence their smug publicising of customer satisfaction surveys as alternatives to controlled trials. When the right questions are asked homeopathy fails.


Well, it is discrimination. You are simply saying the discrimination is justified. You are saying that it isn't you who has the double standard; it is science. It is science that has one standard for old information, and a higher standard for new information.

Roughly speaking, yes you are right, but this is not some amazing admission that you have winkled out from the hardened sceptics, it's what we scientists call The Bleedin' Obvious.

See Bayes theorem.

Roughly speaking, if something is intrinsically unlikely then you are correct to expect a higher level of positive evidence.

Less roughly, if you have an established base of plausible theory and good evidence then you have a lower likelihood of incorrectly inferring that there is a treatment effect.

Hey, but we're generous to homeopathy despite the essentially p=0 likelihood of it working based on prior knowledge and evidence we are allowing it to enter data that has only the same standard of proof as ordinary medical trials. That is effectively giving homeopathy the 'home advantage'. The fact that it fails even under these loose criteria is even more desperately bad news.

But enough of this time-wasting and prevarication. We are on page 10 of this thread. Please answer the question given in the opening post.

You could have found me that cured AIDS or cancer patient. You have not. Prepared to admit failure yet?
 
Last edited:
Well, it is discrimination. You are simply saying the discrimination is justified. You are saying that it isn't you who has the double standard; it is science. It is science that has one standard for old information, and a higher standard for new information.

Thank you, though, for being honest enough to admit that there is a double standard. You do expect "higher standard of evidence" from homeopathy than from conventional medicine. What remains to be argued is whether this double standard is justified.

Here is my response. Bad methodology is bad methodology. Bad methodology doesn't magically get better because there is a mountain of papers, linked to mountains more, cited in its bibliography. That is not how science works. The bibliography helps support finer points of methodology such as which type of lumpectomy to use. But it can't erect a phantom untreated control group where there was none.

The higher standard for new information is called replication. Take Benveniste's paper in Nature. It was a relatively good study; Nature doesn't usually publish utter crap. But skeptics are right to approach it cautiously. Science requires replication of new information, even if the study had been perfect. Until it is replicated with good methodology, preferably hundreds of times, it remains in limbo. That is the higher standard by which science screens new information.

Science doesn't say the methodology for old information can be sloppy, while methodology for new information has to be airtight. No matter what paradigm you're in, established or avant-garde, methodology and design have to meet minimum requirements of scientific rigor. All new papers, even with good methodology, have to be replicated to be accepted. If science has a double standard, it would be that new papers in established paradigm research generally have to be replicated less times and under less variations than new papers in novel paradigms. That's all.

Criticalist didn't say anything about accepting bad methodology. Bad methodology doesn't need to be accepted under either circumstance. He specifically referred to well-performed experiments.

Your criticism was directed toward a claim no one was making. And there's nothing wrong with airing your views generally. But it's starting to look like an evasion. I am thinking of starting a pool predicting 1) is anyone ever going to actually give BSM an example, and b) on what page will it first make an appearance. I may as well try to make some money on this.

Linda
 
I suppose I must apologise for the ongoing derailment of the thread, though its becoming glaringly apparent that this particular challenge is not going to be met. The other posters have already pointed this out but helensan:

I specifically referred to well performed experiments.
I specifically mentioned replication

The point of my post was not to defend bad methodology. I was attempting to explain to you that you cannot consider scientific knowledge in isolation.
JAMA. 2002;288:862-871, Effect of Treatment With Low Doses of Hydrocortisone and Fludrocortisone on Mortality in Patients With Septic Shock (sorry cant do the link) is a clinical trial which has been widely cited in the literature; as a result of it a number of clinicians changed their practice and gave steroid treatment to patients with severe sepsis. Are you honestly attempting to tell me that if you substituted the word "hydocortisone" with "magic pixie dust" the trial should have the same weight and effect on practice? Clinicians accepted the results of this particular trial not in isolation but as a result of previous studies and of biological plausability. Homeopathy does not have these features and so , once again, a higher standard of evidence is necessary, and your substitution game is an invalid comparison.
You posted " what remains to be argued is whether this double standard is justified". Really? You'd be happy to be sprinkled with the magic pixie dust then in lieu of antibiotics? Because that is what you are claiming.
 
As an aside, I really thought, when pv suggested this challenge, that we would be inundated with claimed cures and we would be being forced to accept that there were some impressive stories out there that would give personal experiential support for a belief in homeopathy even though we know it fails under controlled condition, but it is looking increasingly likely that the homs can't even produce that n=1 anecdote for openers.

I think this is a remarkable discovery.

This clearly places homeopathy firmly in the realms of the Urban Myth, where everyone knows a good story that happened to their sister's aunt's first husband's best friend or someone in a village in India that we were told about once when in Goa.

Homeopathy: I never knew there was so little in it.


Yes, exactly.

Unexpected recoveries from things which are not normally self-limiting do occasionally occur. And homoeopathy is so widespread that it seems at least possible that once or twice this has happened when the patient was getting homoeopathic treatment.

BSM, you know I set up a screening scheme for persistent patent ductus venosus (portocaval shunt) in Irish Wolfhound puppies. My system can pick them out with 100% accuracy, so long as you follow the protocol. But I had one puppy, once, which bucked the odds.

The owner was a bit of an oddball, and I'd had trouble with her once previously when she'd refused to believe that her prospective new stud dog had the condition. That puppy died at 4 months old, not a surprise, but she always maintained that he died of something else and had never had a shunt. Yeah, right.

Anyway, the puppy I'm talking about had an absolutely conclusive test at 6 weeks. However, according to protocol we tested him again at 8 weeks, as much to make sure we had the right pup as anything else. Still a definite positive, but in fact less pronounced than the first test. I gave the owner the usual choice. If surgery is contemplated then the sooner the better, take him to a surgeon and get the final confirmation (e.g. portal angiography) done there. If not, then don't sell or rehome the pup, but let him run on until the development of clinical signs shows we're not mistaken, then put him down.

He didn't develop signs, and she had him tested again at 12 weeks. This time the result was equivocal. Not normal, but not a conclusive positive either. I expressed surprise, and suggested another test in another month. That test was negative.

The clear interpretation of these results was that the puppy's ductus venosus had done what it was supposed to do, close up, but at 4 months instead of 4 days. This is the only case I ever met where this happened.

None of the other positive-test puppies I identified ever had a late closure. The ones we let run on just to be sure, all developed encephalopathy and had to be put down. In fact, a fair proportion of them were showing signs of encephalopathy by the second test. I suppose it's possible that some of the pups that went for early surgery might have spontaneously closed up, but we could never know that - given the overwhelming benefits of early surgery and the apparent rarity of spontaneous late closure, I could never recommend it to a breeder who wanted the pup to live.

So, out of a huge number of puppies screened, and a fair old whack or positives, only that one.

As it happened, the owner was not into woo - or if she was, I never heard about it. Her reaction was to start a big fuss about how many possibly non-doomed puppies were we putting down by not taking this possibility into account. I pointed out to her that the protocol allowed for early surgery, pre-clinical-illness, but otherwise recommended waiting for clinical illness as the final confirmation before advising destruction, and she accepted that.

But what if she'd been into homoeopathy, and had tried that? Goodness knows, a lot of these dog breeders are pretty woo. The woman who helps my colleague who does the cardiology screening is always giving the owners homoeopathic remedies, and my colleague bites her tongue because she needs the help. But not apparently here.

If that pup had been given homoeopathic treatment, we'd never hear the end of it. I certainly wouldn't have another spontaneous late closure case to show. Even if there was never another "cure", we'd still be hearing about how homoeopathy can cure portocaval shunts.

I'm actually quite surprised that there seems to be no such case in the homoeopathy archives to be trotted out in this context.

Rolfe.
 
Damn, I had a long-ish post here and I lost it, like an idiot. I'll recreate it tomorrow some time.

Rolfe.
 
Damn, I had a long-ish post here and I lost it, like an idiot. I'll recreate it tomorrow some time.

Rolfe.
:( and with you having just told us all about the joys of saving posts on notepad.......
 
I hadn't got that far! I was half way through, and pressed the wrong button somehow. This time, I composed the post in Notepad!

We're talking not just about published material, but about case reports, possibly unpublished, but presented in enough detail to allow reasonable assessment. Well, here's an example case, just to show what sort of information might be impressive.

Patient is a 4-year-old standard poodle, spayed female, presented in February with a history of lethargy, inappetance and more recently two episodes of collapse. There was no history of polydipsia.

Clinical examination revealed pale, tacky mucous membranes. Dehydration was estimated clinically at about 5%. Extremities were cold to the touch and rectal temperature was 37.2C. Heart rate was 56bpm and femoral pulse was weak and thready.

Chest x-ray revealed marked microcardia but normal lung fields.

Biochemistry and haematology results were as follows:

Total protein 88 g/l
Albumin 46 g/l
Globulin 42 g/l
Sodium 128 mmol/l
Potassium 8.4 mmol/l
Chloride 96 mmol/l
Calcium 3.2 mmol/l
Glucose 3.4 mmol/l
Urea 27.6 mmol/l
Creatinine 97 mmol/l
ALT 62 iu/l
ALP 125 iu/l

PCV 0.34
WBC count 12.7x109/l
Neutrophils 4.5x109/l
Eosinophils 2.3x109/l
Lymphocytes 5.8x109/l
Monocytes 0.1x109/l

RBCs and WBCs morphologically normal, platelets adequate.

ACTH stimulation test: Baseline and 45-minute samples both <28 nmol/l

Diagnosis, Addison's disease, either approaching or in Addisonian crisis.

[Here insert treatment. I'd recomment i/v isotonic saline with quite a lot of dexamethasone in it initially, then once hydration has been restored and the electrolytes are looking somewhat less terrifying switch to oral fludrocortisone +/- prednisolone for maintenance. Or something similar, depending on location - there is a long-acting injectable treatment licensed in the US, for example. However, it seems some homoeopaths take a contrary view, maintaining that steroids will kill the patient, and that homoeopathy can effect a cure. Unfortunately it never seems to be the homoeopath you're speaking to that has experience of this, it's always a friend of a friend, why don't you email him for all the details - email address of gentlemen with Indian-sounding name not supplied. See the link in my sig for the depressing details.]

Follow-up: 24 hours later sodium had increased to 136 mmol/l and potassium had decreased to 6.2 mmol/l. The dog was brighter, eating and drinking.

One week on the laboratory tests were repeated with the following results:

Total protein 72 g/l
Albumin 35 g/l
Globulin 37 g/l
Sodium 141 mmol/l
Potassium 5.3 mmol/l
Chloride 104 mmol/l
Calcium 2.6 mmol/l
Glucose 4.7 mmol/l
Urea 4.2 mmol/l
Creatinine 88 mmol/l
ALT 60 iu/l
ALP 145 iu/l

PCV 0.42
WBC count 10.5x109/l
Neutrophils 7.4x109/l
Eosinophils 0.6x109/l
Lymphocytes 2.2x109/l
Monocytes 0.3x109/l

RBCs and WBCs morphologically normal, platelets adequate.

The clinical presentation and initial laboratory results show a confirmed diagnosis of Addison's disease. Which is invariably fatal if left untreated. The very high potassium in this case indicates that death would probably occur sooner rather than later in this case.

The follow-up laboratory results are normal, indicating not a cure of the Addison's as such, but successful treatment and maintenance.

If homoeopathic treatment inserted in [....] above was capable of producing this result, I think we'd all have to conclude it warranted further investigation, because the situation demonstrated by the initial findings was anything but self-limiting.

The set of results which was not repeated was the ACTH stimulation test. This is because this test demonstrates adrenal failure. Adrenal failure is not reversible, and thus it is a waste of time to repeat the test - we know the result will be unchanged.

Homoeopathy, however, claims "cure". If homoeopathic treatment could, in addition to reversing the metabolic consequences of adrenal failure, actually reverse the failure itself and demonstrate this by producing a normal ACTH response after treatment (and a patient who remained well without maintenance therapy), then I'd say the holy grail had been found.

Now it was something like this that BSM was hoping for when he asked the initial question. Obviously one single case doesn't prove anything, especially if, like this, theres no supporting documentation. However, something as startling as that would at least be worth looking into! Yes, we might find that there was another explanation for the results as presented, or maybe we'd find that the report was inaccurate. But at least, as it stands, assuming no huge errors or lies, it's got substance to it.

Now I could produce 50 or more cases just like that - I mean, diagnosed Addison's cases that survived on conventional treatment. This is entirely unremarkable. Any small animal vet could trot up half a dozen of his own, and any laboratory-based vet like myself will have dealt with scores. And that's just Addison's. All the other things we sort out on a daily basis, from pyometra to diabetes, ask anyone for a case or six where they can confidently show that they made a difference to the outcome, and nobody would have any difficulty at all in documenting them, just by consulting their ordinary case records.

Homoeopaths, where are yours?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Rolfe, sorry that you lost that post. I know how unpleasant that is! (While I am at it, thank you for your suggestions when I lost mine.)

However, something as startling as that would at least be worth looking into! ... and nobody would have any difficulty at all in documenting them, just by consulting their ordinary case records.

Thank you, Rolfe, for the example. I agree that something like this wouldn't prove anything, but certainly should raise some eyebrows.

The problem is, many "homeopaths" I know do not request X-rays and biochemistry / hematology panels. Some do not even make any direct physical examinations at all. So they would not have any of these details documented in their "ordinary case records."

What they have in their case records are all subjectively reported symptoms, sometimes by only the client, other times by close family members as well. They do not routinely have objective documentation of anything, unless a client got them done before coming to the homeopath. And then, they may not even look at them. Things like WBC counts are immaterial in the practice of homeopathy.

Many homeopaths are not practicing medicine. They are recommending, at the the request of a client, a remedy that best matches the client's personal and symptomatic picture.

So yes, the level of medical documentation you guys are requesting is going to be hard to find. I don't think it is unreasonable though, and I am sincere about trying to find one. It'll take some time. I have to email folks, review their stories for confounders, and "interview" them about what kinds of objective documentation they have. Then, if it looks hopeful, they will have to gather their medical records, get them redacted and scanned, and so forth.

As far as submitting a research study goes, I have frankly lost interest on that count. When Linda said that control groups are optional when determining causatiion if the difference between two comparison groups is "overwhelmingly obvious," and no one else disagreed with her, I could no longer take this research study conversation seriously. We have no common ground upon with to discuss "science" and "scientific" standards. And it is highly unlikely that we will ever arrive at any.

So when I find an interesting case with objective documentation, I'll post again. Until then, I'm sure you'll have no trouble mocking me in my absence.
 
As far as submitting a research study goes, I have frankly lost interest on that count. When Linda said that control groups are optional when determining causatiion if the difference between two comparison groups is "overwhelmingly obvious," and no one else disagreed with her, I could no longer take this research study conversation seriously. We have no common ground upon with to discuss "science" and "scientific" standards. And it is highly unlikely that we will ever arrive at any.

You have made a big deal out of misunderstanding this point, as though it means you are holding yourself to a higher standard. Let me ask you a question, then. Do you think that we don't know whether or not smoking causes lung cancer, whether or not blood transfusions in the setting of massive blood loss saves lives, or whether or not restarting the heart of a victim in cardiac-arrest is useful?

Linda
 
Last edited:
HelenSan - So homeopaths "do not request X-rays and biochemistry/hematology panels" and make no physical examinations at all. Could you explain how can they make a correct diagnosis or cure cancer? I think the Italian Corte di Cassazione (Supreme Court) is right when it states that Homeopathy is a medical act and can be practiced only by registered MDs, and those practicing illegaly risk huge fines and jail terms.

There is a substantial difference between MD homeopaths and other "homeopaths": MD homeopaths believe that Homeopathy may be of some value in the treatment of some conditions but they will never claim that Homeopathy can cure Cancer(s), AID and similar.
The (Italian) Dictionary of Homeopathy written by one of the best Italian homeopaths states: "In reality there is no known homeopathic remedy that can cure Cancer or AIDS".
 
While HelenSan is certainly right about some (lay) homoeopaths not doing any diagnostic work at all, this is by no means universal. Those homoeopaths who are medical doctors (and there are a fair number) would be done for negligence if they omitted this. Do these people have no such cases? (Oh,wait....) Not only that, people with well-documented diagnoses from mainstream medicine do consult lay homoeopaths. So, it might just come to the attention of the physician who had made the initial diagnosis that his patient, who had consulted a homoeopath, was inexplicably cured? Has this never happened? (Guess!)

Look, if someone with such a life-threatening condition goes directly to a homoeopath, who proceeds not even to try to diagnose them, then this is frankly a prime example of exactly what we've been warning about, the major danger of homoeopathy, that someone will die because they have an undiagnosed serious condition, but falsely believe they are in safe hands. Even Snoopy, once she'd comprehensively flunked the hypothetical Addison's case, switched her tune rapidly and made that statement in my sig about getting a diagnosis before starting homoeopathic treatment.

So no, HelenSan. Many, many patients who receive homoeopathic treatment have a confirmed diagnosis, either from a medically-qualified homoeopath, or from an mainstream investigation carried out before the patient decides to try homoeopathy. There should be plenty scope to find just one who recovered unexpectedly.

Where's the tumbleweed smilie when you really need it?

Rolfe.
 
Rearrange the following words into a well-known phrase or saying:

homework dog ate my The dog

again.

Millions of patients, thousands and thousands of committed sugar retailers and they can come up with nothing.

HelenSan, while it is quite sweet of you to (claim) to be looking for an exemplary case, if one really existed the homs literature should reveal it after a very brief examination.

When will you accept that these dramatically cured cases simply don't exist?

Do you have the honesty to accept that their absence reveals the Big Lie at the heart of homeopathy?
 
Let me ask you a question, then. Do you think that we don't know whether or not smoking causes lung cancer, whether or not blood transfusions in the setting of massive blood loss saves lives, or whether or not restarting the heart of a victim in cardiac-arrest is useful?

There has never been any scientific proof (evidence of causation obtained through rigorous scientific experimentation) that smoking causes lung cancer, that blood transfusions saves lives, and restarting the heart of a cardiac arrest victim is useful. That doesn't mean these 3 statements aren't true. It just means there isn't any scientific proof.

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Absence of scientific proof is even less meaningful as evidence of absence. Scientific proof of causation is so tediously obtained and has such extraordinarily high standards that scientists usually don't even speak of researching causation. (They talk about investigating and understanding mechanisms.)

In absence of scientific proof, we do our best with observations, correlations, and plain common sense. (These are what medical research consists of.) You don't need scientific proof to have useful information. Sometimes very high correlations, especially high temporal correlations, provide sufficient evidence (even if it is not scientific evidence) to act.

When medical research claims to have scientific evidence of efficacy (or any other type of causation), it does so by lowering the standards of science to its inferior, less rigorous level. It is what real scientists call "pseudo-science" or "junk science" or "cargo cult science." I don't think physicians are out to deceive people with these studies. I think they simply don't see their own biases. As I said before, I am not judging, because it is a real danger all scientists have to watch out for.

"The first principle is that you must not fool yourself -- and you are the easiest person to fool. So you have to be very careful about that. After you've not fooled yourself, it's easy not to fool other scientists. You just have to be honest in a conventional way after that." -- Richard Feynman on cargo cult science.
http://wwwcdf.pd.infn.it/~loreti/science.html

Of course, some junk science papers are worse than others. But in my view, medicine criticizing the scientific rigor of a DB-PC-RCT in homeopathy is like the pot calling the kettle black.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom